Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Partner financial buffer

83 replies

Moneyfun12 · 03/03/2022 19:12

So, I’m happy to be told IABU or otherwise as genuinely not sure.

I earn good money, and my partner has an okay salary at circa 30k. We live together in a rented property. I do own a property separately but we don’t live in it due to location/we live in London for work and who can afford a shoebox even in London central. I also have other savings/investments which are circa 80k

My partner expressed concerns about 1 year ago about not having a financial buffer and as I work in finance I know how important this is.

So instead of paying their % of salary share of the rent and bills I said ‘save for your buffer first’ which we agreed would be circa 4 months salary for them (8k) and then we can do a % of salary as a bills split. Its now been a year and they have had ample time to save this buffer. However they seem a bit annoyed that I’ve suggested that we now go to a % of income bills approach and my assets/earning are a point of contention!

AIBU? Should I just continue to cover it because I can, or should they fairly and proportional to salary contribute?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Puzzledandpissedoff · 04/03/2022 14:42

They are now totally reliant on you

I wouldn't say reliant exactly - after all they must have lived somewhere else before and presumably could do so again - but it certainly sounds as if they're enjoying this cushy number and resent the idea of contributing properly

But then who wouldn't enjoy a London pad for just £500 a month, with everything thrown in and sex on tap?

Gardenista · 04/03/2022 14:36

@Moneyfun12 - your partner is financially abusing you. My ex husband did the same to me, very quickly expected to have an equal lifestyle to mine . I had spent years in higher education and working as a professional. He hadn’t.
I enabled his financial abuse of me.
I posted on mumsnet at the time and was told how it would end - as it did with a divorce, him taking some of my assets and we now have a child he doesn’t take any responsibility for - no maintenance and very little contact. Why would he need to bother? I’m so competent he knows our child is well cared for.
I think you are better off alone than in such an unequal “partnership “.
That he feel entitled to have the same opportunity to invest as you , but is earning a very mediocre wage (at London rates) should tell you all you need to - you are a meal ticket to him.

Lou98 · 04/03/2022 13:04

@HollowTalk

The thing is, you might as well have just given your partner the cash. They are now totally reliant on you. I would personally hate that.

How are they totally reliant on the OP?

They have been together 2 years, for one year of that the Partner hasn't paid any bills so that they can save up a buffer of £8k - that is theirs in their savings, if they were to split they have their buffer (if they actually saved it that is).

The OP wants them to split bills proportionately to their earnings which would mean the partner paying £750 a month - the OP has said they have take home pay of £2K a month - that is £1250 they would be left with in their pockets each month. What exactly is it you would hate?

Sassbott · 04/03/2022 12:49

But the partner isn’t reliant on the OP remotely actually. If what the OP has said has happened, he’s lived off her in order to build his own personal buffer / investment. If they break up tomorrow the OP is essentially out of pocket personally whilst he is considerably better off having lived off and pocketed the proceeds of such. Technically he’s more independent (certainly in the short term) as he now has a cash reserve built up.

What exactly does he have to hate about this situation? He’s quids in and has benefitted from the OP’s immense generosity.

HollowTalk · 03/03/2022 22:49

The thing is, you might as well have just given your partner the cash. They are now totally reliant on you. I would personally hate that.

Lou98 · 03/03/2022 22:45

I agree investments are different.

If they contribute their share of £750 a month, that still leaves them £1250 - what are they spending all of that on that they can't invest/save some?

YANBU OP. You have been together for 2 years and for one year of that they haven't been contributing anything towards bills - when did you move in together? Have they ever paid towards bills? If they've gotten used to having their full salary to keep they won't want to give that up. To be honest, id be questioning if they even saved their buffer

Kite22 · 03/03/2022 22:34

@TheRealityCheque

Man earns more than woman:

Man need to pay more to joint finances to ensure both have the same 'personal money' left other or man is financial abusive.

Woman earns more than man:

They should pay the same amount into joint finances and he should have less personal money. He's her partner, she's not financially responsible for him.

This place is so unbelievably sexist, it's unreal.
Welcome to Mumsnet, lol.

I don't agree. If people have made a commitment to spend the rest of their lives together and have dc together, then money becomes family money.

The OP says they have been together 2 years. They are not married. There are no dc. For a whole year, the partner has paid nothing. They are renting. There is no commitment. At this point, you work out if both people pay proportionately to income, or if they split 50:50 or what. It doesn't matter is it is 2 men, 2 women, 1 man and 1 woman, and who is the higher earner.

latetothefisting · 03/03/2022 22:27

@TheRealityCheque

Man earns more than woman:

Man need to pay more to joint finances to ensure both have the same 'personal money' left other or man is financial abusive.

Woman earns more than man:

They should pay the same amount into joint finances and he should have less personal money. He's her partner, she's not financially responsible for him.

This place is so unbelievably sexist, it's unreal.
Welcome to Mumsnet, lol.

Except OP isn't saying they should pay the same. She's saying they should pay the same proportionally to their wages. She will still be paying much more, as she earns more. Which on all the similar threads I've seen, has been suggested as the best solution whatever the sex of the higher earning partner.

So you're talking shit. And are also homophobic, seeing as at no point OP has said her partner is male.

OP your partner is deluded that they should be able to live for £500 contributions in London. If you were subsidising them because they were on maternity leave or studying full time fair enough. Subsidising them because they want to have more disposable income and "it isn't fair" some careers get paid more than theirs (which presumably nobody forced them into!), when you've already paid all their outgoings for a year, is ridiculous, and only a selfish twat would ask you to.

Ask them how much they'd have left over for fun/investments if you broke up and they had to go back to flatsharing with randoms/covering all bills themselves. Certainly less than £1.5k

SallyMcNally · 03/03/2022 22:25

I think the question around lifestyle is relevant as I know I've found it difficult trying to keep up with a much higher earning partner who wanted to eat out/have expensive holidays all the time which left me struggling.

Of course I was only struggling because I was trying to pay my way though...

I'd say at the stage of life you are in proportional contributions are fair- unless you are insisting on staying in a fancy z1 flat that he wouldn't be able to afford though. If he wants to save why not suggest that you increase the total amount contributed and set up a savings/investment fund together that can go towards if you do eventually buy a house/have a baby etc. I would talk to an advisor to ensure contributions are divided proportionately if you do split up though.

Bunty55 · 03/03/2022 22:24

@DogsAndGin

How the heck can someone on 25k take home, save £8k in one year?! In London, too!
Easy when you let someone else pay all the bills
Luredbyapomegranate · 03/03/2022 22:14

@Moneyfun12

They’ve now suggested to put in £500 per month, which isn’t a total proportional split and they think anymore is unfair on them due to needing the other 1.5k of their salary.

As a proportional split their contribution would be £750 but to be totally honest I could cover the £250 without issue. I just worry that I’ve set a crap precedent here for our relationship and I shouldn’t have to ask for a fair contribution 😕

You aren’t married. It should be proportional at the very least. Many people would insist on 50/50. £750 is very low for London living. I wouldn’t be making any deeper commitment to this person.
Eggs2022 · 03/03/2022 22:06

@Moneyfun12

Their view is that investing is important and they should be able to start investing too now (as I have in the past) to create a more equitable future. I do think it would be good for them to be able to invest too but I just think this is on them to find money for from disposable income. I was happy to subsidise a buffer, makes sense and no one wants to see someone they love concerned and anxious about money and feeling like they have no savings.

Investments feels like another story to me and one they need to fund.

He’s comparing what you’ve done on a much higher salary to what he can do with a lower one… not everyone has a right to have investments etc! Maybe it’s your wording but he sounds as though he’s resentful, as if you having them stopped him somehow (if he covered bills etc and now it’s his turn which obvs isn’t the case). Maybe he needs to have a bit of realism as to what he can achieve on his salary independent of what you managed with yours
Puzzledandpissedoff · 03/03/2022 22:05

Their view is that investing is important and they should be able to start investing too now (as I have in the past) to create a more equitable future

Since you've already offered a "contributions break" so they could save (have they done this?) the translation seems to be that they just want to keep most of their money for themselves
Worse still, from your timescale, it looks as if they came up with this wheeze not long after moving in

Possibly they're thinking "Well she can afford it" since you earn nearly three times as much, but for me that wouldn't be acceptable and I'd be thinking "cocklodger"

Sassbott · 03/03/2022 21:58

Do you know that he built his buffer while you essentially subsidised him?

Sorry but you do realise this is essentially you handing over your hard earned cash into his bank account right? That’s if he saved vs spent.

Acheyknees · 03/03/2022 21:50

So they want to save their money and spend yours because you earn more basically. Its a no from me
If they want to save they need to earn more. Simple.

LuaDipa · 03/03/2022 21:45

@TheRealityCheque

Man earns more than woman:

Man need to pay more to joint finances to ensure both have the same 'personal money' left other or man is financial abusive.

Woman earns more than man:

They should pay the same amount into joint finances and he should have less personal money. He's her partner, she's not financially responsible for him.

This place is so unbelievably sexist, it's unreal.
Welcome to Mumsnet, lol.

When they are married with kids, not after a short term relationship! Op has already been more than generous but £500 per month with no dependents on a £30k salary is taking the piss.
FirewomanSam · 03/03/2022 21:45

How the heck can someone on 25k take home, save £8k in one year?! In London, too!

Pretty easily if they’re not paying any rent or bills.

cuno · 03/03/2022 21:43

@Nightlystroll

If you’re married. People advise to have equal disposal income if you’re married with DC. That’s how it’s different.

Of course both should be contributing but it's according to your ability and income. I don't see what marriage has to do with it. If you're in a committed relationship that you're planning to be long term, the same applies. What is the point of a relationship if one has no money and the other has lots. How will that ever work out? And actually it's even more important outside marriage. If you divorce, you have some chance to rebalanced the situation through splitting the estate. But if you're not married, the poorer one, who has been covering 50% of the living expenses, will have no automatic claim after breaking up and will have to start again with nothing.
DC are a red herring. Surely you're looking at equality within a relationship and that's not influenced by or dependent on DC. Childless people are not less worthy or less in need of finsncial equality and security within a relationship.

That's summed up my thoughts on this too.
Nightlystroll · 03/03/2022 21:40

If you’re married. People advise to have equal disposal income if you’re married with DC. That’s how it’s different.

Of course both should be contributing but it's according to your ability and income. I don't see what marriage has to do with it. If you're in a committed relationship that you're planning to be long term, the same applies. What is the point of a relationship if one has no money and the other has lots. How will that ever work out? And actually it's even more important outside marriage. If you divorce, you have some chance to rebalanced the situation through splitting the estate. But if you're not married, the poorer one, who has been covering 50% of the living expenses, will have no automatic claim after breaking up and will have to start again with nothing.
DC are a red herring. Surely you're looking at equality within a relationship and that's not influenced by or dependent on DC. Childless people are not less worthy or less in need of finsncial equality and security within a relationship.

Ifeelgoodgoodgood · 03/03/2022 21:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

MayMorris · 03/03/2022 21:36

@Moneyfun12

They’ve now suggested to put in £500 per month, which isn’t a total proportional split and they think anymore is unfair on them due to needing the other 1.5k of their salary.

As a proportional split their contribution would be £750 but to be totally honest I could cover the £250 without issue. I just worry that I’ve set a crap precedent here for our relationship and I shouldn’t have to ask for a fair contribution 😕

Nope proportional. Don’t set precedents. You’re not married to give you legal backup if he walks off after you’ve effectively “saved” for him. That’s what you’re doing…giving him £250 a month to go into his saving pots.
nomoneytree · 03/03/2022 21:35

Where did they live before they moved in with you. Did they used to earn more. I couldn't be with someone that saw my salary as their way of achieving a financial buffer.

cuno · 03/03/2022 21:35

@ErickBroch
50:50 isn't proportional to income though. I would say more like 35:65 in their instance. However I don't think the OP should have given him a free year either! It started the whole thing on unusual footing.

ErickBroch · 03/03/2022 21:30

@cuno yes that's exactly my point? He should pay in proportionately?

@PearPickingPorky I am glad that works for you but it's not for everyone and OP doesn't need to make that decision if she doesn't want to. I earn less than my DP and we pay things as a proportion and it works fine. We are going to pool when we get married this year. Just works for us. My point is, just because OP isn't giving in to this person already doesn't mean she isn't a good partner. Especially when she's let them live without contributing fuck all for a year.

cuno · 03/03/2022 21:26

@ErickBroch

People saying posters are hypocrytical... er, no. Huge differences: not married & only been together two years. They shouldn't be pooling all their money at this point if they don't want to.
Well they can still contribute proportional to income without pooling money together.