Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset about this? (Household finances)

134 replies

user1471433387 · 04/03/2022 15:50

To be upset about this?

I know IABU but I’m finding it hard to stop dwelling on it.

I earn OK money and DH earns good money (significantly more than me). We have a comfortable lifestyle, but neither of us are especially materialistic. Recently there have been a couple of changes at my work and I think there’s a chance I could switch to part time hours. I would like to still work every day but leave a couple of hours earlier to pick eldest DC up straight from school so she wouldn’t have to go to after school care. The evenings would be a little less rushed hopefully. I’m currently pretty stressed and not enjoying my life much. I know we could afford this – it would just be a case of saving less money. I broached it with DH and he was completely against it. I know IABU for expecting to work part-time whilst he was full time (and over time) but I can’t help but be upset about it and it is affecting my relationship.

All money is pooled together

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 04/03/2022 17:25

Objectively reducing household income at the start of a cost of living crisis doesn’t seem particularly sensible.

PyongyangKipperbang · 04/03/2022 17:23

Sounds like this more about envy than money. He is probably resentful that you could go part time when he cant and thats why he is vetoing this.

Is schooling non negotiable? Perhaps he would be more amenable to change if he didnt feel under pressure to provide for their school fees on top on everything else.

sweetbellyhigh · 04/03/2022 17:23

This set up is working nicely for him, isn't it?

He gets to further his career and enjoy being lord of the house while neither appreciating nor contributing to the huge amount of work involved in raising small children.

He gets to swan off to his personal interest and social activities knowing the children and house will be taken care of while he's out, at no charge.

This is not a good arrangement for a happy marriage or family.

You are already unhappy, unsurprisingly.

Working ft and caring for small children is hard, it's relentless and exhausting and thankless.

What you are asking is in everyone's interests because it'll make the family stronger. If the mother is unhappy, the whole family starts to fall apart.

I think he is being an absolute arse and I hope you can get through to him. What good is money if the pursuit of it makes you unhappy?

Stuffin · 04/03/2022 17:22

Yes OP could cut their hours and thus pay without his permission but then why should the joint funds just be cut. If OP wants to unilaterally cut the household income then they must take the financial cut themselves.

Income, working hours etc should be a joint decision as marriage is about being a team. OP you said you get emotional but that isn't helpful for discussions so you need to try and have a calm discussion and look at all the pros and cons as a couple.

But do be aware this really isn't the best time to reduce income particularly as you mentioned your future outgoings like private education.

wtfisgoingonhere21 · 04/03/2022 17:19

Mmm it needs to be a calm
Sit down together type of conversation not you putting it to him and him saying no and end of.

Compromise by getting rid of the cleaner as Youl be home earlier it would be easier to do a bit each day to keep on top of it so you save there as well as the after school care

Or you could suggest you out source other things to give you more free time if you can't drop your hours.

Ask him if there's more he would like to choose to do to divvy up the load abit more.

Outhouse71421 · 04/03/2022 17:14

I think it's a problem if he has a veto on anything he doesn't agree with. He has to discuss it with you, not just be the judge and jury.

user1471433387 · 04/03/2022 17:09

This is giving me lots of food for thought - thanks.

I'm not entirely sure why he is completely against it. We should probably discuss it more but it gets emotional for me.

I would be happy for him to reduce his hours, although this is irrelevant as it is not an option. He is not a teacher. It is very common for people in well paid professional jobs to work more than 9 - 5 I've found.

Eldest is in private school and youngest will go to when she is old enough. School fees are more expensive than nursery fees. I can't pay less in nursery fees if I pick up the 3 year old earlier but when she starts school then we could avoid paying 2 x after school care fees if I finish early.

OP posts:
newstart1234 · 04/03/2022 17:09

Yes it’s stressful to be the main earner, especially when money’s tight , but so is being the only one doing chores and being tied down with childcare responsibilities. Value the work you do op, as he clearly values his (unpaid overtime etc.). FWIW when my dc were very small I worked part time for the very same reason, in similar circumstances, and my dh actually was very grateful for the freedom he had to work extra and with flexibility when needed.

GeneLovesJezebel · 04/03/2022 17:06

Kids aren’t small for long, I’d do it.

amylou8 · 04/03/2022 17:05

Could you offer him a share of the reduced hours? You'll cut 2 hours on X days and do the school run, home work, bedtime, he'll cut 2 hours on Y days and do the same. If he won't/can't and you can afford it then I don't think YBU at all.

TravellingFrom · 04/03/2022 17:03

He has a lot more personal time than I do though with hobbies and socialising

Start there.
And whilst you are out socialising and having a life, expect your DH to pick up the chores that need doing in the top of looking after the dcs just like you do.

If there is one thing I’ve learnt at my own detriment, it’s that not putting yourself first, at least some o the time, means you are the one paying the price. You’re not a as good as you could mother. And you are missing out of many opportunities just because of burnt out.

bumpytrumpy · 04/03/2022 16:59

It would be fine if a man were posting it, if he was giving the woman the option.

I'm an ideal world you would be both reducing hours for a better a work life balance now the mortgage is paid and nursery fees are almost done. Just because he won't doesn't mean you shouldn't.

sst1234 · 04/03/2022 16:58

OP, it’s still unclear why he is against it? Or maybe he’s not clear with you also. What is the reason? Is he concerned about losing the cushion of that additional income. The stress of being the main earner in a household can be overwhelming sometimes, even if there are no money worries.
To those saying that he’s unreasonable and it’s not his choice, not sure it would be the same sentiment if a man was posting this.

SkyLarkDescending · 04/03/2022 16:57

Is he a teacher OP? If so, then yes the overtime is expected and a part of the job, but it can't be to the detriment of everything else in family life.

Have you discussed the fact that these early years with your children are over so fast. Are you thinking this would be long term or is it just while the children are young and then you would increase hours or retrain? I think you perhaps need a longer term plan and to communicate it to DH so he can see you're not just wanting to take it easy now the mortgage is paid off while he works lots of hours.

How much does he understand about 'wife work' and what you do to run the household? If you are doing chores when the children are in bed, what is he doing at that time?

bumpytrumpy · 04/03/2022 16:57

You have a decent job & 2 small children. You've paid off a mortgage and live a comfortable life.

There is NO REASON you need to move on from the idea of dropping a few hours. It's not like you're proposing to retire! Life is for living, not working more than necessary for a comfortable life. Your children would benefit hugely when they start school - clubs, brownies etc all become possible.

I actually think this is the ideal way round to do it - work full days when nursery is 7-6pm (and the babies can't tell the time). Then once they start school you can be present on the play ground and help them build their lives - they actually need a lot more in the first few years of primary school than many parents of babies assume.

newstart1234 · 04/03/2022 16:55

I think he’s being unfair because he’s not pulling his weight in the unpaid work part of his life. He is benefitting by a better career from your unpaid labour. I’m not surprised he’s against you going part time as it’s a win win for him atm. You bring in the money and do the house work too. More fair would be either you working part time to compensate for his lack of unpaid work or him changing his job to allow him a bigger role in the house.

timeisnotaline · 04/03/2022 16:55

I would insist on a more equal split of tasks and if free time then if you both have to be full time. I am full time and nothing less than 50/50 is acceptable to me, why would it be? I’d start him on one night he has to do pick up and dinner, plus one new hobby/ social time for you, plus sending some evening chores his way.

NoSquirrels · 04/03/2022 16:51

Why do you need to “move on and forget it”? If all the chores and household stuff falls to you, why can’t you work less to enable more time for this?

When your 3 year old turns 4 they’ll both be school age and you could eliminate childcare expenses pretty much entirely (except school holidays).

It’s not his prerogative to say no. This should be a holistic decision for the good of the whole family.

user1471433387 · 04/03/2022 16:50

It just feels like at the moment, as soon as we've wrangled the kids to bed I'm then in the kitchen doing chores. I get some time to read my book (not long enough to watch a whole TV show) and then I'm going to bed. We never spend time together during the week.

OP posts:
Jvg33 · 04/03/2022 16:47

You don't need his permission. But it may affect your relationship. If you are willing to take the risk just do it. However can you have a nice lifestyle without his income?

user1471433387 · 04/03/2022 16:47

Not paying afterschool care and my potential drop in earnings, would still mean we lose out unfortunately. I don't want to finish work early and just relax, I want to spend time with the kids and get a head start on the chores.

I went back to work FT when DCs were around 6 months, I feel like I have already lost out on so much. I was happier during lockdown (on a completely personal level, of course I wish Covid never happened) as I got to spend more time with the kids.

We are lucky enough to have a cleaner, so that's something.

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 04/03/2022 16:45

So why doesn't he want you to reduce your hours? Is it just because he doesn't think it'll make you happier?

That's not his choice.

TravellingFrom · 04/03/2022 16:43

So @@user1471433387 what does he think would make you happier?

And what do you think would make you happier? Is work really the issue there?

tkwal · 04/03/2022 16:42

Does the reduction in childcare costs come close to balancing out the salary you will lose by working reduced hours ? If it does and you would have the added benefit of spending extra time with your child , I think he has no reason to complain. Quality of life is more important than the amount of savings you have

TravellingFrom · 04/03/2022 16:42

Well if you are not enjoying your life much, something has to give.

The question is: what wouod make your life better?
If you are thinking of going part time, I’m assuming it’s the stress of housework/parenting/putting food on the table etc….

Which means that if your DH is against it, then he should support you finding others ways to make your life easier. Taking in more of the o parenting/cooking/cleaning than he does atm.
But would he?