Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU that school should scrap “Pen Licences”

135 replies

mumof2exhausted · 04/03/2022 18:15

I just don’t get how it’s still a thing, it’s just another way to single out children who struggle with fine motor skills. As long as their writing is neat and legible does it really matter that it’s not cursive?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Podlesterong · 13/11/2022 18:51

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

ChiaraRimini · 13/03/2022 11:35

Some kids are just not capable of developing good handwriting and it has nothing to do with academic ability. My DS age 22 still cannot do joined up writing. school got him permission to use a laptop for GCSE and A level exams and he is now at university studying for a healthcare MSc.
It really isn't a barrier to educational achievement.

Hearditintheplay · 13/03/2022 09:21

@Thewindwhispers

YANBU. It’s like attendance certificates: ritual humiliation of the children who need help.

Teachers underestimate how humiliated and hurt the children feel, and don’t realise that parents have to address this by explaining that the teacher is an unfair idiot following instructions from an incompetent government - not conducive to learning.

This rings very true unfortunately Sad

Not that I would call the teacher an idiot - but I did have to walk a very fine line between calling the whole thing ridiculous (and yes the name Michael Gove came up!) and trying to help them jump through the hoops so they’re not so miserable. Thanks for the advice offered - and glad it’s been resolved for you OP.

Thewindwhispers · 13/03/2022 09:16

YANBU. It’s like attendance certificates: ritual humiliation of the children who need help.

Teachers underestimate how humiliated and hurt the children feel, and don’t realise that parents have to address this by explaining that the teacher is an unfair idiot following instructions from an incompetent government - not conducive to learning.

twominutesmore · 12/03/2022 20:08

" went into school once on a parents afternoon and he was using a stub of a pencil with the grip on it...there were no full length pencils to be found in the classroom."

That's crazy. What reason did they give for not having any pencils in school??

The only time a child in my class might be writing with a short pencil is if they want to (some do) or if they have to wait a bit until I can get out of the classroom and to the stationery cupboard.

twominutesmore · 12/03/2022 20:06

"I guess pen licences are just another way to make SEN kids feel not good enough."

I think kids with hypermobility actually do find writing in pen much easier as they need less pressure. Use of a pen is often recommended by their OT.

It is tricky though if children's writing is neater and more legible, or they write faster, in pencil. Very hard to justify giving them a pen if they're going to slow down or produce writing that's not legible.

Nodancingshoes · 12/03/2022 16:25

My little boy never got one and he was gutted. He struggles with fine motor skills and had to use a pencil grip. I went into school once on a parents afternoon and he was using a stub of a pencil with the grip on it...there were no full length pencils to be found in the classroom. I guess pen licences are just another way to make SEN kids feel not good enough

twominutesmore · 12/03/2022 16:02

"My son is a leftie and just diagnosed with ADHD so struggles with handwriting. I was told in Autumn term that although he was exceeding/greater depth for all parts of English, as his handwriting isn't, he would be marked as emerging! Not sure if the official diagnosis changes this"

You need to challenge this. Handwriting alone definitely doesn't prevent a pupil from being considered greater depth.

Jonny1265 · 12/03/2022 09:55

I've never heard of this. My 4 children passed through primary without this being a thing.

yoshiblue · 12/03/2022 09:35

I really disagree with it, but blame the government, not schools.

My son is a leftie and just diagnosed with ADHD so struggles with handwriting. I was told in Autumn term that although he was exceeding/greater depth for all parts of English, as his handwriting isn't, he would be marked as emerging! Not sure if the official diagnosis changes this?

Personally I ignore government expectations and pen licence bollocks. I tell my son to try as best as he can and that's all I expect from him.

mumof2exhausted · 12/03/2022 09:33

@twominutesmore

"Also you can buy pens with erasers. They are brilliant."

You can but schools can't afford them and not fair to have some children - the ones with interested parents who are happy and able to buy them - using them while others don't imo.

Also, parents are often keen to provide the original pen but less keen to keep up with replacements.

Also, quality varies and some children would come in with leaky rubbish ones.

I think it's right that schools provide the pen.

But I'm glad your dc now has his pen. He must have been very close for your complaint to have worked. I'm pleased he's happy. I hope he didn't celebrate too loudly and make anyone else feel sad.

He was thrilled. They give them out at celebration assembly (this is kind of my issue with it as I feel they make too much fuss). The “certificate “ is crumbled in his bag, he’s not bothered about it at all. He is just happy he gets to use a pen like his friends.

Everyone in his class uses the pens with erasers - he was the one who told me about them! I’ve bought the good ones in bulk from Amazon. Understand that they are not an affordable option for everyone but I’ve never heard of them before so was really impressed.

OP posts:
twominutesmore · 12/03/2022 08:58

"Also you can buy pens with erasers. They are brilliant."

You can but schools can't afford them and not fair to have some children - the ones with interested parents who are happy and able to buy them - using them while others don't imo.

Also, parents are often keen to provide the original pen but less keen to keep up with replacements.

Also, quality varies and some children would come in with leaky rubbish ones.

I think it's right that schools provide the pen.

But I'm glad your dc now has his pen. He must have been very close for your complaint to have worked. I'm pleased he's happy. I hope he didn't celebrate too loudly and make anyone else feel sad.

twominutesmore · 12/03/2022 08:54

Yes I think it's awful when schools hand out licences too. Much better to quietly tell a child that they can use pen from now on. Unfortunately, the recipients are often so proud that it does become a bigger deal than the teacher might want.

I wouldn't want to recommend a book to you in case it was the wrong one for your school, but then I don't think you actually need to spend any money. Ask the school for a sheet showing their preferred handwriting style - they'll easily be able to do this, and then you need only practise the letter formation and joins. If they use specific handwriting workbooks, ask if you can have one or offer to buy one from them (I've given these to parents before now).

Yes lots of people have said to give everyone a pen but it wouldn't work, it really wouldn't, and I am not in the game of making children sad. I have seen children writing 10x slower when using a pen, crossing out to the point their work is illegible, crying because they've made mistakes that are now permanent and can't be erased, letters so big they take up two or three lines on the page. Some children are, for now, doing better work with a pencil, whether they realise it or not.

The coolest kid in my class is the one who happily uses a pencil and loudly tells everyone they're mad to write in pen. He says they're always running out and you can't erase your writing. He does a hard sell on pencil that has obviously come from his mum.

mumof2exhausted · 12/03/2022 08:54

@Hearditintheplay

Hi *@twominutesmore* thank you for this - I am definitely going to speak to the teacher about what is required. I am not a teacher (or an objective judge!) but DC’s writing honestly looks fine to me - neat and well formed - so it would be good to know what the reasons are. I think it might be something to do with not joining up consistently?

And yes I would like to help them at home - are there any handwriting books you’d recommend by any chance?

In terms of how else you could do it, there seem to be other examples on this thread - just not having pen licenses seems the most obvious, so it’s not made into a big ceremony/prize. Or all kids are just given a pen eg at the beginning of year 5...

I spoke to his teacher last week - explained he was getting genuinely upset and totally demoralised…. He got his pen licence thus week.

He’s already said “wow writing joined up with a pen is so much easier as he doesn’t have to press down”.

Also you can buy pens with erasers. They are brilliant.

OP posts:
HikingforScenery · 12/03/2022 08:53

I agree with you OP.

Hearditintheplay · 12/03/2022 08:37

Hi @twominutesmore thank you for this - I am definitely going to speak to the teacher about what is required. I am not a teacher (or an objective judge!) but DC’s writing honestly looks fine to me - neat and well formed - so it would be good to know what the reasons are. I think it might be something to do with not joining up consistently?

And yes I would like to help them at home - are there any handwriting books you’d recommend by any chance?

In terms of how else you could do it, there seem to be other examples on this thread - just not having pen licenses seems the most obvious, so it’s not made into a big ceremony/prize. Or all kids are just given a pen eg at the beginning of year 5...

twominutesmore · 12/03/2022 07:35

Have you thought about finding out what the school's requirements are for a child to use a pen and then helping your child to practise at home?

In my school they need to be writing legibly and without the need to rub out a lot. If a child needs to rub out every third word, then they are better using a pencil.

I periodically give the whole class a pen to see if they rise to the challenge but if their work is illegible due to crossing out then it's better for them to have a pencil I think.

I would be open to suggestions for how else I could do it though. I posted earlier on the thread. No teacher wants to be responsible for children feeling disappointed.

Hearditintheplay · 11/03/2022 21:31

I realise this thread is a week old but I just had to comment after spending most of this evening comforting my DC who was absolutely devastated not to get a pen license today Sad

They are now one of the only ones in their class not to have one (despite handwriting being fine as far as I can tell) and are dreading Monday when they will be surrounded by peers using pens and will feel ‘left out’.

Analogies with sports days are completely inappropriate as this is something that impacts everyday learning and marks some pupils out as inadequate by this standard. I think I am going to speak to the school about it, not that I’m expecting it to change but I feel so strongly that it’s wrong - competitive, exclusionary and doesn’t seem to have much to do with education!

Crunchymum · 05/03/2022 14:31

Oldest DC is Y4. They all use pen.

Surely this is the easiest and fairest way?

MajesticElephant · 05/03/2022 14:21

@sunflower1988

Primary teacher - blame Michael Gove (I like to for everything) as part of his curriculum 'reforms' he made it an expectation that pupils would be able to write in cursive, therefore schools have to encourage it ( my school made it a requirement that teachers would write in cursive and displays would be) Obviously no thought to the fact it actively disadvantages children with a SEN, fine motor skill issues, dyslexia ect... Why would they matter Angry
I’m not sure why we are blaming Gove? Both cursive writing for SATs and pen licences were a thing when I was at primary school over 25 years ago…
nothingcomestonothing · 05/03/2022 14:17

Urgh I hated this with DD, they were made to go and demonstrate their writing to the head before being awarded the pen licence. DD was told she was 'really really close' umpteen times for two academic years. By the start of year 6 I'd had enough, went to the head and asked what exactly she needed to do to get the sodding thing, as being told she was almost there but not quite for so long was destroying her confidence. She got one that week.

CallyfromBlakes7 · 05/03/2022 14:01

Handwriting is just writing. As long as it’s legible and neat that should be enough. It’s what you write not what it looks like

But that's all it was. DS had the neatest, most legible writing so he got his pen licence. The others soon caught up. It was nothing to do with being calligraphic (if that is a word!)

CallyfromBlakes7 · 05/03/2022 14:00

Bizarre and outdated expectations especially in a world where as adults we write everything on devices for the most part

Exams are still done by hand though aren't they. But maybe they won't be for current infant school aged kids. University exams seem to be online now.

CallyfromBlakes7 · 05/03/2022 13:57

My ds who definitely wasn't ahead on physical skills was the first in his year to get his pen licence.

The reason was he was obsessed with football and imagined his own leagues and spent hours and hours and hours writing out his own football leagues and teams and results! It also meant he had heard of fairly obscure (to primary aged kids in the south of England) places such as Alloa and Arbroath.

So his handwriting was better than his peers. For a few weeks, anyway.

I don't think that it is any more discriminatory than (staff) choosing the kids who are better at sport for teams or music for concerts or artwork to put on the school walls for parents' evenings.

twominutesmore · 05/03/2022 13:56

I'd genuinely love some ideas on how this could be done differently, ideas that I can take to my Head.

There are some children who can't effectively use a pen yet - legible in pencil but not in pen, many errors and crossing out, get upset if cant erase mistakes, smudge their work.

How do we allow some children to use a pen but not others? Without it being hard on the ones who can't.

Swipe left for the next trending thread