Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask does your partner need to love your kids, if he's not their biological father?

236 replies

blubberball · 03/03/2022 21:01

Or is it enough that he just cares about them, but doesn't love them?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Choppingonions · 08/03/2022 08:30

Your lived experience and feels doesn't make it true for everyone else.

No. Nor can you say it doesn't happen and unfortunately it does.

Nietzschethehiker · 08/03/2022 08:16

I'm absolutely side stepping the adoption conversation because I am not remotely qualified to comment but to the original OP.

I think like others it absolutely depends. I do think there is a big impact if the step parent and the parent go onto have another child together. Dp loves my dc and absolutely sees himself in the role of a loving step father however given that I know how viscerally I love my dc (partly the biological connection) I can't genuinely but wonder if that love would seem different if he also jad a biological child.

Because of that and other reasons we actively decided not to have a child together. It would have been supremely unfair to my dc and for us personally (emphasise I am not commenting on others) it would have been a selfish choice for the adults.

Dc have a df who is very much in their lives (he is a bit of a Disney dad but to be fair hard to be anything other when he doesn't have them around school etc weekends only due to distance). Dp is his name but loves them very much. However for us we protected that to a point by not splitting his focus. With his agreement obviously.

So yes he loves them and in our house it qould be essential. I'm not naive enough to think he loved them from day one but he certainly does now.

I do think if we met when they were teens that would be different it's a very different relationship.

CadvanTheBard · 08/03/2022 07:45

Your lived experience and feels doesn't make it true for everyone else.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 08/03/2022 07:23

@Choppingonions

18:51Getyourarseofffthequatt

I'm glad that wasn't your experience. As I wasn't trying to suggest it was every child's experience, it proves nothing really but great that you were fine.

It very much sounded like you were trying to suggest that, else why mention it?
Choppingonions · 07/03/2022 23:50

Tbh, I think you just want to blame a stepparent for a parent’s inadequacy here. The problem is not a lack of love from a SP. It’s a shit father

Or mother.

Choppingonions · 07/03/2022 23:49

It’s not about not being chosen. Ever

You can say that until the cows come home. That's how it feels.

Choppingonions · 07/03/2022 23:47

18:51Getyourarseofffthequatt

I'm glad that wasn't your experience. As I wasn't trying to suggest it was every child's experience, it proves nothing really but great that you were fine.

Choppingonions · 07/03/2022 23:46

I have a step parent who has adopted that child in my family. I can assure you it wouldn't have worked at all had the child not been parented and committed to by the now adoptive parent especially when new babies were born. A perfectly valid and necessary form of adoption if that family were going to be together. If the absent parent hadn't signed paperwork it would still have had to be an adoption in all but legal name.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 07/03/2022 18:51

@Choppingonions

Nope. It doesn't help with the yearning or the pain of seeing it within touching distance and knowing that somehow you weren't chosen.
Very dramatic. As a step child myself, and the added bonus of a dad who didn't really want me either, I can guarantee you there was no "yearning and pain". My step dad is lovely. He treats me very well and it doesn't cross my mind whether he lives his biological child more because I am greatful for having him as part of my life.

Some kids might yearn for a dad, but fuck me, a kind step parent is absolutely fine a lot of the time. I didn't need someone to pretend to be my dad.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 07/03/2022 18:48

@Choppingonions

Sorry.

Imagine not having a dad and living with siblings who did have a dad, and he was in your home, but he didn't love you.

We would think this was an awful and damaging situation for a child. Adoption would be preferable for a child.

Adoption would be preferable? Are you joking? What about their actual parent they live with? They're better off without them? Don't be so fucking ridiculous.
cuno · 07/03/2022 18:07

@misspg08

It’s offensive to adopted children and their parents rather than to stepparents.

Why is that offensive? It's specific to the scenario whether it's similar or not. And being offended isn't a golden ticket to silence people.

So it's free game to say step-parents and adoptive parents are similar/the same (a PP literally said they see no difference), yet I don't see people arguing that generally step-parents are no different to bio parents. Funny that. It implies that adoptive parents are somehow not real parents.

Of course there are situations where step-parents become mum or dad, but those are the exceptions not the rule. And that type of step-parent usually goes on to adopt, so of course they are a parent not even a step-parent anymore in those instances.

There are also grandparents, uncles, aunts, siblings that take on the parental role and become mum/dad to that child. Yet still we don't sit here arguing that of course an uncle is no different to being a dad, based on the exceptions that do sometimes happen. Because generally it is really not the case!

Believe it or not, not every time someone finds something offensive they are simply being precious and trying to just shut you up for no reason. Just as it's a free society for people to say what they like, people are also free to take offence to that. Didn't see anyone on this thread advocating for curtailing your free speech!

DoNotTouchTheWater · 07/03/2022 17:30

@misspg08

It’s offensive to adopted children and their parents rather than to stepparents.

Why is that offensive? It's specific to the scenario whether it's similar or not. And being offended isn't a golden ticket to silence people.

It’s offensive because it illustrates ignorance about adoption.
misspg08 · 07/03/2022 17:17

It’s offensive to adopted children and their parents rather than to stepparents.

Why is that offensive? It's specific to the scenario whether it's similar or not. And being offended isn't a golden ticket to silence people.

DoNotTouchTheWater · 07/03/2022 16:59

@Choppingonions

Nope. It doesn't help with the yearning or the pain of seeing it within touching distance and knowing that somehow you weren't chosen.
Framing it as ‘choosing’ is utterly ridiculous.

It’s not about not being chosen. Ever. And if you suspect a child feels that it might be about choices then you should help that child to understand that it’s totally ok for mums and dads to love their own children in a way they don’t and won’t live anyone else.

If there’s a choice involved, then actually the SP is choosing to live with them, spend time with them, care for them. They are not making that kind of choice with their own kids. So they should feel that there’s something special about them. It doesn’t need to be (parental) love.

And their dad’s absence shouldn’t be framed as a choice about the child either. That’s about their own issues and inability to take responsibility - and gain the huge advantage of having their child in their life. But it is hard for the child not to feel rejected by a shit parent.

Tbh, I think you just want to blame a stepparent for a parent’s inadequacy here. The problem is not a lack of love from a SP. It’s a shit father. And that is not the SP’s doing.

Choppingonions · 07/03/2022 16:23

You're amazing changes. If their own mum isn't around I think that's the only way you can be with a person who has children, especially if you have your own. I realise you didn't say that their mum isn't involved so she probably is, which just makes you even more amazing in my book as it would be so easy to think "they have their own mum".

changingstages · 07/03/2022 16:08

I love my stepchildren, who are now 19 and 22. They've been in my life for 15 years. I didn't start out loving them - but I cared for them because they're my partner's children and I thought very hard about getting into a relationship with someone with children. I'd hope anyone would.

I have a child with DP and the truth is that I love her in a totally different way to how I feel about the DSC. But I'd die before I let any of them know that. I want them to feel loved, cared about, welcome, equally, all the time. Sometimes that has been really difficult but I've always seen that as my problem to fix. They drive me mad (or did when they were younger) in a way that my own DD doesn't - but I would NEVER let them know that.

I do love them lots. They're great. It was worth the hard work.

Choppingonions · 07/03/2022 15:40

Nope. It doesn't help with the yearning or the pain of seeing it within touching distance and knowing that somehow you weren't chosen.

DoNotTouchTheWater · 07/03/2022 14:46

@Choppingonions

Children can understand that even if their dad is absent, other children’s are not. It’s not a reflection on them. It’s a reflection on the dads involved.

No, I don't think they necessarily can. It's convenient for you to think, though.

They can if the adults around them ensure they actively teach them that. And to build their feeling of being valued and valuable.

And the rest of the world doesn’t undermine it by insisting that they’re victims by default.

Choppingonions · 07/03/2022 14:39

Children can understand that even if their dad is absent, other children’s are not. It’s not a reflection on them. It’s a reflection on the dads involved.

No, I don't think they necessarily can. It's convenient for you to think, though.

DoNotTouchTheWater · 07/03/2022 14:36

That’s ridiculous. Whether it is a good or bad situation depends entirely on how people handle things.

Children do not have to be loved by everyone to thrive. In fact, the expectation that everyone should love them and act accordingly is probably extremely damaging for a child.

There’s a long distance between not loving a child and mistreatment.

Children can understand that even if their dad is absent, other children’s are not. It’s not a reflection on them. It’s a reflection on the dads involved.

Choppingonions · 07/03/2022 14:06

Sorry.

Imagine not having a dad and living with siblings who did have a dad, and he was in your home, but he didn't love you.

We would think this was an awful and damaging situation for a child. Adoption would be preferable for a child.

Choppingonions · 07/03/2022 14:05

Being a step parent isn't the same as adopting a child, not sure why some are so keen to try and prove that it is.

Definitely not.

But imagine not having a dad and living

DoNotTouchTheWater · 06/03/2022 19:35

@Icemast

Being a step parent isn't the same as adopting a child, not sure why some are so keen to try and prove that it is.
I always just think it shows general levels of ignorance about adoption.

It’s offensive to adopted children and their parents rather than to stepparents.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 06/03/2022 18:38

@undetetected

Everyone needs to realise: A- not everyone has the same circumstances as you. Some stepparents are a child's only second parent B- you have no idea who is related or not. That's not the defining factor C- there's enough parenthood to go around. You don't get to invalidate others loved experience by dating someone who raises a child almost their entire life isn't their parent.
You're taking this very personally. Nobody is saying what you think they're saying.
Icemast · 06/03/2022 17:53

Being a step parent isn't the same as adopting a child, not sure why some are so keen to try and prove that it is.