Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Exceptions for Ukraine refugees

410 replies

myear · 03/03/2022 00:24

I would genuinely be happy if someone can explain to me how IABU so I can feel less upset!

I am pleased for the Ukrainians that the EU is making exceptions for them so that anyone can come in, can get jobs straight away, no need for a visa for 3 years etc, but AIBU to feel bitter about my own treatment as an asylum seeker many many years ago? I can’t help but wonder why these exceptions are made for people fleeing the Ukraine, but not for people who fled my country to survive ethnic cleansing and what the UN found was war crimes against my people.

We had to lie to get a visa to Europe, lie to then get into the country when we were taken away for questioning at the border, apply for asylum 6 times as it kept being rejected, and only got approved on the basis that we had stayed too long to be kicked out, couldn’t work for a long time, and no exceptions were made to reduce bureaucratic hurdles. To be blunt, I question whether exceptions are being made for the Ukrainian refugees because they are white and people from my country are black.

My white DH, who is from the European country that took me in, is upset that the UK is not waiving visa requirements for Ukrainians and only allowing those with family in, rather than anyone seeking refuge. But, he doesn’t really see a problem with how I was treated by his country either, for reasons such as:

  1. We fled a civil war whereas Ukraine is being attacked by another country. Countries need to deal with their own problems (but incidentally thinks it was right to intervene in NI / ROI - again white).
  1. It’s not his country’s duty to help my country as they didn’t cause the war (but neither did his country cause the Ukraine war yet they are making exceptions for them).
  1. Ukraine is geographically closer, although not a direct neighbour (so?)
  1. Why am I not upset at the people who caused war in my country (but how is that relevant to the differing treatment I’m now seeing?)
  1. Why am I not upset at neighbouring countries, they didn’t help either (again, how is that relevant?)
  1. No exceptions were made for Kosovo, Bosnia etc so the Ukraine exceptions are not based on race (can't argue against that!)

I am very grateful that we were able to find safety in Europe and have a great life, but this seems to be upsetting me more than I can rationally explain.

OP posts:
BessieFinknottle · 05/03/2022 11:14

However, the UK hasn't intervened in any war or conflict in Ireland in the years since it became a republic so her statement is confusing either way.

Just to clarify before I get jumped on - if it isn't already clear from the sentence, I'm taking about Ireland the state here (aka ROI), not the island of Ireland.

BessieFinknottle · 05/03/2022 11:09

Educate your self on the reason why there is a war in Ireland, why the british are there at all and why your government claim it is part of the uk.

I know my history very well indeed and I am Irish Mocara. (If your username is meant to say 'my friend' you need to check the spelling btw.) Obviously, giving a one or two line summary of the situation in NI will necessitate
leaving huge amounts out. This doesn't mean I'm not fully aware of it, or that what I have said isn't correct.

My question to the OP was why she said there was a conflict between NI and ROI when there was not. On reflection, I think I may have misunderstood her. I took this

"thinks it was right to intervene in NI / ROI "

to mean intervening in a conflict between NI and ROI, but I now think that maybe she meant intervening in NI and ROI.

However, the UK hasn't intervened in any war or conflict in Ireland in the years since it became a republic so her statement is confusing either way.

Again, my apologies to the OP, as this is far from the point of her thread I know. It's become a big thing when I just wanted to make a clarification.

Frazzled50yrold · 05/03/2022 10:20

'@Jamboree01 I don't understand how educating myself will change DH's view of the NI conflict?? As I said, it's his view, not mine.'
Perhaps it's best not to try and make these comparisons with NI. I lived in NI throughout the troubles, my entire childhood and early adult life were affected deeply by the troubles.My experience and perception may be different to others on this thread and that's OK. Innocent people on all sides were murdered and it was fitting that there was intervention, the interventions may have been poorly advised on occasions. To quote one of our best politicians it was a dirty little war.Colonialism may have affected the issues in your area but NI was exclusively British and had to be treated differently.
I've leaving this thread now as it's turning into a whataboutery discussion and I don't need or want to read a revisionism text on the troubles.

ancientgran · 05/03/2022 09:46

@Jamboree01

There was a campaign of violence and murder against innocent Irish civilians by British state forces who should never have been there.

But, yes, you’re right, colour was totally irrelevant.

I'm from a mixed family, green and orange. The colour might not be on the skin but colour is part of it, your "colour" is determined by the church you go to or the school you go to or even your name.
Mocara · 05/03/2022 09:03

The British Army were sent to NI in 1969 in response to the increasing sectarian violence that was happening there - in my previous post I described this as the UK (government) intervening in NI. Result - the violence escalated until the Good Friday agreement in 1998.

So...again, if I've made an error, please do me the courtesy of pointing it out. Ridiculous to just say it's all wrong.

Interven in secterian violence ???
Educate your self on the reason why there is a war in Ireland, why the british are there at all and why your government claim it is part of the uk.
Ignorent to think the war has stopped because its not all over the media . Brexit : the Uk are happy to break international law at the expense of Ireland and escalating the war .
Did anyone on this thread know that throughout the war in Ireland it has been common practice for northern families to seek refuge in the homes of people in the south of Ireland, somtimes just sending there children so they could escape the worst of the war.
My childhood and home was shared with many of these families/children. My parents are in there 80s and are still in contact with some of these families and still offer refuge to those traumatised and living with the trauma of a British war againest Ireland .

CayrolBaaaskin · 05/03/2022 08:54

I don’t discount that there is racism in the attitudes to refugees. But we can’t say if it had any effect in your case op because we don’t know the details. You say that your case was denied 6 times - we don’t know why but as I said Thur most likely reason is that you were not eligible.

That has nothing to do with Ukrainians fleeing war though. Apart from anything else the EU is offering them temporary residence not permanent asylum. If you want to discuss specific details of why your asylum claim was turned down, please do. But it has nothing to do with Ukrainians.

CarrieHughes · 05/03/2022 08:46

[quote Why2why]@CarrieHughes, by you logic, we can justify any inhumane behaviour based upon n logic and self-interestedness. Ditch older people they are a burden, don’t give women too many rights, they are physically weaker than men, child labour can be justified, slavery, even what Putin is doing now can be justified if we adopted your reasoning of logic and self-interestedness.

It’s exactly your type of thinking that Putin is adopting to justify his invasion.[/quote]
Again, all wrong.
Older people - they've paid in already, care etc is just what's due to them. Furthermore we'll all be old one day, so obviously everybody now will one day suffer if any policy 'ditches' old people as you so eloquently put it.
Women's rights and the education of children are necessary for the prosperity of the whole country. We want an intelligent, numerate workforce, if 50% of the population don't have equal rights how will we achieve this?

So all of this is logical.

Furthermore if you read my post CAREFULLY the response was to the poster saying that caring more for your neighbours, rather than distance people was irrational.

I merely pointed out that it wasn't. It was logical. Now whether something LOGICAL is also RIGHT is a separate issue. But I never said it was.

You don't seem to be very good at this - maybe take a course on critical thinking? An ad hominem doesn't strengthen your argument.

BessieFinknottle · 05/03/2022 08:12

I'm sorry to have gone so off the point OP.

johnnytightlips · 05/03/2022 08:12

A lot of towns in Ireland gave refuge to Nigerian and Congolese people here in the 90s yet there was the Yugoslavian war raging at the time and I don't remember anyone from the former Yugolslavia coming here.
A neighbouring town gave refuge to many Chilean people in the 70s/80s. We have also given refuge to many Syrians and Afghans in recent years who have made Ireland their home. Colour hasn't come into it. Angela Merkel opened the doors in Germany in 2015 for people escaping war torn countries.
Ukraine is geographically close to EU member states, the only other places next to them is Russia and Belarus. They aren't passing through many safe countries to get to the EU. Whether people are deemed as Genuine Refugees or Economic Migrants is where the problem may lie in peoples minds rather than their race.

BessieFinknottle · 05/03/2022 08:10

@Jamboree01

All of it… except ‘ I am very sorry for all you and your family have gone through myear.’
What I've said is correct @Jamboree01.

Are you suggesting that NI is not part of the UK?

That the 'UK' does not stand for the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland?

... NI was created in 1921 after the partition of the island of Ireland - there has never been a war/fighting between NI and ROI (or Ireland to give the state its correct name) as the OP has suggested, which is why I queried that point with her.

The British Army were sent to NI in 1969 in response to the increasing sectarian violence that was happening there - in my previous post I described this as the UK (government) intervening in NI. Result - the violence escalated until the Good Friday agreement in 1998.

So...again, if I've made an error, please do me the courtesy of pointing it out. Ridiculous to just say it's all wrong.

kavalkada · 05/03/2022 07:14

OP, I'm truly sorry for your experience. If I were you, I would also be sad and hurt.

Although there is plenty of racism in Europe, as we can see by the awful things that happen on Ukraine border, when it comes to acts of European Union, I think they're mainly motivated by the fact that it is Russia that attacked Ukraine, and in the lesser degree by the fact that is happening in Europe.

When I say lesser degree, I see that from my own experience. I was a refugee in my early teens when there was a war in ex-Yugoslavia, now Croatia. My parents were not allowed to leave my home town so my father got a special permit to take my brother and me to safety. After he left us with a lovely family that open the door of their home to us (I was 12, my brother 10), he returned home.

There were tens od thousands of refugees from ex Yugoslavia, and although we're white, we didn't get special permits like Ukranins did. The color of our skin had nothing to do with it.

If we were attacked by Russia, I do not know. The world has changed a lot in these 30 years.

Jamboree01 · 05/03/2022 03:17

All of it… except ‘ I am very sorry for all you and your family have gone through myear.’

BessieFinknottle · 05/03/2022 02:54

I absolutely do have knowledge of the facts Jamboree01.
What part of what I've said do you disagree with specifically?

Jamboree01 · 05/03/2022 02:41

@BessieFinknottle

Countries need to deal with their own problems (but incidentally thinks it was right to intervene in NI / ROI - again white)

I am very sorry fof all you and your family have gone through myear.

I am also confused by the above statement - there wasn't any conflict between NI and ROI.

The UK intervened in the conflicts happening within NI (between some of the Irish and British living there), because NI is part of the UK - it's the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. (They managed to mess things up even further, but that's another story.)

🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

You are confused because you don’t appear to have any knowledge of the facts. Your statement is absolutely incorrect.

BessieFinknottle · 05/03/2022 02:35

Countries need to deal with their own problems (but incidentally thinks it was right to intervene in NI / ROI - again white)

I am very sorry fof all you and your family have gone through myear.

I am also confused by the above statement - there wasn't any conflict between NI and ROI.

The UK intervened in the conflicts happening within NI (between some of the Irish and British living there), because NI is part of the UK - it's the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. (They managed to mess things up even further, but that's another story.)

Jamboree01 · 05/03/2022 01:23

It’s beyond heartbreaking and frustrating 😑😞 X

Abitofalark · 05/03/2022 01:22

Which country was the country of origin - I missed that on scanning quickly through the thread.

Jamboree01 · 05/03/2022 01:21

[quote myear]@Jamboree01 I don't understand how educating myself will change DH's view of the NI conflict?? As I said, it's his view, not mine. [/quote]
I think you may want to re read your posts OP.

DandyMandy · 05/03/2022 01:12

@Jamboree01

💯

The majority of the people in the north extend love and solidarity with every oppressed nation on the earth yet their own oppression is rarely spoken of. It’s jaw dropping how many people use NI as some sort of example when they haven’t got a clue about what really happened and what is still going on

Thank you for both of your comments on this page. The ignorance blows me away. The same people who refuse to look at the facts regarding Ireland are the ones who can't keep us out of their mouths. Unbelievable.
myear · 05/03/2022 00:52

@Jamboree01 I don't understand how educating myself will change DH's view of the NI conflict?? As I said, it's his view, not mine.

OP posts:
Mocara · 05/03/2022 00:50

"Nothing to do with the colour, but entirely to do with the fact that an organisation (not a nation) was committing terrorist acts (bottom line it is WAY more complicated than that) on within a soverign nation (UK) what do you expect a government to do? Nothing or something? We can argue until the cows come home about NI but that is the bottom line, it wasn't a civil war it was (supposed to be) a police action (that got completely out of hand and suffered hugely from mission creep)"

You would be well advised not to comment on the war in Ireland as you are clearly profoundly ignorant regarding the topic and have only succeeded in causeing offense.

Jamboree01 · 05/03/2022 00:37

💯

The majority of the people in the north extend love and solidarity with every oppressed nation on the earth yet their own oppression is rarely spoken of. It’s jaw dropping how many people use NI as some sort of example when they haven’t got a clue about what really happened and what is still going on

Jamboree01 · 05/03/2022 00:34

The British created the conflict in the north of Ireland. You obviously don’t don’t know or understand the atrocities that were carried out by the British state. Please educate yourself before using it as some kind of tool to prove a point. Start with C4 news episode on the Ballymurphy massacre and work from there. You might learn something. There is also a documentary. Or the Miami showband massacre on Netflix. Or countless interviews with the families of the victims of those murdered by British paratroopers in Derry on Bloody Sunday- innocent civilians who were marching for civil rights.

EeeICouldRipATissue · 05/03/2022 00:11

@ihopeyoulikemymuff
Don't you not feel anything for other people, though?
It might not be you right now, but if the world turned around and decided you were next, would you not hope for help?

Ihopeyoulikemymuff · 05/03/2022 00:07

I'm pretty uninterested in helping refugees from anywhere. I've got my own shit to deal with. If that makes me a bad person so be it.