Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think smacking was 'acceptable' in the 90s?

308 replies

Grapeflavour · 03/03/2022 21:34

My parents smacked me as a child, usually if I did something they deemed as 'very naughty' or sometimes if I just didn't stop doing something quite trivial, they would threaten me with smacking.

I just assumed this was normal (albeit bad) attitudes back then, but talking to a couple of friends around the same age (30s) recently, it seems like that's not the case? They seemed pretty horrified that my dad used to occasionally hit me well into my teens if I pissed him off. As a teen he would often square up to me and threaten to 'knock me out' if I challenged him or talked back. I was 16 the last time he hit me. (I know this behaviour is totally unacceptable, and bearing in mind he is a huge 6"2 man and I was a 5"5 teenage girl). I think this has had an impact on me and trying to work through it.

Would you say it was fairly typical and normalised for parents to smack kids as punishment in the 90s? Or not at all?

OP posts:
Briony123 · 03/03/2022 22:27

Smacking: in the 80s yes, in the 90s no.
Hitting/belt: in the 70s early 80s kind of depending on your background, totally unacceptable by the 90s.

VickerishAllsort · 03/03/2022 22:26

Not at all.
My dcs were born mid-80s, and I smacked one of them once. And that was a reflex when she slapped me across the face in a toddler tantrum. I beat myself up about it for years after.
I believe that none of my friends hit their children either.

Tonsiltrouble · 03/03/2022 22:25

I was pondering this the other day. I was occasionally smacked as a child, and as an older child my dad certainly had a temper problem that I remember. I don’t want my children to be scared of us as parents like I was of him. And it has affected my relationship with him as an adult.

But. With modern parenting, whilst it’s wonderful that our children are not abused, I do sometimes wonder about not having a more expansive range of discipline. My 7yo said something way over the line to me the other day, something I would definitely have got a slap for as a child, and I wasn’t able to do that much other than goldfish for a bit and send him to his room. Whilst we could talk about it later, there was no clear signal to him at the time just how far over the line he was, whereas I would have been left in no doubt that my words were utterly unacceptable.

Don’t misunderstand me - I’m not making the argument for smacking, I hated being smacked, just that I had a better understanding of how big my transgressions were and it’s not so easy to communicate that these days.

JuliaSways · 03/03/2022 22:25

I was a teen in the 90s. Dad never laid a finger on me, my mum would often give me a good hiding (not beat me, but more than a single smack). I was very naughty, both at home and at school but I now know I had undiagnosed autism and ADHD.

Mum and I are very close now and is a lovely parent/grandparent. She fucked up, she regrets how she was. I have lost my temper once or twice under extreme provocation with my eldest and lashed out, instantly regretted and apologised. Otherwise good parents can make mistakes, I'm not condoning actually abusive parents.

Stompythedinosaur · 03/03/2022 22:25

It wasn't the norm for my recollection.

I don't think hitting a 16 year old or threatening to knock out your child is anywhere close to being acceptable then.

Bellabelloo · 03/03/2022 22:22

I was smacked. I also remember threats of being caned at school, although I don't know anyone who was...!

Jazzyjeffery · 03/03/2022 22:21

I don't think what happened in your house is normal, particularly the squaring up to you and still happening at 16.

I was a kid in the 90s and smacking (on the bum, leg) when very naughty or pre warned if behaviour didn't stop was normal to me and seemed common in friends houses etc.

Now, I dont think smacking is widely viewed as an acceptable form of discipline.

I have smacked my kids twice in 10 years when they were small. It was in anger and I was appalled at myself for losing my temper. I vowed not to do it again.

I dont think my mum felt guilty when I was little and she smacked me. Not because she isn't loving (she is wonderful and we have a very close relationship) but because it was more acceptable back then.

MurmuratingStarling · 03/03/2022 22:21

[quote Grapeflavour]@gingembre
My dad fully stands by his decision to smack me and if ever asked about it says that I didn't turn out too badly so what's the problem? He wouldn't apologise for hurting me or making me scared or fearful as a child in a million years.[/quote]
Flowers

MurmuratingStarling · 03/03/2022 22:20

@latetothefisting

a smack on the leg of a child (up to about aged 5/6) maybe normal, if not ideal (although I grew up the 90s and my parents never smacked us that I can recall). A grown man squaring up to a 16 year old girl and threatening to knock you out, very much not normal or acceptable, and I would have found that upsetting if I'd been your friend at the time, let alone now.
Sod social services. If I witnessed that, I would call the police.
Grapeflavour · 03/03/2022 22:20

@gingembre
My dad fully stands by his decision to smack me and if ever asked about it says that I didn't turn out too badly so what's the problem? He wouldn't apologise for hurting me or making me scared or fearful as a child in a million years.

OP posts:
latetothefisting · 03/03/2022 22:18

a smack on the leg of a child (up to about aged 5/6) maybe normal, if not ideal (although I grew up the 90s and my parents never smacked us that I can recall). A grown man squaring up to a 16 year old girl and threatening to knock you out, very much not normal or acceptable, and I would have found that upsetting if I'd been your friend at the time, let alone now.

DrSbaitso · 03/03/2022 22:17

Ooh, we'll get the "running into the road" lot soon as well, won't we? Hitters always seem to be so shite at road safety.

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 03/03/2022 22:16

@DrSbaitso

Telling my mum that her even touching me would mean I would leave and she could stop referring to me as her daughter stopped the smack threats. She never actually hit me though.

That's pretty good. I don't think anything other than the threat of physical retaliation would have stopped mine, though. He liked to hit. He was an angry and rather stupid man.

Like I said, my mum never actually hit me so I wasn’t up against the same level of shit parenting that you were.
ChocolateMassacre · 03/03/2022 22:15

Late 80s child. My mother smacked us a handful of times when we were very young out of sheer frustration (she was quite young as a mother and I think was overwhelmed by parenting sometimes). But she always felt very guilty afterwards, it wasn't part of her usual parenting and my father was completely against smacking and never hit any of us.

One set of cousins were occasionally smacked right up until senior school. Another set were smacked frequently throughout their childhood and I remember seeing my uncle chasing my cousin around the house to give him a smacking which struck me as bizarre. They were all quite "strong-willed" children compared to us though... we were much quieter and more compliant. I think parents nowadays are much better equipped to handle strong-willed children and to encourage good behaviour though positive parenting strategies, but back then it was considered that some children just "needed a smack". I have to say, it never seemed to have any positive effects on my cousins and just made them feel humiliated and resent their father.

Flittingaboutagain · 03/03/2022 22:15

Born in the 80s and never smacked, neither were any of my friends to my knowledge.

DrSbaitso · 03/03/2022 22:13

Telling my mum that her even touching me would mean I would leave and she could stop referring to me as her daughter stopped the smack threats. She never actually hit me though.

That's pretty good. I don't think anything other than the threat of physical retaliation would have stopped mine, though. He liked to hit. He was an angry and rather stupid man.

RobynMyEmployer · 03/03/2022 22:13

@BabyTurtIe

Was normal with everyone I know growing up including myself
Ditto.
Donson · 03/03/2022 22:13

I was born in the mid 80s and it was unfortunately pretty normalised in our house, and amongst my friends/my partner who are similar ages.
Remember seeing my friend’s mum smack her hard round the face when she was about 15 and being shocked though.

It didn’t happen very often but I used to get hit on my legs/butt (hard!).. I was terrified of my dad losing his temper.

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 03/03/2022 22:13

@Nightlystroll

My mum smacked me. My dad never smacked me. I don't think smacking is abhorrent.
You’re wrong. Smacking is abhorrent and no ridiculous argument about it not affecting you will ever make you correct.
CBFA · 03/03/2022 22:12

I was smacked in the 90s as a form of parenting! Not frequently, but if I was seen as especially naughty, which I wasn't really. It wasn't seen as an abnormal form of parenting. Would never slap my own children though!

BlindBat · 03/03/2022 22:11

I was born 1978 no smacking in the 80's here

Suzi888 · 03/03/2022 22:11

I didn’t get smacked. It was the threat of a smack - to be fair it was when I’d been very naughty and I think born more of fear than anything. Once I ran away after school to see a friends litter of kittens, I think I was 6/7 ish. The other time, my JRT jumped out of the car window and I jumped out into oncoming traffic and ran after him. Both times parents really upset, so think they wanted to scare me enough that I wouldn’t do it again. Both parents were very even tempered, happy, loving etc.

What your describing sounds more like child abuse.

fallfallfall · 03/03/2022 22:11

i don't even think it was "bad" it was very much acceptable and not at all unusual.
it will be interesting if in 40 years time all this debating with children and pandering to their happiness leads to better humans but i suspect it will not solve anything.

Bromse · 03/03/2022 22:09

I never smacked in the 80s, never mind the 90s, neither did most parents I knew. No doubt some did, what they hoped to achieve by it I do not know.

Luredbyapomegranate · 03/03/2022 22:09

Smacking of youngish children - yes more common. Although I grew up in 70s and have friends who were never smacked (I was).

But what you’re describing with your Dad isn’t smacking. My Dad was a bit like this, and it’s a low level of casual violent that does leave its mark, so yes you might need to work through it a bit.