Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Apparently Tuna isn’t a suitable food for a primary aged DC (Lighthearted AIBU?)

163 replies

TunaIsOk · 03/03/2022 17:21

This is from ExH after he video called DD (Aged 7, Year 3) and she told him she’d had tuna pasta for tea (her favourite).

His text to me says that he doesn’t think Tuna is the right food to be feeding a primary aged child.

I asked him if he’d looked at the school menu for lunches recently. Tuna Sandwiches and Tuna Jacket potatoes available every day, three times in the 4 week menu there’s some sort of Tuna Pasta Dish available on the hot menu, it’s very popular from what I’ve been told.

DD often opts for the tuna dish if it’s there.

No reply.

But am I being UR to give DD tuna? I know I'm not don't worry!

For context, tonights was fresh from the fish monger this morning but I do use tinned as well. There was also sweetcorn, tomatoes and peppers in it as well as a tomato sauce I make myself.

OP posts:
Cyw2018 · 03/03/2022 19:12

@incognitoforthisone

Oh, and re the mercury issue - the NHS website suggests that pregnant women only eat 'up to four cans a week' but doesn't warn of any issue with children or other adults eating it. And the NHS weaning website also has tuna recipes for small babies with no warning about how much they shouldn't eat. So I'd be inclined not to fret about that, personally.
Look up some of the guidelines on it from other countries. You'll soon realise that UK guidelines are based on the interests of the fishing lobby and not public health.
TunaIsOk · 03/03/2022 19:11

You've all got me messaging the fishmonger now to find out exactly what kind of Tuna it was.

Lesson learnt, not to post on AIBU if I don't want to be made to think I'm poisoning my child Confused

OP posts:
BadHairDayExpert · 03/03/2022 19:11

Bollocks. It is brain food.

JeffThePilot · 03/03/2022 19:09

@Shrekprincess

Anyone else having tuna for dinner just because this thread has made them fancy it so much?
I have all the ingredients in for a cracking tuna pasta bake which was going to be tomorrow’s dinner, but now… 🤔
gogohm · 03/03/2022 19:08

I would avoid the larger species of tuna due to mercury but the skipjack tuna in cans in fine a couple of days a week

Thatsplentyjack · 03/03/2022 19:03

I would honestly have just sent back this ....

🤣🤣🤣👍

PrimoPiatti · 03/03/2022 19:03

[quote PrimoPiatti]@TunaIsOk
It may be US originated advice, but there's plenty from around the world saying the same.

Mercury is mercury, there isn't any exceptional British non-toxic version of mercury.

Bottom line is, if you want to eat it then do so.

Rather you than me.[/quote]
Sorry that was supposed to be addressed to:

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz

PrimoPiatti · 03/03/2022 19:01

@Unescorted

I would avoid tuna too. Heavy metals build up in lipid cells & the body doesn't metabolise them. Animals that eat other animals are at greatest risk because the HM are taken in and stored in the animals fat cells. So as an animal gets older & larger the more mercury (and other toxic heavy metals) is stored in the animals body and the greater the concentration. Due to the increased solubility of HM in salt water the levels are higher in large fish than other animals.

Just because it is on the menu at a school does not mean it is healthy..... Turkey Twizzlers???

Spot on.
PrimoPiatti · 03/03/2022 18:59

@TunaIsOk
It may be US originated advice, but there's plenty from around the world saying the same.

Mercury is mercury, there isn't any exceptional British non-toxic version of mercury.

Bottom line is, if you want to eat it then do so.

Rather you than me.

Mariposista · 03/03/2022 18:57

Healthy oily fish full of omega 3? load of rubbish - ignore him

DysmalRadius · 03/03/2022 18:56

[quote PrimoPiatti]@DysmalRadius

FDA advice on food for children:[/quote]
Thanks for the screenshot, but do we even get bigeye tuna in the UK? I only seem to see skipjack, which is apparently one of the least problematic and possibly why the FDA advice is so different from the FSA's?

Shrekprincess · 03/03/2022 18:48

Anyone else having tuna for dinner just because this thread has made them fancy it so much?

RupertOscar1999 · 03/03/2022 18:48

My eldest daughter is 4 (starting school in September) and she loves Tuna!

Theunamedcat · 03/03/2022 18:47

My ex said the kids couldn't catch covid because they both have acid reflux......at least the tuna thing Has SOME basis in reality

harriethoyle · 03/03/2022 18:46

He's batshit and I'm glad he's an ex. I was on amazing thread recently about a lidl super deal where a gazillion tins of tuna were 2 pounds 38... would have made his tiny mind explode!

Jewel52 · 03/03/2022 18:45

@Mundra

You shouldn't have tuna more than twice a week due to the concentrations of heavy metals in the fish- this is even more important for children who are small, and thus have lower safe limits of heavy metals in the bloodstream.
May explain his concern then. I just thought he was being awkward!
MzHz · 03/03/2022 18:45

@TunaIsOk

This is from ExH after he video called DD (Aged 7, Year 3) and she told him she’d had tuna pasta for tea (her favourite).

His text to me says that he doesn’t think Tuna is the right food to be feeding a primary aged child.

I asked him if he’d looked at the school menu for lunches recently. Tuna Sandwiches and Tuna Jacket potatoes available every day, three times in the 4 week menu there’s some sort of Tuna Pasta Dish available on the hot menu, it’s very popular from what I’ve been told.

DD often opts for the tuna dish if it’s there.

No reply.

But am I being UR to give DD tuna? I know I'm not don't worry!

For context, tonights was fresh from the fish monger this morning but I do use tinned as well. There was also sweetcorn, tomatoes and peppers in it as well as a tomato sauce I make myself.

Why even dignify it with an answer.

This idiot is exactly why we have the 👍🏻

ThymePoultice · 03/03/2022 18:45

@dollymuchymuchness

Obviously, you should have given her fish fingers and chips.
Good grief. Have you actually worked out the nutritional breakdown for fish fingers and chips versus tuna pasta? There’s not much in it.
Unescorted · 03/03/2022 18:43

I would avoid tuna too. Heavy metals build up in lipid cells & the body doesn't metabolise them. Animals that eat other animals are at greatest risk because the HM are taken in and stored in the animals fat cells. So as an animal gets older & larger the more mercury (and other toxic heavy metals) is stored in the animals body and the greater the concentration. Due to the increased solubility of HM in salt water the levels are higher in large fish than other animals.

Just because it is on the menu at a school does not mean it is healthy..... Turkey Twizzlers???

dollymuchymuchness · 03/03/2022 18:39

Obviously, you should have given her fish fingers and chips.

scottishnames · 03/03/2022 18:33

I expect its' because considerable quantities of tuna are still caught using long lines, which kill - in an horrendous way - all kinds of marine life, from turtles to albatrosses. Over-fishing - with a danger of ultimate extincion - has also been a problem.

HOWEVER sustainable tuna is one of conservation's relative success stories.
So long as the tuna is from an MSC certified source, then it's OK. I think it would be perfectly reasonable to ask school dinner suppliers to confirm this - and for us to look for the relevant info on tins purchased in supermarkets.

www.msc.org/media-centre/news-opinion/news/2021/05/02/world-tuna-day-tuna-fishing-shifting-toward-sustainability

However, there is a really worrying degree of double-think going on about foods of all kinds. At school, children get to read admirable books and have lessons about saving the planet, yet are fed in school dinners (and sometimes at home) foods which rather do the opposite.

I'm not blaming anyone. This is not an easy topic. But - IMHO - there needs to be rather more joined up thinking about it.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 03/03/2022 18:30

Does he eat Tuna at all? The only people I know who don't want children given any at all are those who hate fish and the children's other parents .

My ex is one of them. It might sound strange, but he treated it like fucking heroin - if he found some in the house he'd bin it. He literally took a whole wild trout my brother had caught and given to me out of the freezer when I was shopping once and chucked it onto the verge so foxes could eat it. And then had a go at me for polluting his house with filth.

He also got on the kids' cases about how disgusting all fish was. As it's apparently not an issue during court proceedings, it was perfectly OK for him to convince two children who liked Salmon, Trout, Cod, smoked fish, Tuna, Sea Bass, prawns, scampi and every other type of seafood they were ever offered that they were allergic to it and it would make them die if it was in the house. There was also some shit about Lavender being deadly poison and that a shoulder of lamb was only fit for the bin because there was a trace of fat in it.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 03/03/2022 18:29

The FDA is American is it not? Given all the additives in American products (in comparison with their UK counterpart products), I'd take any advice on how much fish to eat with a pinch of salt.

PrimoPiatti · 03/03/2022 18:27

This is a better screenshot:

Apparently Tuna isn’t a suitable food for a primary aged DC (Lighthearted AIBU?)
PrimoPiatti · 03/03/2022 18:25

@DysmalRadius

FDA advice on food for children:

Apparently Tuna isn’t a suitable food for a primary aged DC (Lighthearted AIBU?)