Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Exceptions for Ukraine refugees

410 replies

myear · 03/03/2022 00:24

I would genuinely be happy if someone can explain to me how IABU so I can feel less upset!

I am pleased for the Ukrainians that the EU is making exceptions for them so that anyone can come in, can get jobs straight away, no need for a visa for 3 years etc, but AIBU to feel bitter about my own treatment as an asylum seeker many many years ago? I can’t help but wonder why these exceptions are made for people fleeing the Ukraine, but not for people who fled my country to survive ethnic cleansing and what the UN found was war crimes against my people.

We had to lie to get a visa to Europe, lie to then get into the country when we were taken away for questioning at the border, apply for asylum 6 times as it kept being rejected, and only got approved on the basis that we had stayed too long to be kicked out, couldn’t work for a long time, and no exceptions were made to reduce bureaucratic hurdles. To be blunt, I question whether exceptions are being made for the Ukrainian refugees because they are white and people from my country are black.

My white DH, who is from the European country that took me in, is upset that the UK is not waiving visa requirements for Ukrainians and only allowing those with family in, rather than anyone seeking refuge. But, he doesn’t really see a problem with how I was treated by his country either, for reasons such as:

  1. We fled a civil war whereas Ukraine is being attacked by another country. Countries need to deal with their own problems (but incidentally thinks it was right to intervene in NI / ROI - again white).
  1. It’s not his country’s duty to help my country as they didn’t cause the war (but neither did his country cause the Ukraine war yet they are making exceptions for them).
  1. Ukraine is geographically closer, although not a direct neighbour (so?)
  1. Why am I not upset at the people who caused war in my country (but how is that relevant to the differing treatment I’m now seeing?)
  1. Why am I not upset at neighbouring countries, they didn’t help either (again, how is that relevant?)
  1. No exceptions were made for Kosovo, Bosnia etc so the Ukraine exceptions are not based on race (can't argue against that!)

I am very grateful that we were able to find safety in Europe and have a great life, but this seems to be upsetting me more than I can rationally explain.

OP posts:
Kendodd · 03/03/2022 20:41

And in any case, some of the countries that refugees come from are closer to the UK than Ukraine.

Also, we, the UK are making a massive great fuss about taking in Ukrainians and erecting as many barriers as possible (as always) its Ukraines neighbours who are taking them in.

Kendodd · 03/03/2022 20:37

Why2why
Thinking about it in a wider context it seems quite accurate, in that, almost all the worlds refugees are accommodated by their neighbours. I believe we actually take very few in Europe and even less in the UK (but scream and shout lies about how generous we are inbetween cries of 'they're not coming here')

Why2why · 03/03/2022 20:29

@Kendodd

As an aside I remember years ago hearing about psychological studies with people around the world asking who's life you would save. I think I'm remembering correctly. People were given the option, they could save 100 of their neighbours, all people they didn't know, or they could save 101 people in some far off land, again, people they didn't know. So for example they would ask people people from the UK, to choose between saving say 100 Dutch people or 101 Vietnamese people. People across the world all chose to save their neighbours for some reason even though the most logical choice would be to do the most good and save more people. I'll try to find the study. Also, I don't know how the responses could be dressed up as anything other than racism, people all over the world responded the same way though.
That stylised study is simply not applicable here. Neither does it explain overt racism that has been documented. And in any case, some of the countries that refugees come from are closer to the UK than Ukraine.
RoastedFerret · 03/03/2022 20:24

@VladmirsPoutine

The reason Ukrainian refugees might stand a better chance of returning to their country than refugees from other regions is because the UK and US haven't spent years and in some instances decades bombing the fuck out of Ukraine. It's very interesting to witness selective memory of world events.
That's got nothing to do with many countries in the EU though and the EU is what the OP is slating. The UK also spent years fucking up my EU country, what is your point? You want us to take in refugees to pay for the sins of the UK? That's fucked up.
Kendodd · 03/03/2022 20:23

As an aside I remember years ago hearing about psychological studies with people around the world asking who's life you would save. I think I'm remembering correctly.
People were given the option, they could save 100 of their neighbours, all people they didn't know, or they could save 101 people in some far off land, again, people they didn't know. So for example they would ask people people from the UK, to choose between saving say 100 Dutch people or 101 Vietnamese people. People across the world all chose to save their neighbours for some reason even though the most logical choice would be to do the most good and save more people. I'll try to find the study. Also, I don't know how the responses could be dressed up as anything other than racism, people all over the world responded the same way though.

Ylvamoon · 03/03/2022 19:53

Clearly the EU has seen that its not right so have changed the rules for Ukraine, but why do people think the rules were fair for me?

What about the tiny fact that most Ukrainian refugees go to Poland / Slovakia as it's really the only first safe country available. Poland and Slovakia are member of the EU ( call it a club).
Now the members of this club get together to help their other members out...
The neighbours of your home country obviously didn't belong to any club that would help with refugees. That's very unfortunate for you and your family.
There isn't such a thing as fairness in the real world.

CayrolBaaaskin · 03/03/2022 19:25

@ancientgran - there isn’t a closed door for “brown refugees” (as you call them) though is there. Nor @VladmirsPoutine do I see any evidence of the asylum system being “inhumane or unjust”. It has its problems yes, mainly that it takes far too long to resolve claims. But not everyone who applies is eligible. I can certainly tell you that from working in the system in the past. Having an application turned down 6 times indicates that likely the application was not well founded (although as I said we don’t know for sure).

Some of my family were refugees. I understand how difficult it is. But that doesn’t change the fact that not everyone who applies for refugee status is eligible (same as everyone who applies for anything).

cherryonthecakes · 03/03/2022 19:08

I think that if something happened in Afghanistan tomorrow that the rules would not be bent for refugees from there. I think that people were sympathetic after the US withdrawal but they wouldn't be so open minded again.

I think that Ukrainian refugees will experience sympathy for now but it will quickly turn into resentment and they will experience the racism that Eastern Europeans experience normally.

ancientgran · 03/03/2022 19:07

[quote CayrolBaaaskin]@myear - you say the rules were not fair for you but we don’t know why your claim wasn’t accepted, can you tell us? All I can see on this post is an attack on Ukrainians who are going through an awful time. We do of course have to be aware that Putin works via cyber space too.

It is not racism to help Ukrainians in need. I have worked with asylum seekers in the past and much as I might like many of them, their claims are not universally well founded.

Unfortunately the most likely reason your claim was turned down 6 times is because you were not eligible. The system does get it wrong sometimes but not as often as claims are refused for being genuinely ineligible.[/quote]
Of course it isn't racism to help Ukrainians, the OP never said it was. Having open arms for white refugees and a closed door for brown refugees is racist.

cherryonthecakes · 03/03/2022 19:02

I think it's because they are white and countries like the UK are more scared of Russia than the people that you fled from because they are closer and have nuclear weapons.

Not helping the Ukrainians risks creating extremists and extremists living in Europe are a scarier prospect than ones living in neighbouring countries to places like Syria and Afghanistan. (I know that some extremists are home grown )

The countries between the EU and Russia formed a convenient geographical buffer until now.

VladmirsPoutine · 03/03/2022 18:53

Unfortunately the most likely reason your claim was turned down 6 times is because you were not eligible. The system does get it wrong sometimes but not as often as claims are refused for being genuinely ineligible.

This sums up the attitude of the majority of people in the UK. OP the system is not faulty, it's working as it's been designed - in other words to be cruel, inhumane and unjust. People who haven't been through your experience won't ever be able to understand it. MN for all it's wonders is not the type of place to seek empathy for these types of experiences. When some of my elder relatives tell me about their plight getting to /living in the UK I'm frankly horrified and I know I do not have the stones to have dealt with even a quarter of what they went through and I'm not from a war torn place.

myear · 03/03/2022 18:53

[quote CayrolBaaaskin]@myear - you say the rules were not fair for you but we don’t know why your claim wasn’t accepted, can you tell us? All I can see on this post is an attack on Ukrainians who are going through an awful time. We do of course have to be aware that Putin works via cyber space too.

It is not racism to help Ukrainians in need. I have worked with asylum seekers in the past and much as I might like many of them, their claims are not universally well founded.

Unfortunately the most likely reason your claim was turned down 6 times is because you were not eligible. The system does get it wrong sometimes but not as often as claims are refused for being genuinely ineligible.[/quote]
At no point have I ever attacked Ukrainians, I really take offence at that.

OP posts:
CarrieHughes · 03/03/2022 18:44

@Cailleach1 and therein lies the rub.
If I was being bombed out of my country I'd want to be safe. That's the first thing.
Someone who has the luxury of being choosy aren't fleeing for their lives, are they?

CayrolBaaaskin · 03/03/2022 18:41

@myear - you say the rules were not fair for you but we don’t know why your claim wasn’t accepted, can you tell us? All I can see on this post is an attack on Ukrainians who are going through an awful time. We do of course have to be aware that Putin works via cyber space too.

It is not racism to help Ukrainians in need. I have worked with asylum seekers in the past and much as I might like many of them, their claims are not universally well founded.

Unfortunately the most likely reason your claim was turned down 6 times is because you were not eligible. The system does get it wrong sometimes but not as often as claims are refused for being genuinely ineligible.

deragod · 03/03/2022 18:29

Russian imperialism is not better than American. But I am not surprised it comes from the person clearly fascinated by Putin (what a funny name, what a pun...)
Russia has long history of comiting genocides, displacing people and eradicating cultures.
Bosnia, mentioned here few times, being one of the nations affected by Russian imperialism.

JellybeansJelly · 03/03/2022 18:28

@myear

The truth was that we were being bombed out of our houses because we were a different race / religion / language. The dominant race didn't want us there. Anyone who protested in a peaceful way risked being taken away by the government and being killed.

But the country that we sought refuge in felt that genocide and war crimes were not a good enough reason to take us in.

And in all this, people are defending the system and saying it was us that were wrong to lie? How can we defend a system that will send a mother and her children to destruction? Clearly the EU has seen that its not right so have changed the rules for Ukraine, but why do people think the rules were fair for me? Can you imagine the outrage we would see if we did this to Ukraine?

This is the first time I have ever spoken about my experiences. No one other than DH knows I was an asylum seeker. My mother always told me never to tell anyone because people won't understand, people will blame me. There have been some lovely posts here which have made me feel more positive, but some of the posts here have also made me realise why my mother said what she did.

I’m from a Middle Eastern background myself, and I understand your trauma completely.

Unfortunately, many people in the UK don’t want to admit their racist viewpoint so will often be in denial, and turn you in the problem, as have others on this thread.

Well done for speaking out and highlighting the double standards that many have.

JellybeansJelly · 03/03/2022 18:26

@Bonheurdupasse Just like the white men of the western world who kidnapped, maimed and raped women and children from Africa…in far greater numbers than the Ottoman Empire ever did.

Your attitude to certain races and a certain religion is shining through in your posts.

CayrolBaaaskin · 03/03/2022 18:21

@CarrieHughes - exactly- how is AIBU on mn a “safe space to discuss trauma”.

Cailleach1 · 03/03/2022 18:14

[quote CarrieHughes]@Cablefable wrong again, I can guarantee that neighbouring countries would have taken them in. Even Syria itself (using as a recent example) took refugees. The biggest refugee housing countries are Turkey, Lebanon and Jordan.
However space + infrastructure is finite. Of course they were unhappy when nobpdy cared to give them money.
It would be better to fund neighbouring states. Saudi Arabia has room for half a million at least, so do Qatar, UAE?

A PP has stated that Europe’s constantly blamed for not taking refugees while other countries shit on them equally. I somewhat agree.

For countries with a colonial past like Britain, France etc and who are still the cause of wars probably theres some blame.
But countries like Poland, Romania etc. While it’s bad that they’re racist, I can’t blame them for not wanting refugees! They’ve spent most of history being bullied by the rest of Europe. It has nothing to do with them.[/quote]
I'm not sure how much Turkey spends on those refugee facilities. I think they are in receipt of very large amounts of EU cash to establish and run them. Simon Reeve did an interesting bit about it in his programme on Turkey. If member serves me right, the EU are funding them, but it is only the Turkish flag that flies overhead. Thus the refugees are led to believe that Turkey are providing everything.

Also, I think it is a bit of a no man's land for the refugees themselves in Turkey. Turkey are very restrictive and I don't think refugees have or can acquire many rights. Or, gain a right to nationality based on how long they are there. Of course, no doubt it is better to be alive and have your family safe. But there isn't a future in it, and you don't have security to be able to have a full live as a citizen. Isn't Turkey's idea that they can go back when safe to do so, irrespective of how long that is?

I think I'd be looking to move on somewhere I and my family could put down roots and become full citizens. Not just waiting, waiting and waiting as years go by.

ancientgran · 03/03/2022 18:13

@blueberryporridge

Because they are white and their way of life looks quite similar to ours?
I think you hit it in one. A commentator even said it on TV the other day, something like people won't accept "people who look like them and live like them" being treated like this. The message being if you look different (brown) and don't live like them (a non european culture) it is a bit of a shame but not our problem.

They showed Nigerian students trying to leave Ukraine and being refused entry to Poland. I can't see why they would be a problem, they wanted to go home so would only be passing through. I hope they got home.

I feel sorry for the Ukrainian people, it is wonderful the help they are being offered by neighbouring countries and even things like lots of phone companies offering free calls to Ukraine and also companies offering free plane and train tickets but there is racism.

CarrieHughes · 03/03/2022 18:13

@VladmirsPoutine

The reason Ukrainian refugees might stand a better chance of returning to their country than refugees from other regions is because the UK and US haven't spent years and in some instances decades bombing the fuck out of Ukraine. It's very interesting to witness selective memory of world events.
That’s not quite relevant isn’t it? If your point is that the destabilisation was these major powers’ fault and they should all be given free flow. Then Commonwealth countries whose wealth the U.K. has stolen for generations should also be given free flow. From an individual, ‘how will this affect me perspective’ people in areas with an influx of people can tolerate it for a couple of years. Not for several unless significant investment in housing, infrastructure etc is made.

You can argue about whose fault it is , who should be giving the money but for an individual most stuff is about how it affects THEM. Especially when so many are already struggling to survive.

Furthermore…
I don’t disagree that racism is a let of attitudes. There are just several factors at play rather than ‘they’re the wrong colour’.
‘race’, and ‘nationality’ can be a shorthand for values, culture. It’s a delicate balance.

VladmirsPoutine · 03/03/2022 18:02

The reason Ukrainian refugees might stand a better chance of returning to their country than refugees from other regions is because the UK and US haven't spent years and in some instances decades bombing the fuck out of Ukraine. It's very interesting to witness selective memory of world events.

Onionpatch · 03/03/2022 17:50

the home office hasnt really welcomed ukrainian refugees with open arms and no checks. The scheme is still quite limited and requires checks.

But the difference is much of the population is demanding a better response which I havent seen before.

seashellsunderthesand · 03/03/2022 17:49

The way I see it is this. Every country has a relationship with other countries round the world, and how these relationships work and their impact upon the home nation, will determine what actions a country takes abroad.
In this case it is the fact that it is Putin doing the invading and killing, not the fact that it's the Ukraine people. It's what he is capable of and how it could effect us. At the end of the day all countries act in their own best interest. We are rightly stepping in and doing all we can, and it's probably right that with Ukraine being a European nation any help given will be more popular, but we shouldn't kid ourselves that if this had'd directly effected us we would be so involved.
I come from a people who suffered one of the first recorded genocides. Even now it isn't recognised by the Uk for fear of annoying another country with which they clearly view as being more useful.
We should do all we can to help the people of Ukraine but I don't think the OP is wrong in coming to this realisation,
just probably that it's not the best time to voice it

EeeICouldRipATissue · 03/03/2022 17:49

but it is a safe space for racist posters?

I'd say yes, as they feel emboldened hiding beyond an anonymous name.