Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Apparently Tuna isn’t a suitable food for a primary aged DC (Lighthearted AIBU?)

163 replies

TunaIsOk · 03/03/2022 17:21

This is from ExH after he video called DD (Aged 7, Year 3) and she told him she’d had tuna pasta for tea (her favourite).

His text to me says that he doesn’t think Tuna is the right food to be feeding a primary aged child.

I asked him if he’d looked at the school menu for lunches recently. Tuna Sandwiches and Tuna Jacket potatoes available every day, three times in the 4 week menu there’s some sort of Tuna Pasta Dish available on the hot menu, it’s very popular from what I’ve been told.

DD often opts for the tuna dish if it’s there.

No reply.

But am I being UR to give DD tuna? I know I'm not don't worry!

For context, tonights was fresh from the fish monger this morning but I do use tinned as well. There was also sweetcorn, tomatoes and peppers in it as well as a tomato sauce I make myself.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
N1no · 06/03/2022 10:10

@Mundra

You shouldn't have tuna more than twice a week due to the concentrations of heavy metals in the fish- this is even more important for children who are small, and thus have lower safe limits of heavy metals in the bloodstream.
I agree with you. It takes about a year for the mercury to leave the system after stopping. You might want to add a few different fish but be aware of salmon as it can also contain high levels of toxins (especially Norwegian farmed salmon).
NeverDropYourMooncup · 05/03/2022 22:20

@LollyLol

The NHS website says 2 portions of oily fish for girls is fine, 4 portions for a boy. The pollutants that build up are more damaging for girls than boys. A portion is about 40g, so a third of a can of tuna.

If a girl is eating 3 portions of week or more on a regular basis it would be better to switch to an pily fish lower down the food chain.

It isn't bonkers. It's science.

A portion is more than that for a child of the OP's DD's age. One portion is 55-80g for her (and nearer the middle of that range), as she isn't under 4.

Technically, a single tin doesn't contain enough for a portion for one adult and one child of her age - 140g is the amount recommended for an adult alone.

This directs to the BDA, which in turn links to this

LollyLol · 05/03/2022 17:58

The NHS website says 2 portions of oily fish for girls is fine, 4 portions for a boy. The pollutants that build up are more damaging for girls than boys. A portion is about 40g, so a third of a can of tuna.

If a girl is eating 3 portions of week or more on a regular basis it would be better to switch to an pily fish lower down the food chain.

It isn't bonkers. It's science.

SartresSoul · 05/03/2022 09:13

Absolutely bonkers! I remember my friend’s ex being like this when they first split. He once turned up to drop the DC off and asked to look in the fridge because the (then very young) children said they’d eaten beans on toast for tea every night which obviously wasn’t true. He also said she needed to go see the GP because their eldest child was too much of a fussy eater, the GP basically laughed her out of the room.

He just sounds like a bit of a controlling wanker, tuna is fine.

liveforsummer · 05/03/2022 09:09

@LollyLol the amount of tuna served on a school jacket is tiny, probably a lot a desert spoon and mixed heavily with Mayo as that's far cheaper than tuna. No need to make that the only portion.

user1471538283 · 05/03/2022 09:05

This is so odd. I've always loved tuna. As a child I regularly had it. As long as she has other foods I dont see the problem.

LollyLol · 05/03/2022 09:00

I don’t give my dd tuna more than once a week for that reason - it may not say it on the NHS, but it is true that there are heavy metals concentrated in large fish. When dd had school dinners she ate tuna jacket potato once a week so we never ate tuna at home.

We eat mackerel or salmon or trout as an alternative, although salmon or trout is expensive so that is once a fortnight. My dd doesn’t like sardines or whitebait or anchovies or pilchards, which is a shame but I keep trying to tempt her, the smell puts her off. I know she would like the flavour of sardines if she tried.

liveforsummer · 05/03/2022 08:48

YABU to waste delicious fresh tuna steak in a pasta dish though.

liveforsummer · 05/03/2022 08:41

@thinkfast

Tuna is fine for a child, but I wouldn't give it to a young child more than twice a week (due to mercury). So if my child were eating lots of tuna at school, I wouldn't be serving it at home.
You don't eat lots of tuna in a sandwich or pasta dish though. It's not the main component. The guidance is based on amounts (ie 2 tuna steaks a week) having 4 tuna sandwiches still wouldn't equal one steak
Vynalbob · 05/03/2022 07:41

Probably being a bit of a twonk tbh.
Here at the end is a link to NHS recommendations if your interested but I wouldn't worry our youngest (now 15) is tuna mad and has it 3 times a week (loves a tuna/Cheddar toastie 4 lunch)... He hasn't had mercury related problems.
www.nhs.uk/live-well/eat-well/fish-and-shellfish-nutrition/

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 05/03/2022 06:32

Wow - reading some of the articles on fish, I am shocked. I always thought fish was super healthy and I’m now WTF. Especially on swordfish.

ProfessionalChancer · 05/03/2022 06:31

@MyrtlethePurpleTurtle

“You can get at least two adult portions out of a 140g tin”

Ah, the new Mumsnet chicken

Tuna is nowhere near as good as a chicken. Tuna only feeds me, my husband and our 4 kids lunches for 2 weeks but a chicken feeds all 6 of us dinners for a month.
MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 05/03/2022 06:28

“You can get at least two adult portions out of a 140g tin”

Ah, the new Mumsnet chicken

RachaelN · 05/03/2022 06:14

He is being a dick and questioning your parenting just to wind you up. Tell him to stfu.

Mundra · 05/03/2022 01:13

Mercury, arsenic and heavy metals leave the body at very slow rates. Once they've been consumed, they stay in you, and subsequent eating of tuna increases the concentration of those contaminants in your body. It takes about six months for mercury to be processed out of us.
The FSA have released guidelines (they're linked in the article from the guardian I posted yesterday) and tuna is safe to eat, provided you limit how much you have.

HTH1 · 04/03/2022 21:55

Could there possibly be a reason why he’s an ex? Maybe if he sends you a full list of his menu items for DD (including all drinks, snacks etc), you’ll be able to feed her to his standards Wink

CowboyJo · 04/03/2022 21:44

I have never heard of tuna making people sick.

Is this the same sort of hysteria as "do not eat raw eggs"? My DDs have licked countless cake mixes Blush

whattodo2019 · 04/03/2022 21:23

Is he saying this because tuna can have high mercury contents?

NannaKaren · 04/03/2022 21:08

He’s just being a twit!

bellac11 · 04/03/2022 20:25

I dont know that its correct to say 'most people are fine' if we mean health wise? we are actuallly quite an unhealthy nation (and I say that as someone who does eat tuna)

Mandyjack · 04/03/2022 20:23

@Shrekprincess

What can eating tuna do to you? People are mentioning mercury, arsenic and heavy metals etc. so can eating tuna make you sick? Is that temporarily or long term? Can it kill you?
Some people have got very sick. A work colleague was regularly ill and her physio suggested stopping tuna and she was fine after.
Mandyjack · 04/03/2022 20:22

Wouldn't say its unsuitable but too much tuna can be harmful, especially for a child. I wouldn't give it more than once a week

LaDamaDeElche · 04/03/2022 20:12

@Shrekprincess

What can eating tuna do to you? People are mentioning mercury, arsenic and heavy metals etc. so can eating tuna make you sick? Is that temporarily or long term? Can it kill you?
I've eaten tuna regularly through my life and I'm fine. Most people are.
Shrekprincess · 04/03/2022 19:32

What can eating tuna do to you? People are mentioning mercury, arsenic and heavy metals etc. so can eating tuna make you sick? Is that temporarily or long term? Can it kill you?

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 04/03/2022 19:30

Well i'm not sure I could eat a whole tuna and I'm almost two adults (according to the bathroom scales).
Next time I would suggest you remove the head and tail (of the tuna, not your child) to make it a tad more manageable.

Swipe left for the next trending thread