Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Not to pay childminders travel expenses

310 replies

AdviceNeeded367 · 04/03/2022 16:22

Last summer, Childminder asked for an extra £10 per week to help pay for activities while she has DS.

In December, she demanded a 27% payrise.

Today she has demanded a 45p per mile travel expense.

AIBU to tell her a flat No?

OP posts:
DixonD · 05/03/2022 18:32

@AdviceNeeded367

The payrise in December was based on rising cost of living, her rent had gone up substantially etc.

Today’s request is in response to rising petrol costs.

My local forecourt has gone up by 7p in 5 days. I don’t blame her!
Silvers11 · 05/03/2022 18:31

@ AdviceNeeded367

So, if I read it correctly she is neither a childminder nor a Nanny but is providing respite care for your DS In her own home. Is that correct?

By implication, for whatever reason,Social Services have decided that you/your son does not qualify for any assistance from themselves, hence the reason you are paying yourself for someone to do it. Is that also correct? have you had a carer's assessment and a needs assessment done for your son?

I take it you have claimed all the benefits you are entitled to as a carer of a child with special needs. They are not all means tested?

As I understand it, you will be classed as an employer for the respite carer - but your best bet would be to phone Social Services and ask them about pay rates etc in your area. Whether or not you have contacted them before, they should be able to advise you on what is or what is reasonable in terms of rates, travelling costs and your obligations as an employer

Hope that helps

law050465 · 05/03/2022 18:28

I’m a Nanny and I recently charged £200 per 24 hours for a job. I don’t think that is excessive. I pay 20% tax on that. As for mileage, if you are employing her as respite and expecting her to be a taxi, then of course you should be paying mileage. Otherwise you should be taking your child there yourself

sunshinesupermum · 05/03/2022 18:27

As you're not a driver OP you probably don't appreciate just how much petrol costs have gone up recently.

And yes, the cost of living is going up exponentially so I would expect your 'nanny' to request further increases. It is up to you whether you can afford them both financially and emotionally on behalf of your DS.

Mandyjack · 05/03/2022 18:22

27% payrise is way above inflation! Or was she underpaid before?.
If you are requesting her to use her car to ferry your kids she's entitled to mileage and travel time to be paid

Hmm1234 · 05/03/2022 18:21

Depends if she asked for travel expenses to be covered in her advertisement.
She is not unreasonable to ask for a pay rise as the cost of living is going up but it’s up to you if you think she works hard enough with the children to get the increase

Heiderose · 05/03/2022 18:20

@AChocolateOrangeaday

£310 a weekend! You are getting a bargain.

We pay £14 per hour for SEN care so 48 hours is £672!

You are currently paying her £6:45 which isn't even NMW is it?

I'll take her OP

I'm a Nanny, I charge this for 48hrs sole charge overnight in the family's home.

I can not take them to mine as there is a limit of how many hours a day a Nanny can have a child in there own house before having to register as a childminder. It also invalidates my insurance so I wouldn't be covered for any accidents the child may have.

This seems like a complete mess unless she's actually registered & insured to care for children in her own home. As a Nanny she should be working in your home not her own.

Suepicano7176 · 05/03/2022 18:01

she's either worth it or not. Is the cost about usual for the care she is giving? If you think she's being unreasonable then get someone else!

Robotdott · 05/03/2022 17:54

Yikes this sounds an absolute mess. For her sake and yours I'd sort out a robust contract and check obligations and expectations. If she is an employee are you following all of your legal obligations? I wouldn't employ someone in this manner in a million years, let alone without understanding how it works as you seem to.

pinkpantherpink · 05/03/2022 17:51

I've always assumed Nanny's are given a car to drive e as part of their employment arrangements

pinkpantherpink · 05/03/2022 17:51

As an employee it is reasonable to claim travel expenses

Teenytinyflowers · 05/03/2022 17:41

YABU…totally unreasonable. Your posts make you sound very entitled…especially the last one about having to adjust your budget so someone else doesn’t have to adjust theirs. I dare say the nanny picked up on your bad attitude which is why she was formal in specifying the price increase to cover her fuel.

The cost of living has gone up and petrol and diesel is crazy expensive….therefore your nanny’s cost base has gone up. As with other service providers your nanny now has to pass on the cost to the consumer(you). If you can get the same service for less money elsewhere( which I doubt) go ahead and do that.

liveforsummer · 05/03/2022 10:46

Well I don't imagine she demanded a pay rise but rather put her rates up to meet the increased costs of running her business. Yes I think it's fair to ask for a petrol allowance unless she's using a car unnecessarily, like for school pick ups that are actually easy walking distance.

You can of course refuse but then you'll need to find a new child minder which might not be a bad thing as doesn't sound like you like or respect her very much.

Your biggest problem here though is that your arrangement is entirely illegal because I'm assuming she's not actually a registered and insured childminder but is caring for your own child in her home and receiving money for it. That isn't allowed

ballsdeep · 04/03/2022 22:10

@AdviceNeeded367

I don’t agree that she’s got a shit deal as she’s always set the rate and the terms. The pay increase that she had in December, she explained, was a realistic hourly rate that she needed and wanted. Now that she’s asking for more money again only a couple of months later, I think is too much.
I think its too much she has your child for the WHOLE weekend for £300!!!!
insatiableme · 04/03/2022 21:45

You are underpaying her surely. A sleep in rate if your son is staying overnight should be paid for for too. So she should be paid every hour he is there including the night

newnameforthis76 · 04/03/2022 21:45

You can say no if you want. She, however, can also say no to looking after your child.

The hourly rate you pay her is her wage and pays for her care of your child. In most other jobs, people can claim travel expenses in addition to their salary for business-related journeys, so I don’t really see why that should be any different for a childminder. And of course that would increase in line with the cost of fuel.

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 04/03/2022 21:38

@Cameleongirl

I have no idea whether it’s a bargain for weekend respite care or not-the OP needs to do some research on this. I personally wouldn’t begrudge paying travel costs.

Different scenario as it’s for young adults not a child, but @yumscrumfatbum said this was typical for her area:

The flat rate for overnight respite in your own home is £60 for a 24 hour period. Expenses such as outings are billed for additionally. The £60 includes food and all utilities. Parents are expected to drop off and collect to and from the carers home. Petrol is billed if it is a journey taken specifically for the individual rather myself or my family

The OP pays about 2.5x that.

Shared Lives is a very different arrangement. From the NHS link:

The schemes do pay the self-employed shared lives carers but not by the hour. Carers, as well as their families and friends, contribute a lot that is unpaid.

labyrinthlaziness · 04/03/2022 21:14

[quote DysmalRadius]www.gov.uk/night-working-hours[/quote]
If this person is working as an employee during the night as well as during the day, then they are working from Friday to Sunday straight with no breaks?

There are more issues to this than just the amount paid per hour and other expenses. This person is in a very dodgy working arrangement.

EthelTheAardvark · 04/03/2022 21:13

Is 45p per mile seriously how much more petrol costs now??

It is presumably go cover all related costs including insurance, road tax, MOTs, maintenance, and wear and tear. As a mileage rate it's actually quite cheap - the official Inland Revenue rate has been at 45p per mile for several years despite the fact that petrol costs have more than trebled.

FantasticFebruary · 04/03/2022 21:10

@AdviceNeeded367

You’re right, it isn’t a huge amount, but the cost of living is going to continue to go up and it’s only a matter of time before she says that she has to be paid £20 an hour and I guess that I’m just annoyed that I have to adjust my household budget so that she doesn’t have to.
Such is life.

If you think you can get respite cheaper, where you son us happy... go for it.

You'll soon be back lamenting the lack of any childcare for children with SEN, let alone overnight.

Genegenieee · 04/03/2022 21:01

@AdviceNeeded367

She is only “an employee” as she does not want the faff of being self employed. I use a nanny tax service for wages slips, tax calcs, NICs etc

Which is another expense on top of everything else.

From everything you've said, she'd not meet the test for being self-employed.
Dimondsareforever · 04/03/2022 20:59

An employee asking for the HMRC rate of 45p to do things required as part of the job is not unreasonable. Assuming this is for an activity she takes child too. Not her travel to and from her place of work.

TwiggletLover · 04/03/2022 20:56

£310 for someone to be caring for your child
from
Friday to Sunday seems like a huge bargain to me

busyeatingbiscuits · 04/03/2022 20:55

@cherish123

A childminder should charge an hourly rate. If they choose to take the children in their care on excursions, they cover the costs. If it's too expensive, they do something local. Different if you have specifically asked childminder to take DC somewhere.
The OP is employing a nanny, not using a self-employed childminder.
Bananarama21 · 04/03/2022 20:52

Your taking the piss.