Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can’t afford chiropractor

133 replies

21butterflies · 03/03/2022 10:45

Posted before, long story short am suffering from burnout and also a bad neck/shoulder due to a severely out of place first rib.

Hoping to take sick leave for 2 weeks due to both stress and my back.
Went to the chiropractor today and they showed me very bad x rays and said how often I would need treatment. The total came to £950.

I burst into tears in the middle of the office.

I feel like I’m desperate for this time off but I need good reasoning for my boss and I also feel like if I can’t get my back fixed in time then it’s pointless. I feel if I go down the GP route I’d have to wait a long time.
I can’t afford the chiropractor on normal terms; let alone if I take sick leave so now I’m even questioning that.

If I’m honest my life feels like a mess and I have no idea what direction to turn to. I’m currently in bed in tears and I’ve been taking it out on my poor DP too who even offered to help but no chance am I letting him!

What on Earth do I do ☹️

OP posts:
WutheringHeights66 · 05/03/2022 19:07

Ok, please don’t pay it. Try a registered osteopath. I’ve gone to one on and off for years for a chronic problem and 2-3 Sessions sort me out. Every osteopath I’ve had hasn’t had a good word to say about chiropractice and DD who is a radiographer says they aren’t qualified sufficiently to product X-rays worth their salt.

bringmelaughter · 05/03/2022 18:59

@SpecialSexBlanket

These threads are frustrating, because as usual it's peoples opinions on these professions, and not the reality.

Osteopaths and chiropractors do undertake medical level degrees. They train longer than the initial physio degree which is only 3 years. An osteo does 5. They are allowed, to diagnose all sorts of health issues, as well as MSK. They can also refer people for scans.

Both professions are seriously regulated and accredited. Osteopathy is also an allied health professional, recognised and employed in the NHS, at a higher band in the NHS than a physio (unless a specialist like respiratory or pediatric).

As far as the OPs concerned, in their position I'd seek a second opinion from an osteopath. They'll use a combination of techniques which may include soft tissue work, articulations, METs and possibly manipulation.

For cheaper sessions, depending on your location, OP may wish to consider visiting a teaching clinic. Here, students who have passed certain exams and logged a certain amount of hours will consult, assess and suggest a diagnosis. They'll perform some of the soft tissue work, but only the qualified osteo will do any HVTs/manipulation. Everything is overseen and approved by them. I know of 2 clinics that are offering free treatments for new patients.

Should OP wish to try NHS physio, it'll be a long wait. Paying privately won't be much difference to paying a private osteo. Don't sign up to any plans, even with a physio. No one can tell you how many you'll need in advance. It should be based purely on how each treatment goes and your reaction to it.

Just to correct: Osteopathy degrees are 4 years full time not 5.

Newly qualified osteopaths tend to start in the NHS at a band 5. This is the same as a newly qualified physio.

There isn’t always a long wait for physio. Many areas allow self referral and many GP surgeries now have in house physios.

OnOldOlympus · 05/03/2022 18:26

Osteopaths and chiropractors do undertake medical level degrees.

Are you actually joking? That’s hilarious 😂

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 05/03/2022 18:19

I AM a student osteopath, coming to the end of my degree, so I'm pretty sure I know what I'm talking about

Ah yes, you've been taught the lies to tell to con people out of their money.

SpecialSexBlanket · 05/03/2022 17:37

Like your whole post is based on your misinformed opinions. These people do NOT do a medical degree, cannot diagnose conditions, and do not practice evidence-based medicine. They are charlatans
I AM a student osteopath, coming to the end of my degree, so I'm pretty sure I know what I'm talking about.
You, on the other hand, don't have a clue, and are exactly what I was referring to.

ThinWomansBrain · 05/03/2022 15:35

I have a brilliant chiropractor - been using him for about 30 years, probably see him about once every 3 years or so for different issues.
In lockdown, took up an offer from a chain that I'd once used for massage, v.v.cheap offer. The whole thing was about upselling further appointments - they reccomended a course of 12 appointments at one stage.
As soon as my regular chiropractor was working again, one appointment and I was fine.
If you're going to go private, shop around & ask for local reccomendations.

bringmelaughter · 05/03/2022 15:23

Any clinician or practitioner who shows you had X-rays and then gives you an expensive invoice to ‘fix it’ should be avoided.

X-rays and other imaging are helpful to rule out or diagnose certain conditions but don’t always relate to problems. Most adults will have ‘damage’ but this doesn’t mean it’ll be causing a problem.

A ‘displaced first rib’ also sounds an odd diagnosis. Was this from the chiropractor or a medical diagnosis?

In most areas you can self refer to nhs physio and this would be a good start. If you’re needing 2 weeks sick leave you will need to contact a GP anyway so you may as well get assessed there.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 05/03/2022 14:34

These threads are frustrating, because as usual it's peoples opinions on these professions, and not the reality.

Like your whole post is based on your misinformed opinions. These people do NOT do a medical degree, cannot diagnose conditions, and do not practice evidence-based medicine. They are charlatans.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 05/03/2022 14:32

Chriopractic is pure quackery. Please don't give these conmen any money.

Elsiebear90 · 05/03/2022 14:27

Don’t see a chiropractor, they’re money making businesses, they’re not licensed healthcare professionals and the evidence for it is very sketchy, it’s mostly pseudoscience and placebo. See a physiotherapist.

gannett · 05/03/2022 13:56

Chiro is complete woo. Paying through the nose for an indeterminate number of sessions is part of the scam. There's no scientific basis to any of the "adjustments" they do.

Just go to a physio. NHS ones are perfectly fine if you can wait, but the expense of a private one is worth it if you can't.

DP investigated chiro when he had a bad back recently and there were red flags all over the initial session, not least when the guy told him it was important not to think too hard about how it worked but that it was very necessary to commit to multiple indefinite sessions Hmm There was also no mention of any strengthening exercises he could do at home.

He booked a physio appointment the next day. A brisk, no-nonsense young woman with big "hockey captain at school" vibes diagnosed what was wrong in about 30 minutes, gave him a set of tedious and difficult stretches and exercises, wagged her finger and told him not to shirk them. And when the problem entirely disappeared in less than a fortnight she said "well, you won't be needing me any more!" and cancelled their upcoming sessions. He can still do the set of exercises she prescribed and his back's been perfect ever since.

Polyanthus2 · 05/03/2022 12:56

Get your Xrays - post a pic on MN of the rib - somebody is bound to be able to read it

INB4 · 05/03/2022 11:00

Don't bother: it's a pseudoscience.

ChrissyPlummer · 05/03/2022 10:55

Indeed @sashh. My MIL got more when she was recovering from breast cancer, she lives in Wales and so a very different health system. I have spent ££££ on trying to get my shoulder in a good place.

It restricts me from doing certain jobs; I can’t do retail as I can’t lift boxes/heavy items. I work on the railway but can’t do certain roles as the ramps that they use on the train are too heavy for me. I can do things as a one-off and when my shoulder was OK I worked in retail for the Christmas period. I do martial arts (non-contact) but that can cause me grief as well.

LakieLady · 05/03/2022 08:34

@MissMaple82

No, don't run for a mile. I have suffered back pain since early 00's and chiropractic treatment is the only thing that worked for me. I had a few, my suggestion is go with a man, I know it sounds sexist, but the women I went to just didn't have the strength. Pay per session amd see how you get on
My chiropractor is nothing short of a miracle worker imo, so good that I haven't had to see her for 2 years! Not only is she a woman, she is tiny: about 5'3" and very slender, but she does amazing stuff.

She also works quite holistically. She can tell when I'm stressed or anxious, when I've been sitting at a desk too long and she suggested that I might have an under-active thyroid long before my GP thought of it (and she was right).

And it was my GP who recommended I give chiropractic a try and it's been worth every penny I've spent on it.

Unpopular37 · 05/03/2022 08:24

@CharlotteRose90

If you can’t get it on the nhs then I would do whatever it takes. Borrow money off someone or take a loan etc, the longer you stay like this the worse you’ll be.
You are advising someone to go unto debt over something that is available freely elsewhere? Potentially v harmful on so many levels. Jeez. And OP, please don't even think about going into debt over this. I understand that constant pain and discomfort is wearing and depressing, but go back to your GP and ask for a referral to a physio - or you may be able to self refer through the Patient Access app. Check out Dept Heath website. Good into available
SpecialSexBlanket · 05/03/2022 08:15

These threads are frustrating, because as usual it's peoples opinions on these professions, and not the reality.

Osteopaths and chiropractors do undertake medical level degrees. They train longer than the initial physio degree which is only 3 years. An osteo does 5. They are allowed, to diagnose all sorts of health issues, as well as MSK. They can also refer people for scans.

Both professions are seriously regulated and accredited. Osteopathy is also an allied health professional, recognised and employed in the NHS, at a higher band in the NHS than a physio (unless a specialist like respiratory or pediatric).

As far as the OPs concerned, in their position I'd seek a second opinion from an osteopath. They'll use a combination of techniques which may include soft tissue work, articulations, METs and possibly manipulation.

For cheaper sessions, depending on your location, OP may wish to consider visiting a teaching clinic. Here, students who have passed certain exams and logged a certain amount of hours will consult, assess and suggest a diagnosis. They'll perform some of the soft tissue work, but only the qualified osteo will do any HVTs/manipulation. Everything is overseen and approved by them. I know of 2 clinics that are offering free treatments for new patients.

Should OP wish to try NHS physio, it'll be a long wait. Paying privately won't be much difference to paying a private osteo. Don't sign up to any plans, even with a physio. No one can tell you how many you'll need in advance. It should be based purely on how each treatment goes and your reaction to it.

CatNeedsFed · 05/03/2022 08:14

I'd definitely see GP first and try and access NHS physio. If NHS physio is going to involve a long waiting list, look into a good private physio - IME they try and pack a lot into each session because they know you are paying for it.

I went to see a (recommended) osteopath because I was having a shoulder problem. The session itself seemed fine and they didn't try and lock me into any further treatment but they were pretty non- committal about what was going on.

As it then got worse, I went to the GP. They referred me on to NHS physio who straight away saw it was a frozen shoulder (I now know I was a prime candidate due to age and sex) and explained what the progress of it would be (gets worse before it gets better over a long period).

I got to see the NHS physio regularly while it ran it's course.

Still confused as to why the osteopath didn't spot it though.

nomistake · 05/03/2022 07:51

Speak to your GP first, surely? Are you just assuming it will take ages to be referred? You might be surprised.

If it does take a long time then I would suggest getting a second opinion, that cost seems way to high. And maybe see an osteo instead.

Secretname123 · 05/03/2022 07:48

Argh! Not doing well for my first time on mumsnet. Was trying to correct typo!

cultkid · 05/03/2022 07:48

Get a second opinion

Secretname123 · 05/03/2022 07:47

tempory

Secretname123 · 05/03/2022 07:46

I don’t think the OP has been told she has a dislocated rib. I suspect she has been told it is thoracic outlet syndrome. If this is caused by posture and muscle tension it is usually tempo et so don’t be scared by talk of surgery to fix it.
www.physio-pedia.com/Thoracic_Outlet_Syndrome_(TOS)

TravelDreamLife · 05/03/2022 07:46

A chiro marginally helped my chronic neck/shoulder problem but didn't cure it. Charged me for x-rays, scared me then planned 2 x visits a week for 8 weeks then said 'maintenance' was 1 x week or I'd be symptomatic & all sorts of scary things.

Found a physio who actually knew what they were doing (first one was green & had no idea). It is muscular strength issues, NOT skeletal. I'm 80% better, and improving after a couple of weekly and now 1 x fortnightly visits & with exercises & physio suggesting 3/4 weekly so see how I go. Cheaper, too.

Difference is a physio's goal is to improve you enough you don't need them anymore. Chiro's is to keep you coming.

Polyanthus2 · 05/03/2022 07:31

Take your xrays to your GP.
Webpage about dislocated rib - no mention of long term chiro treatment to fix it.
dislocatedrib.org/