Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset about this? (Household finances)

134 replies

user1471433387 · 04/03/2022 15:50

To be upset about this?

I know IABU but I’m finding it hard to stop dwelling on it.

I earn OK money and DH earns good money (significantly more than me). We have a comfortable lifestyle, but neither of us are especially materialistic. Recently there have been a couple of changes at my work and I think there’s a chance I could switch to part time hours. I would like to still work every day but leave a couple of hours earlier to pick eldest DC up straight from school so she wouldn’t have to go to after school care. The evenings would be a little less rushed hopefully. I’m currently pretty stressed and not enjoying my life much. I know we could afford this – it would just be a case of saving less money. I broached it with DH and he was completely against it. I know IABU for expecting to work part-time whilst he was full time (and over time) but I can’t help but be upset about it and it is affecting my relationship.

All money is pooled together

OP posts:
user1471433387 · 04/03/2022 16:41

It isn't his choice to work overtime. He has a demanding job and it is expected of him. He couldn't stop doing this unless he changed careers. He doesn't earn any extra money by doing the overtime, it is already factored into his salary. Of course it is a burden on him being the main breadwinner and it must be stressful. I should probably tell him more often how much I appreciate this.

He has a lot more personal time than I do though with hobbies and socialising.

I do every pick up and drop off. When he is working in the evenings, for the most part I am doing chores (meal prep for nursery and school, for example) so I do the majority of chores but not all. Kids are 3 and 4. I used to do all kids sick days (luckily we haven't had too many) but not anymore.

I don't have a career really - there aren't any opportunities to better myself in what I currently do. I am not asking to be completely supported by him, I want to carry on working! Just leave at 2:45 every day.

I have tried explaining to him how unhappy I am right now but he doesn't think me working part time will help me. I just remember when we were first dating he said he would be happy to have a stay at home wife (he now denies this!).

We can 100% afford this. We have just paid off our mortgage and the mortgage repayments would have been more than my cut in salary. Money is not usually stressful for us, as we have a good income. I know I need to move on and just forget about working PT!

OP posts:
RewildingAmbridge · 04/03/2022 16:40

You're stressed but he already carries the primary financial burden and is working overtime? I see his point. If he was in a high paying role that wasn't stressful and didn't command long hours and he wasn't working the overtime it would be up for discussion, but why should he fund you to have an easier life while he slogs on. Surely if anything reduces it's his overtime.

ScarlettSunset · 04/03/2022 16:36

It seems unfair for you to reduce your hours and out more pressure on your DH, when he is already working overtime.
People are asking if you do more looking after the children, but I would suspect that is likely anyway if he is working extra hours.

zoemum2006 · 04/03/2022 16:33

I’d be absolutely fine with this as long as DH is picking the kids up from school, cooking the meals, cleaning the house, doing world book day, organising birthday parties, buying school friends presents, prepping school uniform….. 50% of the time.

If not he’s taking the Piss.

newstart1234 · 04/03/2022 16:32

Need to know how much unpaid work each of you do before knowing which position is unreasonable.

Threeboysandadog · 04/03/2022 16:26

I found cutting my hours so that ds3 wasn’t in childcare until 6pm also saved money as I was available to plan and cook a cheaper evening meal instead of using ready made bits or even grabbing a take away. I also had time to do packed lunches for the next day instead of school lunches. I (obviously) paid less tax and all in wasn’t much worse off.

I understand why your dh may not be keen but is he doing his fair share around the house and with the children. If not then he needs to start.

girlmom21 · 04/03/2022 16:26

Why he's against it is clearly relevant here...

Is he worried about his own earnings? Is he resentful of having the 'provider' responsibility? Is he worried about your chances of progression etc changing? Is he thinking about your pension contributions?

smorgasbords · 04/03/2022 16:23

This is such a bad time to be cutting back your household income, I’m sure you’re DH is looking at things from that angle as well. Cost of living is going to be incomprehensible soon, and by next winter we could all be in a very different financial situation, so what you can afford as a household now is not likely to be the same in a few months time. That’s bleak, but the truth. I’d also echo other posters - your husband should be able to stop his overtime before you go part time. That feels like an unfair burden to place on him.

NoSquirrels · 04/03/2022 16:23

What’s the actual costs vs savings (drop in salary vs what you currently spend on childcare)?

What are the other tangible benefits (not your mental health, though I’m absolutely not dismissing that) e.g. save money on shopping because less convenience foods, save time at weekends on X because can do it in the week etc?

If he’s a black and white thinker you need a coat-benefit analysis that makes sense to him rather than appealing to his emotional intelligence.

I don’t think he should get to say a unilateral No though, just because he’s the higher earner.

Chocomelon · 04/03/2022 16:20

What does after school care cost?

Maybe he'd like to do it but doesn't feel he can

You can only afford it because of what he earns I assume

LampLighter414 · 04/03/2022 16:19

High inflation across the board, notably household bills, fuel etc that you can't really avoid. Interest rates likely to go up. The general sense of increased pressure as the main breadwinner in the household.

I can see why your DP might be against it inherently, especially at the current time. Any chance of sitting down for a more detailed chat about the pros and cons and assessing the impact on household budget and any other future plans you have (e.g. moving, large family holidays in the next couple years)

BillMasen · 04/03/2022 16:18

@Barkingmadhouse

I would expect your husband to be able to stop the over time before you go part time
Very much this It feels unfair to let one person keep working overtime and the other go part time.
FlowerArranger · 04/03/2022 16:16

What NumberTheory said!! Especially this:

it isn’t just about your current budget, if you have any sort of career, lowering your hours is likely to have a knock on effect for the rest of your working life

You have to consider the entirety of your life, not just the here and now. You are already behind your husband in terms of earnings even though you both work full-time. If you reduce your hours, the gap will widen. There could be resentment on his part. Other things could threaten your marriage at some point in the future.... just read the boards here to get an idea. You simply cannot rely on bring supported/subsidised by a man.

Illstartexercisingtomorrow · 04/03/2022 16:15

How is the housework/childcare/mental load split?

Because if you are doing the majority of that then I would argue there’s a good case for you going part time.

Tryingtokeepgoing · 04/03/2022 16:15

@Barkingmadhouse

I would expect your husband to be able to stop the over time before you go part time
Well yes, indeed. I’m sure there was a thread yesterday where the higher earning OP wanted her lower paying husband to earn more…I can imagine the response if he’d wanted to work less ;)
Stuffin · 04/03/2022 16:14

Missed the fact that he works overtime as well.

Some people live to work and are happy with their partners at home or PT but it sounds like your DH isn't one of them so it is even more unfair for you to drop hours and put more pressure on them.

coconuthead · 04/03/2022 16:14

What was his reasoning for being so against it?

Returnoftheowl · 04/03/2022 16:12

@Barkingmadhouse

I would expect your husband to be able to stop the over time before you go part time
I agree with this. If your husband is having to work overtime then it would seem unfair to put more pressure on him by going PT.
Barkingmadhouse · 04/03/2022 16:09

I would expect your husband to be able to stop the over time before you go part time

Jamnation · 04/03/2022 16:05

Is your eldest still quite small? PT is really, really helpful in hols too - DC need to spend fewer weeks in holiday club and a tonne of clubs finish at 3/3.30, often the most interesting or skill based ones. PT was the key to making holidays work for us.

It's not just the cost, it sounds like it would be really positive for DC to have more time at home/with you. Are you sure he's not that materialistic?

Merryoldgoat · 04/03/2022 16:03

If you can afford it I don’t see why it’s a problem.

I work 26 hours a week and have a whole day to myself plus can pick up 3 days. My boys don’t need additional childcare.

It’s much better for us as a family.

rwalker · 04/03/2022 16:02

DH is having to pick the slack up finically He's working full-time and overtime .
It's alright saying you can afford it but anything could be round the corner and his overtime could disappear overnight

NumberTheory · 04/03/2022 16:02

Is your DH stressed working full time too or do you do all the running around and work longer hours?

I don’t think it’s that reasonable to expect to be able to make your life easier at a cost to the family budget just because the opportunity’s come up if things are currently pretty even between you.

And it isn’t just about your current budget, if you have any sort of career, lowering your hours is likely to have a knock on effect for the rest of your working life.

But if you’re run ragged because you do all the wife work as well as a full-time job and he doesn’t really step up if you’ve ever mentioned this to him then I think it’s more reasonable.

YellowHpok · 04/03/2022 16:00

I don't think it's an unreasonable request, but perhaps he feels that it would put additional pressure on him if he is already working overtime.

How did you broach it with him? Would a discussion about the pressures at home in the context of two FT parents and see what he comes up with as potential solutions? Maybe he doesn't "see" the problem so needs it spelling out a bit more explicitly.

Could he reduce his hours to help for example?

Lucifersleeps · 04/03/2022 16:00

Maybe he would like to go part time and you share the financial burden more equally?