Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask does your partner need to love your kids, if he's not their biological father?

236 replies

blubberball · 03/03/2022 21:01

Or is it enough that he just cares about them, but doesn't love them?

OP posts:
caringcarer · 05/03/2022 08:41

My dh married me when my kids were 18, 15 and 8. My eldest went off to uni. He was and is a really good stepdad to my 2 eldest, they get on well and he is kind and generous to them both, but he has a special relationship with my youngest because he helped me bring him up from a young age. DH has no biological children of his own. He is a great Grandfather to dd's 2 children. He undoubtedly loves the grandchildren to bits. He is very fond of my dd but I would not say he loved her. After uni she got a job and remained in uni city, eventually married and bought a house there. We visit her, she visits us but they have never lived in same house. DH occasionally goes to cinema with eldest son and he has helped him in his career. DH and DS lived in same home for about 8 years and they became close. I would say DH loves eldest DS and youngest DS. He often spends 1-1 time with youngest son. He has left all 3 of my children equal amounts in his will.

Sheeeeba · 05/03/2022 08:28

@RainbowMum11

Further, I would ask, if you have children why are you insisting they live with an unrelated adult? Couldn't you keep your sex life out of your children's homes and lives? There is no need for any 'partner' to love your children, or to know them at all.

What an absolutely ridiculous thing to say!
So your relationship breaks down with the other parent of your child, you shouldn't enter another long term relationship, ever?

That just ludicrous.

To be honest, to me it's about as ludicrous as suggesting I love step children as much as my own child.

I have step children, obviously I care about them because they live in my home and I spend a lot of time with them. I do not love them like my son though and I never will, that seems utterly impossible to me personally.

But they have a mother and weren't babies (primary school) when we met so 🤷‍♀️

smilingthroughgrittedteeth · 05/03/2022 08:19

Ive got stepchildren, ive been in their life for 10yrs, they are now 18 and 23. The eldest and I have a very aunt/niece type relationship she will talk to me about things she wouldnt talk to her parents about and she regularly comes to visit (sometimes just for the day sometimes stays overnight) she sees herself as family and just slots seamlessly into our lives, adores her younger siblings and i would say i love her in the same way i love my best friend and she loves me like she does her aunts.

The youngest was very hard work as a child and used by his mother to manipulate DH, he has never seen himself as part of the family theres a very distinct divide when he visits in that its him, DH and DSD and then theres me, dh, and our children together. He has very little interest in his siblings and expects the world to stop when he decides to visits and to be treated like a guest. He has always been treated the same as DSD so there is no real need for him to feel this way its just the way he feels so although I care about him and try to make him feel part of the family i certainly dont love him and he doesnt love me but we also dont dislike each other and get on fine.

When he was younger and before i had children of my own i used to feel i had to forge some kind of amazing relationship with him otherwise i was a terrible stepparent, it took having my own children to realise that as long as i was kind to him and he always feels welcome thats enough and is all he wants from me.

Quamora · 05/03/2022 08:12

@Lunalicious

My DH loves all my 4 kids. 2 are his and 2 aren't. He treats them all the same... does he love them all equally deep down? I will never really know, but the kids all feel they are loved and treated equally and that is what matters.
Same here. Although another poster said about it being a two way street and this is also true. A few years ago I would have been absolutely certain that if we split up or I died he would continue to have a relationship with all the children. Now one of my teenagers is going through a challenging time and is pushing him away and I know that while he would try to maintain a relationship with them if he got nothing back it would be easy for that to peter out over time.
Sally872 · 05/03/2022 07:57

@blubberball

Thanks for your replies. My situation is that I have 2 dc who are aged 14 and 10. Been with my dp a few years, but it is a ldr. He doesn't live with us, and I mostly see him without the dc, whilst they are with their biological dad eow. My dp has no dc of his own.

We were planning to move in together, but my eldest got very upset about the thought of being away from his friends and family. So we are continuing a ldr. My dp does drive down here and spend weekends with me and dc once a month or so. He cares about them, seemingly more than their own biological father does. He cares about their behaviour and their school work, where as their bio father takes no interest whatsoever. He set up bedrooms for them at his house, and built my youngest dc a bed. Their bio father never did this, and never would.

He is kind and caring to them, but I know that he gets frustrated with their attitude and behaviour towards me sometimes. He doesn't let on to them though.

This is pretty close to love if not loving them. What makes you think he doesn't?
ProfFloss · 05/03/2022 07:53

@DoNotTouchTheWater

It’s genuinely offensive to adoptive families to drag adoption in as your ‘mic drop’ argument about a completely different situation: stepfamilies. Just blood boilingly offensive.

Two things about step parenting:

  1. How loveable (or even likeable) someone’s children are - especially to a steppparent - depends enormously on their parents’ approach to everything. You’re fucked with a difficult ex and a parent operating out of fear, obligation and guilt about their children. No matter how kind of caring someone is, they’ll always be the handy bad guy. Most of these parents do not acknowledge that they are doing these things, because a stepparent is such a handy scapegoat for all things.
  2. As others have said, it’s very difficult to build a meaningful relationship with other people’d children a few days a month. However much people will insist that ‘it’s their home too’, it isn’t their main home and it makes a huge difference to the relationships they form and their attitude to things.
Probably one of the best posts I’ve ever read on MN!!
ProfFloss · 05/03/2022 07:51

I’m a step mum. A step parent should never be cruel, unkind or hurtful but doesn’t have to love.
It’s a two way street, if my step kids had ever shown me any kind of affection (in the early days when I was affectionate to them) it would have been repaid 100 fold.
Unfortunately this didn’t happen (thanks mum) and they were cold and distant with me. Many years later we have no relationship.
A step parent can’t build a love bond with a child they are not blood related to unless they get some affection back.
A sad realisation of the truth.

PaddlingLikeADuck · 05/03/2022 07:45

I don’t think a step parent can ever love a child in the same way they’d love a biological child.

I’m very close to my sister and I love her children very much (aged 8 and 14) but that love doesn’t even compare to how I love my own children, and they’re related. I just cannot imagine loving other children more than mine, or even on par.

Maybe it’s different if the step parent doesn’t already have a biological child of their own? So they have no love to compare the way they feel about their step children to?

I have to admit I would worry if I was with a childless man and he was stepdad to my children, and then we had a child together and he would then be a biological father. I would worry that he would always feel more strongly for our joint child than my children.

I know a woman who has a two year old daughter and after 9 months of dating another man (childless) she is moving in with him. He’s already expressed his displeasure to her that apparently she doesn’t make him feel special enough and that he’s fed up of her always prioritising her daughter over him.

I can’t believe she’s moving in with him - it’s got complete disaster written all over it.

DoNotTouchTheWater · 05/03/2022 07:44

@Usou

It's completely unrealistic to expect a stepfather or stepparent to love stepchildren as much as their own. Biology/attachment just does not work like that.

However, as a number of PPs have mentioned, it is possible to develop very strong relationships over time, althouogh it generally takes a lot of effort.

A great deal of effort and a supportive environment.
Usou · 05/03/2022 07:33

It's completely unrealistic to expect a stepfather or stepparent to love stepchildren as much as their own. Biology/attachment just does not work like that.

However, as a number of PPs have mentioned, it is possible to develop very strong relationships over time, althouogh it generally takes a lot of effort.

amylou8 · 05/03/2022 07:11

I was kind to my stepson, I made sure he was cared for and safe. I didn't like him and certainly didn't love him, but I made sure he never knew this.

DoNotTouchTheWater · 05/03/2022 06:50

It’s genuinely offensive to adoptive families to drag adoption in as your ‘mic drop’ argument about a completely different situation: stepfamilies. Just blood boilingly offensive.

Two things about step parenting:

  1. How loveable (or even likeable) someone’s children are - especially to a steppparent - depends enormously on their parents’ approach to everything. You’re fucked with a difficult ex and a parent operating out of fear, obligation and guilt about their children. No matter how kind of caring someone is, they’ll always be the handy bad guy. Most of these parents do not acknowledge that they are doing these things, because a stepparent is such a handy scapegoat for all things.
  2. As others have said, it’s very difficult to build a meaningful relationship with other people’d children a few days a month. However much people will insist that ‘it’s their home too’, it isn’t their main home and it makes a huge difference to the relationships they form and their attitude to things.
Gardeningcreature · 05/03/2022 06:27

The whole point of this thread is the question do you have to love someone else's child or is it good enough to like them and treat them with respect and kindness.

Some posters are failing to see the difference.
Teachers treat your kid with kindness and respect but you would be all kinds of weird if you seriously expected them to love your child as much as they live their own family.
Nobody knows how much, or little, another person really loves anybody in this situation. Sure you can tell if someone is calling your child a fucking cunt and trying to hit them it's a reasonable assumption to think that they don't care much for the child, but you a really don't know the level to which someone loves them.
It's not a crime to love your own child more than any one of anything else.
It's also expected that if you adopt a child you absolutely should love that child as much as you would your biological child. Interestingly I know of couples who have been rejected from adopting because they would not categorically stop trying for their own biological child. This highlights that professionals believe they would perhaps be inclined to favour their biological child over the adopted one.
Anyhow I think the op is being wise and doing the best thing in her circumstances.

Marty13 · 05/03/2022 01:21

And I'll add - though I'll probably get hanged, drawn and quartered for this - that I wouldn't love stepkids the same as my own children and I certainly wouldn't try to parent them beyond the minimum required to cohabit, if I ever were in this situation. Therein lies the path to madness and unhappiness, and I'll steer well clear.

Marty13 · 05/03/2022 01:18

For what it's worth OP I do think that cohabitation is hard in general, more so with blended families, and considering your kids are already almost grown it's probably kinder to your relationship to wait.

I'm not interested in a relationship right now but even if I was I'd strongly advocate that we each have our own place (and even more so if the partner also has kids).

Marty13 · 05/03/2022 01:16

Interesting to see the range of responses there.
I have two boys (3 and almost 2). I'm single and if I were to meet a partner I wouldn't expect them to love my kids. Though to be fair I also wouldn't expect, or indeed want them to take on a parenting role. Maybe more like an uncle, due some respect as an adult and able to set rules in the house if necessary, but not a father. Because he's not their father and if our relationship broke down they might never see him again so it's hardly fair to either the boys or the partner. You also can't force feelings. I'd expect him to be kind and caring and to take some interest in them but definitely wouldn't expect him to treat them as if they were his.

And people who compare this to adoption are getting it wrong. When you adopt you commit to a child and take on the responsibility to be this child's dad. It's a whole process that takes usually years and where you commit from the start towards the goal of building a family with a child. That's entirely different to having a relationship with some kids just because they're your partner's. When a guy hooks up with a gal it's all about their relationship (and kids have to fit around it, or try to), whereas adoption is all about each parent's relationship with the child.

Stompythedinosaur · 05/03/2022 00:01

If they are going to live with you, they need to love the dc.

If you are going to live separately then not so much.

ComeOnSpringtime · 04/03/2022 23:58

I can and have 'loved' other people's young kids as my own. Friends', family, strangers.

The emotional connection at first will be different because you've known your child longer (but it will catch up) but in terms of how you treat them and care for/about them? No difference.

I've always felt sad for children whose step parents, step grandparents, etc treat so obviously different from the biological ones, and sadder for children whose parents let that happen. It just doesn't make sense.

I agree with pp who said it's a deal breaker if someone doesn't have the capacity to do that.

Simonjt · 04/03/2022 16:49

[quote Willyoujustbequiet]@Gardeningcreature

I don't have any stepchildren so it's a moot point and again a ridiculous question.

So adopted children would always perish? Gay couples be expected to sacrifice kids that aren't biologically theirs? It's just utterly bizarre to me that anyone would stoop to ask this.Confused[/quote]
You’d be suprised how many stupid people think adopted children aren’t your own, but just some random kids you’re babysitting.

Doratheexploret · 04/03/2022 14:06

I’ve been a step mum for 27 years. I love my step daughter. We haven’t always had the best relationship but I do love her, care about her and feel as protective of her as I do my other kids.

Choppingonions · 04/03/2022 14:05

Not if the child who isn't his has no father. Nobody's fault but that would be torture.

nearlyspringyay · 04/03/2022 14:03

No imo. They can care deeply for them but it won't be the same as the love for your own kids (IMO) unless they have been involved from very early on.

blubberball · 04/03/2022 14:01

We're not moving, we're staying where we are. We were going to move because honestly, it's a much nicer area where he lives and I love it up there. He's bought a nice detached place, where as we rent a small house in an area I don't like. That's absolutely not happening now, and we're just keeping our ldr as things are until the dc are grown.

OP posts:
georgarina · 04/03/2022 13:03

If they are young, yes they would need to love them. And there could be no favouritism between step children and biological children.

StopStartStop · 04/03/2022 12:57

Just stop doing it. Calling me 'batshit' doesn't alter the fact that 'mothers boyfriends/stepfathers' are statistically most likely to harm children.