Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Not to pay childminders travel expenses

310 replies

AdviceNeeded367 · 04/03/2022 16:22

Last summer, Childminder asked for an extra £10 per week to help pay for activities while she has DS.

In December, she demanded a 27% payrise.

Today she has demanded a 45p per mile travel expense.

AIBU to tell her a flat No?

OP posts:
OfstedOffred · 04/03/2022 17:35

It doesnt matter what it costs her or whether she previously had a full time job & would do it for less.

It is supply and demand. She is willing to provide a service that you need. She is entitled to charge as much as possible - she isn't a charity.

There's a price point at which you will find you can get what you need elsewhere for less. At that point she's charging too much and you can vote with your feet

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 04/03/2022 17:35

A nanny is employed by you and works at your house. You do tax and NI and pay expenses. Usually you offer a salary and they decide whether to accept it and work for you.

A CM is self employed and works from their house/ place of business. They do their own tax, NI etc. They charge their set fees, and you decide whether to accept them and send you child to their setting. They are Ofsted registered.

RedWingBoots · 04/03/2022 17:34

@CoastalWave as I said there is nothing stopping you do the same or a similar role. Personally I can't stand looking after other people's children for that long.

C8H10N4O2 · 04/03/2022 17:33

But putting it another way - she's working 4 weekends and getting over £1200 a month. For working 2 days a week

Two days and two nights continuous care with no breaks. Not two * eight hour days.

Faevern · 04/03/2022 17:32

I think you’ve had a cheap deal previously and I wouldn’t be squabbling over £20 if my SEN child had a trusted person. How much would it cost you to drop off DC?

I do understand that costs are rising for you too and it’s two rises in quick succession. Do you get the full amount of DLA to help towards it, can you use direct payments to top up? If she gets £310 how much does it actually cost you?

DysmalRadius · 04/03/2022 17:31

The minimum wage requirements don't apply if an employee is expected to spend some of their 'work time' sleeping, so I think you need to work out what her actual hourly rate is and consider if it is reasonable /affordable to add an additional £18 per week to cover her travel.

Simonjt · 04/03/2022 17:30

Employee sorry, not employer.

C8H10N4O2 · 04/03/2022 17:30

Is 45p per mile seriously how much more petrol costs now??

Its the standard rate set by HMRC for claiming expenses for fuel where mileage is less than 10,000 miles per year. That reflects fuel and wear and tear on the car but also hasn't been updated in years.

How often do you employ her? If its 3-4 times per year for respite then surely she is providing a service and should invoice you? If its every weekend then it could be either. If its in her own home I'd have thought she was a childminder and would invoice.

IME nannies do not take the child to their own home but I was never using a nanny for respite so maybe the rules are different. I did always pay all costs of outings and travel with the children.

I get your point about an hourly rate for day time and flat rate for night but the total for the weekend still doesn't seem high.

Simonjt · 04/03/2022 17:30

@AdviceNeeded367

She is only “an employee” as she does not want the faff of being self employed. I use a nanny tax service for wages slips, tax calcs, NICs etc

Which is another expense on top of everything else.

So you’re actually declaring that you’re failing to pay the national minimum wage, so your employer has a lovely paper trail when she asks for all of her earnings owed to her for her entire time in employment.
OfstedOffred · 04/03/2022 17:29

Doesnt really matter what she calls different parts of the fee.

What's the total you are paying. Can you get this service somewhere else for this price?

It doesn't sound like much tbh for a full weekend respite care for a child with SEN, including overnight AND pick up/drop off.

cultkid · 04/03/2022 17:29

It's not just the petrol it's the insurance the wear and tear and the road tax

I don't think you'll find anyone to do this for less then her

You need to pay the money.

RedWingBoots · 04/03/2022 17:29

OP when she walks because she can find another family who can pay her more, what are you going to do?

MyOtherProfile · 04/03/2022 17:29

I get paid 48p a mile for my job as an advisory teacher so her rate seems fair.

Also, she is coming and collecting him and bringing him home again after a weekend of childminding him. I would think it's fair for you to pay her petrol for this. Perhaps you need to look again at the charge for a weekend. Keep it separate from the petrol charge.

CoastalWave · 04/03/2022 17:29

[quote RedWingBoots]@CoastalWave nothing is stopping you becoming an overnight baby sitter. You would get more than £6.50 per hour for NT children but the work is unlikely to be regular.[/quote]
But putting it another way - she's working 4 weekends and getting over £1200 a month. For working 2 days a week.

That's not low.

SuperSocks · 04/03/2022 17:28

@AdviceNeeded367

She lives about 20 miles away and takes DS to her house. It’s regular but not frequent.

She is employed by me on the basis like as a Nanny.

That's illegal, assuming she has him for more than 2 hours at a time. She needs to register with OFSTED and have her home approved as a suitable setting and start u a childminding business, or come to work for you at your house as a nanny.
betwixtlives · 04/03/2022 17:27

@AdviceNeeded367

She is only “an employee” as she does not want the faff of being self employed. I use a nanny tax service for wages slips, tax calcs, NICs etc

Which is another expense on top of everything else.

oh fgs are you for real? you’re complaining about ‘another expense’ when you’re paying this woman less than minimum wage? You can’t HONESTLY think you’re being reasonable here
lockdownalli · 04/03/2022 17:27

So when you submit her hours to the nanny service, are you reducing them in order to hide the fact you are paying her less than minimum wage? I am still really confused.

QforCucumber · 04/03/2022 17:26

45p a mile is the allowable expenses claim for employees who travel for work purposes. She is employed and is able to claim mileage at this rate, by law.

AdviceNeeded367 · 04/03/2022 17:25

I think it’s a valid point re the evolution of the role. When it first started she had a FT job and so it was just pocket money. Now she does not and only has a low income, I think things are different.

OP posts:
Sirzy · 04/03/2022 17:25

www.gov.uk/expenses-and-benefits-business-travel-mileage/rules-for-tax

45p a mile is standard rate

Jamnation · 04/03/2022 17:25

45p is standard business rate, has been for years. It covers a contribution towards wear and tear, be wise the journey contributes towards wear and tear.

Rickrollme · 04/03/2022 17:24

OP you said you “agreed to pay her as an employee.” This is a good example of what you are misunderstanding. This woman is your employee. It’s not a choice, it is based on the duties and terms of the job. You are legally obligated to pay her as your employee and that includes mileage.

You are very caught up in the fact that she asked for a certain rate but that’s irrelevant. Look at the total amount she wants now, including mileage and anything else you are legally obligated to pay, and ask yourself: can you find someone else to do this job to your standards for the price you are willing to pay? It seems to me it would be difficult to find someone who will be as good to your son and take him for the whole weekend for such low pay but if you can then go ahead and tell her no.

AskingforaBaskin · 04/03/2022 17:24

@AdviceNeeded367

She is only “an employee” as she does not want the faff of being self employed. I use a nanny tax service for wages slips, tax calcs, NICs etc

Which is another expense on top of everything else.

You do know you have two choices right?

So what is plan B if she walks?

RedWingBoots · 04/03/2022 17:24

@AdviceNeeded367 45p per mile covers not only petrol but wear and tear of the car.

AdviceNeeded367 · 04/03/2022 17:23

She is only “an employee” as she does not want the faff of being self employed. I use a nanny tax service for wages slips, tax calcs, NICs etc

Which is another expense on top of everything else.

OP posts: