Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to use a normal light switch that I can turn on or off easily

91 replies

Enidcat5 · 04/03/2022 06:51

My husband is very tech savvy, he was very keen when we bought our first house to put in technology to 'makes things easier'. The problem is that I don't agree that it's making things easier, as everything seems more difficult to do.

There are smart plugs and wireless switches everywhere. Aside from the fact that I think they look awful (they are the white plastic ikea ones) and don't fit with our 1890 style house (it has lots of period features that I love) I am increasingly frustrated with how much harder these switches and systems make simple tasks.

This morning I went to put the dining room light on, so I pressed the normal wall switch. Nothing happened. I then see one of these smart switches on the table. He's programmed it to 'dim' the lights in the room so now I have to find the portable light switch each time I want to turn on or off the light. I have small children so there's no way this switch will stay where its meant to be. Also it's the room we use for working and kids homework plus meals, so I don't understand why we'd want to dim the light.

My hallway is dark so I have to put on a light to put kids shoes on to leave for nursery and school in the morning. We're always in a hurry. But to put light on I usually have to try at least 2 times to get the flipping smart switch to work, as its stiff and also for some reason they decided to make these things so they stick to the wall holder with a magnet. The amount of times it flies off when I'm rushing and I then have to hunt on the floor for it. It adds stress to the proceedings. There are also 2 of them and I inevitably pick the wrong one, so end up having to do the dropping and retrieving process twice.

My husband's reasoning is that it's useful to be able to dim the lights (we have soft lamps which could be used instead, or we could just use a dimmer?) and we can turn lights on and off from our phones. I don't understand the point of this. I'm walking past the light switch as I leave the room, I don't want to have to get my phone out to turn the bloody thing off when I can just point my finger at it and press. I get the interest in dimming but there are dimmer switches that look a whole lot nicer than these things and are much easier to use.

I want to get rid of them. I have said this several times and he's ignoring me. I've said it again this morning and he's in a huff. I am at the point of screaming.

Aibu?

OP posts:
Crazykatie · 04/03/2022 09:14

My BIL is a geek fixed up the house to work by voice command, very clever at first, the novelty quickly wore off, it’s a pain in the arse having to speak to the kettle instead of flicking a switch.
Alexa is cute for browsing but not the house.

RitaFires · 04/03/2022 09:09

I have some hue bulbs so that I can dim them from an app but they still work with the normal wall switch. Technology should make your life easier not harder.

CasperGutman · 04/03/2022 09:06

I can understand wanting to dim the lights in the room where you have meals. A romantic dinner for two on Valentine's Day, or a sophisticated dinner party, would be absolutely ruined for me if the only option for lighting was bright overhead light.

Other than that though, you're entirely right. Annoying remote controls and smart lights are just a silly fad that adds no value. When we had our extension the electrician initially said it wasn't even possible to have under cabinet LED tape which dimmed by turning a knob on the wall, but it was perfectly do-able.

(In case anyone else is struggling, we just needed one of these www.tlc-direct.co.uk/Products/LTYT40DC12.html )

YetAnotherSpartacus · 04/03/2022 09:03

YANBU - are you sure you’re not married to my husband?! I’ve had to switch the shower off four times this morning because the internet decided that it should be on

Is the internet linked to a smell receptor that decided you are rather whiffy and is giving you a hint?

refreshingseahorse · 04/03/2022 09:02

I thought I was the only one!! There should be a support group.

We have the Philips system which does at least offer a wall switch. I don't think DH quite understood my unwillingness to use my phone to operate the lights but he did install the smart wall switches in response to my complaints.

Enidcat5 · 04/03/2022 08:59

@OldTinHat

This has made me laugh! I'm like your DH, OP, but all of my lights are hooked up to Alexa so operated by voice (but I can use my phone too). No unsightly contraptions as I use Philips Hue bulbs.

It works perfectly for me, I live alone, I can turn the bathroom lights on before getting out of bed in the middle of the night and so on.

However! When my family come to stay they're flicking light switches on and off (they will work but bugger up my Alexa settings), they try the voice controls but get the light names wrong (bathroom, lounge, dining room, landing...really so hard?!). I have to follow them to reset the switches and sort out the phone app 😆 It's hilarious and really annoying at the same time but they only come to visit a couple of times a year! I'm planning on putting post it notes on the switches next time they come!

Maybe you should come over and fix them. I like the sound of yours
OP posts:
Enidcat5 · 04/03/2022 08:59

[quote windthatbobbin]I was crying with laughter by the end of your OP. Of course YANBU. It's quite a funny set of images, this reasonable person looking defeatedly at things that are supposed to help that actually make life harder. You should show him this guy on TikTok:

[/quote] I've already sent him this thread so I'll send this too, thank you!
OP posts:
Whingasaurus · 04/03/2022 08:58

Bin, break, deny rinse and repeat til he listens to you. Life is too short for arguments you've said your piece and been ignored nows the time for malicious compliance. I also repeatedly ask for help if I can't work instantly whatever ridiculous piece of new tech arrives it then gets consigned to the garage fairly quickly. However I bloody love my Alexa so I'm open to reasonable adjustments.

Chihuahuapower · 04/03/2022 08:58

YANBU

My husband did the same thing. A year later, he replaced them all because he said he was sick of my huffing... but I suspect he found them a pain in the arse too

Enidcat5 · 04/03/2022 08:57

@Cissyandflora

I’m with husband. I love tech! I’ve gone even further than him with it. (I do understand your frustration though)
Husband is that you? Halo
OP posts:
Enidcat5 · 04/03/2022 08:57

@gamerchick

Husband tried the Alexa thing but I kept turning it off downstairs. He's confined the speaking to a machine bollocks to his bedroom. Stick to your guns, maybe give him one room he can fill his boots in.
I love alexa in the kitchen, she records my shopping list. We don't have her anywhere else though
OP posts:
Enidcat5 · 04/03/2022 08:56

@FinallyHere

I'm the tech geek in our household. DH humours me so long as the solution is at least as easy for him to use as before and things work reliably.

We have these light switches

https://wifi-smart-home.co.uk/smart-switches/smart-wifi-light-switches/pure-glass-wifi-smart-light-switches/

He can use them as a normal switch.

In addition they 'glow in the dark' so easy to find and they can be controlled though Alexa and my phone.

No going downstairs again if someone has left a light on. Last thing at night I can turn off all the lights in one go. When we are away, the lights can come on as usual so the house looks occupied.

Alexa does need to know the names of things but things can be grouped together so that ' kitchen lights on ' turns on the lights we use when cooking. 'Let there be light' turns on every light in the house. 'Lights out, no talking' turns everything off.

It's not really the technology you are complaining about, it's the implementation you have which makes all the difference.

Really useful thanks!
OP posts:
Enidcat5 · 04/03/2022 08:54

@LadyRoughDiamond

YANBU - are you sure you’re not married to my husband?! I’ve had to switch the shower off four times this morning because the internet decided that it should be on. Most smart home tech has an option to go back to manual settings - I’m quietly switching everything back to manual.
Oh my! If he starts messing with my shower it's divorce! Grin
OP posts:
FinallyHere · 04/03/2022 08:54

I'm the tech geek in our household. DH humours me so long as the solution is at least as easy for him to use as before and things work reliably.

We have these light switches

https://wifi-smart-home.co.uk/smart-switches/smart-wifi-light-switches/pure-glass-wifi-smart-light-switches/

He can use them as a normal switch.

In addition they 'glow in the dark' so easy to find and they can be controlled though Alexa and my phone.

No going downstairs again if someone has left a light on. Last thing at night I can turn off all the lights in one go. When we are away, the lights can come on as usual so the house looks occupied.

Alexa does need to know the names of things but things can be grouped together so that ' kitchen lights on ' turns on the lights we use when cooking. 'Let there be light' turns on every light in the house. 'Lights out, no talking' turns everything off.

It's not really the technology you are complaining about, it's the implementation you have which makes all the difference.

Enidcat5 · 04/03/2022 08:54

@MMAMPWGHAP

100% with you OP. My husband has put some in too (but mainly in areas I don’t use much). My objections include: Harder to use, especially in the dark. Losing the remote. On a light fitting with 3 bulbs sometimes they get out of sync and only 2 come on. Eco nightmare, all that extra plastic and batteries.

He’s used some colour changing bulbs but as he’s colour blind can’t see that even set to white they do match the other bulbs and look absurd.
Hilariously he’s recently redecorated his office and I note has reverted to the manual light switch. I’ve not gloated but am obvs very pleased.

What happens when your Wi-Fi is down?

I can press the switch if WiFi down but then what's the point of the extra switch. Your objections sound very much like mine.
OP posts:
Enidcat5 · 04/03/2022 08:52

@AgentJohnson

You both sound ridiculous and entrenched in your views. Set up a motion detector, programme your lights etc. There is a compromise to be found but it appears neither of you want to reach it.
Who rattled your cage this morning? I've already spoken to him about it reasonably, he disagrees. I'm asking for opinions on whether I'm being unreasonable. That's the absolute contradiction of 'entrenched in my views'. Go and have your ready brek, you sound awfy hangry.
OP posts:
cortex10 · 04/03/2022 08:46

DH is into this sort of thing but our set up is pretty useful. We've got PIRs in key rooms like hall, landing and kitchen which is really handy not to have to use the switch with hands full. Also bulbs in other rooms that can be programmed to come on and off at set times - they can also be set to different colours and light levels using the phone app or home pod.

OldTinHat · 04/03/2022 08:46

This has made me laugh! I'm like your DH, OP, but all of my lights are hooked up to Alexa so operated by voice (but I can use my phone too). No unsightly contraptions as I use Philips Hue bulbs.

It works perfectly for me, I live alone, I can turn the bathroom lights on before getting out of bed in the middle of the night and so on.

However! When my family come to stay they're flicking light switches on and off (they will work but bugger up my Alexa settings), they try the voice controls but get the light names wrong (bathroom, lounge, dining room, landing...really so hard?!). I have to follow them to reset the switches and sort out the phone app 😆 It's hilarious and really annoying at the same time but they only come to visit a couple of times a year! I'm planning on putting post it notes on the switches next time they come!

LadyRoughDiamond · 04/03/2022 08:43

YANBU - are you sure you’re not married to my husband?! I’ve had to switch the shower off four times this morning because the internet decided that it should be on. Most smart home tech has an option to go back to manual settings - I’m quietly switching everything back to manual.

windthatbobbin · 04/03/2022 08:40

I was crying with laughter by the end of your OP. Of course YANBU. It's quite a funny set of images, this reasonable person looking defeatedly at things that are supposed to help that actually make life harder. You should show him this guy on TikTok:

gamerchick · 04/03/2022 08:39

Husband tried the Alexa thing but I kept turning it off downstairs. He's confined the speaking to a machine bollocks to his bedroom. Stick to your guns, maybe give him one room he can fill his boots in.

Alwayscheerful · 04/03/2022 08:36

I would be livid but I would make my point by using a torch instead.
I have 3 lamps set up via Alexa in the sitting room and I love to say Alexa turn on the lamps rather than bend d out we n 3 times.

Hellorhighwater · 04/03/2022 08:33

YANBU. Those are really shit smart lights. I have smart switches almost everywhere, but if you didn’t know or like them, they the same as regular switches (well, they are flat, but you can just press them) they ADD functionality of being able to turn lights on and off with your hands full, dim them, or remotely turn them off, or put them on timers. Yours sound utterly pointless and seriously annoying.

I ADORE tech, but it should always make life easier, not harder. He’s a twit. Maybe a compromise would be to get better ones that actually are smart?

godmum56 · 04/03/2022 08:23

I do like my Alexa stuff but it has its limits and I live alone so I can do what I like. my setup is that the plug in lamps are smart and the wired in lights are not. Honestly if I was married to your DH I would be using the screwdriver for murder and not for electrical work, and I do like my tech. I'd be telling him he can have us much tech as he likes in the garden shed and he can go live there and if you haven't got a garden shed then send him out to build one. a ps is that I find the newer Echo Shows much better than the old Dots for voice recognition. I went over to Shows to monitor my tortoises.

gungemonster · 04/03/2022 08:16

YADNBU

We have a group of lamps set on Alexa so we just tell her to switch them on and off. It works very well.
Switched next to switches for switches sake is just a dick move