Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU that school should scrap “Pen Licences”

135 replies

mumof2exhausted · 04/03/2022 18:15

I just don’t get how it’s still a thing, it’s just another way to single out children who struggle with fine motor skills. As long as their writing is neat and legible does it really matter that it’s not cursive?

OP posts:
Arucanafeather · 05/03/2022 03:40

But again on sports day being last is soon over and they’re onto next race. With the pen license, giving the certificate is similar as it’s i but then the ones who aren’t given a pen license towards the older years when most people have them stand out all day every day still writing in pencil.

Twitterwhooooo · 04/03/2022 23:25

I generally hate the way that writing in taught in primary, and I also blame Gove and his legacy.

I was looking through my old school books from the 1970s the other week. In those days, children could write a story or whatever and just have the odd spelling mistake circled with a tick and 'good work' at the end.

So much more relaxing that the multi-coloured marking that kids' writing is subjected to these days, along with suggestions to use '3E' sentences and the like.

sunshineandshowers40 · 04/03/2022 23:15

I dislike it too. Also not a fan of cursive writing.

BogRollBOGOF · 04/03/2022 23:13

I've got an 11 year old still using a bloody pencil in year 6 in contradiction to the advice from OTs and the dyslexia specialist. With Covid keeping parents conveniently at bay for 2 years (including the entirity of y5) I hadn't realised that this was occuring until recently and have managed to raise my concerns. DS has and always will have poor handwriting because of dyslexia, dyspraxia and hypermobility. He also has sensory processing disorder so we'll need to identify pens that are comfortable to hold and use because any cheapo biro won't necessarily be comfortable to grip. This will take trial and error and time which he is now rapidly running out of.

It's a ridiculous policy that actively penalises children with SENs that can not be incentivised into writing neatly, then deprives them of time to practice using the equipment that they will inevitably have to use in secondary school anyway.

Fortunately for him, he's great at maths and science because there's a lot of children with developmental conditions causing handwriting difficulties who also won't be finding glory in English, art or on the sports field.

Nothing wrong with praising good writing, but don't impede the children who struggle with it.

Having been introduced to pens (whole class) in y3 and using them full-time in y4 (as it wasn't back in the 80s) I hadn't known of this ridiculous concept prior to using MN.

Crumbleburntbits · 04/03/2022 23:04

This brings back memories of my (now adult) DC who never gained their pen license. I think they were using a pen at some point in year 6 but they never really mastered cursive writing. Poor handwriting hasn’t held them back in any way as they’re a junior doctor and it seems normal for doctors to be illegible!

NellePorter · 04/03/2022 22:51

I've never heard of this, they must not do it at my DC's primary.

WyfOfBathe · 04/03/2022 22:36

I don't understand pen licences. I used to live in France, where school children all write with pens, and it hasn't stopped French people from learning to write in cursive!

At my DC's school pen licenses can be earned during Year 5, and then in Year 6 all pupils use pen. No child is going to start using pen more than a few months after their classmates, so hopefully DC stand out less than at other schools. I still don't see the point of it though.

Fairislefandango · 04/03/2022 22:28

I don't know, it's kind of like should we scrap sports day or winning in football because some won't be able to? Of course not.

That's not a useful comparison at all. What is the justification in having to get a licence to use a pen instead of a pencil? If a child is happier with a pen amd writes as well with a pen, why on earth insist they're not allowed to use one? It's frankly baffling.

Summerfun54321 · 04/03/2022 22:25

Send him in with a pen and tell the teacher he got his license over the weekend 🤷‍♀️. The whole thing is so ridiculous I would be tempted to treat it the same way.

gogohm · 04/03/2022 22:25

My kids school didn't do this. They all used pens from year 5

Arucanafeather · 04/03/2022 22:24

Sorry that last post was in reply to pp saying that in their school pen licences were for early years but at some point in primary all kids got pens.

Arucanafeather · 04/03/2022 22:22

Not at my kids school. Both left/leaving year 6 with no pen license and having to write in pencil till they go to secondary school.

mumof2exhausted · 04/03/2022 22:06

@Obimumkinobi

I agree they should be scrapped. Children's efforts to improve their handwriting can be praised with positive comments in their exercise book or getting a more general "merit" point. This way, all children have a chance to get an award for something, instead of the daily reminder that you don't, and may never, measure up. With reading bands/free readers there are lots of levels - whereas the pen licence splits the class into "haves" and "have nots". My DC's school gave out licence "credit cards" which kids kept on their desks.
I agree with this so much. I’m fine with grading, streaming and book levels etc. My son has friends on higher book levels and he is fine with that as he is aware reading isn’t his strength but he’s brilliant at Maths but this bloody pen thing has no range. It’s have or have no and as the have nots have to write with a pencil it’s so obvious. And often there’s a physical reason which makes it more difficult.

It’s just all the more ridiculous as with the way the world is progressing hand writing just isn’t that important. I ironically love writing and when I was young I did a calligraphy course as loved it (I know weirdo) but it didn’t help me get my first at uni as shock horror I had to type up my dissertation and in the exams they couldn’t give a flying fuck about hand writing, more that I got the questions correct. Throughout lockdown / home learning all work was completed on computer and marked online.

OP posts:
Obimumkinobi · 04/03/2022 21:50

I agree they should be scrapped. Children's efforts to improve their handwriting can be praised with positive comments in their exercise book or getting a more general "merit" point. This way, all children have a chance to get an award for something, instead of the daily reminder that you don't, and may never, measure up.
With reading bands/free readers there are lots of levels - whereas the pen licence splits the class into "haves" and "have nots". My DC's school gave out licence "credit cards" which kids kept on their desks.

ItsAlwaysThere · 04/03/2022 21:49

@ItsAlwaysThere

My child's school do it but it isn't about neatest writing. It's stressed that it's about taking some extra care and showing that they're working on it. Even if handwriting isn't neat, if a child has been working hard on presentation, grip etc whatever it may be, they get the pen license.
They all do get one eventually, by a certain point in year 4.
Dimondsareforever · 04/03/2022 21:49

I voted yabu because there are lots of awards for a board range of subjects. (I am of course assuming your school is similar to ours). My dc struggles with most. She sees everyone in the class being a higher reading range, getting their time tables award etc … she felt down …. however, she was then the first to get her pen license in her year. This did her confidence the world of good. All children have different skills and abilities. Provided they are all catered for, then yabu.

ItsAlwaysThere · 04/03/2022 21:48

My child's school do it but it isn't about neatest writing. It's stressed that it's about taking some extra care and showing that they're working on it. Even if handwriting isn't neat, if a child has been working hard on presentation, grip etc whatever it may be, they get the pen license.

madeittofriday · 04/03/2022 21:45

We had pen licenses in the early 1980s!

Fridgeorflight · 04/03/2022 21:43

Not only does our school do pen licenses, but they revoke them at the end of each year and they have to be re-earnt. My eldest finds this tedious - she's now at the stage where her writing is definitely pen license worthy, so it's just a stupid process. My youngest had an early diagnosis of dysgraphia, which I think may not be correct, but I'm not holding out much hope for a pen licence. I didn't think much of it with my eldest, but it is giving me an insight into how difficult it is when you are an outlier.

Greenandcabbagelooking · 04/03/2022 21:43

I’m a teacher, although not one who gives out pen licenses, and I wouldn’t earn my pen license in my school.

My head saw my writing on the board during a learning walk, and noted that I need to write in joined up writing. I could, but it would take an age, be illegible and make me achy. My printing is lovely.

Arubaa · 04/03/2022 21:42

I'm not entirely sure the criteria for rewarding them in our school. My dd got hers in yr2 and I remember her being really happy about it but apparently there are still some children in her yr 4 class who still write in pencilHalo

CasperGutman · 04/03/2022 21:40

This is something I've only heard of on Mumsnet. It wasn't a thing in my own education in England in the 80s and 90s, and it isn't a thing in my children's education in Wales now. Thank goodness!

FairyCakeWings · 04/03/2022 21:38

@Arucanafeather

And taking the sports day analogy… it feels to me more like telling some children they’re too rubbish to take part. There is only 1 winner in a race but possible for all but 1 or 2 children in a class to get a pen license.
There’s only one person in a race that comes last though, and that person can be seen by everyone all at the same time.

Not every child will get their pen licence in the same term and by the time the majority have them the children have lost interest in who’s writing with what.

Hankunamatata · 04/03/2022 21:37

Urgh never realised the pain these were until my wee leftie start school. In the end the teacher agreed he could print as being dyslexic and left handed was not a good combo for him

notnowbernadette · 04/03/2022 21:35

Pen licences are overrated. DS stopped joining up his writing on day 1 at secondary school when nobody cared about handwriting and it's done him no harm at all.