Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask does your partner need to love your kids, if he's not their biological father?

236 replies

blubberball · 03/03/2022 21:01

Or is it enough that he just cares about them, but doesn't love them?

OP posts:
thepeopleversuswork · 05/03/2022 12:53

FWIW I think we would make it a lot easier for step parents and step children to develop a loving reputation if we minimised the expectation on step parents to act like parents from the get-go.

I think step-parents can undoubtedly come to love their step-children very deeply but it has to move at a pace which is comfortable to the step-parent and the step-child. Depending on the circumstances and the involvement (or not) of the biological parent, the best approach is to take it very very slowly.

You see so many scenarios where people move a new lover in within weeks or months and the step-parent is expected to step into the recently vacated role of the father and the children are expected to adapt to having a near stranger living with them. It's very often enormously stressful for all concerned and potentially very unhappy for all concerned.

I don't believe blended families can't work but people need to accept that a relationship has to be left to develop at its own pace (and potentially for it not to develop at all).

BabyTurtIe · 05/03/2022 12:52

I always think it’s weird when people claim to love their step kids as much as their own, I have nieces and nephews I don’t even love them anywhere near as much as my own kids. I don’t think a step parent needs to love their step kids being kind and caring for them is enough IMO, and as someone said judging by the step parents board on here most seem to not love their step kids.

blodbav · 05/03/2022 12:52

[quote ProfFloss]@Soffit
It’s just not relevant to this conversation. There are murderers and serial killers from all kinds of backgrounds, some are step parents and some are not but it’s just such a tiny minority (thankfully).

As an example, if a homosexual man was having an issue with his boyfriend would you remind him that Stephen Port killed his boyfriends?[/quote]

Yeah, and in those cases the parents were a bit shit to begin with. The new partner is a catalyst for it to escalate. The bio parent fundamentally does not love or care about their child- that's why they allow it to happen or participate in the abuse.

There are millions of kind and loving stepparents but you'd never know unless they told you. There's no way to tell who's a stepparent or not just by looking really.

ComeOnSpringtime · 05/03/2022 12:52

@blubberball

Thanks for your replies. My situation is that I have 2 dc who are aged 14 and 10. Been with my dp a few years, but it is a ldr. He doesn't live with us, and I mostly see him without the dc, whilst they are with their biological dad eow. My dp has no dc of his own.

We were planning to move in together, but my eldest got very upset about the thought of being away from his friends and family. So we are continuing a ldr. My dp does drive down here and spend weekends with me and dc once a month or so. He cares about them, seemingly more than their own biological father does. He cares about their behaviour and their school work, where as their bio father takes no interest whatsoever. He set up bedrooms for them at his house, and built my youngest dc a bed. Their bio father never did this, and never would.

He is kind and caring to them, but I know that he gets frustrated with their attitude and behaviour towards me sometimes. He doesn't let on to them though.

He's definitely showing them love/care and so far, nothing says otherwise.

The problem some people have is they expect the step - anything to never be upset or annoyed with the children but if you expect him to treat them like his own or simply normal like everybody else, they're bound to annoy each other. It's how he reacts to the annoyance that shows how he feels, not that he can't get reasonably frustrated with their behaviour.

ProfFloss · 05/03/2022 12:45

@Soffit
It’s just not relevant to this conversation. There are murderers and serial killers from all kinds of backgrounds, some are step parents and some are not but it’s just such a tiny minority (thankfully).

As an example, if a homosexual man was having an issue with his boyfriend would you remind him that Stephen Port killed his boyfriends?

ItsDisneyBitch · 05/03/2022 12:42

Do I love my step kids? No. Do I care about them, yes. Do I care that they are healthy and happy and are well fed and cared for and treated equally. Yes.

My husband I imagine is the same. But we are an older blended family.

Soffit · 05/03/2022 12:40

I did not wish to offend the optimists but did qualify my comment as applying to the criminal extreme. The statistics do back this up. I don't want to compile lists of names but sadly, it has happened time and time again.

blodbav · 05/03/2022 12:36

@U2HasTheEdge

For me, yes a partner would need to love my children. I wouldn't say he needs to love them the same way he loves his biological children, but there would have to be love there.

I wouldn't have stayed with my husband if he didn't love my children from my first marriage. He tells me that the love he has for his step-children is the same as the love he has for his biological children (again, it helps that they were so young).

I can't see into his heart, but my children are now young adults and I have never had any reason to question it, and that's good enough for me.

This is so sweet @U2HasTheEdge

ProfFloss · 05/03/2022 12:31

@Soffit

I don’t wish to generalise but at the extreme end, all of the horrific child murders which I can recall recently, there Was a step parent thrown into the toxic mix. That is not to take credit away from the blended families that manage to make a great success of it.
Are you aware of how offensive your comments are to step parents?
CarlCarlson · 05/03/2022 12:21

Not realistic to expect love or to think of them like their own kids but as long as they’re tolerant of them and friendly

Soffit · 05/03/2022 11:42

I don’t wish to generalise but at the extreme end, all of the horrific child murders which I can recall recently, there Was
a step parent thrown into the toxic mix. That is not to take credit away from the blended families that manage to make a great success of it.

LeoOliver · 05/03/2022 11:38

This an interesting question.

My sense is that step parents view their step-children differently. In the same vein, step children view their step parent differently than their biological parent.

I think step children and adopting children are two separate things. When you adopt a child, that child is yours whereas a step-child usually isn't yours. I personally don't view my step parent in the same way I view my biological parent and I wouldn't expect them to view me in the same way their biological children.

I think all the children should be treated fairly and equally in blended families.

Soffit · 05/03/2022 11:35

Nope, I don’t think it they would have a biological disposition towards doing so either so why pretend/ delude yourself into expecting it. A man can love another’s child -‘a lot a bit like they may love a friend or a beloved pet or family member but not actually as their father. Those who claim to are usually not emotionally literate enough to discern the difference

sadpapercourtesan · 05/03/2022 11:31

I don't think any child should have to live with adults who don't love them. I think most blended families don't work, and the children are unhappy. Even in families where the adults think it works just fine.

DisneyMillie · 05/03/2022 11:29

I think it’s age dependent. My dh came into our lives when my dd was 3 and has lived with us since she was 5. My exh lives a long way away and therefore dh has been for all purposes her everyday dad since she can remember. If he didn’t love her it wouldn’t work for her or me.

I was worried when we had a child of our own in case it made his feelings change but he says it hasn’t and he loves them the same. I’m not sure I 100% believe that but he doesn’t treat them any differently and there’s nothing that implies it’s not true which is all that matters. He does all the dad stuff / running around after her / parents evenings etc - I never really think of him as not her dad.

If dd had been older I’m guessing we wouldn’t have needed that in the same way and care and kindness would have been enough

FairyCakeWings · 05/03/2022 11:25

I wouldn’t expect a step parent to love a step child like their own, but I would expect them to love them if they were going to be part of my family.

It’s fine for a step parent to only care about the children at the beginning of the relationship, but by the time they are marrying or living with the parent t should have developed into more than that.

How can anyone build a happy and successful family life with people they don’t love?

U2HasTheEdge · 05/03/2022 11:18

For me, yes a partner would need to love my children. I wouldn't say he needs to love them the same way he loves his biological children, but there would have to be love there.

I wouldn't have stayed with my husband if he didn't love my children from my first marriage. He tells me that the love he has for his step-children is the same as the love he has for his biological children (again, it helps that they were so young).

I can't see into his heart, but my children are now young adults and I have never had any reason to question it, and that's good enough for me.

DoNotTouchTheWater · 05/03/2022 11:10

Similar to in-law situations

It is an in-law situation. Not just similar to it.

Iknowitisheresomewhere · 05/03/2022 10:28

Once they are over 10, I think expecting unconditional love from a step parent, particularly if they don’t live with the children full time, is optimistic. Similar to in-law situations - some people get on brilliantly, most care for each other but nothing like the relationship they have with their own parents/children.

Parenting tweens/teens is hard work, and if you haven’t done it before I think it would be very difficult to build unconditional love in that time. It might come later though.

CeriBerry · 05/03/2022 10:16

My stepchild is two and I absolutely adore her. I’d defend her and put her first at all costs. She was very easy to love because she’s part and parcel of my DP. She has a very involved mother so I’m careful not to overstep but the more people who love her the better really. We haven’t had children of our own (yet- hopefully we will do) so I can’t say if things would be different if I had a biological child but I can say for a fact that I love her to absolute bits.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 05/03/2022 09:44

No IMO. Which is why I didn't date again before my son left home in his 20s.

Branleuse · 05/03/2022 09:41

Needs to love them. I wouldnt have ever moved dp in with ds1 if I hadnt been confident there was love there.
Hes treated ds1 as his own the entire time. Ds was 4 when we met dp and hes an adult now. Dp has made sure ds1 will have same rights to inheritance as his biological children etc.

I couldnt be with someone that didnt love my children.
I had a stepdad and I think.he loved me to an extent, was definitely fond of me and did lots of things with me and taught me lots, but not very emotionally available. I guess thats ok too, but i think the fact that all the important men in my life, dad, brother, stepdads love was either very conditional, intermittent/absent, or half arsed, certainly had effects in my adult relationships.

Sheeeeba · 05/03/2022 09:34

@HRTQueen

He gets frustrated after spending one weekend a month with your children

Isn’t that your answer

It depends what he's getting frustrated with. The OPs child is 14. I know from my own DSS of a similar age that he can have a horrid attitude toward his mother and father at times. It wouldn't matter how often I saw him, witnessing that would frustrate me.

My SS's mother's partner gets frustrated with the same thing. He cares about DSC but he doesn't like how the teenager can be with his Mum sometimes.

Sheeeeba · 05/03/2022 09:28

I know she doesn’t love me the way she loves my (half) brother and she knows I don’t love her the way I love my mother, but that doesn’t diminish the relationship we have.

This is what I don't understand, why does the relationship have to be like parent - child for it to count? There are many people that I love in different ways to my son. It doesn't diminish those relationships. I don't love my God daughter in the same way as my son. But I still love her. It's the same with DSC, I don't think of them nor love them as if they were my own but I still have a good relationship with them.

Sheeeeba · 05/03/2022 09:25

@Willyoujustbequiet

Yes for me. I couldn't be in a relationship with a man not capable of loving my children as his own. It's a deal breaker.

For those saying no because they arent biologically his I hope you never adopt.

I know people like to think this is some big "gotcha" thing but it's not at all... I actually think comparing adoption to step parenting is incredibly insulting to adoptive parents.

Me being a step mother to my husband's children IS NOTHING like being an adoptive mother, in any way shape or form. My step children have a mother, they do not need that relationship from me.

Unless we are talking a situation where the other biological parent isn't involved at all and you've raised that child as their parent, it's nothing at all like adoption. Can we stop with this stupid comparison.