Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask does your partner need to love your kids, if he's not their biological father?

236 replies

blubberball · 03/03/2022 21:01

Or is it enough that he just cares about them, but doesn't love them?

OP posts:
Getyourarseofffthequattro · 06/03/2022 08:33

@MooseBreath

Caring is necessary, love could grow over time.

I would not have my children living in a house where someone living there didn't care for them.

I agree. That's what's important. I went in with the intention of being a kind friendly adult who he could trust. Nothing more. Not his mum. I didn't intend to love him like my own child because he has a mum. I do love him, and that builds as time goes on, but not in the same way I love my own child and I think that's fine.
Simonjt · 06/03/2022 08:27

@TheBigDilemma So you’re confirming that you think adopted children aren’t our own children?

MooseBreath · 06/03/2022 08:26

Caring is necessary, love could grow over time.

I would not have my children living in a house where someone living there didn't care for them.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 06/03/2022 08:26

I personally don't think they share many similarities at all unless you enter that child's life when they are very young, and their other parent is either completely uninvolved or dead. Equally, you still don't enter that relationship with the only intention being wanting to become a parent. If you do, frankly thats fucking weird.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 06/03/2022 08:23

@TheBigDilemma

Sorry, but I have heard after adoptions going bad after the adopting couple got a new baby of their own, where the parents could not love the previously adopted child in the way they they love their own.

I have also seen adoptive parents who love their children and adopted children exactly the same.

I fail to see the difference between adopting and step parenting, both have their own individual difficulties, which vary according to case specific circumstances. Some adoptive parenting relationships succeed some don’t, much like with step parenting.

The only big difference I can see is that stepparents are often portrayed as the evil characters in Disney stories while adopted parents get brownie points for opening their heart and home to a child… much in the same way as stepparents also do, with good intentions and with children who may have been caught in a lot of conflict and a result are carrying trauma which may interfere when blending a family or building/increasing one through adoption.

How about the other biological parents? That's a big bloody difference there that you've neglected to note.
TheBigDilemma · 06/03/2022 08:13

@Simonjt

Sorry, but I have heard after adoptions going bad after the adopting couple got a new baby of their own, where the parents could not love the previously adopted child in the way they they love their own.

So you think adopted children aren’t our own children?

Jesus, what I am saying is that being an adoptive parent and being a step parent share a lot of similarities. Every case is different, sometimes blending/adopting works sometimes it doesn’t.

Period.

TheOriginalEmu · 06/03/2022 07:22

I would never be with someone who didn’t love my kids.

MintyFreshBreath · 06/03/2022 07:20

@TeachesOfPeaches

The step parent normally never sees the non-bio children again if they split with the parent. Tells you all you need to know.
You have to admit, it’s a very difficult situation and much of it’s going to depend on the age of the kids when the adults split. I never saw my first step mum again but I was 11 so it’s not like I had the money to get the bus to see her and mobile phones weren’t a thing. Regarding my second step mum, it was far easier as I was an adult and could make my own choices.
MintyFreshBreath · 06/03/2022 07:17

I don’t expect my husband to love DS but I know he cares about him. I feel much the same about the step-kids.

TeachesOfPeaches · 06/03/2022 06:52

The step parent normally never sees the non-bio children again if they split with the parent. Tells you all you need to know.

Simonjt · 06/03/2022 06:47

Sorry, but I have heard after adoptions going bad after the adopting couple got a new baby of their own, where the parents could not love the previously adopted child in the way they they love their own.

So you think adopted children aren’t our own children?

cuno · 06/03/2022 01:32

@TheBigDilemma

I see both as parents, there are a lot of people in this thread saying it is not the same.

My only blanket statement is that every case is different.

You just typed a whole post explaining why adoptive parents and step parents are the same. Apparently the only big difference is Disney portrayals! No mention of bio parents, as if they are in a league of their own. You came across as a defensive step mother to be honest. Are you?
TheBigDilemma · 06/03/2022 01:20

I see both as parents, there are a lot of people in this thread saying it is not the same.

My only blanket statement is that every case is different.

cuno · 06/03/2022 00:31

@TheBigDilemma

Sorry, but I have heard after adoptions going bad after the adopting couple got a new baby of their own, where the parents could not love the previously adopted child in the way they they love their own.

I have also seen adoptive parents who love their children and adopted children exactly the same.

I fail to see the difference between adopting and step parenting, both have their own individual difficulties, which vary according to case specific circumstances. Some adoptive parenting relationships succeed some don’t, much like with step parenting.

The only big difference I can see is that stepparents are often portrayed as the evil characters in Disney stories while adopted parents get brownie points for opening their heart and home to a child… much in the same way as stepparents also do, with good intentions and with children who may have been caught in a lot of conflict and a result are carrying trauma which may interfere when blending a family or building/increasing one through adoption.

And there are bio parents who abuse or neglect their own children or don't love them, can happen when a new baby is in the picture, what is your point? Both bio parents and adoptive parents are equally known as 'parents'. You know, the people who have parental responsibility and moral and financial obligations to their children? It is dismissive to suggest that just because a child may be adopted, their parents love them any less or the children are somehow less deserving.

Step-parents however do not have parental responsibility, and fewer moral obligations, neither do they have financial ones. Generally speaking, both parents are equally responsible over their children, or if a lone parent then the buck stops with them. Step-parents are not equal parents with equal say. Normally they don't get to make decisions about the child's health and education, or take them for a haircut, or permit a piercing under the age of 16, or bathe the step-child etc. Yes there are some step-parents who are equally involved, but only on the initial say so of the parent, and this is usually only the case when the step-parent has been around since the child was a baby or toddler. But most often they step into the child's life much later, and many step out much the same too after the relationship with parent falls apart. Some step-parents stay in touch, but there is not even a moral obligation on them to do that.

Every blended family is different, but it's just plain wrong to make a blanket statement that says there is no difference between adopting and step parenting. As if every bio parent is amazing and we don't have millions of feckless fathers as well as children in the care system because both their bio parents failed them miserably.

sst1234 · 06/03/2022 00:25

If everyone just loved their own children rather than needing to live other people’s, it might be better for the children. Why do you need a step parent to love a child, where’s that child’s own biological parent (father in most cases). Loving someone else’s kid probably - based on this ridiculous expectation.

Jellyfishjean · 06/03/2022 00:02

Lol. Stepmother on the stepparent thread are like how do I nacho this child, little shit, and then there are people on this thread saying a stepdad needs to love the kids. Double standards! 0Grin

Bunty55 · 05/03/2022 23:48

My partner and I have lived together for over twenty years. My husband had left us and he had been single for years when we met.

My children have put the poor man through hell especially when they were teenagers and he still stayed !

He has supported them all with advice and help and money. They know he is not their father but they all respect him now and admit they were bastards to live with. I would not call it love but as far as family relationships go, if anything were to happen to him they would be as devastated as I.
He cares for them all, but he does not love them the way he loves his own daughter, that's understood.
He is a part of their lives, and that is good enough for me

TheBigDilemma · 05/03/2022 23:29

Sorry, but I have heard after adoptions going bad after the adopting couple got a new baby of their own, where the parents could not love the previously adopted child in the way they they love their own.

I have also seen adoptive parents who love their children and adopted children exactly the same.

I fail to see the difference between adopting and step parenting, both have their own individual difficulties, which vary according to case specific circumstances. Some adoptive parenting relationships succeed some don’t, much like with step parenting.

The only big difference I can see is that stepparents are often portrayed as the evil characters in Disney stories while adopted parents get brownie points for opening their heart and home to a child… much in the same way as stepparents also do, with good intentions and with children who may have been caught in a lot of conflict and a result are carrying trauma which may interfere when blending a family or building/increasing one through adoption.

Erinyes · 05/03/2022 20:38

@thispooshallpass

What does that have to do with loving a non bio child like yours? The fact you had to get approved...?

It depends on the circumstances. A stepparent involved from early on with no other parent is as much a parent as a biological or adoptive parent, the end.

You don’t see a difference between (1) deciding to adopt, going through the lengthy approval process and being matched with a child whose legal relationship with birth parents has been legally terminated and (2) happening to fall in love with X, who has a child or children you would never have met had you not been in a relationship with their parent, and who is likely to have two functioning parents in their life?
Getyourarseofffthequattro · 05/03/2022 20:32

@thispooshallpass

What does that have to do with loving a non bio child like yours? The fact you had to get approved...?

It depends on the circumstances. A stepparent involved from early on with no other parent is as much a parent as a biological or adoptive parent, the end.

You're literally ignoring the point. Do you marry someone specifically because you want to become a parent? No, you do not.

I don't know why you're deliberately misunderstanding. Nobody is denying your husband is a parent, just saying it's not the same as adoption, because it's not.

thispooshallpass · 05/03/2022 20:21

What does that have to do with loving a non bio child like yours? The fact you had to get approved...?

It depends on the circumstances. A stepparent involved from early on with no other parent is as much a parent as a biological or adoptive parent, the end.

Erinyes · 05/03/2022 19:19

@Getyourarseofffthequattro

I've literally agreed that it's possible. Of course it's possible. It's not the same if another parent is involved, it's not the same if the parent you're married to had years of bringing up the child before you. I'm not denying in some circumstances step parents can love a child as their own, I'm sure they can, but I don't agree it's the same as adoption. They're two different sets of circumstances, in both, yes the child can be loved by someone biologically unrelated. I don't think it's all that common in step parenting, where it is likely very common in adoption. The intent is clear in adoption, from day one they are your child, when marrying someone with a child, they're not. It might grow, it might not but they aren't just your child overnight like in an adoption.
Well, yes, exactly. Comparisons to adoption are mad. In adoption, each adoptive parent has worked very hard to be approved and then to be linked to a child, survive introductions etc — their intent is to bond, create an attachment and, eventually, love. A step-parent by definition is only in their stepchildren’s life because of their relationship with the children’s parent. That doesn’t mean love and attachment can’t grow, but it’s not the primary motivation.
Getyourarseofffthequattro · 05/03/2022 18:46

I've literally agreed that it's possible. Of course it's possible. It's not the same if another parent is involved, it's not the same if the parent you're married to had years of bringing up the child before you. I'm not denying in some circumstances step parents can love a child as their own, I'm sure they can, but I don't agree it's the same as adoption. They're two different sets of circumstances, in both, yes the child can be loved by someone biologically unrelated. I don't think it's all that common in step parenting, where it is likely very common in adoption. The intent is clear in adoption, from day one they are your child, when marrying someone with a child, they're not. It might grow, it might not but they aren't just your child overnight like in an adoption.

ChocolateIsAlwaysTheAnswer · 05/03/2022 18:46

My colleague is step mum to her partners kid. Been together 4 years and she was put in the mum immediately. She liked it as always wanted more kids. She has a 22 year old, he has a 12 year old. Seems to work perfectly for them and I am surprised as he got with her only a few weeks from splitting with his wife of 10 years who he adored. Very lucky to have met someone perfect for him and his family just weeks after he split with his wife.

thispooshallpass · 05/03/2022 18:43

[quote Getyourarseofffthequattro]@cookiemonster2468 I understand that, I too have a step parent whom may as well be my real parent and i am also not adopted. What I'm saying is marrying someone with a child is not the same as going through the process of adopting a child unrelated to both parents.[/quote]

How? It is for the non-related parent. I get that adoption is hard with the process etc. But I don't get the massive difference. The point is it's possible to love an unrelated child like your own- why would any adopter/adopted child disagree with that