Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask does your partner need to love your kids, if he's not their biological father?

236 replies

blubberball · 03/03/2022 21:01

Or is it enough that he just cares about them, but doesn't love them?

OP posts:
Gardeningcreature · 04/03/2022 06:43

Willyoujustbequiet let's say you have one child and one step child then. Now answer the question truthfully.......

ILikeYourButt · 04/03/2022 06:40

@StopStartStop

Further, I would ask, if you have children why are you insisting they live with an unrelated adult? Couldn't you keep your sex life out of your children's homes and lives? There is no need for any 'partner' to love your children, or to know them at all.
Eh? So single parents should never get remarried or have any more kids?

I had my first at 16. Would have been a lonely life if I was never allowed to be in another relationship.

Darbs76 · 04/03/2022 06:38

No, they don’t need to love them like their biological parent does. It’s perfectly reasonable for them to care about the child and ensure that child is treated the same as any bio children. But to insist they love the children is silly, as most don’t. That’s fine

Willyoujustbequiet · 04/03/2022 06:36

I think the house on fire who do you save is a stupid argument. What if you have 3 children and can only save one? Where does it end....

To my mind DNA is no guarantee of love. Wasn't in my upbringing and have sadly seen it also with deadbeat dads. My partner loves our children like his own and I honestly couldn't have it any other way. I don't anyone who would accept less.

tootiredtospeak · 04/03/2022 06:29

It depends how they treat them. If they are kind compassionate and treat them equally that's all you need. It doesnt need to be love and will never be the same as a biological child. But as the biological parent you will always know if the treatment is right or not. If anything my partner always had more patience and understanding with my eldest who isnt his. Maybe because he knew the feelings back are not unconditional.

Gardeningcreature · 04/03/2022 06:17

I think it's perfectly natural to love your own children more than you do other peoples.
I doubt many step parents love their partners children as much as they love their own.
Of course it's totally fine to be kind and caring towards them and to like them. I agree with posters who say it's like the care shown by school staff.

In reality I know lots of people who as children were treated kindly by step parents but still treated differently to their half/step siblings.
It also depends on the age of the children.
In fact of all the adults I know who's parent's marriages broke down, I would say the vast majority recall that there were discrepancies in the treatment they received and their half/step siblings received.
Ask yourself this, if your house was on fire and you could save only one person, would you really save your boyfriend's child over your own?

Willyoujustbequiet · 04/03/2022 06:07

@Waxonwaxoff0

It's not forcing love - its being careful who you choose to have a relationship with. I wouldn't want anyone who could only love a child that is biologically related. That's not a quality I could ever find attractive.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 04/03/2022 06:00

@StopStartStop

Further, I would ask, if you have children why are you insisting they live with an unrelated adult? Couldn't you keep your sex life out of your children's homes and lives? There is no need for any 'partner' to love your children, or to know them at all.
I agree although it's not a popular opinion. Successful blended families are the exception rather than the norm and I think a lot of parents like to kid themselves that it's fine, the children would probably say different. I'm a single parent and I'm quite happy alone, I think it's a bit sad if you can't go without a live in partner for a few years for the sake of the kids.
Waxonwaxoff0 · 04/03/2022 05:49

@Willyoujustbequiet

Yes for me. I couldn't be in a relationship with a man not capable of loving my children as his own. It's a deal breaker.

For those saying no because they arent biologically his I hope you never adopt.

I wouldn't adopt, I know it's not for me. I think it's weird to try and force love.
Waxonwaxoff0 · 04/03/2022 05:46

No. I know I could not love someone else's kids as my own. My DS has a stepmum, I don't expect her to love him, as long as she treats him well.

ZombeaArthur · 04/03/2022 05:44

It really depends on the situation. My stepmother came into my life when I was 5 and I know she loves me, however we don’t have a mother/daughter relationship. I know she doesn’t love me the way she loves my (half) brother and she knows I don’t love her the way I love my mother, but that doesn’t diminish the relationship we have.

My brother has stepchildren that he loves as his own, however he doesn’t have any other children and they don’t have another father in their lives, which may or may not change things.

My Dad had a stepfather who came into his life as an adult and, although he cared for him, I don’t think he loved him. He was however treated as a member of the family.

Willyoujustbequiet · 04/03/2022 05:41

Yes for me. I couldn't be in a relationship with a man not capable of loving my children as his own. It's a deal breaker.

For those saying no because they arent biologically his I hope you never adopt.

Simonjt · 04/03/2022 05:22

@RainbowMum11

Further, I would ask, if you have children why are you insisting they live with an unrelated adult? Couldn't you keep your sex life out of your children's homes and lives? There is no need for any 'partner' to love your children, or to know them at all.

What an absolutely ridiculous thing to say!
So your relationship breaks down with the other parent of your child, you shouldn't enter another long term relationship, ever?

That just ludicrous.

They’re batshit, in a now deleted thread they told me I would abuse my children as apparently I’m not related to them.
Pyewhacket · 04/03/2022 04:52

I had a step father for a few years. He was OK but he kept his distance being much more hands on with his daughter, my step sister. I got on really well with my step sister, and still enjoy a close relationship. My relationship with my mother is another story. At the age of 14 I came back to the UK to live with my grandparents. That was the first time in my life I experienced the love and warmth of close family. They were amazing , beyond words. I miss them dreadfully and proof that blood is definitely thicker than water.

RainbowMum11 · 04/03/2022 03:26

Further, I would ask, if you have children why are you insisting they live with an unrelated adult? Couldn't you keep your sex life out of your children's homes and lives? There is no need for any 'partner' to love your children, or to know them at all.

What an absolutely ridiculous thing to say!
So your relationship breaks down with the other parent of your child, you shouldn't enter another long term relationship, ever?

That just ludicrous.

Kanaloa · 04/03/2022 03:22

I just think it depends on the specific relationship etc. If DH didn’t love my older two children our relationship wouldn’t work. But for me that’s part and parcel of dating with me having children previously. If he had not wanted to play that role then we would not have ended up together to maybe would have dated casually rather than marrying and having more children together.

StopStartStop · 04/03/2022 02:46

Further, I would ask, if you have children why are you insisting they live with an unrelated adult? Couldn't you keep your sex life out of your children's homes and lives? There is no need for any 'partner' to love your children, or to know them at all.

Person123456 · 04/03/2022 02:33

I think my stepmum actually resented me, she stole my father away from me and my brothers to give her younger kids a dad so yes as i said i think it depends on their intentions and what kind of people they are

Person123456 · 04/03/2022 02:27

as for caring for them, I think they'd care for step kids just as much as their own, well if they truly love their partners anyway

Person123456 · 04/03/2022 02:25

I have a stepmum and stepdad and when i lived with either of my parents i was treated like an inconvenience in the marriages, Both my step parents have kids, in the end my father chose them over me and my brothers and my mother hasn't spoken to us in years. My point here is that it all depends on the parents themselves, there's no rules, obviously i think yes step parents can love step kids just as much as their own i just think its unlikely

ComeOnSpringtime · 03/03/2022 22:47

I was coming to say of course but I see you wrote 'caring about them' separately. So that stopped me a bit in my tracks.

Caring about someone and being kind and compassionate to then IS love but I know when we say "love", we really/also mean the sentimental attachment (and often) co-dependence we have in our relationships because they're family or close friends or people we've known for a long time.

If your partner cares about them, their happiness, is kind and understanding and just simply treats them with respect and like they/their needs matter (because they do), that's all that's needed, whether you call it love or not. The sentimental attachment part of it comes with time after they've been in each other's lives for a long time, know and care about each other.

You can't be that emotionally attached to someone you haven't known for long or don't have some sort of physical intimacy with. It will be more a conscious effort at first before it becomes automatic.

peachgreen · 03/03/2022 22:36

I don't know that I could be in a relationship with someone if they didn't feel they would ever be able to love my child. Not necessarily in the same was as they might love their own child (although I believe it's possible), but at least to some degree. After all, loving our family doesn't stop us from loving our friends.

Those feelings may change as she gets older but for now, I would want them to grow to love her and if they didn't I would have some serious thinking to do. And I definitely wouldn't have more children with them.

CadvanTheBard · 03/03/2022 22:31

No but I would expect him to make an effort to get to know them and develop a relationship with them.

I honestly don't think blending families work unless you can go all in. That doesn't mean he has to love them but the relationship needs to be able to withstand normal dc irritations and him being able to voice those irritations - like say a dcs job was to wash up but they 'forgot', the step parent would have enough of a good relationship to tell the dc to do it without there being resentment from any of the involved people in that dynamic. That only comes with a good relationship.

So yes not love but he would have to be able to show my dc enough unconditional positive regard (that's not saying he can't get annoyed like a parent would, its a theoretical model of practice).

I have been an unmarried step parent and a married one. It's very hard, the first unmarried step parent relationship worked well dc and step dc wise. Two partners on the same page around values of child rearing, parent actually parented but I was involved, included and we felt much more of a family than what I did as a married step parent because of that.

Some people will say they find disengaging works for them, it didn't work for me. I needed the mum place in the family. Not being their mum, but the mum place if that makes sense. It might sound a bit strange but I did the wife work, the planning days out, films to watch, shared finances so bought his dc (my dcs siblings) clothes when I bought my two, took sdc out when doing trips to the park ect with my friends, I really did see them as my family too. Although I'm not with dcs dad anymore they still come over to see my dc sometimes and they're happy to see me.

With my stb ex husband (roll on April 6th) I was shut out. His son was placed above my dc. It wasn't shared parenting. Some people may like that but I didn't. I didnt want a seperate life and seperate holidays and seperate rules. To me, being a family means being all in. But I do understand others don't feel that way. I wanted my stb x to be all in with my dc. I wanted him to like them as they liked him. He didn't. He was so caught up in his ex drama and his dc drama he couldn't see anything else apart from his dad guilt.

Lunalicious · 03/03/2022 22:31

My DH loves all my 4 kids. 2 are his and 2 aren't. He treats them all the same... does he love them all equally deep down? I will never really know, but the kids all feel they are loved and treated equally and that is what matters.

optimistic40 · 03/03/2022 22:12

Hmmmm. I wouldn't expect a partner / husband / wife to love them in the same way as a biological parent but as long as their caring shows in their actions that is the main thing.

My answer is the same thinking about my kids' relationship with my boyfriend and the relationship my daughter has with her dad's partner.