Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Daughters school not doing world book day

217 replies

Bibbitybobbityboo86 · 04/03/2022 18:14

So my daughters school never do world book day - AIBU to be disappointed?
I imagine some parents will be relieved but my daughter gets upset when she sees the costumes in Sainsbury’s or sees other kids in their costumes.

It’s not just world book day- it’s also children in need & Red Nose Day. The school won’t do anything in fact none of it even gets mentioned - it’s like it’s not happening.

Would you feel disappointed?

WIBU for me to contact the head teacher and ask why? I don’t want to be that parent

I’ve mentioned it to other parents and they agree and say it’s a shame but they don’t seem as bothered by it as me

OP posts:
NellePorter · 05/03/2022 16:38

Sounds like a great school, these events can be very stressful for some parents, and not great for the environment. You could encourage your children yourself to fundraise for Children in Need and Comic Relief, get the packs from their websites. Some libraries and bookshops run events for WBD, get them dressed up and take them there. Or even just to borrow/buy a book. Organise a second hand book collection/stall ... there really are lots of things you could do if you feel like they're missing out.

Sirzy · 05/03/2022 16:29

Dressing up as a character from a book (or more likely a Disney Princess or super hero!) isn’t going to create a love of reading. It just creates issues for families who can’t do it.

World book day should focus on books and reading for pleasure not who can make the best costume!

Pumperthepumper · 05/03/2022 16:22

@Bibbitybobbityboo86

I feel sorry for kids that miss out on things due to not having the money or the parents just not having time. I imagine there’s some parents that can’t be bothered It’s a shame
I’m a teacher and I can’t be bothered. I’d be surprised if making a costume for a very specific theme fills anyone with joy tbh.
slaybell · 05/03/2022 16:12

Our school does it but have a theme each year which utilises clothes you generally already have. This years' theme was 'dress as bright as you can'. It's brilliant because we can just use their own clothes and no need to go out and buy tacky costumes they will only wear once!

Wafflesnsniffles · 05/03/2022 16:09

No book day, no children in need, no red nose day - Id be delighted tbh. So much less single use tat!
Many many better ways to raise money. Plus I dont support child in need or red nose day so dont want to feel obliged to contribute.

AuntFlorence · 05/03/2022 16:00

There aren't at the school the op's kids go though, I do agree some schools go way overboard which is a big expectation on overburdened parents, but to never do dress up days also seems really joyless. & I have been both the poor kid the poor parent. I get financial restraints. I get that when they have to wear stripes and work finishes after the charity shops shut and the supermarket ones are too expensive and your feet hurt and it's raining it's hard to think of a way to send them in stripy. And they might look silly with stripes drawn all over them and an old top in marker pen. I get all of that and I still think we need dress up days sometimes. In the same way that we need Christmas lights and fireworks and poetry and drama and music and all the other things that are a finger up to the relentless quicksand of joyless misery that comes from all sides and tries to suppress your lightness and energy. We need the joy more when times are hard.

ChampagneLassie · 05/03/2022 15:56

Someone else may have said this and I might have missed this but WBD own stats "1 in 5 children receiving free school meals said the book they ‘bought’ with their WBD book token was the first book they had of their own" - suggest that this is good thing for poorer children. I do expecting kids to come in costumes is incredibly unfair - design and make something in school or have a dressing up box that could be re-used year on year.

thewhatsit · 05/03/2022 15:54

And also I always make my DC’s own costumes at home but this doesn’t make it particularly environmentally friendly either. Eg I’ve had to buy plain T shirts of the right colour in order to sew and stick on bits to or you pick up a few random accessories to add to an outfit, buy materials and craft things even if just packs of Pom poms or felt or buttons.

Yes the whole thing feels more wholesome and less consumerist but it’s still just buying things I wouldn’t have otherwise that are destined to lie in landfill for a thousand years. Some of these dress up days have been hugely enjoyable for DC so that feels worth the effort and waste but some of the themed days are not at all (mini beast day ..)

I think schools should all have to have environmental goals and pledges and try to work to reducing waste. Maybe the weeks before the dress up days parents should be encouraged to bring old costumes, old toys, accessories etc into school for swaps.

notacooldad · 05/03/2022 15:44

I would have been so happy if our primary school didn’t do WBD, as well as all the other stuff apart from the cHristmad fair.
I hated doing them and the lads weren’t fussed either!

PinkSyCo · 05/03/2022 15:40

I feel sorry for kids that miss out on things due to not having the money or the parents just not having time. I imagine there’s some parents that can’t be bothered
It’s a shame

That’s a bit patronising. Just because parents don’t have the time/ability/materials to make something or the money or want to buy a one time wear outfit does not mean that their kids miss out on a fun childhood.

thewhatsit · 05/03/2022 15:39

Our school doesn’t do comic relief or children in need but we have started doing dress up for WBD in the last few years AND a whole raft of other things at least twice a term (dress up in the colours of the French flag! Dress up as a mini beast! Etc etc).
I find it surprising as the waste produced on these days must be astronomical and I find it confusing that instead of moving away from that we’re now actually encouraging it.

Prior to this our school did WBD in a (IMO) better way - author visits, children bringing in their favourite books to share with the class, visits between older and younger classes to share books and read to each other. I wish we would go back to that if only to stop the extra Amazon costumes that will end in landfill.

HikingforScenery · 05/03/2022 15:28

Our school goes on dressing up as a word. So all black for mysterious, intelligencer, etc

Our school used to dress up and characters and I hated this days tbh not because of money at all but mine would not wear dress up much outside school and I hated the waste. I’d to negotiate with DC on what they wanted to wear and what we could create together.
I’m very pleased they change to our current one

SE13Mummy · 05/03/2022 15:15

The school I teach in joins in with WBD but it's low key and is much more about a book-themed day than dressing up. This year, some children made masks or hats related to characters in the book their class is currently studying, others made scenes from the book using shoeboxes, another class used clay to make the characters. We arrange to collect the WBD books from a local independent book shop and set up our own 'shop' in school so each child can choose the book they'd like which means everyone gets one but at no extra cost or hassle to their family. Children (or parents) who are keen to dress up for WBD are very welcome to but it's not a big element of the day.

amnm · 05/03/2022 14:55

I agree with the head to be honest. So many schools make a huge fuss for World Book day, make a big deal with teachers in fancy costumes (that most of the time are based on how the character is portrayed in films, not in the related book!!) but make zero link to the actual purpose of the day which is to encourage reading.

Bibbitybobbityboo86 · 05/03/2022 14:51

I feel sorry for kids that miss out on things due to not having the money or the parents just not having time. I imagine there’s some parents that can’t be bothered
It’s a shame

OP posts:
BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation · 05/03/2022 14:34

I'm autistic with adhd and can't make costumes or do anything like that. It totally defeats me. I spent all my executive function on keeping body and soul together. I used to keep them off sometimes if it got too complicated (dress like a Roman day for example).

Kanaloa · 05/03/2022 14:34

@AuntFlorence

It's not all the time though is it it's one day a year And it's not crazzeee fun it's just a bit of dressing up and some book related activities and a book voucher.
It’s not only one day a year. It’s world book day, and it’s the hallowe’en dress up day, and then Christmas jumper day, and a few days later Christmas non uniform day, and Red Nose Day, and ‘children in need’ wear spots day, and crazy hair day, and odd socks day, and school fundraising day where you have to wear your special class colour (which is never blue or red, it’s always orange or violet or some obscure colour). After that it will be dress as an ancient Roman, and evacuee dress up day, and wear red and white for St George’s day, and pyjama day…

Saying it’s ‘just one day’ is so dismissive. Maybe until you’ve been the child who isn’t involved because your parents can’t be bothered/can’t afford it, you just simply won’t understand how pointlessly exclusive all this stuff is.

The ‘benefit’ of these events for some children simply does not outweigh the damage it does to others. Not when there are much better ways to encourage reading and community involvement anyway. What about a walk to the library for world book day? Or a chapter a day from a class book every day then on world book day a project of making a display about that book? Actual lesson plans focusing on a book would be much more beneficial than a supermarket Roald Dahl costume.

Kanaloa · 05/03/2022 14:26

@RicStar

My kids really like WBD, almost no kids wear bought costumes at their school , its a sea of anti consumerist home made items here- although its a very mixed demographic indeed. The school encourages home made costumes for cost / environmental reasons - it does require some parental engagement to get a costumes together. The kids love talking and comparing costumes and on a dull March day it was nice, fun but learning was still normal. I think its hard for schools to change from one side to the other, parents all hate change!. I dont think its wrong for OP to wish her child school did these things, but I think you have to accept all schools are different.
If anything I think this is worse. The expense and effort of hand making a costume is even more than buying one, and the type of parent who won’t (or can’t) drop £15 on a Harry Potter costume definitely won’t (or won’t be able to) research book characters to dress as, buy crafting or sewing materials, make use of clothes that can be made into something else etc.
BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation · 05/03/2022 14:20

@AuntFlorence dressing up isn't just for one day a year though is it? If I remember correctly there are: non uniform days (bring money in), wear x colour days (bring money in), children in need (bring money in), Easter hat, Halloween, xmas jumper day and god knows how many more depending on each school. It used to cost me a fortune to send ds1 to school. Ds2's weren't so bad as his school wasn't as grabby.

Liverbird77 · 05/03/2022 12:38

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

tsmainsqueeze · 05/03/2022 12:35

I think the head has the right idea , there is no need for a school to ask for families to do anything for wbday .
I think it is great for books to be recognised on one day a year for the wonderful amazing things they are but a school can do this with their own resources alone .
No cost for teacher reading stories , no cost for watching the film of a book ie Matilda , Railway children , paint pictures of a book character and fill the room with them , so much could be achieved with just a bit of imagination and no cost to a family or the school , all children having the same experience of the day with no difficulty or embarrassment .
Same with bbc charity ,all that plastic crap ,hype etc i hate giving to them.
I would prefer to be asked for money as little as possible and if i am i want it to be used directly in school or given to a local charity .

AuntFlorence · 05/03/2022 12:01

It's not all the time though is it it's one day a year
And it's not crazzeee fun it's just a bit of dressing up and some book related activities and a book voucher.

NeverAgainSam · 05/03/2022 11:54

@BeHappy91818

The school sounds crap to be honest.
Really? Fucking hell? Do you make so many sweeping judgements on so little evidence on all elements of your life?
TheWitchCirce · 05/03/2022 11:50

Most books that we share with children are real children in real clothes, and we encouraged our classes to use their own clothes to look as though they'd stepped out of the pages of a book. They could find a magnificent stick and be Stanley from Stanley's stick in any clothes at all; they could wear their prettiest hijab and be Rumaysa etc

The day was more about a celebration of reading and a chance to come off timetable and read in different places and spaces and talk about books.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 05/03/2022 11:23

My husband recalls reading an interview with a children's author who said he'd purposely created a character who always wears a t-shirt and jeans so that almost any child could dress up as this character on WBD. Unfortunately he cant remember who the author was, but maybe that will help somebody here for next year! Could almost be Harry Potter in the school holidays, if you can put a lightning mark on the forehead with a pen.