Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Exceptions for Ukraine refugees

410 replies

myear · 03/03/2022 00:24

I would genuinely be happy if someone can explain to me how IABU so I can feel less upset!

I am pleased for the Ukrainians that the EU is making exceptions for them so that anyone can come in, can get jobs straight away, no need for a visa for 3 years etc, but AIBU to feel bitter about my own treatment as an asylum seeker many many years ago? I can’t help but wonder why these exceptions are made for people fleeing the Ukraine, but not for people who fled my country to survive ethnic cleansing and what the UN found was war crimes against my people.

We had to lie to get a visa to Europe, lie to then get into the country when we were taken away for questioning at the border, apply for asylum 6 times as it kept being rejected, and only got approved on the basis that we had stayed too long to be kicked out, couldn’t work for a long time, and no exceptions were made to reduce bureaucratic hurdles. To be blunt, I question whether exceptions are being made for the Ukrainian refugees because they are white and people from my country are black.

My white DH, who is from the European country that took me in, is upset that the UK is not waiving visa requirements for Ukrainians and only allowing those with family in, rather than anyone seeking refuge. But, he doesn’t really see a problem with how I was treated by his country either, for reasons such as:

  1. We fled a civil war whereas Ukraine is being attacked by another country. Countries need to deal with their own problems (but incidentally thinks it was right to intervene in NI / ROI - again white).
  1. It’s not his country’s duty to help my country as they didn’t cause the war (but neither did his country cause the Ukraine war yet they are making exceptions for them).
  1. Ukraine is geographically closer, although not a direct neighbour (so?)
  1. Why am I not upset at the people who caused war in my country (but how is that relevant to the differing treatment I’m now seeing?)
  1. Why am I not upset at neighbouring countries, they didn’t help either (again, how is that relevant?)
  1. No exceptions were made for Kosovo, Bosnia etc so the Ukraine exceptions are not based on race (can't argue against that!)

I am very grateful that we were able to find safety in Europe and have a great life, but this seems to be upsetting me more than I can rationally explain.

OP posts:
HowtoStop · 04/03/2022 17:27

[quote User121212121212121212]@Why2why
There is another thread where you can express your anger about treatment of African students in Ukraine, go comment there. This one is discussing why EU decided on different approach toward Ukrainians vs different refugees and this has been explained many times by different posters. Even OP understood that it's a different and more complex situation, but in your world everything is simple.[/quote]
So you’re on here trying to shut down comments of maltreatment of Indian, Pakistani and African students in Ukraine. It’s not a complex situation. Fact is that most of Europe is racist. The far right Polish groups are using this opportunity to commit disgusting crimes against those of colour. And all you can say is use a different thread or label people as xenophobic. Admit it, you’re a proper racist aren’t you? No need to hide it, we’re all strangers here.

Im2022 · 04/03/2022 17:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

User121212121212121212 · 04/03/2022 14:36

@Why2why
There is another thread where you can express your anger about treatment of African students in Ukraine, go comment there. This one is discussing why EU decided on different approach toward Ukrainians vs different refugees and this has been explained many times by different posters. Even OP understood that it's a different and more complex situation, but in your world everything is simple.

User121212121212121212 · 04/03/2022 14:32

@Im2022

This whole thing is making me despise the world. White supremacy at its worst. Black and brown people studying in Ukraine being blocked from getting on buses and trains out of Ukraine by officials telling them only Ukrainian citizens are allowed. They’re being made to walk 18-20 hours because only white people are allowed on buses. It’s very sad what’s happening, but my sympathy is wearing thin. How the fuck can you remain a racist cunt when your country is being invaded? Black and brown people have no status? They’re not humans? They’re not even allowing these people to fight for them, yet the president is waiving visas inviting people into the country to fight. So they only want white people? Makes me wonder if the Russian “ethnic cleansing” claim is true.
Give your head a wobble. There is a word for people who spout nonsense like you about 'ethnic cleansing' - useful idiots. You're clearly a xenophobe, who is using the situation to show how much you hate Ukrainians or white people in general.
Why2why · 04/03/2022 08:10

@CarrieHughes, by you logic, we can justify any inhumane behaviour based upon n logic and self-interestedness. Ditch older people they are a burden, don’t give women too many rights, they are physically weaker than men, child labour can be justified, slavery, even what Putin is doing now can be justified if we adopted your reasoning of logic and self-interestedness.

It’s exactly your type of thinking that Putin is adopting to justify his invasion.

Im2022 · 04/03/2022 07:20

@deragod www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-africa-60573719
This isn’t a man. It’s a black woman made to walk. Listen to her when she says the problem is at the Ukraine border, they will shout and beat you if you’re black. There was a Pakistani trainee doctor on the news the other day saying they asked for weapons to fight, but were told only Ukraines were allowed to help.

@CayrolBaaaskin this is from the Russian ambassador’s speech in New York on Monday. They say there was evidence Of it happening. We don’t know. But I’m making my own judgement by how Ukraine are treating people who are black. When there is hate embedded in you, anything can happen.

CarrieHughes · 04/03/2022 06:50

@Kendodd

As an aside I remember years ago hearing about psychological studies with people around the world asking who's life you would save. I think I'm remembering correctly. People were given the option, they could save 100 of their neighbours, all people they didn't know, or they could save 101 people in some far off land, again, people they didn't know. So for example they would ask people people from the UK, to choose between saving say 100 Dutch people or 101 Vietnamese people. People across the world all chose to save their neighbours for some reason even though the most logical choice would be to do the most good and save more people. I'll try to find the study. Also, I don't know how the responses could be dressed up as anything other than racism, people all over the world responded the same way though.
Wrong. The most logical choice as a self-interested human would be to save people who would benefit you. Meaning neighbours.

Faraway people dying has zero impact so why bother.

Is it morally abhorrent? I’ll leave that to you.
Is it logical? Yes.

‘All human life’ is not the same. And it’s NEVER ‘just’ human life. It’s economics, politics, reciprocity. Also scarcity.

CayrolBaaaskin · 04/03/2022 05:51

@Im2022 - where did you get that information from? There is no evidence of any “ethnic cleansing” carried out by Ukraine at the present time as far as I am aware.

deragod · 04/03/2022 01:43

@Im2022

Ukraine and Poland have different culture.
Pregnant women are prioritised in ques, men know to gave up the seat on the bus/tram for pregnant women. Thus, in situation like that men are made to walk because they are physically stronger, do not get pregnant and tend to not have periods. And young students dont have children to take care of .

Children were alredy born on the trias to Poland. I am glad that those women were not walking to the border.

It's funny, how VladmirsPoutine can see injustice but not when it comes to Ukraine.
Ukraine wasn't treated by the West any better. They were used, the West wasnt that keen on making a fuss about attack in 2014.
Georgia in 2008 also couldn't rely on the West.

Im2022 · 03/03/2022 23:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 03/03/2022 23:41

They fought and received no such warm words and admiration.

I would imagine you had warm words and admiration for them. You cannot dictate who I have wam words and respect for.

User121212121212121212 · 03/03/2022 23:40

Some people already mentioned the practical and legal reasons why EU (not UK) has decided on different approach for Ukrainians vs other refugees. Simply put - most Ukrainians are fleeing to Poland (as this is their neighbouring country), which is a part of EU. Poland itself doesn't have resources to deal with additional few million people, although they do what they can to help them temporarily. As Poland is a part of bloc of countries that generally help each other in situations like that, it is understandable that they dealt with it together. It's the same way EU has managed refugee sitaution in Greece - by relocating them to different countries within EU. I know for some posters it's hard to understand that not everything is about the race, but that's not the situation here.
On UK note- they don't give a shit about any refugees - black or white (which is funny considering they colonised half of the world so should take responsibility for them now). They are pressured to accept few hundred thousand on strict conditions, which is a drop in the ocean.

Porcupineintherough · 03/03/2022 23:39

The west is not responsible for every war everywhere @Why2why and you are being very partial of your recollection of the Arab spring.

Why2why · 03/03/2022 23:35

@ChardonnaysPetDragon

Ukraine was colonised by Russia. They are fighting back.
The others are not fighting back? What role has the West played in not only abusing and debilitating them, but then creating wars and conflicts that the innocent people of these are ill-equipped to fight back. To add insult to injury, the West often give arms to groups that further oppress innocent people. As long as the West can get its oil, diamonds and other goodies, it cares not about the lives of people in developing countries and makes sure that they are never in a strong position to fight against despot. When they do, we see how they are crushed and no one comes to their aid as we see in the case of Ukraine. Remember when the people fought back in many Arabic countries not too long ago? They fought and received no such warm words and admiration.
whenwillthemadnessend · 03/03/2022 23:09

@Thebestwaytoscareatory

You forget the french and napoleon way before 70 years ago

And also they have nuclear weapons.

That is the only reason west have held back IMO and for good reason!

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 03/03/2022 23:03

Ukraine was colonised by Russia. They are fighting back.

DandyMandy · 03/03/2022 22:58

Why did you bring Irish people into this? Irish people have done lots to help predominantly black and asian countries, so you failed when you brought us up. Just say you hate Irish people and go. You'll be in good company here because Mumsnet proved a few weeks ago how anti-Irish it is.

Wolfie12 · 03/03/2022 22:55

@Why2why

They are fighting back with massive Western help with ammunition and other resources. On the other hand, the West goes into these other “developing “ countries, abuse and pillage and cause civil war. Then they pack up and leave.

Let’s not open up that can of worms about fighting back against a potential coloniser.

Exactly this.
Why2why · 03/03/2022 22:51

They are fighting back with massive Western help with ammunition and other resources. On the other hand, the West goes into these other “developing “ countries, abuse and pillage and cause civil war. Then they pack up and leave.

Let’s not open up that can of worms about fighting back against a potential coloniser.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 03/03/2022 22:23

@Wolfie12

The hand-wringing in this country for white Europeans is interesting. Where is the same moral outrage for those who are still suffering in Afghanistan and Syria? You know the people who were royally fucked over by this country and the West? Ukraine is and will continue to be a fascist and racist state but people are conveniently forgetting that.
I have more sympathy for them because they are fighting for their country.

The Afghan army disintegrated and the Taliban waltzed right in. Ukraine is fighting back, and I respect then for it.

CayrolBaaaskin · 03/03/2022 22:10

@Wolfie12 - can you explain what you mean by a Ukraine being a “fascist and racist state”? Where did you get that information?

CayrolBaaaskin · 03/03/2022 22:07

Tbf Ukraine has had plenty of bombing over the last century from a variety of different parties. The people there have not had an easy time of it

Why2why · 03/03/2022 21:59

@Kendodd

Why2why Thinking about it in a wider context it seems quite accurate, in that, almost all the worlds refugees are accommodated by their neighbours. I believe we actually take very few in Europe and even less in the UK (but scream and shout lies about how generous we are inbetween cries of 'they're not coming here')
What is your point exactly? I’m lost. Are you saying that the UK treatment of refugees from outside of Europe (both in the media and institutionally) is fair when compared to how it treats and discuss refugees from Ukraine? Are you saying that racism isn’t playing a part? Are you saying that everything can be explained by proximity?

It’s not the numbers that matter here. It’s how whatever number that is allowed in is treated and how easy or difficult it is for that number to gain access.

Wolfie12 · 03/03/2022 21:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

CallyfromBlakes7 · 03/03/2022 20:47

@BobLep0nge

No exceptions were made for Kosovo, Bosnia etc so the Ukraine exceptions are not based on race (can't argue against that!)

I've always thought that it was probably because Kosovo and Bosnia are majority Muslim.

I had a look at the figures for this. According to Croatia Today the UK took around 8000 refugees from the Bosnian war. Ireland took 20 (sic).

Germany took around 300,000, Sweden around 77,000.