Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask does your partner need to love your kids, if he's not their biological father?

236 replies

blubberball · 03/03/2022 21:01

Or is it enough that he just cares about them, but doesn't love them?

OP posts:
Sarah180818 · 06/03/2022 17:36

Myself and my DH have two DSs. He adores them. I have a DD from a previous marriage. DH has been in her life since she was 4. I share custody of her 50:50. my DH loves my DD but I know it's not as much as our 2 DS but when she is at ours, she is treated the same and I don't think has any idea that she is loved a little bit less and never will.

cuno · 06/03/2022 14:11

@undetetected

We are saying that you don't go comparing step-parents to adoptive parents, same way as you don't compare step-parents to bio parents. Because adoptive/bio parents are the parents and the same thing apart from the child not being biologically theirs, but the child is still theirs. Parental responsibility, moral and financial obligations, which step-parents do not have. There are exceptions to the rule of course, but that's what they are, exceptions! You're the one that can't grasp it!

Sheeeeba · 06/03/2022 13:54

That's fair enough, but for others it's different depending on circumstances. I don't get why people can't grasp that. For some children they know no different than their stepparent

In which case yes it can be similar to adoption BUT in general terms, step parenting is nothing like adoption. Only in very certain circumstances does it become similar. On the whole it's not.

undetetected · 06/03/2022 13:11

Everyone needs to realise:
A- not everyone has the same circumstances as you. Some stepparents are a child's only second parent
B- you have no idea who is related or not. That's not the defining factor
C- there's enough parenthood to go around. You don't get to invalidate others loved experience by dating someone who raises a child almost their entire life isn't their parent.

PinkSyCo · 06/03/2022 13:11

PinkSyCo
I think it would be very very rare for a stepfather or stepmother to truly love their stepchild. We’re just not biologically primed to love other people’s kids like we do our own.

What about when a couple have used a sperm donor? Is the woman’s partner not capable of loving that child like his own?

I’ve said I think it would be very rare for a non biological parent to truly love the child, not impossible.
In the way you describe is rather different because the ‘father’ will have entered the situation from a point of love and with his eyes wide open. He would be there throughout his partner’s whole pregnancy, attend scans, help with the choosing of names etc. He would more than likely watch that child come into the world, hold him/her straight away. He would be part of that child’s growth from day dot, helping to nurture him, instilling good behaviour and morals in the child as it grew, so overall I think the bond would naturally be very much stronger in this case.

undetetected · 06/03/2022 13:02

@Mummytobe93

Adoption is about becoming a parent legally to a child that has got no other adults responsible for him/her.

Step-parents are biological parents partners are there to support them in parenting. I’m a step mum but my step son has got two very involved, loving parents in his life - I surely don’t feel the same level of responsibility for him as though he was adopted by me. I don’t do school pick ups, don’t go to parents evenings etc.

I haven’t got a parental responsibility, I don’t have maternal feelings towards him - I care for him, I want all that’s best for him, want him to be safe, happy and loved. And he is, with or without me in his life.
Adopted child relies in 100% on their adoptive parents.

That's fair enough, but for others it's different depending on circumstances. I don't get why people can't grasp that. For some children they know no different than their stepparent.

Long term foster parents aren't a legal parent. Sometimes they are essentially the only parents the child knows. Whereas a teen being fostered won't feel the same way. It depends.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 06/03/2022 12:00

@CounsellorTroi I personally think again that's different. That's a baby you're actively planning and intending to parent from the very beginning, more similar to adoption than step parenting.

CounsellorTroi · 06/03/2022 10:03

@PinkSyCo

I think it would be very very rare for a stepfather or stepmother to truly love their stepchild. We’re just not biologically primed to love other people’s kids like we do our own.
What about when a couple have used a sperm donor? Is the woman’s partner not capable of loving that child like his own?
Mummytobe93 · 06/03/2022 09:34

Adoption is about becoming a parent legally to a child that has got no other adults responsible for him/her.

Step-parents are biological parents partners are there to support them in parenting. I’m a step mum but my step son has got two very involved, loving parents in his life - I surely don’t feel the same level of responsibility for him as though he was adopted by me. I don’t do school pick ups, don’t go to parents evenings etc.

I haven’t got a parental responsibility, I don’t have maternal feelings towards him - I care for him, I want all that’s best for him, want him to be safe, happy and loved. And he is, with or without me in his life.
Adopted child relies in 100% on their adoptive parents.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 06/03/2022 09:31

@undetetected

I'll ask again. Does the step father in that situation marry the mother with the only intention being to become a parent?

Relevance? You don't have to be offended and you don't have to gatekeep parenthood. Can you answer why a stepparent who adopts a child isn't their parent please?

It OBVIOUSLY depends on the circumstances. But yes, a stepparent can be a child's parent based on:

  • how long they've known the child
  • age when they first met
  • closeness of relationship
  • how much childcare they've done
  • if they live with the child
  • if there is no other living or present mother/father
The bloody relevance is that intending to parent and nothing else would be what makes it like adoption. That is literally the conversation we are having!

I haven't said a step parent who Adopts a child isn't their parent. They literally are, by law. I'm unsure why you're questioning this as literally nobody has said that's the case, at all.

None of that makes it comparable to adoption, especially if they have two living involved parents. Living with a child and doing childcare does not make you a parent, btw. Legally, a step parent isn't a parent unless they adopt, which most don't. Of course you may take on the role of a parent, but many don't, and it shouldn't be the expectation.

Going back to the adoption comparison, it's still not the same despite your erm, compelling argument.

undetetected · 06/03/2022 09:27

I'll ask again. Does the step father in that situation marry the mother with the only intention being to become a parent?

Relevance? You don't have to be offended and you don't have to gatekeep parenthood. Can you answer why a stepparent who adopts a child isn't their parent please?

It OBVIOUSLY depends on the circumstances. But yes, a stepparent can be a child's parent based on:

  • how long they've known the child
  • age when they first met
  • closeness of relationship
  • how much childcare they've done
  • if they live with the child
  • if there is no other living or present mother/father
Robotdott · 06/03/2022 09:25

I fail to see the difference between adopting and step parenting

Then perhaps have a think about it and stop being ignorant?

In answer to the OPs question, no personally I don't think they have to love their step children (especially not the competitive love people seem to think exists on here), but absolutely should treat them well.

Sheeeeba · 06/03/2022 09:25

Some people are lone parents. Not everyone has the same life as you hun

Of course. Which is why most people have said the only comparable thing is when the other biological parent isn't on the scene and the step parent has been that figure.

But that is not most blended families.

It's not right to generally compare step parenting to adoption. Because outside of certain cases, it is generally nothing like it.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 06/03/2022 09:24

Yes, I know @undetetected it's okay for you to state that being a step parent makes the children yours, but not ok for me to point out some actual parents wouldn't be on board with that. Maybe you're a lone parent and your husband has taken over, but not everyone has the same life as you, Hun.

Sheeeeba · 06/03/2022 09:23

I'll ask again. Does the step father in that situation marry the mother with the only intention being to become a parent?

Exactly.

When you adopt your sole reason is to become that child's parent.

You marry your husband primarily for the adult relationship with him, not for the step parent relationship with his kids. That is a secondary thing that just happens when you marry someone with children, not the sole reason you do.

undetetected · 06/03/2022 09:22

[quote Getyourarseofffthequattro]@undetetected my step sons mother would have a looooot to say if I said he was "mine"[/quote]
Some people are lone parents. Not everyone has the same life as you hun x

Sheeeeba · 06/03/2022 09:22

I fail to see the difference between adopting and step parenting

The only across the board similarity with adoption and step parenting is that the child in question is not biologically yours.

But when you adopt that child is your child. You are a mother or a father like any other.

It's like saying being a mother and being a step mother are the same thing. They are not in I'd say most cases. There will be the exception of course where the biological mother is not around and the step mother has been that figure. But lots it not most step parenting cases I imagine, there are two actual parents still there. Two parents who don't need or often want you acting like mum.

It's entirely different to adoption. I am so shocked you think it's exactly the same tbh. It's so blaring obviously different.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 06/03/2022 09:20

@undetetected my step sons mother would have a looooot to say if I said he was "mine"

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 06/03/2022 09:19

@undetetected

Have you not seen those videos on YouTube where the kids are raised by the stepfather and they surprise him by asking to be formally adopted? That's their father.

The amount of turmoil that goes into acquiring a baby doesn't make someone more a parent. Someone who had many miscarriages and a difficult birth isn't more a mother than a 19 year old.

I'll ask again. Does the step father in that situation marry the mother with the only intention being to become a parent?
Sheeeeba · 06/03/2022 09:17

The experience of being my son's actual parent compared to being a step parent to children who have two involved parents already is COMPLETELY different. As it would be with adoption v step parenting.

Sheeeeba · 06/03/2022 09:16

It's no different to adopting a child and a minority of stepparents do go on to adopt their kids. I'm not sure who is so offended by that, but it's definitely the same in theory. It's loving a child you aren't related to biologically who you raised, possibly from a young age. I definitely don't think that's odd even if you couldn't personally

Of course it's different. When you adopt you become that child's parents and everything else that goes along with that.

Unless we are talking about a situation where the child's biological parent is not in the picture then very often step parents are not wanted to take on parenting roles.

My step children have a very involved mother. She does not want me playing Mum to her kids and I don't need to either because they have her and their Dad in my husband.

I'd be utterly ludicrous to suggest that situation is the same as adopting the children. Of course it bloody isn't.

undetetected · 06/03/2022 08:42

[quote Simonjt]@undetetected So you think my children aren’t related to me and as well as not being my own Hmm[/quote]
You have issues. NOBODY said that. If you adopt or foster a child they are yours. If you birth a child they a yours. Stepparent. Yours. OK?

undetetected · 06/03/2022 08:40

Have you not seen those videos on YouTube where the kids are raised by the stepfather and they surprise him by asking to be formally adopted? That's their father.

The amount of turmoil that goes into acquiring a baby doesn't make someone more a parent. Someone who had many miscarriages and a difficult birth isn't more a mother than a 19 year old.

Simonjt · 06/03/2022 08:38

@undetetected So you think my children aren’t related to me and as well as not being my own Hmm

undetetected · 06/03/2022 08:36

[quote Simonjt]@TheBigDilemma So you’re confirming that you think adopted children aren’t our own children?[/quote]
You know you don't have to be offended. They are in your favour, unlike people who say they could never love a child that's not related to them.
@TheBigDilemma
said nothing wrong.