Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think smacking was 'acceptable' in the 90s?

308 replies

Grapeflavour · 03/03/2022 21:34

My parents smacked me as a child, usually if I did something they deemed as 'very naughty' or sometimes if I just didn't stop doing something quite trivial, they would threaten me with smacking.

I just assumed this was normal (albeit bad) attitudes back then, but talking to a couple of friends around the same age (30s) recently, it seems like that's not the case? They seemed pretty horrified that my dad used to occasionally hit me well into my teens if I pissed him off. As a teen he would often square up to me and threaten to 'knock me out' if I challenged him or talked back. I was 16 the last time he hit me. (I know this behaviour is totally unacceptable, and bearing in mind he is a huge 6"2 man and I was a 5"5 teenage girl). I think this has had an impact on me and trying to work through it.

Would you say it was fairly typical and normalised for parents to smack kids as punishment in the 90s? Or not at all?

OP posts:
WhoKnowsProbsNotMe · 03/03/2022 22:43

I grew up in the 90s and got smacked ALL the time (though I was a little sh*t) though never with much force i.e. any slight mark/redness left wouldn’t be there long (less than half an hour). Though it really was the norm both sides of the family and all my friends parents (though only smacking their own child) I’m not any worse off for it, however what you are talking about is a complete different level that’s not smacking in my opinion that’s full on abuse x

hangrylady · 03/03/2022 22:42

I was a child in the 80s and 90s and my parents have some pretty old fashioned ideas, but the only time mum ever hit me was a Peggy Mitchell style slap across the face when I was about 15 and being an absolute bitch to her. My Dad has never raised his hand to me not once so in my experience YABU.

Snazzyjazzpants · 03/03/2022 22:42

Spanking primary school age children was acceptable, but threatening to knock a teenager out wasn't.
My parents smacked my very occasionally, but I had a friend whose father would hit her with a belt as a teen. I saw no correlation between these punishments and knew what happened to my friend was very, very wrong. I think one of the dangers of spanking is a belief that if the behaviour continues you haven't hit them hard enough, hence the escalation in violence.
I'm sorry your father was such a sick to you op. My friend took years to process what happened to her and has trouble with relationships to this day as a result.

blameless · 03/03/2022 22:42

Corporal punishment was used in my secondary school until 1987. It continued to be legal in independent schools until 1999.
From a personal perspective, while the punishment was both cruel and unusual (my school and one other applied a peculiar form of beating to to the hands), it was preferred by many to detention (2 hours on a Friday night) because it was over quickly and the infraction deemed settled.
Despite it becoming far less common for children to be smacked, many cultures support physical chastisement by the head of the household (male or female) with some horrific outcomes.

tonic.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/Domestic-Abuse-Perpetrators-within-minoritised-communities-TONIC-v1.8-FINAL.pdf

Acesup · 03/03/2022 22:42

It was normal where I lived for me and younger cousins. But only a light tap on the bum really (meaning "you've really gone too far this time"). I don't think squaring up to a teenager would have been acceptable at all.

LindyLou2020 · 03/03/2022 22:41

@Grapeflavour.......
I'm sorry that happened to you. I'm totally unsurprised that it has had a lasting impact on you Flowers
I was a child in the 50's and 60's, when corporal punishment was seen as the norm, ("spare the rod and spoil the child" - appalling).
I was smacked a lot by a quick-tempered mother for the heinous crime of being a lively, sometimes a-bit-naughty child. I saw classmates in primary school caned.
It still haunts me now, in my 60's.
My kids were born late 80's/early 90's, and smacking was never on my agenda.
I can't remember what the societal norms were at the time, but my experiences made me determined never to hit my children.
I am no saint, and there were times when I lost my temper and could easily have hurt them.
But I could not do to them what was done to me.
Hitting children is abhorrent, inexcusable and damages them - often more than we can ever know.

BasicBinaryBltch · 03/03/2022 22:40

@Rno3gfr

Even by 90s standards smacking a young child and threatening to “knock out” a 16 year old girl were on two different levels.

Apparently I was occasionally smacked as a toddler in the late 90s. I don’t remember it though. I wasn’t smacked during my childhood in the naughties.

Now it’s considered abhorrent to smack. Although I don’t condone smacking and haven’t smacked my own child (and won’t), I don’t consider it child abuse to occasionally lightly smack a child in limited circumstances, e.g. I’m dangerous situations/ if they’re in danger of doing something harmful to themselves. It is child abuse to hit a child to the point where it hurts them at any age. It’s bizarre to use smacking as a form of punishment past a certain age.

Yeah exactly. Smacking isn't great but there is actually a vast difference between the exceedingly rare single smack VS beating your child with objects/leaving bruises or bleeding.

Unfortunately the latter still happens, I've seen it. Any physical hitting isn't great but one smack is not that bad and it won't traumatise anyone.

Same as shouting. It can be abuse. But there's a difference between the odd shout at the end of your tether VS relentless insults and emotional abuse, non stop shouting and fear.

Once again, not great, but the odd smack isn't the end of the world. Parents should apologise at the time and move on.

housemaus · 03/03/2022 22:40

I was threatened with a smacked bum a few times, and got precisely 2 smacks through the years - one, on the arm, when I ran into the road at about 7 and my mum must have been TERRIFIED and smacked me on the arm when she finally caught me. And one - which I'm sure she's not proud of now, but I think was the only thing that shocked me into shutting up at the time - when I was 15 and was being a horrible cow and screamed in her face to shut the fuck up, and she slapped my cheek.

It wasn't seen as that unusual, or at least the idea of 'if you're naughty you'll get a smack' - I dunno how many people actually did.

That's not what you're describing though, OP - that was abuse :(

HamCob · 03/03/2022 22:38

@JunkIsland

Yes, it was more normal. Primarily the tapping or light smacking that pps are talking about, but because that’s subjective it allowed people like my dad to hit me a lot harder, while I’m sure thinking it was all perfectly respectable and norms. When I got smacked, it bloody hurt and left palm prints. I also had the threats. Like you, I haven’t really got over it op.

I’m glad it’s now unequivocally wrong to hit kids. No fudging around tapping.

Yes I think smacking was still just about acceptable in the 80s/90s and it allowed a huge range of unacceptable behaviour to pass under the radar in my family, from a 'tap', to being beaten black & blue once with a slipper and a belt. I used to think it was a bit of a working class thing as I couldn't imagine it happening in the homes of my mc friends at school, however DH had a similar upbringing and his parents never laid a finger on him. I have a good relationship with my parents now. They are like different people, but since having DC I really struggle to reconcile it all.
Thriwit · 03/03/2022 22:38

I was born mid-80s and neither me nor my sister were ever smacked by either parent. I don’t remember seeing family smack, or friends being smacked, either. Its just not something that I’ve ever really encountered

Kanaloa · 03/03/2022 22:36

@Rno3gfr

Even by 90s standards smacking a young child and threatening to “knock out” a 16 year old girl were on two different levels.

Apparently I was occasionally smacked as a toddler in the late 90s. I don’t remember it though. I wasn’t smacked during my childhood in the naughties.

Now it’s considered abhorrent to smack. Although I don’t condone smacking and haven’t smacked my own child (and won’t), I don’t consider it child abuse to occasionally lightly smack a child in limited circumstances, e.g. I’m dangerous situations/ if they’re in danger of doing something harmful to themselves. It is child abuse to hit a child to the point where it hurts them at any age. It’s bizarre to use smacking as a form of punishment past a certain age.

If it doesn’t hurt them then what is the point? How will it suddenly work to teach them not to do these ‘dangerous things’ if it doesn’t hurt? All these harmful things can somehow be solved by a light smack that doesn’t hurt?

Also think it’s totally fucked up that you find it ‘bizarre’ to hit an older child, but okay and justifiable to hit a small toddler/smaller child. I guess they’re less likely to tell anyone though.

Kanaloa · 03/03/2022 22:34

@DrSbaitso

Ooh, we'll get the "running into the road" lot soon as well, won't we? Hitters always seem to be so shite at road safety.
Yeah they’ll be along to tell us how sometimes a ‘sharp shock’ is the only way to stop your 2yo from sticking his face on the burning hot stove. Absolutely nothing you could do except smack him, no other way to prevent it.
Overtheroadroundthecorner · 03/03/2022 22:33

Normal to me. I was born late 80s so grew up in the 90s.

I have my own children now and it’s made me think, my mother in particular smacked me and my siblings regularly, not because we were naughty, she’d smacked us because she’d lost control of the situation and took her frustration out on us.

Being a parent myself I understand that feeling when your children are pushing you to the edge, but I don’t smack and never will.

Rno3gfr · 03/03/2022 22:32

Even by 90s standards smacking a young child and threatening to “knock out” a 16 year old girl were on two different levels.

Apparently I was occasionally smacked as a toddler in the late 90s. I don’t remember it though. I wasn’t smacked during my childhood in the naughties.

Now it’s considered abhorrent to smack. Although I don’t condone smacking and haven’t smacked my own child (and won’t), I don’t consider it child abuse to occasionally lightly smack a child in limited circumstances, e.g. I’m dangerous situations/ if they’re in danger of doing something harmful to themselves. It is child abuse to hit a child to the point where it hurts them at any age. It’s bizarre to use smacking as a form of punishment past a certain age.

PatientlyWaiting21 · 03/03/2022 22:32

I remember it happening to me and now that I’m a mother myself I will never understand how you can hit your child. You are the one person the look up to, rely on, I’ll never raise my hand.

Sometimeswinning · 03/03/2022 22:31

Huge difference to being smacked on the bum to what you went through. I remember my parents did smack me or would threaton to. Only one individual time when I think my mum lost it with me. I was older and moved out the way. Other than that I don't feel bothered about their form of punishment. I only know I would never do it but there is so much more understanding for children and behaviour these days. (I was 80/90 child)

Kanaloa · 03/03/2022 22:31

Who SMACK obviously. Far be it from me to tell you you can’t scoff a back of dairylea dunkers.

Momicrone · 03/03/2022 22:31

Is that a Calvin Harris remix?

Kanaloa · 03/03/2022 22:30

It may have been more normalised but it was as unacceptable as it is now.

I would never smack my kids and throughly disagree with it as a method of teaching. I think parents who snack are at best very lazy and selfish, and at worst nasty bullies.

SoberSerena · 03/03/2022 22:29

I think it probably was slightly more acceptable, but my parents never hit us and we were all 80s babies. They were extremely against hitting children, (as am I).

A mum I knew through work used to talk about giving her toddler a smacked bottom and that was only in 2015 and I've heard parents talking about it in the supermarket even more recently than that; "don't do that or I'll give you a smacked bottom in front of all these people".

So I think it just really varies.

Can't imagine anyone thinking a grown man hitting a 16yo girl or squaring up to her was OK

Gingembre · 03/03/2022 22:29

[quote Grapeflavour]@gingembre
My dad fully stands by his decision to smack me and if ever asked about it says that I didn't turn out too badly so what's the problem? He wouldn't apologise for hurting me or making me scared or fearful as a child in a million years.[/quote]
My mother is similar.
Yet, it has caused me quite some problems. Just because she refuses to recognise them doesn't mean she's right. There's more than one view or experience and the unwillingness/inability to recognise mine is exactly what underlies hitting me in the first place.

I've turned out ok, despite being hit. My friend who weren't hit also turned out fine. So, what was so beneficial about making me grow up scared?

Anyway, what exactly would turning out not ok look like? Like a person who terrorises children in their care? 😉

Rupertpenrysmistress · 03/03/2022 22:29

I think it was more acceptable in the 70's although my DM was a bit extreme. My dad rarely hit me but my mum would belt me, leaving marks and handprints and stinging. I was terrified of my mum, I honestly was not a bad Child and now feel like I am always a disappointment.

I have never hit my children, I don't know what is to be gained from hurting a vulnerable child, it feels like a power trip. My DM used to scream in my face, I remember her grabbing me and forcing me back over the bath, my db had to intervene. I know this is not normal and it still affects me now. My DM admits she was not a great mum but has not ever really addressed this. I don't have a genuine relationship just a duty.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 03/03/2022 22:28

I was smacked on the bum if I was naught and if my brother and I were arguing we would have our heads cracked together. The last time he did it I ended up with a broken nose and 2 black eyes right before a family wedding.

I told my parents in no uncertain terms, if they ever raised a hand to my child they would never see him again.

They are way better grandparents than they were parents. But now I'm a parent, I can sort of understand how that can be the case.

NameChanger45465465 · 03/03/2022 22:27

I grew up in the 90s and was never smacked.

ohfook · 03/03/2022 22:27

Yeah I was smacked and to my eternal shame I remember accidentally treading mud into my friend's house and her getting the blame and getting a smack off her mum in front of me.