Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask does your partner need to love your kids, if he's not their biological father?

236 replies

blubberball · 03/03/2022 21:01

Or is it enough that he just cares about them, but doesn't love them?

OP posts:
Getyourarseofffthequattro · 05/03/2022 18:21

@thispooshallpass

Adopting and step parenting are two entirely different things. It's actually a little bit offensive to compare the two

Why? Stepparents aren't real even if they're there from a young age and a child's only father figure for example? I think that could equally be dismissive and offensive to people who spent years raising a child just because it's not down on paper, doesn't make them less of a parent.

Step parents aren't real? What?

I'm not saying they're less of a parent, many step parents do more parenting than the parent themselves, but it's not the same as adopting, is it? Unless you actually do adopt, and the bio parent is not on the scene. But it's still different than adopting a child unrelated to both you and your partner. Of course it is. it's weird to pretend it's not.

PinkSyCo · 05/03/2022 18:20

Bit victim Blamey @PinkSyCo**

How? I’m not blaming the kids am I?

OchreDandelion · 05/03/2022 18:20

My step-dad loves me. My step-mum definitely does not! I think, like much in life, it varies on the person not on the role.

AntithesisOfThis · 05/03/2022 18:20

@thispooshallpass

Adopting and step parenting are two entirely different things. It's actually a little bit offensive to compare the two

Why? Stepparents aren't real even if they're there from a young age and a child's only father figure for example? I think that could equally be dismissive and offensive to people who spent years raising a child just because it's not down on paper, doesn't make them less of a parent.

When you adopt you become a parent. There are no other parents (except your partner/spouse where applicable). With everything that entails.

That’s not what happens when you marry someone with children.

BabyTurtIe · 05/03/2022 18:20

It’s been said more than once to not compare it and it’s offensive so I don’t really want to comment on that as I haven’t adopted and I’m not a step parent so I will respect people saying it’s not the same.

thispooshallpass · 05/03/2022 18:19

@Getyourarseofffthequattro

It's entirely different *@thispooshallpass* especially if they have two living parents Confused
Mine doesn't have an involved bio father, stepparent is their parent. It's not hard to use critical thinking, there's different scenarios.

Of close dating the parent of a teen with a mother is different, it's kinda obvious aint it.

thispooshallpass · 05/03/2022 18:17

Adopting and step parenting are two entirely different things. It's actually a little bit offensive to compare the two

Why? Stepparents aren't real even if they're there from a young age and a child's only father figure for example? I think that could equally be dismissive and offensive to people who spent years raising a child just because it's not down on paper, doesn't make them less of a parent.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 05/03/2022 18:17

Bit victim Blamey @PinkSyCo

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 05/03/2022 18:17

It's entirely different @thispooshallpass especially if they have two living parents Confused

thispooshallpass · 05/03/2022 18:15

@BabyTurtIe

* I mean why not? People love their adopted children as much as their bio ones (if they have them), it's no different. You don't have to be related to a child.

If you raise a stepchild from young they are pretty much your child, you knew them before your other biological children in some cases, so🤷🏻‍♀️

Maybe you couldn't but it's not really an odd thing.*

It’s been said on here not to compare adopted children to step children so I can’t comment on that however adoption wouldn’t be for me either. I do find it odd as I don’t think humans are programmed to love other children as much as their own and in all honesty when relationships end step parents don’t usually see that child again so I very much doubt they love them like their own children.

It's no different to adopting a child and a minority of stepparents do go on to adopt their kids. I'm not sure who is so offended by that, but it's definitely the same in theory. It's loving a child you aren't related to biologically who you raised, possibly from a young age. I definitely don't think that's odd even if you couldn't personally

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 05/03/2022 18:15

The reason I don't love my step child in the same way as my own child is likely down to the age I met him, and his mother's behaviour. It was incredibly hard to gain his trust because of his mother's actions, and when I did the poor kid was continuously torn trying to be loyal to his mum but also wanting to be involved with me and his dad and brother. I didn't want to step on anyone toes so held back somewhat. I believe you can love a child like your own, and I'm sure if I adopted a baby I would love them the same as ds, but there wouldn't be another parent involved who hated me so it would be completely different. They would for all intents and purposes be my child, dss is not.

PinkSyCo · 05/03/2022 18:14

I did not love my stepchildren. They’re extremely challenging - and that’s their parents’ fault.

I never stood a chance because of the situation. And I really tried. Their own father struggles to love them. He describes them as ‘a mistake’ and ‘an obligation’. Obligation is the main way he sees his relationship with them. He admits that he is not close to them and even that he feels almost repulsed by them. He compensated for this by parenting entirely out of guilt, which was really not good.

As far as I can tell, their mother sees them pretty much as a means to an end. He eldest was her way if securing a meal ticket. She didn’t want to have the youngest and it appears that she doesn’t love him. There are obvious attachment issues there that are difficult to deal with.

Basically these are parents who fight over the kids but they’re fighting to be the one that doesn’t have to spend time with them or do anything. Their mother would drag really poorly children out of bed to deposit them at their dad’s - even where the kids made it clear they absolutely wanted to stay at home in bed. And the next morning their father would drag them back. It wasn’t that the mother had work (she does not work) or was struggling to find time for herself (two school aged children). Neither of their parents wanted to look after them.

Given that, I was merely a well meaning fool who blundered into a situation beyond my comprehension. After all, you start from the assumption that children’s own parents adore them. Obviously. No one assumes a parent would say they struggle to bring themselves to touch the children as they are a bit repulsed by them. Especially the poor youngest. The whole thing was a bit like boiling a frog. I didn’t realise his terrible it all was, and how unloveable the situation made the children, until it was a complete nightmare. The whole thing nearly broke me.

Their parents manage to meet the superficial needs of the children (fed, clothed, clean etc). But the children are extremely challenging because of the utterly fucked up emotional dynamic that’s been their entire lives.
No step parent is going to love those children. The children wouldn’t know what to do if they were properly loved. And I am so much better off out of there.

My ex is angry though because he’s lost his free nanny and housekeeper and has to look after them when he has “access”.

How sad. Nice man you picked there. Sad

BabyTurtIe · 05/03/2022 18:11
  • I mean why not? People love their adopted children as much as their bio ones (if they have them), it's no different. You don't have to be related to a child.

If you raise a stepchild from young they are pretty much your child, you knew them before your other biological children in some cases, so🤷🏻‍♀️

Maybe you couldn't but it's not really an odd thing.*

It’s been said on here not to compare adopted children to step children so I can’t comment on that however adoption wouldn’t be for me either. I do find it odd as I don’t think humans are programmed to love other children as much as their own and in all honesty when relationships end step parents don’t usually see that child again so I very much doubt they love them like their own children.

AntithesisOfThis · 05/03/2022 18:07

I should say that I spent a lot of that time blaming myself. I felt utterly dreadful that I found the children so challenging. Unlikeable never mind questions of love. I developed serious mental health problems based in thinking that I was evil and broken because I couldn’t feel anything but negative about the children.

But the distance that comes with getting divorced (plus the revelations that came from hearing my ex describe his children in arguments) and a lot of counselling has really helped me to see that I wasn’t the problem. I went into it warm and kind and helpful. But the toxicity of the situation was such that no one could thrive.

cuno · 05/03/2022 18:06

@AntithesisOfThis

I did not love my stepchildren. They’re extremely challenging - and that’s their parents’ fault.

I never stood a chance because of the situation. And I really tried. Their own father struggles to love them. He describes them as ‘a mistake’ and ‘an obligation’. Obligation is the main way he sees his relationship with them. He admits that he is not close to them and even that he feels almost repulsed by them. He compensated for this by parenting entirely out of guilt, which was really not good.

As far as I can tell, their mother sees them pretty much as a means to an end. He eldest was her way if securing a meal ticket. She didn’t want to have the youngest and it appears that she doesn’t love him. There are obvious attachment issues there that are difficult to deal with.

Basically these are parents who fight over the kids but they’re fighting to be the one that doesn’t have to spend time with them or do anything. Their mother would drag really poorly children out of bed to deposit them at their dad’s - even where the kids made it clear they absolutely wanted to stay at home in bed. And the next morning their father would drag them back. It wasn’t that the mother had work (she does not work) or was struggling to find time for herself (two school aged children). Neither of their parents wanted to look after them.

Given that, I was merely a well meaning fool who blundered into a situation beyond my comprehension. After all, you start from the assumption that children’s own parents adore them. Obviously. No one assumes a parent would say they struggle to bring themselves to touch the children as they are a bit repulsed by them. Especially the poor youngest. The whole thing was a bit like boiling a frog. I didn’t realise his terrible it all was, and how unloveable the situation made the children, until it was a complete nightmare. The whole thing nearly broke me.

Their parents manage to meet the superficial needs of the children (fed, clothed, clean etc). But the children are extremely challenging because of the utterly fucked up emotional dynamic that’s been their entire lives.

No step parent is going to love those children. The children wouldn’t know what to do if they were properly loved. And I am so much better off out of there.

My ex is angry though because he’s lost his free nanny and housekeeper and has to look after them when he has “access”.

That is so upsetting and heartbreaking. Sad
Getyourarseofffthequattro · 05/03/2022 18:04

@Willyoujustbequiet

Yes for me. I couldn't be in a relationship with a man not capable of loving my children as his own. It's a deal breaker.

For those saying no because they arent biologically his I hope you never adopt.

Adopting and step parenting are two entirely different things. It's actually a little bit offensive to compare the two
Marmelace · 05/03/2022 18:04

@AntithesisOfThis

I did not love my stepchildren. They’re extremely challenging - and that’s their parents’ fault.

I never stood a chance because of the situation. And I really tried. Their own father struggles to love them. He describes them as ‘a mistake’ and ‘an obligation’. Obligation is the main way he sees his relationship with them. He admits that he is not close to them and even that he feels almost repulsed by them. He compensated for this by parenting entirely out of guilt, which was really not good.

As far as I can tell, their mother sees them pretty much as a means to an end. He eldest was her way if securing a meal ticket. She didn’t want to have the youngest and it appears that she doesn’t love him. There are obvious attachment issues there that are difficult to deal with.

Basically these are parents who fight over the kids but they’re fighting to be the one that doesn’t have to spend time with them or do anything. Their mother would drag really poorly children out of bed to deposit them at their dad’s - even where the kids made it clear they absolutely wanted to stay at home in bed. And the next morning their father would drag them back. It wasn’t that the mother had work (she does not work) or was struggling to find time for herself (two school aged children). Neither of their parents wanted to look after them.

Given that, I was merely a well meaning fool who blundered into a situation beyond my comprehension. After all, you start from the assumption that children’s own parents adore them. Obviously. No one assumes a parent would say they struggle to bring themselves to touch the children as they are a bit repulsed by them. Especially the poor youngest. The whole thing was a bit like boiling a frog. I didn’t realise his terrible it all was, and how unloveable the situation made the children, until it was a complete nightmare. The whole thing nearly broke me.

Their parents manage to meet the superficial needs of the children (fed, clothed, clean etc). But the children are extremely challenging because of the utterly fucked up emotional dynamic that’s been their entire lives.

No step parent is going to love those children. The children wouldn’t know what to do if they were properly loved. And I am so much better off out of there.

My ex is angry though because he’s lost his free nanny and housekeeper and has to look after them when he has “access”.

What horrible people, those poor children, disgusting
AntithesisOfThis · 05/03/2022 18:01

I did not love my stepchildren. They’re extremely challenging - and that’s their parents’ fault.

I never stood a chance because of the situation. And I really tried. Their own father struggles to love them. He describes them as ‘a mistake’ and ‘an obligation’. Obligation is the main way he sees his relationship with them. He admits that he is not close to them and even that he feels almost repulsed by them. He compensated for this by parenting entirely out of guilt, which was really not good.

As far as I can tell, their mother sees them pretty much as a means to an end. He eldest was her way if securing a meal ticket. She didn’t want to have the youngest and it appears that she doesn’t love him. There are obvious attachment issues there that are difficult to deal with.

Basically these are parents who fight over the kids but they’re fighting to be the one that doesn’t have to spend time with them or do anything. Their mother would drag really poorly children out of bed to deposit them at their dad’s - even where the kids made it clear they absolutely wanted to stay at home in bed. And the next morning their father would drag them back. It wasn’t that the mother had work (she does not work) or was struggling to find time for herself (two school aged children). Neither of their parents wanted to look after them.

Given that, I was merely a well meaning fool who blundered into a situation beyond my comprehension. After all, you start from the assumption that children’s own parents adore them. Obviously. No one assumes a parent would say they struggle to bring themselves to touch the children as they are a bit repulsed by them. Especially the poor youngest. The whole thing was a bit like boiling a frog. I didn’t realise his terrible it all was, and how unloveable the situation made the children, until it was a complete nightmare. The whole thing nearly broke me.

Their parents manage to meet the superficial needs of the children (fed, clothed, clean etc). But the children are extremely challenging because of the utterly fucked up emotional dynamic that’s been their entire lives.

No step parent is going to love those children. The children wouldn’t know what to do if they were properly loved. And I am so much better off out of there.

My ex is angry though because he’s lost his free nanny and housekeeper and has to look after them when he has “access”.

thispooshallpass · 05/03/2022 17:44

@BabyTurtIe

I find it weird because I could never imagine loving anyone else’s child as much as my own, In fact I know I wouldn’t. It’s weird for me as in I don’t understand it and do find it odd.

I mean why not? People love their adopted children as much as their bio ones (if they have them), it's no different. You don't have to be related to a child.

If you raise a stepchild from young they are pretty much your child, you knew them before your other biological children in some cases, so🤷🏻‍♀️

Maybe you couldn't but it's not really an odd thing.

BabyTurtIe · 05/03/2022 17:35

@PinkSyCo

I think it would be very very rare for a stepfather or stepmother to truly love their stepchild. We’re just not biologically primed to love other people’s kids like we do our own.
Yes basically this, it’s odd to me as I don’t think it’s normal to love someone else’s child as much as your own, love them sure, but as much as your own, no I don’t get that.
BabyTurtIe · 05/03/2022 17:34

I find it weird because I could never imagine loving anyone else’s child as much as my own, In fact I know I wouldn’t. It’s weird for me as in I don’t understand it and do find it odd.

PinkSyCo · 05/03/2022 17:20

I think it would be very very rare for a stepfather or stepmother to truly love their stepchild. We’re just not biologically primed to love other people’s kids like we do our own.

Darkstar4855 · 05/03/2022 17:13

I think it totally depends on the age of the child, whether both parents are present, how much time is spent with them, presence or absence of siblings and lots of other things.

My stepson is a teenager, we see him every other weekend and he lives with his mum who is brilliant and has a fantastic relationship with him. I can’t in all honesty say I love him in the same way that I love my own son. I’ve only known him for a few years and I’ve never been in the role of parent as his own parents do that job perfectly well themselves. However I am hugely fond of him and care very deeply about his happiness and wellbeing. I treat him as equally important to my son as much as I possibly can.

So I think it’s ok not to love them exactly. It’s how you treat them that counts rather than how you feel (although obviously the latter will influence the former).

cuno · 05/03/2022 17:09

All that matters is my child feels loved, safe, and wanted, whether the step parent actually loves them or not.

U2HasTheEdge · 05/03/2022 17:00

@BabyTurtIe

I always think it’s weird when people claim to love their step kids as much as their own, I have nieces and nephews I don’t even love them anywhere near as much as my own kids. I don’t think a step parent needs to love their step kids being kind and caring for them is enough IMO, and as someone said judging by the step parents board on here most seem to not love their step kids.
Why is it weird?

I don't think it is weird that my husband loves his step-children as much as 'his own'. He has lived with them since they were little.

I don't love my nieces and nephews as much as I love my own either, but if I was living with them and taking an active parenting-like role, I might grow to. The comparsion doesn't really work.

I don't think a step-parent needs to love their step-children as much as they love their biological children. If they do though, I would hardly call that weird. I think it's lovely. Every situation and the people involved are different.