Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think smacking was 'acceptable' in the 90s?

308 replies

Grapeflavour · 03/03/2022 21:34

My parents smacked me as a child, usually if I did something they deemed as 'very naughty' or sometimes if I just didn't stop doing something quite trivial, they would threaten me with smacking.

I just assumed this was normal (albeit bad) attitudes back then, but talking to a couple of friends around the same age (30s) recently, it seems like that's not the case? They seemed pretty horrified that my dad used to occasionally hit me well into my teens if I pissed him off. As a teen he would often square up to me and threaten to 'knock me out' if I challenged him or talked back. I was 16 the last time he hit me. (I know this behaviour is totally unacceptable, and bearing in mind he is a huge 6"2 man and I was a 5"5 teenage girl). I think this has had an impact on me and trying to work through it.

Would you say it was fairly typical and normalised for parents to smack kids as punishment in the 90s? Or not at all?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BingBangB0ng · 06/03/2022 18:32

Born in 1990. Definitely used to get smacked occasionally as a kid. Wrong in my opinion, but it wasn’t hard or very regularly as far as I can recall.

My dad hit me once when I was a teen after I’d argued with my mum. I hit myself in the same place to make a visible bruise and make him feel guilty, which worked.

Ciaram55 · 06/03/2022 12:45

I was a parent of young children then, I never hit my kids once. I knew people who did though.

Mollyforgot · 06/03/2022 12:36

I remember my english teacher in secondary in 93/94 saying she had hit her two young girls hard enough to leave a mark and that she felt bad about it. I remember feeling horrified and wondering why she had chosen to share this with a class of 14 year olds!

Newmumatlast · 06/03/2022 11:30

@Grapeflavour

Ps. I think smacking kids is abhorrent. I'm just curious about attitudes of the time as I wouldn't be able to tell, I was too young.
Yanbu that it was more acceptable to be smacked.

Yabu if the question were whether what you endured was normal. A parent squaring up to a child threatening to knock them out etc I think would have been considered abuse under any standard even 90s.

I grew up in 90s. Parents tapped my hand when little and smacked me maybe twice on the bum/legs when primary with an open hand once or twice each time and not hard.

Burgoo · 06/03/2022 11:29

At the time I didn't know any different. I hated it and resented the person who would inevitably dish it out. I can now see that the whole culture was wrapped up in this attitude of beating your kids and so I can't really blame the person for what was "normal" socially.

Looking at it now it was not okay and should never be okay. If you have to hit a child then you have lost your cool. If you haven't lost your cool then you are psychopathic and don't care about the trauma it can leave on a child. The idea "I didn't do me any harm" is ludicrous but I hear it all the time. In James O'Brien's book "How Not To Be Wrong" he gives examples of how people use that phrase when actually they haven't stopped to question the statement.

Ironically its those who were smacked a lot that often have the more hard line views and dismiss it. I suspect this is defensive; protecting the person who smacked them about. People don't want to see loved ones as abusers.

CheapFoodShits · 06/03/2022 11:23

My mum never smacked my brother and I, but my dad did. On the back of the legs. Not often, but often enough.
Once, when I was 6, I called my brother a "twat" during an argument (in my defense, I'd never heard the word and was attempting to make up a new insult so took an existing one- "twit"- and tried it with different vowels. "A" seemed to fit nicely🤦‍♀️). My dad came storming into the living room and smacked me right across the face.
When my mum came home I told her and she was livid with my dad because she obviously knew as a 6yo I wouldn't have a clue what the word meant.

DrSbaitso · 06/03/2022 10:41

Why not? Because they could hit back?

Yes, of course.

PurpleHollyhocks · 06/03/2022 09:57

@BeingATwatItsABingThing Calm down, I didn’t say it was right, I said it was normal, which it really really was then.

It was considered an acceptable thing to do, I don’t think hitting teenagers was considered normal or acceptable then and that is what the OP asked.

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 06/03/2022 09:05

@PurpleHollyhocks

Smacking a younger child across the legs etc was normal. Hitting a teenager was absolutely not normal and didn’t happen in any house I know of
Why not? Because they could hit back?
PurpleHollyhocks · 06/03/2022 08:58

Smacking a younger child across the legs etc was normal. Hitting a teenager was absolutely not normal and didn’t happen in any house I know of

Malibuismysecrethome · 06/03/2022 08:03

Many families in the 79s and 80s refused to send their children to schools that had corporal punishment and caning. My father and father-in-law refused to allow their children to attend catholic schools because the nuns were known to be spiteful and the priests abusive.

DrSbaitso · 06/03/2022 08:01

Lots of things are hard, but there seems to be only one time when it's acceptable and sympathetic to resort to hitting, and that's the one time when the victims can't defend themselves.

Smacking is always a failure of parenting. We might look at why that failure happened but it's not a reason to make out that it isn't a failure and doesn't require further thought.

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 06/03/2022 07:59

Meant to add, I teach a class of 31 and a lot of them are very challenging. They are 7/8 so in the age range a lot of people have said they’d think smacking is acceptable. I manage to keep them all safe and on task without ever resorting to violence.

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 06/03/2022 07:57

Parenting is hard, she had 3 under 4

I really hate these excuses for crap parenting! Parenting is bloody hard so many people manage to do it without resorting to abuse. Having 3 under 4 is not the children’s fault.

ButtercupOfFlorin · 06/03/2022 07:22

@Nelliephant1

Definitely not acceptable in the '90's or any other time. It was frowned upon as far as I remember. As to if it happened not with anyone I knew thankfully.
Of course smacking was acceptable, until not that long ago!

Caning was still a form of punishment in the school in the late 80’s

ButtercupOfFlorin · 06/03/2022 07:20

I can count on one hand how many times I got smacked as a child, just by mum, in very extreme circumstance (once told my stepdad to fuck off and my mum gave me a right whack across the back of the legs). I’m definitely not in the ‘never did me any harm’ camp but I don’t think less of mum for this. Parenting is hard, she had 3 under 4 and honestly we weren’t the best behaved of children. She coped far better with her 3 kids than I do with my 2 (though I don’t smack them but I shout more than I want to Sad)

Nelliephant1 · 06/03/2022 07:15

Definitely not acceptable in the '90's or any other time. It was frowned upon as far as I remember. As to if it happened not with anyone I knew thankfully.

DrSbaitso · 06/03/2022 07:10

Good grief.

Good, solid answer. You have convinced us all!

TomPinch · 05/03/2022 22:58

@DrSbaitso

I hope so too, but I don't believe you.

Why would I care about that? Why would I imagine that you know my mind, and indeed my future, better than I do, oh internet smacking apologist?

You are very aggressive in your replies

I'm pissing myself at the fact that you see aggression in robust internet discussion more than you do in adults slapping kids across the face.

and you insinuate too.

Hey, you noticed.

I believe you think your targets deserve this

Ya think?

but you should be mindful that people who smack children will justify their lack of empathy the same way.

No, they justify it the way you did!

I know you think this is some amazingly devastating "you have become what you despise" put down that will utterly destroy me. But it's actually just as arse about face as your idea that an internet argument against smacking is somehow more deserving of condescension than bashing around a child. If anyone's failing to see what they're becoming...

You're angry because people are rightly criticising your parents' failings and mistakes. That's ego. I'm angry because people are minimising, justifying and downplaying a parenting technique, if you could call it that, that is known to damage children, stunt parents and frequently leads to escalations. In short, you're here to talk about yourself, and I'm here to talk about not harming kids. They are not comparable, and no pseudo-Yoda cobblers will change that.

Good grief.
DrSbaitso · 05/03/2022 21:50

I hope so too, but I don't believe you.

Why would I care about that? Why would I imagine that you know my mind, and indeed my future, better than I do, oh internet smacking apologist?

You are very aggressive in your replies

I'm pissing myself at the fact that you see aggression in robust internet discussion more than you do in adults slapping kids across the face.

and you insinuate too.

Hey, you noticed.

I believe you think your targets deserve this

Ya think?

but you should be mindful that people who smack children will justify their lack of empathy the same way.

No, they justify it the way you did!

I know you think this is some amazingly devastating "you have become what you despise" put down that will utterly destroy me. But it's actually just as arse about face as your idea that an internet argument against smacking is somehow more deserving of condescension than bashing around a child. If anyone's failing to see what they're becoming...

You're angry because people are rightly criticising your parents' failings and mistakes. That's ego. I'm angry because people are minimising, justifying and downplaying a parenting technique, if you could call it that, that is known to damage children, stunt parents and frequently leads to escalations. In short, you're here to talk about yourself, and I'm here to talk about not harming kids. They are not comparable, and no pseudo-Yoda cobblers will change that.

Kanaloa · 05/03/2022 21:05

I hope so too, but I don't believe you. You are very aggressive in your replies, and you insinuate too. I believe you think your targets deserve this, but you should be mindful that people who smack children will justify their lack of empathy the same way.

Disagreeing with someone on an online forum isn’t really comparable to hitting children in your care as a parenting method. Being passionate about your disagreement of adults who like to hurt children in their temper isn’t really indicative of an aggressive personality.

TomPinch · 05/03/2022 20:55

@DrSbaitso

Good grief no.

Of course she didn't. It's only with children that people "just snap" or whatever, and it's considered acceptable.

And your response does suggest to me that you won't take the criticism that well.

I'm a product of smacking, love. What, you don't like it?

But fear not. Unlike those whose feelings on this are driven by a desire to justify parenting fails, I'm driven by a desire not to damage children. I'll live with your personal disapproval, but if I am told - hell, if it's been bloody proven- in years to come that my parenting did this kind of harm, I can assure you I'll be humble about it.

And it has nothing to do with telling you what you want to hear about hitting children.

I hope so too, but I don't believe you. You are very aggressive in your replies, and you insinuate too. I believe you think your targets deserve this, but you should be mindful that people who smack children will justify their lack of empathy the same way.
DingleyDel · 05/03/2022 20:39

Speaking as a primary school teacher, who has worked in some really deprived areas, and some quite affluent ones, I would say most under-10s have been smacked by parents at some point. About 5 years ago, my then head teacher surveyed my class of 8-9 year olds about it. 16 kids, and only one of them had never had a smack.

Interesting you say this. I was thinking I’d bet it’s way more common than parents care to admit, and I’m sure many more parents have smacked when they’ve completely lost control than would admit it. Most parents of the 80/90s I know will admit it wasn’t their finest parenting moment and it was when they’d lost control. At least they can admit it I suppose. I have a friend who admitted to smacking a couple of years ago, though I’ve never seen her do it. I was in a large park a few months ago and a grandfather (I assume) smacked his grandson in the middle of the park several times. No one said a word but there were certainly a few looks shot his way.

dogaibu · 05/03/2022 20:16

I was smacked loads as a kid, mainly by my dad. Mum was a leg slapper, Dad would leave welts on me which would last for days. I have smacked my ds twice in his life, and he's 11. I hate smacking. Me and my dad were never close because I couldn't get over how he treated me when I was young.

DrSbaitso · 05/03/2022 19:54

Good grief no.

Of course she didn't. It's only with children that people "just snap" or whatever, and it's considered acceptable.

And your response does suggest to me that you won't take the criticism that well.

I'm a product of smacking, love. What, you don't like it?

But fear not. Unlike those whose feelings on this are driven by a desire to justify parenting fails, I'm driven by a desire not to damage children. I'll live with your personal disapproval, but if I am told - hell, if it's been bloody proven- in years to come that my parenting did this kind of harm, I can assure you I'll be humble about it.

And it has nothing to do with telling you what you want to hear about hitting children.