Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU: handsoap?

111 replies

Dottdoo · 03/03/2022 02:24

What's the view?

Is it unreasonable to switch to a bar of soap instead of pump dispensing handwash in bathrooms and kitchen? I made the switch in our ensuite and it's lasted yonks. Plus no plastic to throw away and storing bars of soap is easier. I'm converted.

But I can't help thinking would guests be thinking 'ewww no hand-wash in the bathroom only a bar of soap, this is disgusting?'

Plus is a bar of soap as hygienic for washing hands in the kitchen?

YABU - ewwww gross, save the planet but do it with clean hands at least and without weirding out visitors
YANBU - it's soap - does the same job, do it! I might do it now too! Or/ I already do this.

OP posts:
BobLep0nge · 03/03/2022 14:46

I don't want to use something that's been used to clean someone's arsehole to clean my own hands

Why would you even think of this? I've never heard of nor ever have rubbed a bar of soap on my arsehole.

MorningStarling · 03/03/2022 14:37

Liquid soap is more hygienic and and creates less waste overall provided you're using it properly. The good thing is that it doesn't come wrapped in cellophane or whatever they use to wrap soap bars in, that's terrible for the planet.

I am not averse to using soap bars in my own home but dislike using them in someone else's house or, even worse, in a public toilet (uncommon but happens at smaller touristy places). The trouble is, you don't know where the soap has been. There are people who use the same bar of soap for washing hands as they do for cleaning themselves when they've had a bath. I don't want to use something that's been used to clean someone's arsehole to clean my own hands.

PS am I the only one for whom the term "soapbar" immediately conjures up the old GLC song?

Burned a new hole in my tracksuit today,
Smoking soap bar without an ashtray,
Red-hot nylon dripping on my skin,
I ripped the fucker off, and threw it in the bin,
Soap bar's cheap, and so's my clothes,
They've gotta be cause of all the fucking holes,
It tastes like shit and it makes you cough,
And it's the fucking rubber in it that gets you off.

Blossom64265 · 03/03/2022 14:28

I always hated bar soap just because the perfect soap dish does not exist.

Liquid soap really shouldn’t be generating much waste. We buy a large bottle of concentrated soap and just refill the containers at each sink over and over. I suspect the one large bottle I buy a year adds up to about the wrappers on all the bars of soap we would buy.

StellaEllaIsabella · 03/03/2022 14:23

We have both. The liquid soap was bought about three years ago, and is still almost full, so I guess most people we know prefer bar soap.

My mother also has both, but in her case the bar soap lasts much longer than the liquid. It's possible I'm the only person using Mum's bar soap.

I have a refillable JosephJoseph liquid soap dispenser in the kitchen- the type that you press with the back of your hand, and it dispenses into your palm. I love it as it seems very hygenic.

UniversalTruth · 03/03/2022 14:19

@Blossomtoes and @snippysocks

The pp is correct is saying soap washes the germs off, it doesn't kill them necessarily. However, if you use the soap correctly, you'll wash off any new bacteria transferred from your bar soap.

I use liquid soap as my children are bad at using bar soap properly.

blobby10 · 03/03/2022 14:01

Give me a bar of soap over pretty handwash any day - my hands never feel properly clean after washing with liquid soap however hard or long I wash them for!

Sunshineandflipflops · 03/03/2022 13:59

Well I went to a friend's house the other day, used their bathroom, noticed they had bar soap, though "good for you, I might switch too", washed my hands and thought nothing more of it!

deadlanguage · 03/03/2022 13:50

@WeirdlyKind it doesn’t matter to me but I thought it might matter to the kind of people that think bar soap is dirty Grin

Rosehugger · 03/03/2022 13:35

I remember Imperial Leather making my skin so dry it would squeak. There are bars with moisturiser in now though.

GalaPie · 03/03/2022 13:32

For those who are anti-bar soap because it either dries out in the guest room or goes all squidgy, buy a good antibac soap such as Dettol and cut a bar into three or six smaller soaps. That way chucking them out when they offend you doesn't seem that wasteful.

PinkForgetMeNot · 03/03/2022 13:21

I use bar soap for all the reasons mentioned but leave handwash out for a regular visitor who doesn't think bar soap is hygienic. Although she would have grown up with it in the 70s

EatSleepRantRepeat · 03/03/2022 13:18

Handwashing technique is far more important than the type of soap used - that's why they have handwashing instructions on the wall in hospitals and the instructional adverts broadcast early on in the covid pandemic.

Bar soap is far cheaper per wash as well - bar soap and shampoo bars last for months.

nopuppiesallowed · 03/03/2022 13:15

@NarcissasMumintheDoghouse

Soap gets rid of stuff, it doesn't kill germs. A bar of soap can retain live bacteria.
If bar soap retained live bacteria, I'd have spent my entire life up until aged 50ish suffering from an upset stomach! Guess what? I didn't. Another vote for common sense bar soap versus anti environmental liquid soap. And Baylis and Harding soap seems to be made in China....
stripeyflowers · 03/03/2022 13:14

How well I remember the exclamations in recent times gone by of horrified and disgusted mumsnetters at the thought of using a nasty, unhygienic bar of soap instead of handwash. Gin

DespairingHomeowner · 03/03/2022 13:06

@NewYearCalavicci

I use bar soap in the bathroom both for hand and hair washing . I was given a huge container of liquid soap which I use in the kitchen but once that is gone ( in about 3 yrs ! ) I will go back to bars of soap there too .

The only thing I dont like about bars is what to do with all the bits once they are too small to grip easily , I was going to buy a sponge and cut a hole in it and shove the soap in but that seems to defeat the object of using less plastic ! plus how do you rinse it after using it without wasting the soap ( I use a flannel )

@NewYearCalavicci

Mash the bars together & wrap your flannel round, lather up & scrub away

Tbh I have a (plastic) loofah, they last years for me, so I mash the bits into that to lather up. I think for our individual use, switching to soap (or dove bars and the like) is a really good way to use less plastic. I’ve been on holiday with a friend who uses an entire 200ml of shower gel in a week (!). The plastic loofahs or a sponge/flannel are so much more economical on soap & shower gel

eddiemairswife · 03/03/2022 13:03

Surely the soap only turns to sludge if you leave it in the sink in the water. Most sinks have an indentation by the tap which is meant for soap.

VelvetChairGirl · 03/03/2022 13:02

Liquid soap is crap and dries your skin out anyway, bars are better, the only place that shouldnt have bars is public toilets because eeewwwww.

MumThatsNotFair · 03/03/2022 13:01

We use bar soap, mostly due to liquid soap drying our hands out. I put a pump bottle out for guests though, so they can choose.

I know what you mean about some people not liking bars in others' houses.

Fairislefandango · 03/03/2022 13:00

Bar soap is ‘eww’?
I think I have now seen the height of MN hygiene-freak lunacy.

^This. I use bar soap. Better for the environment, better for your skin, and cleans just as well as liquid soap. Some people seem to just invent random, paranoid stuff about hygiene. It's ridiculous.

TheTurn0fTheScrew · 03/03/2022 12:38

we use bars of soap, but if I am expecting guests then I whip out the glass bottle of liquid handsoap in case they find the bar off putting. Once guests are gone, I hide the bottle again so my DC are forced to use the bar.

Nsky · 03/03/2022 12:38

Use bio d liquid hand soap, bought a 5 ltr while ago, lasts ages, never buy bar soap

EatSleepRantRepeat · 03/03/2022 12:37

@NewYearCalavicci

I use bar soap in the bathroom both for hand and hair washing . I was given a huge container of liquid soap which I use in the kitchen but once that is gone ( in about 3 yrs ! ) I will go back to bars of soap there too .

The only thing I dont like about bars is what to do with all the bits once they are too small to grip easily , I was going to buy a sponge and cut a hole in it and shove the soap in but that seems to defeat the object of using less plastic ! plus how do you rinse it after using it without wasting the soap ( I use a flannel )

Collect all the bits and squish them together in a small dish, eg a ramekin. It forms another bar of soap.
EatSleepRantRepeat · 03/03/2022 12:35

I use bar soap in the shower, bar soap in the bathroom for us and liquid soap for the kitchen or when guests come. I prefer using liquid soap after handling raw meat, it's easier to clean places like under the fingernails and rings, but it's in a reusable glass bottle that gets refilled by the milkman. I don't mind the odd bit of beard hair or whatever in the bathroom soap, but I'd prefer guests to have a clean glass bottle to use.

Dogmum40 · 03/03/2022 12:35

I have bar soap in our en-suite and main bathroom, liquid soap in the downstairs loo (guests use that toilet) and liquid antibacterial in the kitchen ( both liquids are refills, so you still get packaging unfortunately but not as much)

NewYearCalavicci · 03/03/2022 12:30

I use bar soap in the bathroom both for hand and hair washing .
I was given a huge container of liquid soap which I use in the kitchen but once that is gone ( in about 3 yrs ! ) I will go back to bars of soap there too .

The only thing I dont like about bars is what to do with all the bits once they are too small to grip easily , I was going to buy a sponge and cut a hole in it and shove the soap in but that seems to defeat the object of using less plastic ! plus how do you rinse it after using it without wasting the soap ( I use a flannel )