Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to use a normal light switch that I can turn on or off easily

91 replies

Enidcat5 · 04/03/2022 06:51

My husband is very tech savvy, he was very keen when we bought our first house to put in technology to 'makes things easier'. The problem is that I don't agree that it's making things easier, as everything seems more difficult to do.

There are smart plugs and wireless switches everywhere. Aside from the fact that I think they look awful (they are the white plastic ikea ones) and don't fit with our 1890 style house (it has lots of period features that I love) I am increasingly frustrated with how much harder these switches and systems make simple tasks.

This morning I went to put the dining room light on, so I pressed the normal wall switch. Nothing happened. I then see one of these smart switches on the table. He's programmed it to 'dim' the lights in the room so now I have to find the portable light switch each time I want to turn on or off the light. I have small children so there's no way this switch will stay where its meant to be. Also it's the room we use for working and kids homework plus meals, so I don't understand why we'd want to dim the light.

My hallway is dark so I have to put on a light to put kids shoes on to leave for nursery and school in the morning. We're always in a hurry. But to put light on I usually have to try at least 2 times to get the flipping smart switch to work, as its stiff and also for some reason they decided to make these things so they stick to the wall holder with a magnet. The amount of times it flies off when I'm rushing and I then have to hunt on the floor for it. It adds stress to the proceedings. There are also 2 of them and I inevitably pick the wrong one, so end up having to do the dropping and retrieving process twice.

My husband's reasoning is that it's useful to be able to dim the lights (we have soft lamps which could be used instead, or we could just use a dimmer?) and we can turn lights on and off from our phones. I don't understand the point of this. I'm walking past the light switch as I leave the room, I don't want to have to get my phone out to turn the bloody thing off when I can just point my finger at it and press. I get the interest in dimming but there are dimmer switches that look a whole lot nicer than these things and are much easier to use.

I want to get rid of them. I have said this several times and he's ignoring me. I've said it again this morning and he's in a huff. I am at the point of screaming.

Aibu?

OP posts:
MMAMPWGHAP · 04/03/2022 08:13

100% with you OP. My husband has put some in too (but mainly in areas I don’t use much).
My objections include:
Harder to use, especially in the dark.
Losing the remote.
On a light fitting with 3 bulbs sometimes they get out of sync and only 2 come on.
Eco nightmare, all that extra plastic and batteries.

He’s used some colour changing bulbs but as he’s colour blind can’t see that even set to white they do match the other bulbs and look absurd.
Hilariously he’s recently redecorated his office and I note has reverted to the manual light switch. I’ve not gloated but am obvs very pleased.

What happens when your Wi-Fi is down?

AgentJohnson · 04/03/2022 08:11

You both sound ridiculous and entrenched in your views. Set up a motion detector, programme your lights etc. There is a compromise to be found but it appears neither of you want to reach it.

Sparticuscaticus · 04/03/2022 08:00

I agree OP especially as you have an old period home and he's putting in cheap looking glitchy smart bulb tatt that's doesn't work anyway

I wouldn't wait for electrician
You can remove the lightbulbs if they are smart ones. Go to b&q and buy Norma led replacement bulbs or whatever you prefer.

Put his smart lightbulbs into a box in the loft. Job done.

Lights back and remind him when he gets home that you don't have time for this cheap shit, you've young DCs to look after, who all need to be able to see. He can have a smart lightbulb in the lamp by his bed. Other than that , until it's better quality and reliable and pre-agreed by you, he better not touch the lights again.

PopGoesBang · 04/03/2022 07:59

Similar here. The novelty was ok to start with. Especially during lockdown.
Dd has misplaced the remote that can go on the wall countless times. You always need a light when you don't have your phone.
And, lockdowns over and my dad was looking after dd for a couple of hours... sat in darkness as he doesn't have the app (and didn't know which lights were on that and which weren't).

My mission is to remove all and just return to old skool lights and switches that actually do their job.

AngelinaFibres · 04/03/2022 07:58

Friends have had a camper van conversion done. Very beautiful, very expensive. Everything is controlled by Alexa. God what a load of absolute tossery. 'Alexa turn on the lights '.......loooooong pause and silence and no activity......alexa wakes up and says 'turning on lights'.....pause then lights come on. You could have turned then on with your hand, got what you wanted, turned them off again and be halfway across the bloody field in the time it takes the faff to happen.

Stuffin · 04/03/2022 07:58

That is so annoying.

Thankfully I am the techie in our house so if it isn't helpful or practical it doesn't happen.

Pottedpalm · 04/03/2022 07:56

I feel your pain! I’m forever pressing switches when I ‘shouldn’t’ and am fed up
Of lights dimming or going out when I don’t want them to. DH has Hive; I couldn’t be bothered.

DisforDarkChocolate · 04/03/2022 07:53

We only have one smart switch in our living room and it's bloody annoying. I am much more likely to decide about the lighting when I walk in or out of a room than any other time. I don't want to ask Alexa to put the light on, or find an app on my phone that's in a different room!

Cissyandflora · 04/03/2022 07:53

I’m with husband. I love tech! I’ve gone even further than him with it.
(I do understand your frustration though)

rifling · 04/03/2022 07:51

So so glad my dh is a bit of a technophobe
Me too! We have one smart plug that we use for the Christmas Tree lights and that's it - and we couldn't get that to work this year. If the whole house was wired up we would probably be in the dark half the time!

frazzledasarock · 04/03/2022 07:49

We have a remote for a set of lights in our house. But the switch in the wall also works.

What happens when the remote runs out of battery power?

MrsClatterbuck · 04/03/2022 07:48

So so glad my dh is a bit of a technophobe

Thewindwhispers · 04/03/2022 07:45

Yanbu. Out your foot down. It’s your home too.

I have a light installed by a previous owner that I can only turn on or off with my phone. I HATE it. Especially when my phone is flat battery!

A lot of thisnis nonsense dreampt up by young male tech geeks who live at google/amazon etc and have no idea how middle aged women live. They can’t imagine a phone having a flat battery or a child losing a remote control. Resist them!!

suckingonchillidogs · 04/03/2022 07:42

I feel like such a dick speaking to an inanimate object, it's bad enough requesting music, I don't think I could cope with lights as well!

Enidcat5 · 04/03/2022 07:41

It's unanimous so far!!! Yes!!! The screwdriver's coming out

OP posts:
savehannah · 04/03/2022 07:40

Sympathy. We have Alexa controlled lights (my husband's idea not mine obvs) which ocassionally are good like switching off when you're on bed, or switching off everything upstairs the kids have left on, using the app. But mostly I find it annoying and takes longer than using the switch. You can still use the switch but you have to switch it off and on again so I tend not to.

GiantSweetcorn · 04/03/2022 07:39

It sounds more to me like he's bought rubbish smart products than the issue is actually with having smart products...

We have Lightwave switches and they are absolutely fine - the switches work as normal on the wall, no pinging off, no ruining routines, no lights going haywire if the internet cuts out, or anything like that. But I can also do it from my phone, and can tell Alexa to do it for me if my hands are full. We have also set it up to be able to say things like "Alexa we're leaving" and all the lights in the house go off, rather than coming home to find a stray bedroom light has been on all day because a child rushed back for a jumper and turned every light on on the way. I thought it was all wholly unnecessary but genuinely use it a lot now.

I don't think you're unreasonable at all for being furious with your awful sounding set up - and that needs to go - but there are better options.

Debroglie · 04/03/2022 07:39

Dh not dc

Debroglie · 04/03/2022 07:38

I should have said that the heating is also controlled by his app as are the bloody speakers.
I’m going to buy myself a little battery-powered radio just so I can listen to radio 4 when I’m at home despite us having fancy Bose speakers in every room because I don’t know how to use them!
It’s like dc is living in the future and I’m off back to the 70s!

EffOrfagain · 04/03/2022 07:35

We have both Siri and Alexa and both are limited use as you seem to have to say the exact phrase or they don't know what you are on about, Alexa thing is particularly useless. Hive seems ok as long as it is not connected to Alexa which seemed overly complicated to set up in the first place, Alexa's use is really limited to setting alarms, asking it to play a particular piece of music seems to be a step too far, Siri does manage this ok though. Getting these OP will probably not help much

Debroglie · 04/03/2022 07:34

Oh god I have a very similar issue.
Dh has put all the lamps on this WiFi system and sometimes I’m sitting reading and the lights will all just turn off and I’m plunged into darkness. I have mentioned that this happens and dh just mutters something about fixing the timings and nothing changes.
The heating also seemingly randomly switches on and off. The other day I was home alone and doing some cleaning so I opened all the windows to air the house and after a while realised that the heating had clicked on.
Dh has a weird control thing and is totally egocentric so I’m not going to fight about it but I do feel your pain.

MaryLennoxsScowl · 04/03/2022 07:32

Oh god, my DH did this too, without explaining to me first that I’d need to download an app to use the bloody lights. My phone had stopped downloading apps as it was old and shit, so every time I needed the lights on I had to message him at work and tell him to put them on from his phone!!

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 04/03/2022 07:31

Sounds like a bloke thing to me - the love of gadgets, whether they’re more of a PITA to use or not.

What’s wrong with a dimmer switch? We’ve had those in 2 downstairs rooms for decades.

I suspect that’s also the reason why my washing machine has 14 zillion programmes, instead of the few that I actually use - but not the ‘just spin’ function I really do want now and then. Designed by men, for sure.

Enidcat5 · 04/03/2022 07:29

@Joystir59

He is playing games with your house tech, like a child. Call an electrician and have the lot of it removed, and tell him to stop being such a knob. Be assertive FFS! It's your house and home too.
Also yes to the child bit. Very much agree
OP posts:
AlwaysFireFighting · 04/03/2022 07:29

This would drive me fucking mental. My DH tried to insist we always play the radio through the Sonos speaker, which involves walkimg to wherever a phone or tablet has been left, unlocking it, scrolling to BBC Sounds app, finding correct station and clicking play.

I insisted on keeping my radio where it is thanks. Right next to meal prep area. One button to switch it on, and already preset to my preferred station.

Currently trialling smart radiator valves to save money by not heating upstairs whenever downstairs is heated. Sometimes my son's doesn't connect to internet and he wakes up in a freezing cold room.