Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed by DH scoffing birthday chocolates?

193 replies

user1499609760 · 03/03/2022 09:33

It was my birthday earlier this week and as part of my gifts DH gave me a box of nice chocolates.

I opened them yesterday to have one with our post-lunch coffee (both WFH) and offered him one. He then asked for another, and another, while I only had one, trying to savour them. Then after dinner, he asked for more! I said one each and he got annoyed, saying it was offensive that I wouldn’t share with him. AIBU unreasonable to not want to share my birthday chocolates like this? I would always offer him one of anything I’m eating but he then takes more and more, so inevitably I end up with about one-third of the treats. Since he specifically bought them for me for my birthday, I think I should be able to say no. Or am I being massively petty?

(Mostly lighthearted, as I realise this is a microscopic problem in the wider context! Smile)

OP posts:
Comefromaway · 03/03/2022 14:43

When you don;t have much spare money then expensive chocolates are a luxure and yes, I do make them last.

My absolute favourite Fortnum & Mason biscuits I made last for a year. My Laderach & Venchi chocolates I make last 6 months.

AnybodyAnywhere · 03/03/2022 14:42

[quote KitKattaktik]@AnybodyAnywhere blimey are you married to a bear?[/quote]
@KitKattaktik

Pretty much sums him up…although bears are more cuddly 😂😂

There’s never a dull moment and although my friends and I often have a laugh at his expense he takes it all in good part.
He just loves food, especially things that aren’t good for him!….but he’s still slim 😒🤷🏻‍♀️

Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 03/03/2022 14:42

People seem to be confused about the meaning of the word 'share' - it means to partake in an equitable portion - not gob down the lot while your friend/partner is still eating their first. That's not sharing, its gobbling, and I think its ugly.

TravellingFrom · 03/03/2022 14:41

@Hugsgalore

My god the responses here are making me laugh! It's a box of fucking chocolates!! Get over yourself. And also one chocolate at a time ffs! Are you trying to make them last until your next birthday Confused
Everyone is different thoough.

My FIL used to eat one chocolate organge at the time and one "orange' would last months. His present, his choice.
DH is more likely to eat it whithin a day or so and looks at his dad Hmm. Again his present, his chpice.

why the need to be judgemental about how someone is eating their chocs??

betwixtlives · 03/03/2022 14:38

@Hugsgalore

My god the responses here are making me laugh! It's a box of fucking chocolates!! Get over yourself. And also one chocolate at a time ffs! Are you trying to make them last until your next birthday Confused
yeh this! i find it so cringe when mumsnetters describe ‘savouring’ their ‘very rich’ ‘luxury’ treats. Ugh I’ve just made myself shudder
phoenixrosehere · 03/03/2022 14:37

More likely that they're like OP and take part in competitive under-eating and only let him have one square of dairy milk every 7th Sunday.

Or people know themselves and know that they struggle with certain foods in their home knowing they would overeat?

Why is that a bad thing? Why is that something to be mocked for? If it was someone who limited alcohol, would you say the same or is food “different”?

Whatever the case, it is OP’s gift, her property, and her DH is being worse than a toddler for sulking over something he could likely go out and buy himself but rather eat OP’s.

Hugsgalore · 03/03/2022 14:35

My god the responses here are making me laugh! It's a box of fucking chocolates!! Get over yourself. And also one chocolate at a time ffs! Are you trying to make them last until your next birthday Confused

rainbowmash · 03/03/2022 14:31

@Moonface88

Going well and truly against the grain, but this wouldn't bother me whatsoever! Food isn't to be rationed out or savoured, everything gets scoffed in my house 😂 even if it's a present
"Tee hee, I'm so low-maintenance! Pick me! Pick me!"
girlmom21 · 03/03/2022 14:29

I wonder if mumsnet was around when he was a child and his parents were some of those who never said no to their son.

More likely that they're like OP and take part in competitive under-eating and only let him have one square of dairy milk every 7th Sunday.

phoenixrosehere · 03/03/2022 14:28

*Were they your only gift? If they were, fine, I get it.

If they're a little 'extra' then let's be honest, they were bought to be shared.

I'd be a bit confused if DP put the chocolates we were sharing away because he wanted to 'savour' or 'moderate'*

That’s completely irrelevant since they were a gift to OP and since it is her gift she has every right to do as she sees fit with it and that includes limiting how much she wants to give someone. Her DH could have bought a box for himself if he wanted to choose how many and often he liked.

Food gifts can be a treat/luxury for some because they wouldn’t often buy it for themselves for xyz.

I’d be confused why anyone thinks it’s nice or ok to buy a gift for someone you plan to use up more than the actual receiver. It’s not really a gift then.

girlmom21 · 03/03/2022 14:27

@CityHigh it makes a difference because as I said earlier he probably bought them as an 'extra'... for them to share...

Nobody rations boxes of chocolates like that unless they're really expensive.
Really expensive chocolates tend to either be shit or too rich to binge on.

Moonface88 · 03/03/2022 14:23

Going well and truly against the grain, but this wouldn't bother me whatsoever! Food isn't to be rationed out or savoured, everything gets scoffed in my house 😂 even if it's a present

Brefugee · 03/03/2022 14:22

Wtf, I don't know a single person in real life who would think someone wanting more than one chocolate is a repulsive pig.

don't be daft. He bought her a birthday present of a box of chocolates. She doesn't have to share them with anyone, but she has been sharing them, one for one so far, with him. But he has overstepped by a) asking for more and b) sulking at hearing a no.

I wonder if mumsnet was around when he was a child and his parents were some of those who never said no to their son. And this is where these idiots come from: they are badly brought up.
People should be asking their new boyfriends what their mum's (or dad's) mumsnet name is so they can check stuff like this.

CityHigh · 03/03/2022 14:19

[quote girlmom21]@CityHigh yeah but you're not talking about chocolates her husband bought for her, are you?

I didn't say I'd be confused if he wanted to save them for later. I'd find it a bit strange if I was only allowed 2 because he was 'savouring' them or because he thinks you have to moderate chocolate on your birthday. [/quote]
Why does it make a difference if he bought them? Him buying them doesn’t mean he can just eat her gift? If he thinks that then he clearly bought them for himself and not her.

Savouring them means to save them for later? It’s OPs birthday chocolate if she doesn’t want to eat them all in her birthday, presumably to stop her husband who thinks they’re ‘sharing’ her gift, then she should be able to do that.

Notjustanymum · 03/03/2022 14:18

I don’t eat chocolates unless they are really expensive (it’s a diet trick that I’ve mastered to avoid buying them unthinkingly) so if someone gives me a box of milk tray, the rest of the family know they can help themselves to as many as they like.
Woe betide anyone helping themselves to any gift that came from Charbonel & Walker though! I can make a box of truffles last for weeks as I treat the as a pure luxury.
So if OP’s chocolates were “her luxury”, she shouldn’t be sharing them with the person who bought them FOR HER, knowing that was the case (although it is nice to share - if someone other than DH gifted them only!)

Eggs2022 · 03/03/2022 14:17

@Ohsugarhoneyicetea

I wonder how the dick panderers on here would feel if another woman treated them like this. Would you be perfectly understanding if you opened the birthday chocolates your girlfriend gave you and offered her one and took one yourself, she then helped herself to 3 more, and later on demanded more and sulked when you said you wanted to keep them for later. Would that be all fine for your friend to behave like that? I find it very unattractive.
I dunno why it’s coming down to being a ‘dick panderer’ or a man v woman thing, where you won’t say no to a man… I got my husband his favourite chocolates for Valentine’s Day, a week later my sister was over and we watched a film and ended up eating most of his chocolates - he came home and sent the rest of them home with my sister cos he knows they’re her favourite too. Under no circumstances did any of us think it was a massive deal. They were expensive, they weren’t replaced and my DH thought no more of it cos he knows they’re JUST CHOCOLATES and was glad we had a nice evening. That’s why I have no problem sharing anything with him, we just don’t see it as a big deal
Deadringer · 03/03/2022 14:17

I thinking eking them out one at a time is a bit weird, we would have 2 or 3 minimum at a time, but no way should dh be having more than you, it's your present.

girlmom21 · 03/03/2022 14:14

@CityHigh yeah but you're not talking about chocolates her husband bought for her, are you?

I didn't say I'd be confused if he wanted to save them for later. I'd find it a bit strange if I was only allowed 2 because he was 'savouring' them or because he thinks you have to moderate chocolate on your birthday.

CityHigh · 03/03/2022 14:11

@girlmom21

Were they your only gift? If they were, fine, I get it.

If they're a little 'extra' then let's be honest, they were bought to be shared.

I'd be a bit confused if DP put the chocolates we were sharing away because he wanted to 'savour' or 'moderate' Confused

You’d be confused if your partner put their birthday chocolates away because they didn’t want them to be eaten in one go? Really?

I’ve just bought my friend an expensive box of her favourite chocolates. I’ve also bought her a necklace (it’s a big birthday). If she wants to share them with her DP then that’s absolutely fine as it’s her gift and her decision, but my intention when I bought them was absolutely not for her to share them as an ‘extra’. If she told me he was eating them as she was trying to put them away I’d be annoyed, because I didn’t buy them for him.

diddl · 03/03/2022 13:52

"DH would polish the box off if I didn't hide it - even though there is loads of other chocolate (that I don't eat) in the house"

What is that all about I wonder?

jackstini · 03/03/2022 13:32

YANBU

I only like dark chocolate and usually ask for a small box of a specific brand I love

I only eat one every couple of days as a special treat as they are expensive and very rich

DH would polish the box off if I didn't hide it - even though there is loads of other chocolate (that I don't eat) in the house

Generally up for sharing everything - but if it's one box of 10 or so very indulgent chocolates given as a gift, they're mine!

SartresSoul · 03/03/2022 13:32

Obviously bought them for himself.

KitKattaktik · 03/03/2022 13:30

@AnybodyAnywhere blimey are you married to a bear?

lockdownhasbrokenme · 03/03/2022 13:25

@hamsterchump
It is up to the person who receives the gift to decide how much they want to share or not.
Rather than saying mumsnetters are controlling you could say that many on Mumsnet live on a budget and can't afford to have their husband eat as he pleases, what might cost £2 for 2 bags of biscuits for pack lunches for 2 children lasting a week soon becomes much more once you've had to re buy those 2 bags and then more add to that if the same happens with crisps, cheese strings etc plus add in travel costs, finding the extra time and current food production issues all because a grown man can't use self control. Or are we expected to just magic up the extra money from thin air.

To be annoyed by DH scoffing birthday chocolates?
girlmom21 · 03/03/2022 13:22

Were they your only gift? If they were, fine, I get it.

If they're a little 'extra' then let's be honest, they were bought to be shared.

I'd be a bit confused if DP put the chocolates we were sharing away because he wanted to 'savour' or 'moderate' Confused