Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Not to pay childminders travel expenses

310 replies

AdviceNeeded367 · 04/03/2022 16:22

Last summer, Childminder asked for an extra £10 per week to help pay for activities while she has DS.

In December, she demanded a 27% payrise.

Today she has demanded a 45p per mile travel expense.

AIBU to tell her a flat No?

OP posts:
AmyDudley · 04/03/2022 19:43

*Oh the staff are just so demanding nowadays.

Maybe you can find a refugee to be an au-pair for you, they’ll surely be grateful just to have a roof over their head.*

That's a pretty shitty remark to make. Did you miss the bit where Op says she has a child with SEN and she pays for respite care so she can have a break? Do you know what her child's care needs are, or how much she needs a break sometimes so she can care for her child without being exhausted. You write as if she is some kind of spoilt lady of the manor. You do understand that everyone you pay for any kind of service, be it a plumber, a hairdresser, a shopworker is essentially 'staff' of a variety in that you are buying a service from them? It doesn'tt mean you think you are royalty. It is how the world works we all buy and provide services. Whatever your opinion on the Cm's price rise, your attitude towards the OP stinks and I think you owe her an apology.

Nanny0gg · 04/03/2022 19:39

@Aimzxo

I think it depends on the child minder, my child minder doesn't charge for petrol, she doesn't even charge for activities any activities she takes the children on she pays for out of her own pocket, I'd be happy to pay her I even offered to but she wouldn't accept, I pay 2 pound for a hot dinner or I can send a pack lunch, I guess each child minder has their own rules, I'd be abit irked but I suppose the only option you have is to use a different child minder, mine also hasn't raised her fees in 2 years, unless mine is a rare lovely breed lol xz
But she's not a childminder.

She's a nanny in her own home

blublub · 04/03/2022 19:38

Are you crazy? ‘Adjust your household budget so she doesn’t have to’?! I have heard some cheeky things in my time, but I am astounded. She has to request more because clearly she is just scrapping by on this amount and things are going up for her too as well as you, so to keep in the same underpaid place she needs more money. She isn’t getting more she’s staying the same by the sounds of it.

You are employing someone below minimum wage who will drive a ridiculous way there and back for you. As others have said, why don’t you try an agency for a price comparison and see what a great deal you’re getting. Oh and stop exploiting someone!! You really are taking advantage of this poor woman. It’s a proper job you’re expecting , with the amazing perk of being driven there and back. You should be counting your lucky stars and valuing her accordingly. She isn’t baby sitting but giving up her weekends.

Cameleongirl · 04/03/2022 19:31

I have no idea whether it’s a bargain for weekend respite care or not-the OP needs to do some research on this. I personally wouldn’t begrudge paying travel costs.

Different scenario as it’s for young adults not a child, but @yumscrumfatbum said this was typical for her area:

The flat rate for overnight respite in your own home is £60 for a 24 hour period. Expenses such as outings are billed for additionally. The £60 includes food and all utilities. Parents are expected to drop off and collect to and from the carers home. Petrol is billed if it is a journey taken specifically for the individual rather myself or my family

The OP pays about 2.5x that.

AdviceNeeded367 · 04/03/2022 19:28

You’re right, it isn’t a huge amount, but the cost of living is going to continue to go up and it’s only a matter of time before she says that she has to be paid £20 an hour and I guess that I’m just annoyed that I have to adjust my household budget so that she doesn’t have to.

OP posts:
florianfortescue · 04/03/2022 19:19

She's within her rights to ask (or "demand" as you keep putting it). You're within your rights to say no.

Personally for the sake of £18 a time (assuming you pay 45p per mile for 80 miles of travel) I'd suck it up. She obviously has a good relationship with your kid and you won't be able to replace her easily. In the context of the £300+ per weekend it's not a huge amount.

BoredZelda · 04/03/2022 19:10

Oh the staff are just so demanding nowadays.

Maybe you can find a refugee to be an au-pair for you, they’ll surely be grateful just to have a roof over their head.

Tillow4ever · 04/03/2022 19:08

Plenty of people have commented advising on the money side, so I won't pile on too - you've heard it!

Have you checked that she has the appropriate car insurance if she's driving your child in it? Presumably she needs business insurance for this? What about any insurance or licenses she needs for having your child in her home? It might not seem a problem for occasional weekends, but what happens if there's a car accident? Or if something happens in her home? God forbid, if there's a serious accident leaving your child with permanent injuries that could change their life, you want to know there's insurance in place to pay for anything they might need as a result!

Alandinasane · 04/03/2022 19:06

You've got a bargain there Op!

Cameleongirl · 04/03/2022 19:05

How often does she provide this weekend respite care? Is it once a month or more?

ButtockUp · 04/03/2022 19:03

You're being messed about.

AdviceNeeded367 · 04/03/2022 19:01

Thank you all for your comments. It’s definitely given me food for thought.

I accept that I’m unreasonable for not wanting to pay the requested travel costs and will agree to pay them.

The arrangement was very causal to start off with and then having it made more official has been a bit of a headache as it was always supposed to be on the basis that she would be self employed and because I have no choice, I’ve had to become her employer and do all the nanny tax stuff.

The pay increase in December was originally on the basis of her becoming a self employed CM, as she had done some sums considering her higher living expenses etc, putting an amount aside for holidays etc. Then a few weeks later when the changes were supposed to be put in place, she told me that she no longer wanted to be self employed and that I’d have to continue being her employer but that she still wanted the increased rate and there was no compromise to be had.

And again, her message to me today was very formal and was not asking me but telling me that she’ll be charging me 45p per mile from now on.

She’s just rubbed me up the wrong way with her demands I think.

OP posts:
misssunshine4040 · 04/03/2022 19:01

@AdviceNeeded367

She is only “an employee” as she does not want the faff of being self employed. I use a nanny tax service for wages slips, tax calcs, NICs etc

Which is another expense on top of everything else.

You do understand that you are not doing her a favour? It's not her concern what your costs are.

If you value her service and want to keep her, pay her and do not sour the relationship.

You sound very out of touch with how difficult decent quality childcare is and how much is costs.

You have found someone who is willing to have your child in her own home all weekend from pick up to drop off and she just wants her petrol paid.

ButtockUp · 04/03/2022 19:00

I'm a bit gobsmacked at the responses to my post.
I'm just going by a sudden 27% increase in prices.

It's a considerable amount. If the childminder was happy with the previous price, prior to the news about inflation for this current year, then a 27% increase is a huge amount.

Most folk would vote with their feet.
Given that a current thread is all about people giving up hairdressers, nail technicians, cleaners , gardeners .. all of whom are asking for a modest increase but are being dumped ... I don't know why a nanny/childminder, who is asking for a massive increase , should be any different.

bluebird3 · 04/03/2022 18:56

I think that a lot of people are unfamiliar with respite care and getting hung up on the technicalities that aren't really relevant to your question.

She is not unreasonable to name the price she feels her time is worth. You are not unreasonable if you feel the service is not worth that. Nobody is forcing you to employ her or her to take the respite role.

All you have to do is decide how much the service is worth to you. Offer her that and she can either accept or decline. If you do this then she may decline and you will lose the respite care.

notthemum · 04/03/2022 18:48

Op, having read further into the thread I am becoming increasingly concerned . You say that she is on payroll, you pay tax and national insurance for her.
Therefore you should be paying her petrol, any money for outings and activities that she does with your child because she is your employee.
She also needs to be working at your home NOT hers.
There are extremely strict rules for childminders (childcarers who look after children in the childcarers home) especially regarding overnight care. Her home would need to be inspected and Ofsted would be involved.
There are strict monetary penalties for childcarers and parents who break the law.

Kazzyhoward · 04/03/2022 18:48

@Nocutenamesleft

Is she employed. Or self employed

If she’s employed. You pay mileage.

If she’s self employed. She Claims it on taxes…..

No, self employed charge their clients for mileage if that's part of the job. HMRC don't pay it. I have clients who are solicitors, consultants, engineers, translators, decorators, house-sitters, caterers, etc who all charge their clients for mileage on their invoices which had be pre-agreed as part of their quotation/contract etc. I've always charged my clients mileage to their premises if they didn't want to come to my office (accountant).
Kazzyhoward · 04/03/2022 18:44

@AdviceNeeded367

She is only “an employee” as she does not want the faff of being self employed. I use a nanny tax service for wages slips, tax calcs, NICs etc

Which is another expense on top of everything else.

She IS an employee because what she does for you ISN'T self employment (i.e. being in business). Have a look at the HMRC website which has an employment versus self employment questionnaire. As an employer, YOU do have to pay employers NIC, employer's pension, PLUS holiday pay, sickness/maternity pay, etc etc as well as the administration costs for doing so. You need to start accepting responsibility as her employer. It's a long way away from baby-sitting for a couple of hours.
Nocutenamesleft · 04/03/2022 18:44

@Blossomtoes

Ha. I was actually self employed for 20 years

But ha. Yes. Claims it I meant. God. I’m tired. My eyes are crossing I’m so tired.

Nocutenamesleft · 04/03/2022 18:43

Yes. Sorry. Meant she claims it!

Sorry. Brain freeze.

Nocutenamesleft · 04/03/2022 18:43

@AdviceNeeded367

The rate is workers out as so much per hour and then a nominal fee for the overnight, which is what she suggested when she suggested having DS overnight.

For the most part, they have an Aunty/nephew relationship, which is fantastic but the repeated requests for pay rises is frustrating.

I have agreed to pay her as an employee as she doesn’t want the faff of being self employed.

So you pay her tax. Her sickness. Her maternity?!?

Etc…

Blossomtoes · 04/03/2022 18:42

@Nocutenamesleft

Is she employed. Or self employed

If she’s employed. You pay mileage.

If she’s self employed. She Claims it on taxes…..

You don’t understand self employment, do you? Self employed people claim their mileage. I certainly did.
Nocutenamesleft · 04/03/2022 18:40

Is she employed. Or self employed

If she’s employed. You pay mileage.

If she’s self employed. She Claims it on taxes…..

yumscrumfatbum · 04/03/2022 18:39

Askingforabaskin, it really is transparent and accurate. As I say not quite the same scenario as the op's but perhaps this explains it better than I did?
www.nhs.uk/conditions/social-care-and-support-guide/care-services-equipment-and-care-homes/shared-lives-schemes/

mylifestory · 04/03/2022 18:39

Tricky one. What exactly do u mean by SEN as it covers a multitude of things, and also what age is DS? yes, she is being cheeky asking for another rise so soon, trying to milk it. Bt also she can say she won't do it anymore, can u afford this in a non-monetary way? definitely get this all in writing for a set amount of time with her, say a yea. Put that before her now id say