Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are the majority of people on here well-off?

332 replies

ThisBloodyNoiseInMyHead · 04/03/2022 20:13

As the title says, are most people on here financially well-off?

I've read about a woman who earns £32k a year, another who decorates every year, one who has got 1 4 bedroomed detached house, anther who has got a "budget" of £1 million to buy a house.

I live in a 1930s semi (mortgage paid), my husband earns £25k, I don't work (recovering from being very ill last year)and we haven't decorated for about 6 years. Am I the only working-class -strapped for cash- person on here?

OP posts:
sala7 · 10/03/2022 07:21

And why are you a “SmallestGiraffe” and then a “GiraffeinScarves”?

sala7 · 10/03/2022 07:18

“I find it sad that so many women don't pursue any financial independence and rely on men to provide for them”

Well what’s that got to do with this thread?

Just because you’re a single mum - so what? If you were in a two parent set-up, then obviously, that would determine how “well-off” you are. Eg. if he was a gambler with massive debts you would be less “well off.” If he earned many times what you earn, you would be much more “well off” have a totally different lifestyle. It is what it is Confused.

Imperfectp3rf3ction · 10/03/2022 05:41

They are rich but only because the buy 1 whole chicken at the beginning of January and it feeds their whole family all year round ( including Christmas Dinner) and they only do 1 load of washing a week =)

Rummikub · 10/03/2022 05:07

@TheSmallestGiraffe

This thread isn’t asking about what your job is.
I was responding to others posts saying they’re skint but they are paying lots into pension./ mortgage.

The relevance of ex being a teacher is that it’s well known they have decent pensions. We made choices as a family. Then those choices are taken away on divorce.
I work in education sector if you really must know.

And what’s your job/ role?

GiraffesInScarfs · 10/03/2022 04:01

@sala7

TheSmallestGiraffe - What is your point though? If you are married, of course your DH’s salary will affect how wealthy you are. Especially if you’re a SAHM.
It's just a bit lame really. Boasting about what somebody else does as if it's your own achievement. I find it sad that so many women don't pursue any financial independence and rely on men to provide for them.
TheSmallestGiraffe · 10/03/2022 03:59

[quote Landedonfeet]@TheSmallestGiraffe

What do YOU do?[/quote]
I'm a lone parent and I earn my own salary to support my children. I work in finance.

ufucoffee · 09/03/2022 20:18

[quote qualitygirl]@ufucoffee we are not in the U.K. [/quote]
Makes sense Grin

qualitygirl · 09/03/2022 20:09

@ufucoffee we are not in the U.K.

Freemymind · 09/03/2022 20:04

Assortative mating definitely happens. You choose a "partner" who you consider to be a peer in the social, economic, and educational sense. Sure you may be all that when you are child-free but when you have kids things change quite a bit - usually, someone pulls back and stays at home more and hence becomes a little less career-orientated - I know people from lots of different industries I don't recognise the pattern of either career focused or the 'little woman' maid...it's nonsense stereo typing

ufucoffee · 09/03/2022 19:59

@qualitygirl

I would consider us extremely comfortable and I'm very thankful .

Combined income of 116 (we just both had our annual 2.5%pay rise)
But we also have no mortgage or car payments.

The only bill that we HAVE to pay in the house is electricity. The rest is all by choice

We only pay for childcare if we need it. Do it is very little also

What about council tax and water?
PersephonePomegranate · 09/03/2022 19:49

I earn decent money but am pretty cash poor. Once childcare fees are done, I'll be in a much better place. I don't think my situation is at all unusual.

Babyroobs · 09/03/2022 19:48

@notanothertakeaway

On MN, a lot of children seem to attend private school, and lots of SAHM's with high flying DH
My heart is bleeding for these posters managing month to month with only a couple of rental properties to fall back on !!
Freemymind · 09/03/2022 19:47

@Babyroobs

No you're not. There seems to be a lot of high earners on here, but I'm sure there are many on less too. There was one poster the other day with a household income of 70k and worried about increases in bills. Honestly some people need to live in the real world. I now await loads of people saying 70k really isn't much to live on.
It depends where you live. ~The op sees herself as working-class living in a 1930's semi, her house is worth £180k, a 1930's semi would cost you £1.2mill where I live. £70k would comfortably buy the OPs but £70k around here would get you a one-bed flat if you were lucky.
Babyroobs · 09/03/2022 19:45

@SouperNoodle

We're an odd case as DH earns good money, I'm a SAHM, we live in a big detached house and are comfortable.

At the same time, our mortgage and bills are stupidly high, nursery fees are ridiculous and we can range from well off to extremely strapped for cash depending on what month it is.

If it's not a stupid question why would you be paying nursery fees if you are a sahm??
qualitygirl · 09/03/2022 19:44

I would consider us extremely comfortable and I'm very thankful .

Combined income of 116 (we just both had our annual 2.5%pay rise)
But we also have no mortgage or car payments.

The only bill that we HAVE to pay in the house is electricity. The rest is all by choice

We only pay for childcare if we need it. Do it is very little also

BambinaJAS · 09/03/2022 19:41

@Babyroobs

No you're not. There seems to be a lot of high earners on here, but I'm sure there are many on less too. There was one poster the other day with a household income of 70k and worried about increases in bills. Honestly some people need to live in the real world. I now await loads of people saying 70k really isn't much to live on.
70k is little if you live in London and you have kids.

Nursery fees are astronomical here.

Babyroobs · 09/03/2022 19:40

No you're not. There seems to be a lot of high earners on here, but I'm sure there are many on less too. There was one poster the other day with a household income of 70k and worried about increases in bills. Honestly some people need to live in the real world. I now await loads of people saying 70k really isn't much to live on.

BambinaJAS · 09/03/2022 19:37

@Freemymind

Intelligent men generally want to find similar, independent, intelligent women with careers, IME. But that's based on my industry. In others, perhaps some just look for the "little woman" to be the maid at home. You have a very simplistic way of seeing relationships...two categories, that's it? Career orientated or maid? Reductive - you think?
She is not wrong on the whole.

Assortative mating definitely happens. You choose a "partner" who you consider to be a peer in the social, economic, and educational sense.

The higher your income, the more you tend to look for.

BankingOnChange · 09/03/2022 19:27

Well off is subjective.

We're mid 30's. I work for a bank and earn £35k. DH is a taxi driver, self employed, and earns about the same. So household income about £70k.

So we out-earn you as a household...but we rent. And have no real chance of buying the size house we need (3dc) in this area. We could move 10 miles to a very, very undesirable area with awful awful schools and buy. So we have options...but it's not an option we'd take with the dc.

So chances are we'll be renting forever. Not much chance of a relaxing retirement in that case as we'll never be mortgage or rent free.

Freemymind · 09/03/2022 19:12

Intelligent men generally want to find similar, independent, intelligent women with careers, IME. But that's based on my industry. In others, perhaps some just look for the "little woman" to be the maid at home. You have a very simplistic way of seeing relationships...two categories, that's it? Career orientated or maid? Reductive - you think?

Freemymind · 09/03/2022 18:58

Where I live a 1930's semi is currently costing £1.2 M and to have that with no mortgage would feel very nice indeed.

5128gap · 09/03/2022 18:54

I think I'm well off although not a high earner by any means. But I don't live in London, benefitted from house price increases and downsized, so mortgage is small with repayments less than £200 a month. I don't have any credit debts, drive an old car, so no car loan, and have no dependent children anymore. I buy what I want and go where i please, because my tastes veer towards the cheaper end anyway, definitely high street rather than high end, and Aldi not Waitrose. I'm often shocked when people on here post pictures of clothes they're thinking of buying, jumpers for £50, dresses £100 or more, as I'd not pay that. I could afford to, but habits of a life time have me exclaiming 'how much???' On the other hand, I'm not worried that I'll have to turn the heating off or not be able to afford petrol, so relatively that makes me very well off indeed, and I'm grateful.

LeedleLee · 09/03/2022 18:28

We're definitely not well off. Our combined income is 45k after tax. There does seem to be an unusually high number of high earners (or people who at least claim they are), on MN though.

I remember a thread once where OP said she felt 'poor' on her husband's 250k a year salary Hmm

MrsDThomas · 09/03/2022 17:47

Working class. 4 bed detached small holding. Both of us work part time. Mortgage, youngest car is 8 years old. We have another 2 houses we rent out for well under what it should be, because who we have there are desperate but great tenants.

We could easily kick them out and sell both places then be hit with capital gains tax. Id rather live as we are than sell and pay a huge tax bill so we’ll stick to how we are and oass the houses on to the kids.

On paper we look great, in the bank we get by monthly.

LairyMaclary · 09/03/2022 10:10

We’re better off than a lot of people, two good salaries, we own our own home in the South East. But we have a significant mortgage on a £500k property and are really stretched by nursery costs, which down here are prohibitive. So that money doesn’t go as far as it should.

Swipe left for the next trending thread