Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To keep sister away from daughters birthday

52 replies

Feelingsicky · 03/03/2022 20:58

My daughters 6th birthday is in 2 days. I have OCD and covid has been an enormous challenge for me and triggered a lot. Family aware of this. I have sought therapy and am now doing really well.

Throughout the whole pandemic I have been consistent with family, who tend to bend the rules re covid restrictions/isolation or play ignorant. E.g my mum defending her partners multiple ‘social bubbles’ by telling me she doesn’t think he knows what it means. He’s an engineer for crying out loud. I have told family, if you’re having contact with me and my children, just follow the advice/rules before you visit, otherwise do what you like, I’m not here to police them.

Anyway, upcoming daughters birthday. My sister has gone to see her covid positive bf within the last few days, more than once, they don’t live together. Stating ‘the rules have lifted’, well things only changed about 5 minutes ago and the advice is still to isolate it’s just not a legal requirement anymore.

I’m not comfortable with her coming to the house now, and my mum is sending me messages asking if she can. I even said to her before she saw him, I won’t feel comfortable her coming to my house within a few days of seeing him while he’s positive and she did it anyway.

I also have a baby at home. I know my OCD will play a role in how I follow the advice re covid, but I’m literally asking them to just follow the advice before they see us, nothing more. One way I look at it, is if he had flu, would she see him and then come here, where there’s a baby, no.

AIBU to say she can’t come?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
bluebird3 · 04/03/2022 21:02

YANBU at all. I do not have OCD and would definitely not allow a close contact into my home to potentially spread covid to me or my baby. I am of the opinion that there is no going back to 'normal' and burying our head in the sand. I'll choose the level of risk I'm willing to put myself and children at.

We do go out to restaurants, socialise indoors, attend school, etc but we do not knowingly expose ourselves to any diseases or illnesses. Like you said, it's similar to measles, the flu, norovirus etc. I'm not going to spend time with someone who has this or likely has it. She can visit next week.

Sparticuscaticus · 04/03/2022 19:57

Ps I don't have a baby now! My DC are all mostly teens now, but I wouldn't have taken the risk when mine were babies even to expose them unnecessarily to someone carrying heavy flu or any respiratory viruses . Let alone covid. They're fine and tougher now. They shook off covid they caught 3 weeks ago easily.

My eldest (now huge 6footer DS) as a baby /to about 9 yo had multiple ambulances who had to race him in to hospital over the years- very scary- for sudden acute exacerbations -from far milder respiratory viruses -than covid. It's very different when their lungs are small and their immune systems aren't up and running yet.

Sparticuscaticus · 04/03/2022 19:45

It's be good to see this thread back in a helpful place

It's interesting that some would take risk and some wouldn't

I wouldn't, not with my baby as lugs aren't as strong nor , my DD or the other children coming to DDs birthday party.

DSis has exposed herself to covid by going round to her bfs (& kissing etc) whilst he is covid positive - which may well no longer breach legal requirement to isolate - but it does rather increase extremely high likelihood shes also infected & contagious with covid too now!!!

Anecdotally if you RTFT - only 50 posts- has been discussions about high level false negatives LFTs for first few days before it starts to register positive, even with covid symptoms and even fully vaccinated.

I can't find the recent published stats for it but vaguely recall the figure being surprising high for false negative LFTs especially with omicron variant .

I just wouldn't rely on Dsis testing when she's been so closely exposed to DP sick with covid (compared to general risks of "might have sat near someone" that we now all have to live with )

Sparticuscaticus · 04/03/2022 18:56

TheOccupier

PPs were able to read your posts themselves. You weren't saying the Mental Health board "would be more sympathetic" that's untrue you said something entirely different and unkind. You don't get to use peoples disability in that way .

MNHQ have deleted your post so clearly agree it breached guidelines.

Calling out people who discriminate is not "the oldest trick in the book", it is much needed, we stand together against it.

I have no idea who OP is.
All I can see she understandably asked you to stop. As have /and can / other PPs who have tried to get you to stop this all afternoon.

saoirse31 · 04/03/2022 18:13

Just get her to do a test on the day, and if it's positive she doesn't go. I presume given your concerns all of your family other than the baby are vaccinated so presumably that should lessen your worries.

Feelingsicky · 04/03/2022 17:17

@TheOccupier I said move along because your posts seem intentionally aimed to rile up rather than to be helpful, which I what I thought these mumsnet threads were for. I can absolutely say that to you, and you have every right to ignore me and continue to be unhelpful.

You think I’m changing my user name posting to myself and then back again and so on? 🤔 I call rile up tatic

OP posts:
TheOccupier · 04/03/2022 17:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Sceptre86 · 04/03/2022 16:54

Yanbu in my opinion op but your sister definitely is. I wouldn't knowingly go to someone else's home after being in close contact with someone who is covid positive, especially if that family had a baby.

We caught covid at the end of January, a family friend had come to see our baby but failed to mention she had been to a party the week before where someone tested positive. She tested positive the day after coming to ours but again neglected to mention that she had symptoms since the party. I tested positive 6 days after she had been to mine, I felt a little rough but was mostly OK. My dh was ill for a week and a half as was my baby. My at the time 4 month old baby had a horrendous cough, couldn't keep her feeds down and was close to being hospitalised. My 5 and 4 year old were asymptomatic. It was a stressful time that could have been avoided had she employed some common sense. Your dd has to ho to school, there isn't a choice there, it is a necessity so you have to accept that risk. Your sister on the other hand doesn't need to see her boyfriend and since she has should be sensible enough to know she needs to avoid your family.

Feelingsicky · 04/03/2022 16:45

I would have the same issue if she’d him and he had measles or flu, etc, then cam here soon after. There’s no legal requirement there, but most people would isolate themselves from others, especially there vulnerable.

@cantbecoping re living like this forever. Probably not, but I won’t have young children forever. Also, I don’t restrict where we go out of fear or anything like that, it’s only when I know someone is positive.

OP posts:
PonyPatter44 · 04/03/2022 16:38

Can you not just ask your sister to do a LFT before she comes? If even that is too stressful, you'll just have to put up with the family drama, and ask her not to come.

All the people saying that she definitely has it if she visited her covid-positive boyfriend are getting a bit dramatic. My DP came down with it on NYE; I slept in the same bed as him before, during and after his infection, and I still tested negative all the way through. It doesn't mean your sister doesn't have covid, but just cuddling her boyfriend doesn't automatically mean she does have it, either.

Chely · 04/03/2022 16:33

OTT but it's your right to refuse visits. Will not go down well and cause a rift so good look with that.

HeckyPeck · 04/03/2022 16:22

I think when you post about Covid you'll get told your unreasonable as it is a very divisive subject on here.

If you posted that your sister had visited her boyfriend who had noro and wanted to come and visit you and your 4 month old baby I'd hope most people would agree you should say no.

Although I suppose even before Covid there were selfish arseholes who didn't care they were spreading d&v or flu etc.

Sparticuscaticus · 04/03/2022 16:17

TheOccupier as I said disengenious replies. You don't understand ableism at all and are trying to cover up what you wrote earlier

OP a thread is to ask a legitimate AIBU question about if SWBU not to invite her sister to her DDs birthday party. Perfectly appropriate for AIBU - some threads cover multiple issues and multiple topics and you as a stranger to her don’t get to now decide she should only post in Covid forum.

By all means PP should post different YABU YANBU views respectfully , but your earlier post on here was unkind ableism to tell an OP that their thread belongs in Mental Health -just because you saw she'd mentioned (as background context) she had OCD. You don't misuse information about peoples disabilities like that

TheOccupier · 04/03/2022 16:10

It's not ableism. The OP brought up her OCD at the top of the thread, and said that this is an additional challenge for her. I don't give a shit whether she posts in Mental Health, Covid, or Chat. However, if someone who starts a thread in AIBU then gets annoyed when someone tells them that actually yes they are BU, and tells that person not to respond, the OP has clearly been posted in the wrong place.

Sparticuscaticus · 04/03/2022 15:58

TheOccupier
You are being disingenuous again

It was patently obvious that I was referring to your unpleasant disability discrimination where you said OP should post in Mental Health thread instead

Awful to read such ableism and it has no place here

TheOccupier · 04/03/2022 15:47

@Sparticuscaticus

Don't post in AIBU if you don't want anyone to tell you YABU - sounds like this thread would have been better suited to the Mental Health or Covid boards.

This is a disgusting thing to say Occupier. It isn't about OPs ocd at all or a mental health issue.

No it's not. If you don't want to be told YABU, don't post in AIBU! It's not rocket science. And the Covid forum exists for a reason.
thegcatsmother · 04/03/2022 15:14

YANBU. I thought I had got away with not getting Covid. I had a positive LFT Tuesday night and a positive PCR yesterday. I am not enjoying the experience much, so I don't expect a baby would.

cantbecoping · 04/03/2022 14:47

YABVU

Are you going to live like this forever? Covid is going nowhere.

That said, up to you who comes into your house, your house, your rules.

Feelingsicky · 04/03/2022 14:27

@TheOccupier others have said ‘YABU’, not many but a couple, I have no issue with it. The differing opinions and proportion of those opinions is helpful.

Telling me I’m ridiculous and need to post on the mental health threads is not.

OP posts:
AlternativePerspective · 04/03/2022 14:26

If you have a 6yo in school it is ridiculous to make an issue of your sister's behaviour, the schools are full of covid! Greet her at the door with a lateral flow test if it makes you feel better. bullshit. We don’t know what illnesses our children come into contact with, but if you knowingly go round to someone else’s house wen they’re infected with something *I would take the same line with flu, norrovirus etc,) then you do so with consideration to the fact that you probably shouldn’t then go around to others’ houses where you know you could be infecting them.

“Walk around the park” my arse. As they don’t live together they likely had a shag and everything and she has likely caught COVID.

I would just be saying no on this occasion. If they have a problem with that then that is their problem to deal with.

If any of my family knowingly came into contact with someone who was covid positive they just wouldn’t come round to my house, because they’re not arseholes. So what if the law says you don’t have to be careful, doe people really need the government to hold their hands to tell them what to do because they have no idea how to put their own brains into action and use a bit of common sense and take personal responsibility?

StringFellow · 04/03/2022 14:25

If I was your sister I wouldn’t be spending time with someone with covid and then go visit my sister’s baby, just seems thoughtless

dreamkitchenhelp · 04/03/2022 14:20

I think you have every right to say to your sister that no you prefer she waits another week then she is more than welcome to come over.
She has done nothing wrong but she has not been concerned about your feelings.

If I had visited someone who was positive I would stay out the way of others. I would hate to be the carrier. I would also do an LTF but as other say it will probably show up negative.

Feelingsicky · 04/03/2022 14:19

@HeckyPeck thank you 😊 (I don’t mind people disagreeing with me but it is frustrating when things are assumed to be OCD related just because I have it).

@MaChienEstUnDick. Basically my mum said ‘just to let me know they’d had contact’, literally those words. Because they know what the boundary but they seem to think if they tell me then they’ve done their part and expect everything to go ahead a usual.

After that I text my sister and said if she’s had contact with bf while he’s covid positive I don’t feel comfortable with her coming to the house. She replied it was just a walk around the park. I was getting some advice from my other sister about something else who has a similar boundary as to me re covid and also has a baby, she was due to meet up with our sister and said ‘oh, she told me she was only dropping shopping at the door’. She has a reputation for half truths so I asked my mum directly ‘did she go into his house and spend time there’, my mum started with ‘they met up’, ‘he needed shopping’. I wasn’t getting a straight answer so asked again and she said yes she went in and spend a fair amount of time there and then again a couple days later. I said well in that case she isn’t coming, not to be nasty, I’d be the same with anyone.

A bit background, I often feel like the rock of the family, if any of them have a problem, they come to me. I don’t mind taking on that role but please respect this boundary.

OP posts:
Sparticuscaticus · 04/03/2022 14:15

Don't post in AIBU if you don't want anyone to tell you YABU - sounds like this thread would have been better suited to the Mental Health or Covid boards.

This is a disgusting thing to say Occupier. It isn't about OPs ocd at all or a mental health issue.

TheOccupier · 04/03/2022 14:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Swipe left for the next trending thread