Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Not to pay childminders travel expenses

310 replies

AdviceNeeded367 · 04/03/2022 16:22

Last summer, Childminder asked for an extra £10 per week to help pay for activities while she has DS.

In December, she demanded a 27% payrise.

Today she has demanded a 45p per mile travel expense.

AIBU to tell her a flat No?

OP posts:
CeeceeBloomingdale · 04/03/2022 20:51

Bare in mind minimum wage increases on 1st April each year. The new rate will be £9.50ph if she’s over 23. Might as well factor that in now as well as the standard mileage. She can’t be replaced at the rates you are paying, don’t lose her.

Newnamefor2022 · 04/03/2022 20:45

@AdviceNeeded367

You’re right, it isn’t a huge amount, but the cost of living is going to continue to go up and it’s only a matter of time before she says that she has to be paid £20 an hour and I guess that I’m just annoyed that I have to adjust my household budget so that she doesn’t have to.
She doesn't have to adjust HER budget to look after YOUR child!
cherish123 · 04/03/2022 20:43

A childminder should charge an hourly rate. If they choose to take the children in their care on excursions, they cover the costs. If it's too expensive, they do something local. Different if you have specifically asked childminder to take DC somewhere.

HiJenny35 · 04/03/2022 20:39

Massively unreasonable if you think 310 is a lot for looking after a sen child for the weekend including 2 nights. As for people saying you can't charge for being asleep that isn't strictly true, throughout the night you are expected be on call as and when necessary, to not have had a drink, to be alert and able to respond to any situations you are considered on the clock and the pay is reflective of that. London fees are 150-160 per night with sen experience. So pretty much what you are paying however extras such as miles driven, places visited, some aspects of supplementary items would all be additional costs passed on to the parents. I don't think she's taking the p but ifs it's bothered you and you no longer want to use her then don't but be aware there are very few people willing to take on these sorts of roles so finding a replacement may be very difficult.

MrsSkylerWhite · 04/03/2022 20:26

With rising costs that seems perfectly reasonable to me. Parents should cover increased costs, not childminders. She’s not a charity.

A few months ago, I could half fill my tank for £30. That barely reaches 1/3 now. Her electricity bills will have increased to: don’t suppose many adults would have heating on all day if they weren’t caring for children.

You need to cover her increased costs.

Kate0902900908 · 04/03/2022 20:22

YABU.
she is a nanny not a childminder. She collects you child from you in her car to take him to her house over night all weekend. Yes you have to pay extra for increase in petrol and yes you have to pay her online with the rising cost of living. She is your employee you pay a wage to everything extra I.e travel ect you pick up.

AChocolateOrangeaday · 04/03/2022 20:21

£310 a weekend! You are getting a bargain.

We pay £14 per hour for SEN care so 48 hours is £672!

You are currently paying her £6:45 which isn't even NMW is it?

I'll take her OP

momtoboys · 04/03/2022 20:20

I'm not clear on the frequency of the respite (so glad you have that!). "regular but not frequent" to me means that maybe the increase in costs for once a month(?) isn't that much to quibble over? I agree with a previous poster that said that good childminders/nannys are really hard to find,

eunace · 04/03/2022 20:19

Would this not be the perfect time to put a contract in place? We've established she's on the payroll as an employee, so ball is now in your court. I would agree to the mileage allowance, and say you will review her pay in December.

Moo31 · 04/03/2022 20:16

In relation to the overnight / sleeping hours aspect others have alluded to the 2021 Mencap ruling -
"The Supreme Court Justices were unanimous in finding that the NMW Regulations clearly state that a worker who is permitted to sleep during a shift and is only required to respond to emergencies, is not entitled to be paid at NMW rates for every hour of that shift. In reaching their decision, the Supreme Court was guided by the recommendations of the Low Pay Commission, which the Government is bound to follow, and which have been consistently clear that sleep-in shifts should not attract NMW."

busyeatingbiscuits · 04/03/2022 20:10

@GlitterNails

I agree with *@Merriwicks* that overnight care doesn't get paid an hourly rate if the person is sleeping.

I have a direct budget from the council and sleeping nights vs awake nights are paid differently. When you sleep and are just there for the occasional time to wake up i.e. for the toilet, but the majority of the time is spent sleeping it's usually a flat rate. If you have to stay awake to care then it's hourly rate.

So all those saying the OP isn't paying mimimum wage aren't right.

This issue went to court and that was what was agreed. See: www.theguardian.com/society/2021/mar/19/sleep-in-care-workers-not-entitled-minimum-wage-supreme-court I don't think anything has changed since then legally.

OP - have you looked at direct payments for your son? If he qualifies you might get help towards paying for the respite care or have a PA during the day. You could likely continue employing the same person - you'd just get financial help to do so.

You are welcome to PM me for more info on this if you are interested.

Again though, being a sleep-in carer for adults is pretty different to being solely responsible for a young child for 48 hours at a time. That's a very long shift.
ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 04/03/2022 20:10

45p a mile is the HMRC standard rate for the first 10K miles

busyeatingbiscuits · 04/03/2022 20:08

@Cameleongirl

I have no idea whether it’s a bargain for weekend respite care or not-the OP needs to do some research on this. I personally wouldn’t begrudge paying travel costs.

Different scenario as it’s for young adults not a child, but @yumscrumfatbum said this was typical for her area:

The flat rate for overnight respite in your own home is £60 for a 24 hour period. Expenses such as outings are billed for additionally. The £60 includes food and all utilities. Parents are expected to drop off and collect to and from the carers home. Petrol is billed if it is a journey taken specifically for the individual rather myself or my family

The OP pays about 2.5x that.

Adult social care through the council is very different than nannying.

Just like you can't really compare a foster carer with a nanny.

Kazzyhoward · 04/03/2022 20:07

@Thehop

I’m a registered childminder and charge £30 a day for holiday club. I pay for all food, drink, travel and days out! (We only do one big ticket trip per week, use national trust and English heritage membership the rest and take picnics.)
How many kids do you look after though? The OP's respite carer is only looking after one child, so only one lot of income. If you're looking after, say, 5 children, then the comparison is you charging £150 for just, say, an 8 hour day, whereas in OP's case it's two half days, two nights and a full day. So completely different really.
Flossieskeeper · 04/03/2022 20:06

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Blondeshavemorefun · 04/03/2022 20:05

The 27% rise is misleading as you were majorly under paying her before then
still are IMO

Nannies who do overnights often will charge from say 10 -6 an overnight fee of ag least £50. Many much more

Plus then all the other hours

She does 2 over nights plus all day Saturday, and fri after school plus sun am

45p is the set mileage rate. It’s been that for years. Tbh should go up to least 50p the way petrol costs have gone up

If anyone on this thread had to use their car for work, you would expect work to pay the going rate

alltheapples · 04/03/2022 20:04

That £60 for respite sounds like it is being done by volunteers and the monéy is for costs. Social Services do have volunteers for respité.

betwixtlives · 04/03/2022 20:03

you just aren’t getting how much of a cheeky fucker you’re being OP. unbelievable

Thehop · 04/03/2022 20:01

I’m a registered childminder and charge £30 a day for holiday club. I pay for all food, drink, travel and days out! (We only do one big ticket trip per week, use national trust and English heritage membership the rest and take picnics.)

yumscrumfatbum · 04/03/2022 19:59

Bunnycat101 as a Shared Lives Carer you do get certain tax breaks. Most Carers already have long term placements and use respite to top up their income. If you have a regular respite placement its often a week or so at a time so that does add up.

GlitterNails · 04/03/2022 19:59

I agree with @Merriwicks that overnight care doesn't get paid an hourly rate if the person is sleeping.

I have a direct budget from the council and sleeping nights vs awake nights are paid differently. When you sleep and are just there for the occasional time to wake up i.e. for the toilet, but the majority of the time is spent sleeping it's usually a flat rate. If you have to stay awake to care then it's hourly rate.

So all those saying the OP isn't paying mimimum wage aren't right.

This issue went to court and that was what was agreed. See: www.theguardian.com/society/2021/mar/19/sleep-in-care-workers-not-entitled-minimum-wage-supreme-court I don't think anything has changed since then legally.

OP - have you looked at direct payments for your son? If he qualifies you might get help towards paying for the respite care or have a PA during the day. You could likely continue employing the same person - you'd just get financial help to do so.

You are welcome to PM me for more info on this if you are interested.

Bunnycat101 · 04/03/2022 19:59

OP in all honesty I think you were massively underpaying previously. £310 sounds broadly right assuming something close to £10 an hour plus a night rate of £40 from say 10pm until 7. Given the journey I think mileage is reasonable. Realistically you’d struggle to get similar levels of care for anything less and I suspect if you went to an agency you’d be paying a good deal more.

Absc · 04/03/2022 19:58

I would say if your son had additional needs then that rate you pay is on the lower side for a weekend. Local authorities pay more under direct payments for that type of care. Maybe it’s worth exploring if your entitled to any help from your local disabled childrens team.

cansu · 04/03/2022 19:56

I think that you may need to think about how much the arrangement is worth it to you. If she is employed then you set the pay and she either accepts the job or not. The travel is I think reasonable as you can't take him yourself although the 45p a mile is high. I think the problem is that this started out as one thing and developed into something more formal. That said decent respite care is very rare so I would look at what I could afford and then be upfront about this. Can you get any direct payments to put towards it?

Bunnycat101 · 04/03/2022 19:47

yumscrumfatbum The flat rate for 24 hours respite seems incredibly low at £60 unless it’s subsidised. My nursery is now £80 for a 10 hour period.