Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Not to pay childminders travel expenses

310 replies

AdviceNeeded367 · 04/03/2022 16:22

Last summer, Childminder asked for an extra £10 per week to help pay for activities while she has DS.

In December, she demanded a 27% payrise.

Today she has demanded a 45p per mile travel expense.

AIBU to tell her a flat No?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
louiseofthelakes · 08/03/2022 16:10

I have disabled sons who are now adult. As children (some years ago) any respite was £14 per hour plus £90 extra if overnight, plus 45p per mile if the respite carer travelled to collect/drop home. We also paid extra for any activities. This would have been for one child, as they never went together. This was the standard rate locally. I therefore am quite shocked you pay so little. Now they are adults we cannot afford any respite so we manage without, but honestly I think you are paying very very little for this service.

lanthanum · 08/03/2022 15:40

45p has been the HMRC recommended rate for mileage since 2012 - it hasn't yet been increased in line with the recent fuel price rises. It's more than pure petrol money as you have the upkeep of the car to consider.
Employers don't have to pay that rate (mine doesn't) but if they pay less then the employee can set the difference against tax.

busyeatingbiscuits · 08/03/2022 15:29

@TXmum3

For all those saying she is illegally paying her or massively underpaying... Whether that is true or not, it won't hold up. OP(original poster) already said that the childminder has set her own price and pay from the beginning. It's not the moms fault that the care provider either under asked pay in the beginning and is now realizing she needs/wants more, or low balled her rate to get the job etc. She can't be that surprised that the mom is resistant to continually keep raising her pay in such short time frames. The mom has agreed already twice to up her pay. The third time in a time frame, that's a lot to ask. That's on the provider, not the mom. I feel for the OP.
The OP is an employer, so minimum wage laws apply.

I could apply for a job and say don't worry, I only want £5 an hour. But it's the employer's responsibility to pay minimum wage.

Blondeshavemorefun · 08/03/2022 14:38

She’s not a cm. they are self employed and set rates

Op is employing her so needs to pay nmw

TXmum3 · 08/03/2022 14:32

@Blondeshavemorefun

In the end *@AdviceNeeded367* you are happy and your child is happy with her care

The pay rise she asked for sounds huge but you were under paying her hugely !!!! And illegally as not nmw

Tho as you employ her , she should be at your home for the weekend , maybe you can go somewhere when she looks after dc

Her pli wouldn’t cover her

Hope you asked to see her pli

How is she illegally paying her when the childminder set her own rate from the beginning? That's the providers error, not the moms.
TXmum3 · 08/03/2022 14:31

For all those saying she is illegally paying her or massively underpaying... Whether that is true or not, it won't hold up. OP(original poster) already said that the childminder has set her own price and pay from the beginning. It's not the moms fault that the care provider either under asked pay in the beginning and is now realizing she needs/wants more, or low balled her rate to get the job etc. She can't be that surprised that the mom is resistant to continually keep raising her pay in such short time frames. The mom has agreed already twice to up her pay. The third time in a time frame, that's a lot to ask.
That's on the provider, not the mom. I feel for the OP.

Blondeshavemorefun · 07/03/2022 13:50

In the end @AdviceNeeded367 you are happy and your child is happy with her care

The pay rise she asked for sounds huge but you were under paying her hugely !!!! And illegally as not nmw

Tho as you employ her , she should be at your home for the weekend , maybe you can go somewhere when she looks after dc

Her pli wouldn’t cover her

Hope you asked to see her pli

FluffyBooBoo · 07/03/2022 13:29

It's not breaking the law to not pay mileage, and there's no set rate to pay either. You can pay more or less than the hmrc tax-free rate, but it just gets complicated, especially if people pay more.

Mirw · 07/03/2022 13:17

Think you might be breaking the law. Maybe check with HMRC? If she is self employed, she can charge what she wants and it is up to you whether or not you want to pay her fee. But it sounds like you employ her, therefore you have to pay tax, NI etc and pay mileage too. HMRC might come knocking at your door if you don't knock at theirs first.

Silvers11 · 06/03/2022 23:06

45p per mile is the HMRC rate for business travel. It is designed to cover not just petrol, but wear and tear of the car being used. Since the Carer is travelling to your home OP to collect and return the child it is perfectly reasonable to pay this to her. She has to do the travel to be able to carry out the work you are paying her to do so it's not unreasonable.

Silvers11 · 06/03/2022 23:01

@notthemum

Op. I am going to try this one more time. As others have mentioned lots of times now A nanny works from the childs/ employers home. The employer pays the nanny's tax, national insurance, pays for any outings, entrance fees and often provides a car and pays for petrol. A nanny does not have to be Ofsted registered or inspected. A childminder works from their own home. They can charge what they please. Some will offer a flat fee and others will charge for extras, such as food or outings, however they should not charge extra for things that they claim for on their tax. They have to be registered with both the LEA and Ofsted as a chilminder. They have strict rules about what they are and are not allowed to do with the children. Whether or not they have a some sort of teaching degree or a nanny certificate is irrelevant. They will have to join a course usually run by their local council at thier own expense. Then they must provide policies and procedures information for parents to read and copies of these for the parents to take away and they must provide a contract for both themselves and the parents to sign which covers them both. Their home will be inspected possibly initially by the council, they will have to apply to Ofsted for permission to mind overnight and they will be told whether or not they will be allowed to care for a child in their home overnight. You may leave your child in their care in their home for 2 hours, as a PP has said. This is for no exchange of money, gifts or services. Otherwise they will be deemed to be childminding. As I said the penalties for doing this Childminding without being registered can be severe. When I began minding years ago if you were caught both the minder and the parent could be fined up to £1000 each. Just before I finished minding nearly 2 1/2 years ago the fine had increased up to £10k each and/or a prison sentence. I know how difficult it is to care for a child with special needs and how useless most of the LAs are with providing support but please think carefully before continuing as to how your child may cope if you were not not around at all for a bit. Feel free to PM me if you want any more information. Best wishes. 💐
It would appear that the person who is watching the child for a few weekends a year is a Respite carer and as such operates under different 'rules' if you like. They certainly can and do have children overnight to give the parents a break. Perhaps this person is a registered respite foster carer for their local council but doing this privately because the OP doesn't qualify for financial assistance?
law050465 · 06/03/2022 19:27

Perhaps she doesn’t drive 20 miles to pick each kid up 🙄

notthemum · 06/03/2022 18:57

Busyeatingbiscuits, Hi sorry, trying to track down info. Did Op actually state how old her child is ? (As I appear to have missed that bit if so and it could make a big difference) Thanks.

busyeatingbiscuits · 06/03/2022 16:57

@liveforsummer childminders don’t have to register if they only care for children aged over 8.
I hadn’t heard that the rules were different for day and night but maybe they are.

cantbecoping · 06/03/2022 16:36

So you WERE paying her less than £6.50 an hour before she put it up 27% to make it $6.50 an hour?

I am not good at maths but that is disgraceful. THEN she has to use her own petrol money to collect and drop back off? You are seriously deluded.

LottyD32 · 06/03/2022 16:17

@AdviceNeeded367

DS has SEN and she has him for the weekend at her house. The rates went from £230 to £310 per weekend with the price increase.

She and DS get on very well. If the price issue wasn’t an issue, I’d have no issue with her!

I'd call her a respite carer, not a childminder Confused
liveforsummer · 06/03/2022 15:54

[quote notthemum]@busyeatingbiscuits.
Sorry, I did not check on tthe age of the child but although a childminder does not have to be registered with Ofsted to look after over eights I am almost certain that overnights are a completely different kettle of fish. I can check with friends still minding if you like and see what is now different or has remained. May take me a bit of time though. [/quote]
Surely they still have to be registered with and inspected by the local council though regardless of age? And have suitable insurance?

clpsmum · 06/03/2022 15:50

@AdviceNeeded367

The rate is workers out as so much per hour and then a nominal fee for the overnight, which is what she suggested when she suggested having DS overnight.

For the most part, they have an Aunty/nephew relationship, which is fantastic but the repeated requests for pay rises is frustrating.

I have agreed to pay her as an employee as she doesn’t want the faff of being self employed.

You're not paying her anywhere near enough tbh
notthemum · 06/03/2022 13:38

@busyeatingbiscuits.
Sorry, I did not check on tthe age of the child but although a childminder does not have to be registered with Ofsted to look after over eights I am almost certain that overnights are a completely different kettle of fish. I can check with friends still minding if you like and see what is now different or has remained. May take me a bit of time though.

Hankunamatata · 06/03/2022 13:06

www.nidirect.gov.uk/articles/employing-professional-carer-or-personal-assistant
This is for ni but should give u an idea of responsibilities such as taking out liability insurance as an employer

busyeatingbiscuits · 06/03/2022 12:57

@notthemum

Op. I am going to try this one more time. As others have mentioned lots of times now A nanny works from the childs/ employers home. The employer pays the nanny's tax, national insurance, pays for any outings, entrance fees and often provides a car and pays for petrol. A nanny does not have to be Ofsted registered or inspected. A childminder works from their own home. They can charge what they please. Some will offer a flat fee and others will charge for extras, such as food or outings, however they should not charge extra for things that they claim for on their tax. They have to be registered with both the LEA and Ofsted as a chilminder. They have strict rules about what they are and are not allowed to do with the children. Whether or not they have a some sort of teaching degree or a nanny certificate is irrelevant. They will have to join a course usually run by their local council at thier own expense. Then they must provide policies and procedures information for parents to read and copies of these for the parents to take away and they must provide a contract for both themselves and the parents to sign which covers them both. Their home will be inspected possibly initially by the council, they will have to apply to Ofsted for permission to mind overnight and they will be told whether or not they will be allowed to care for a child in their home overnight. You may leave your child in their care in their home for 2 hours, as a PP has said. This is for no exchange of money, gifts or services. Otherwise they will be deemed to be childminding. As I said the penalties for doing this Childminding without being registered can be severe. When I began minding years ago if you were caught both the minder and the parent could be fined up to £1000 each. Just before I finished minding nearly 2 1/2 years ago the fine had increased up to £10k each and/or a prison sentence. I know how difficult it is to care for a child with special needs and how useless most of the LAs are with providing support but please think carefully before continuing as to how your child may cope if you were not not around at all for a bit. Feel free to PM me if you want any more information. Best wishes. 💐
Only if the child is under 8 though, right?
Hankunamatata · 06/03/2022 12:53

OP have you had carers assessment and do you get direct payments?
Skybadger website may be of help or you might find more help in sen boards.

Mickarooni · 06/03/2022 11:50

While legally you do not have to pay NMW for a sleeping night care worker, many providers do indeed pay it. Unsurprisingly, workers who feel valued and respected tend to stay in the organisation and develop good skills. The alternative is demotivated and undervalued staff who don’t remain in the job and there is a high turnover. These are the people who care for the most vulnerable individuals in our society - both adults and children with additional needs. I know which one I would choose.

ImaniMumsnet · 06/03/2022 10:34

Hi @Mangotea,

We agree that you should probably start up your own thread so other users are able to see it and provide some support. We are going to delete your posts but do get in touch with us on [email protected] if you need some assistance with starting up your own thread.

Robotdott · 06/03/2022 10:30

You could pay for a taxi if you don't want to pay her increased petrol charges (which sound reasonable as petrol has risen a tonne). Let us know when you ask for a quote if it will be cheaper.