Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The president of Ukraine

213 replies

Mynameisnew · 04/03/2022 07:02

Used to be a stand up comic and actor, and was the voice of Paddington bear when Ukraine dubbed the film!

What good things have made your jaw drop recently?

OP posts:
Zotter · 05/03/2022 14:15

This war need never have started if Donetsk and Luhansk had been allowed to become semi-autonomous regions, as was promised to them in negotiations between Ukraine and Russia, which Ukraine then backed out of.

Leatmarmite, the egotiations between Ukraine and Russia you refer to above are known as the Minsk agreements. They have not been implemented because neither side can agree on the terms set out. A major blockage has been Russia's insistence that it is not a party to the conflict and therefore is not bound by its terms.The situation is not as straightforward as you imply and you present a very one sided view.

Likewise the far right exist sadly as a movement in Ukraine and as you say the Asov battalion began as a far right volunteer regiment fighting pro separatists in 2014 which the then-President Petro Poroshenko officially integrated into Ukraine’s National Guard, however the movement electorally is marginal. When its political wing joined forces with several other far-right parties to participate in Ukraine’s most recent parliamentary elections in 2019, the bloc drew barely more than 2% of the vote.

The far right movement is grim and when Ukraine is desperate for all to resist the invasion the movement worryingly will probably use the current crisis as an opportunity to try and gain support, but Zelensky is not a supporter of it and as said electorally it has v little support.

BlanketsBanned · 05/03/2022 13:05

Putin wants Ukraine to turn on NATO but he knows full well they will not bomb the fucker because he is weak, a coward, he doesnt want his own people nuked while he hides away in his luxury home. .

DownNative · 05/03/2022 12:54

@JaniieJones

'Your attitude is basically, "I'm alright, Jack.....those Ukrainians will have to fend for themselves because I'm afraid of Putin!".

It isn't my attitude in the slightest. They are not fending for themselves they are getting NATO support with the provision of military equipment and humitarian support.

My 'attitude is basically' NATO cannot implement a no fly zone as the Russians will break it NATO will have to shoot them down and then Putin will consider nuclear weapons. Can you seriously not understand how escalating this further could lead to mass destruction?!

Once again, NATO is NOT involved in supplying anything to Ukraine militarily. Some NATO members are acting INDEPENDENTLY of NATO.

That's a big difference and it's obvious you fail to grasp nuances/distinctions. It's a crucial point to understand.

NATO more than has the capability to implement a no fly zone.

Putin is engaged in psychological warfare with the West, NATO and our civilians. His goal has been to stop us doing anything by making us believe he would use nuclear weapons.

He'd be assuring his own destruction if he did. All he needs is for NATO to believe he'd do it and he can do whatever he wants.

You blatantly ignore this aspect of the debate every time.

Military aid is the key thing that can change the situation and end this war. If Russia takes Ukraine, they may well want to impose themselves on another country.

After all, Putin has tested and seen the West is weak. On top of that, NATO knows its member states are below full strength in Military terms, so they are literally afraid of Russia's numbers rather than strength.

Germany, for example, has a decrepit military to the point they painted broomsticks black in 2018 to pretend they had machine guns on their tanks. All this is public information.

Once again, Putin looked West and all he saw was Western weakness at all levels.

Including, unbelievably, militarily.

Putin's Russia has clearly convinced you that they'd use nuclear weapons on us. In order for the West to fulfill its obligations under the Budapest Memorandum.....let them try it.

No way does Putin want Russia to be destroyed via Nuclear Mutual Assured Destruction.

War is psychological as much as physical. NATO needs to toughen up.

RoseRedRoseBlue · 05/03/2022 12:43

@BlanketsBanned you are completely right, this is EXACTLY what Putin wants. For Gods sake, let’s not give it to him.

@JaniieJones I am also right with you. Some people on here are being deliberately obtuse. We cannot implement a No Fly Zone. It will end in the worst way possible.

thepeopleversuswork · 05/03/2022 12:28

I'm sure Zelensky isn't whiter than white. Ukraine is incredibly corrupt, as mentioned, he has had some fingers in dodgy offshore activity and there's an unpleasantly authoritarian strain in elements of Ukrainian society and the military. (Although I doubt there are people in senior positions in Ukrainian politics who haven't done similar).

But it is relative. There's no way anyone can with a straight face draw an equivalence to Putin's Russia.

FWIW I don't doubt he's got a vain and narcissistic streak because most politicians do. But you have to give him credit for the way he's stepped up in this dire situation.

Shoot me but I also would if he weren't young enough for it to be embarrassing.

SueSaid · 05/03/2022 12:22

'Its Putin who is to blame for this atrocity'

Exactly.

BlanketsBanned · 05/03/2022 12:12

So now people think its ok to turn on Zelensky after all he and his people are going through. Can you imagine how they feel seeing their country destroyed and their people killed. Its Putin who is to blame for this atrocity and you cannot blame the Ukrainian people for feeling let down, dont let Putin win by turning people against each other.

SueSaid · 05/03/2022 12:11

'Your attitude is basically, "I'm alright, Jack.....those Ukrainians will have to fend for themselves because I'm afraid of Putin!".

It isn't my attitude in the slightest. They are not fending for themselves they are getting NATO support with the provision of military equipment and humitarian support.

My 'attitude is basically' NATO cannot implement a no fly zone as the Russians will break it NATO will have to shoot them down and then Putin will consider nuclear weapons. Can you seriously not understand how escalating this further could lead to mass destruction?!

DownNative · 05/03/2022 11:52

@Polyanthus2

Putin went into Crimea and no one did anything, he poisoned opposition leaders in the UK, he went into Syria, he watched the Uk and US botch the Afghani withdrawal, Germany has gone into a nice friendly agreement to get all their cheap gas from there - cheaper than the rest of Europe - no wonder he thinks he can do what he likes. That Easyjet flight flying over Belarus was brought to Minsk by ?Russian fighter jets, the poor guy they took is still in jail, hopefully still alive. And we did nothing. Gordon Brown former PM says we need to do something to threaten Putin. Or he will just continue.
You know it! Wish people would wake up to the weakness of the West which Putin has been slowly testing for years.

This war may yet come to NATO whether they want it or not.

DownNative · 05/03/2022 11:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Polyanthus2 · 05/03/2022 11:29

therefore giving Putin the green light (as if he needs one but even he seems to think ww3 may be best avoided) for widespread escalation with even more horrific consequences.

So as long as he has nuclear weapons he gets to do what he wants. That's the upshot of this.

Polyanthus2 · 05/03/2022 11:27

Putin went into Crimea and no one did anything, he poisoned opposition leaders in the UK, he went into Syria, he watched the Uk and US botch the Afghani withdrawal, Germany has gone into a nice friendly agreement to get all their cheap gas from there - cheaper than the rest of Europe - no wonder he thinks he can do what he likes. That Easyjet flight flying over Belarus was brought to Minsk by ?Russian fighter jets, the poor guy they took is still in jail, hopefully still alive. And we did nothing.
Gordon Brown former PM says we need to do something to threaten Putin. Or he will just continue.

SueSaid · 05/03/2022 11:26

'Zelensky actually didn't say NATO was responsible for every death from now on! His words verbatim:'

"All the people who die from this day forward will also die because of you, because of your weakness, because of your lack of unity."

'He said "ALSO" which means Zelensky blames Putin as a primary cause and NATO inaction as a secondary cause.'

Ah. 'Also'. Riiight.

Well if I was Zelenskyy I'd stop and think what implementing a no fly zone would mean going forward. Russian jets would be shot down therefore giving Putin the green light (as if he needs one but even he seems to think ww3 may be best avoided) for widespread escalation with even more horrific consequences.

AKASammyScrounge · 05/03/2022 11:07

@BurnDownTheDiscoHangTheDJ

Hate to lower the tone but he’s also fit as fuck. And the braver he is the sexier he is. It’s very confusing when the news is on at the moment; terror of nuclear war and worry for everyone in Ukraine and then he comes on screen and gives me a racing heart.

We really are living in the strangest timeline.

Have you seen the Ukranian ambassador to London? He is gorgeous too.
MrsFezziwig · 05/03/2022 10:49

@Mynameisnew

Used to be a stand up comic and actor, and was the voice of Paddington bear when Ukraine dubbed the film!

What good things have made your jaw drop recently?

Rather sad that this lighthearted thread has been completely derailed. If you want a thread about political corruption maybe start your own?
MrsFezziwig · 05/03/2022 10:45

I love Bob, but not sure he's prime minister material. He seems a bit thick on 8 out of 10 cats! (though I guess our current crop are the pinnacle of intelligence..)

If your measure of intelligence is “knows a lot of facts” then I’m sure you’re right. I bet Boris knows loads of facts.

Jedsnewstar · 05/03/2022 10:37

Yes and now Facebook is full of idiots posting how the war is faked and how he is an actor (showing the IMDb page as evidence). These are on local groups and selling pages etc, if I had these morons as friends I would delete them immediately, even family.
I also searched some of their names in the same groups, funnily enough many are the same people who have been posting anti vax stuff.
We live in dangerous times in many ways.

Tigersonvaseline · 05/03/2022 10:37

I must say thank god for the USA

It's one of the only things I agreed with trump on, raise your spending! I bet they regret that now!!

Why have they let it slide?
The USA are all over the world providing support and buffers everywhere???
Their plane's and base's area all over the EU.

Thank god for them, non of us it seems could hold the line without them.

DownNative · 05/03/2022 10:36

@JaniieJones

"Individual NATO member countries are sending weapons, ammunition, medical supplies and other vital military equipment to Ukraine."

'In military terms, this is NOWHERE near enough. It is effectively doing nothing of significance militarily.'

Nothing will be enough. But to say it is nothing of significance is just not true.

Not true!

NATO fighter jet capability would make a huge difference to the Ukrainian Army. This would enable Ukraine to turn the tide which is slowly going against them as they become depleted.

DownNative · 05/03/2022 10:32

@LittleEsme

The question though, is why?

Why haven't they sent in more defence?

As a total lay person with zero expertise in anything military, it feels like NATO are treading on eggshells because heavier intervention leads to the utter unthinkable.

Fear of nuclear war is one reason, but the other reason is NATO member armies are much weaker than they used to be.

Look at what happened with the US Army. German Parliamentary report showed the German army is decrepit with ageing equipment and Germany unable to fulfill NATO training exercises. The British Army is much smaller than in the past.

In short, NATO has been carried by the US fir years while Europe allowed their military strength to slide.

Tigersonvaseline · 05/03/2022 10:30

I read somewhere in a haze of Twitter that 66 thou Ukraine have gone back to fight.
Also from uk 1,600 have been said to go? I'e Brits.

Then I heard rumours of ex retired sas and ffl.... that's all what we know about.
I wonder if other countries have people going to help ?

It takes time to get all these weapons into Ukraine and then get them to the right places.

Hopefully a ceasefire gives them that Extra time?

DownNative · 05/03/2022 10:29

@JaniieJones

'NATO itself is NOT providing any military assistance of any description to Ukraine.'

Member states have provided massive military support equipment etc. He has had global support, countries rushing to help. There isn't a no fly zone why on earth can't he see that would lead to horrific escalation??

His 'i need ammo not a ride' style comments are a bit Confused imo.

No doubt he is stressed and exhausted but to say NATO is responsible for every death from this day is a terrible thing to say. Again, no, Putin is.

The member states themselves are NOT NATO. If you bother to look at the excerpts from NATO'S own website, you'll understand that crucial difference.

By your logic, NATO was involved in the invasion of Afghanistan because three NATO members were! Hmm

Zelensky actually didn't say NATO was responsible for every death from now on! His words verbatim:

"All the people who die from this day forward will also die because of you, because of your weakness, because of your lack of unity."

He said "ALSO" which means Zelensky blames Putin as a primary cause and NATO inaction as a secondary cause.

On both counts, he's 100% correct.

Despite NATO'S claims, they are not always a defensive alliance. They have been on the offensive before.

SueSaid · 05/03/2022 10:25

"Individual NATO member countries are sending weapons, ammunition, medical supplies and other vital military equipment to Ukraine."

'In military terms, this is NOWHERE near enough. It is effectively doing nothing of significance militarily.'

Nothing will be enough. But to say it is nothing of significance is just not true.

LittleEsme · 05/03/2022 10:23

The question though, is why?

Why haven't they sent in more defence?

As a total lay person with zero expertise in anything military, it feels like NATO are treading on eggshells because heavier intervention leads to the utter unthinkable.

SueSaid · 05/03/2022 10:23

'NATO itself is NOT providing any military assistance of any description to Ukraine.'

Member states have provided massive military support equipment etc. He has had global support, countries rushing to help. There isn't a no fly zone why on earth can't he see that would lead to horrific escalation??

His 'i need ammo not a ride' style comments are a bit Confused imo.

No doubt he is stressed and exhausted but to say NATO is responsible for every death from this day is a terrible thing to say. Again, no, Putin is.