Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

You aren't "investing" your money, you're spending it.

307 replies

Torak · 05/03/2022 07:54

I hate it when people say they are "investing" in the purchase of some sort of pricey consumable item.

I'd be interested to see your ROI on that £500 baby sling. 🙄

Gifting is another one I hate. But today I'm irritable about investing.

OP posts:
Cuck00soup · 05/03/2022 10:33

@merrymouse

Happy baby? Happy parents?

A baby doesn’t know anything about brands and the sling isn’t better than one that is much cheaper, so happier baby would be debatable.

Happy parents possibly, but as pp says, there is no difference in this case between investing and splashing out - it’s just that one is perceived to be more virtuous than the other.

People should just buy what they want to buy.

I'd probably add happy parents for a very short amount of time. Babies aren't in slings for long.

We had a 10 year gap between DC 2 & DC 3 and had got rid of the baby stuff. DC's 1 & 2 had a mamas and papas pram and a Laura Ashley nursery. DC 3 got mothercare . We were old enough and wise enough by then to know that nothing would be used for long and needed to be good enough but we didn't need to spend £££ on designer stuff.

Hasselhoffsheadband · 05/03/2022 10:32

This thread has cracked me up!

'Romford market?'

'I must tell them they are worthless'

'Not a house I would care to live in'

🤣🤣🤣

Synchrony · 05/03/2022 10:32

I invested some money in an actual investment and the company went bust. I actually wish I'd spent it on a baby sling, it would have still been worth more now!

RosesAndHellebores · 05/03/2022 10:31

Hmm. I think there are a couple of interpretations. The wishful thought that spending a great deal of money on something will render an intangible return: pleasure, longevity, avoidance of buying twice or thrice; or genuine investment purchases.

The real investments are those that render both. Regarding clothes cost per wear is also important.

Examples: I bought a Burberry raincoat in 1984 for £175. I could probably flog it on Ebay for close to £100. A couple of pictures I bought in the mid 80s have escalated due to the then unknown artist becoming famous and I have loved them. The same goes for some antique pieces or beautiful pieces, genuinely enjoyed and loved and bought new.

My engagement ring was £2kish 32 years ago, now valued at £7,500 for insurance but our local jeweller says they would give about £3k. The real mind bender is my wedding ring, bought in 1991 for £165: a simple yellow and white 18ct band with beading at the edges. I recently had to have it repaired after it was cut off after an accident (costing £185). I balked at the cost of the repair and the jeweller told me it would be £2k retail, £1k resale. However if one factors in cpw which after 32 years is miniscule compared to the pleasure they have given me, I think they have been fabulous investments.

Don't get me started on DH's "ridiculous" sports car which has not been an investment.

Things like very expensive kitchens will add equivalent value to a house providing the expense is proportionate to the value of the house but only if sold within five years of installation. After that it's about enjoying them but 10/15 years later they will not extrapolated into a premium.

Heytheredemons · 05/03/2022 10:30

Investing is more than a monetary return. If someone buys something that saves them time, then they have invested, as the gain is time.
If someone buys something expensive that doesn't need replacing, then they have saved the future spend of having to replace something cheap multiple times, so they have saved times, effort and money.
There is more to investing than popping money in an isa or buying shares in tesco.

Lookingforphev · 05/03/2022 10:28

I kind of get what the op is saying, but it's also incorrect.

The instant pot for example, lots of people get them with the Intention of it saving money in long. So it is for financially gain.

Buying a good quality winter coat that will last 10-15 years, is usually cheaper than one cheap one every year. So you are gaining financially.

So even if it did only relate to finances it could still be used. But it's not just financial.

Like the 'word' curate. Technically it's correct in most cases, but also feels like word overkill. So I do get what op is saying.

luckylavender · 05/03/2022 10:25

You can think that but in my experience it rarely pans out as expected.

pawpaws2022 · 05/03/2022 10:25

I would say "it was well worth me investing in X" but not that they're an investment. If that makes sense!
For instance I have a pair of ariat boots that I winced at buying. Now had them 12 years which is longer than any others, and they have been WELL worn Grin with water/horse muck/mud

ninnynonny · 05/03/2022 10:25

@hobstey

I'd personally keep it in PBs
Yes, probably right - can't be doing with all the faff!
merrymouse · 05/03/2022 10:24

Happy baby? Happy parents?

A baby doesn’t know anything about brands and the sling isn’t better than one that is much cheaper, so happier baby would be debatable.

Happy parents possibly, but as pp says, there is no difference in this case between investing and splashing out - it’s just that one is perceived to be more virtuous than the other.

People should just buy what they want to buy.

EatSleepRantRepeat · 05/03/2022 10:23

@PollyPage

My rokexes and vintage chanel bags could buy a house tomorrow. I must tell them that they are worthless. Maybe just chuck them away Biscuit
Their value rests completely in that company's brand manager. If one of their top tier is outed as a massive nazi or KKK member tomorrow, the brand can end up untouchable by the gen z's who like to buy this stuff second hand. Look at Russian brands at the moment.
LookItsMeAgain · 05/03/2022 10:23

@LimeSupper

Dictionary definition of investment: the action or process of investing money for profit.

Buying a handbag or expensive pair of work shoes to save you money over the long term is not an investment. It may well be spending your wisely though!

Why can't an investment also be seen as spending wisely?

For example - If I needed a handbag and I could pick up a decent enough bag for say £50 and the 'shelf life' of that handbag is maybe 2 years of daily use but I could spend £500 on something that would last 20 years of daily use, that would, to me be both spending wisely and an investment as I wouldn't have had to replace that handbag as frequently as the one for £50 (so not being wasteful by having more handbags that I would need) and economically I wouldn't have had to spend as much on handbags overall (thereby me having more money in the end in my pocket).
Does that make sense?

Similarly, if you're starting out on the road of having children, if you spend a lot on a baby carrier for #1, wouldn't that be seen as both spending wisely, and an investment if you can use it for #2 and #3 as you wouldn't have to buy again for them?

Or am I spectacularly missing the point here ???? Grin

Mundra · 05/03/2022 10:22

@allthegoodusernameshavegone

Well I don’t have any money, so I’m not investing, I’m out
Best comment!!
hobstey · 05/03/2022 10:22

Or put some into s&s

hobstey · 05/03/2022 10:21

I'd personally keep it in PBs

ninnynonny · 05/03/2022 10:20

I have a genuine question here. I have £17,000 in premium bonds at the moment.
It's obviously not enough to be life changing or even ever so useful while I'm working and managing, but we will probably need it in the future. What is the best investment for this amount - Rolex? Gold?

D0lphine · 05/03/2022 10:19

Some very high end fashion items increase in value (whereas normal clothes depreciate). just as some classic cars increase in value (where as the usual cars depreciate).

I think when people say they're making an investment in a winter coat or whatever, they mean an investment in themselves, ie they will be warm and look good this winter.

They don't mean it in a financial sense.

But there is also probably a justification element there too - "investment" sounds better than "splashing out" for example.

OpheliaThrupps · 05/03/2022 10:16

I'd be interested to see your ROI on that £500 baby sling. 🙄

Happy baby? Happy parents?

MissBPotter · 05/03/2022 10:15

Sorry I mean pp

MissBPotter · 05/03/2022 10:14

Actually do have clothing that I no longer fit into that I bought in the 80s that I was looking at EBay prices the other day and they have gone up.
I bought good quality and top designer brands of clothing mainly in their sales that I did wear for years. (Unfortunately no amount of dieting and exercise will push my ribcage back into position after Ds or Dd or both pushed my left side ribcage so it now sticks out at a strange angle when they were dancing away inside me)

That’s great @Kennykenkencat but it is unusual for someone to keep clothing items in good condition for 30-40 years. If you’ve managed to then brilliant, you are a better woman than me. I still think the word is well overused, so support the op. Especially overused by influencers, who will probably buy/be gifted four or five expensive handbags/coats etc rather than one and use it for years. Wine and Rolexes are different to clothes I’d say.

@Tulipomania I think op means £20 in the eighties which was probably a lot

VelvetChairGirl · 05/03/2022 10:14

I suppose I invested in a wok.

I could have got another frying pan after the surface of my last one ended up all ruined, but instead I went to a chinese shop and bought a proper chefs wok with a bamboo handle that I had to spend 3 days pissing about seasoning.

but now I never have to worry about scratched up teflon again.

Viviennemary · 05/03/2022 10:14

It annoys me too. Investing in the latest pricey upmarket handbag or designer clothing. Confused

BoredZelda · 05/03/2022 10:12

I take the point about metaphorical investment, but I do think people use it in a way to justify the purchase of expensive things.

It isn’t “metaphorical” it is the other definition of the word investment.

an act of devoting time, effort, or energy to a particular undertaking with the expectation of a worthwhile result.

Maybe you’ll be less irritated if you understand the word has more than one definition.

BoredBoredBoredB · 05/03/2022 10:11

The trouble is @Torak, what you are really complaining about is other people’s self-justification for their folly, I think. The actual definition of the word isn’t that important.
I did read that ‘it’s fuck all in a five-year plan’ was a way to justify any extravagance to your OH. I wouldn’t try it myself.

SilverGlassHare · 05/03/2022 10:10

@Tulipomania

Is anyone else wondering where you can buy a black skirt suitable for work for a fiver?

I think even £20 is cheap for a work skirt.

No, because the OP is obviously talking about buying the £20 skirt quite some time ago.