Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Exceptions for Ukraine refugees

410 replies

myear · 03/03/2022 00:24

I would genuinely be happy if someone can explain to me how IABU so I can feel less upset!

I am pleased for the Ukrainians that the EU is making exceptions for them so that anyone can come in, can get jobs straight away, no need for a visa for 3 years etc, but AIBU to feel bitter about my own treatment as an asylum seeker many many years ago? I can’t help but wonder why these exceptions are made for people fleeing the Ukraine, but not for people who fled my country to survive ethnic cleansing and what the UN found was war crimes against my people.

We had to lie to get a visa to Europe, lie to then get into the country when we were taken away for questioning at the border, apply for asylum 6 times as it kept being rejected, and only got approved on the basis that we had stayed too long to be kicked out, couldn’t work for a long time, and no exceptions were made to reduce bureaucratic hurdles. To be blunt, I question whether exceptions are being made for the Ukrainian refugees because they are white and people from my country are black.

My white DH, who is from the European country that took me in, is upset that the UK is not waiving visa requirements for Ukrainians and only allowing those with family in, rather than anyone seeking refuge. But, he doesn’t really see a problem with how I was treated by his country either, for reasons such as:

  1. We fled a civil war whereas Ukraine is being attacked by another country. Countries need to deal with their own problems (but incidentally thinks it was right to intervene in NI / ROI - again white).
  1. It’s not his country’s duty to help my country as they didn’t cause the war (but neither did his country cause the Ukraine war yet they are making exceptions for them).
  1. Ukraine is geographically closer, although not a direct neighbour (so?)
  1. Why am I not upset at the people who caused war in my country (but how is that relevant to the differing treatment I’m now seeing?)
  1. Why am I not upset at neighbouring countries, they didn’t help either (again, how is that relevant?)
  1. No exceptions were made for Kosovo, Bosnia etc so the Ukraine exceptions are not based on race (can't argue against that!)

I am very grateful that we were able to find safety in Europe and have a great life, but this seems to be upsetting me more than I can rationally explain.

OP posts:
ittakes2 · 03/03/2022 06:29

People can't help how they feel - I think to me what this is is you need some counselling to process your past. This is not about them its about you. I hope you get the help you need.

TeloMere · 03/03/2022 06:27

Would it make you feel better if Ukranian women and children were refused entry to EU countries and had nowhere safe to go?

Jalapinot · 03/03/2022 06:20

Lessons have been learned. It's not fair but that's the way it is. I think social media and the instant-ness of news nowadays plays a big part. If the Cyprus conflict had come about in times of social media then Turkey would not have been allowed to illegally occupy half the island and steal peoples homes.

CheeseTown · 03/03/2022 06:13

Yanbu op. I do think we should do all we can for Ukrainians but I don't see how we can be so hard nosed about other refugees. I think there are a lot of factors here (white Ukrainians, Putin bring seen universally as the enemy, lots of media coverage, etc) but essentially it is unfair. People will tie themselves in knots trying to justify it because they want to feel like good, generous people but we are not generous people. This story appeals to us...luckily for Ukrainians. Others haven't been so lucky to attract our fancy.

Ladylornax12 · 03/03/2022 06:08

Because these are women and children. People are more suspicious of young men trying to get in and their motives.

SapereAude · 03/03/2022 06:07

Any HK citizen not coming to the UK was entitled to BNO (British National Overseas) status, and since 1997 further possibilities for those who didn't take up any of the possibilities before 1997 have been put in place. No other people in fairness have been given as many possibilities to not lose their British status.
In a flip of the coin- not this time because they are white, but because they are generally wealthy and educated. And of course, because they were British to start with, allbeit without ROA at the time.

SapereAude · 03/03/2022 05:59

[quote Nahnanananahna]@Greeceisthebest

What about the U.K. opening doors to people from Hong Kong? They’re not white. It’s because we have a shared history and connection with them. We feel we owe them greater help.

We should have given Hong Kongers citizenship in 1997 instead of just dumping them with no protection and running. If they were white we would have done. This is a small step to correcting that.[/quote]
We did.
To many many people.
I was part of the team seconded to HK to fast track it.
In the years prior to 1997 any BDTC (the British Citizenship held by HK citizens) could come to the UK and then apply for full BC status. BDTCs had fast-tracked paths to BC status since 1983.
Everyone knew that 1997 was going to happen and the Home Office had systems in place for years to allow anybody who wanted to the opportunity to do that.
We weren't talking about a "backward"nation where people didn't know what was coming. We're talking about what was one of the wealthiest little corners of the world at the time.

HadaVerde · 03/03/2022 05:40

YANBU.

Stevenage689 · 03/03/2022 05:31

It feels like it is predominantly about who is attacking and what Europe thinks about the war. I don't think it's about the Ukrainian people themselves.

Europe condemns the war in the strongest terms, therefore we want to help the civilians affected. Citizens in Europe are also given a lot of news coverage and therefore can see and understand the effects of the war. Furthermore, it is easier to comprehend the effects when the initial lifestyle is so similar to your own.

All of this is to say that it's understandable, but wrong, that people from peaceful European countries have different reactions to this war compared to other wars of recent times.

Your husband likely can't really comprehend what happened in your country. He is seeking to logically justify something that isn't actually logical.

sashh · 03/03/2022 05:21

I have no idea what you have been through, this is not criticism of you but some points to think about. And I will look at your questions / comments in more detail.

When ever there is a war civil or otherwise countries near the conflict always take more refugees, there are arguments that it is better to fund those countries rather than encourage people to move further.

This is particularly true when people are wanting to return home after the conflict.

Refugees who can come to Britain and then be 'looked after' by families and organisations are easier to accommodate, and the UK has a lot of Ukrainian people and organisations. So a family may be willing to offer accommodation and food to a relative or a friend of a relative but not a stranger.

Someone arriving with nothing and no contacts is a more difficult person to help, and yes I know they are also in more need.

At the moment any Ukrainian can be seen to be in need of safety, that's not the case with every refugee it can be difficult to tell who is in genuine need eg in Uganda (and some other countries) it is illegal to be gay so a gay person may have need of refuge where their sibling isn't at risk but how do you tell if someone is gay or not?

Nahnanananahna · 03/03/2022 04:45

@Greeceisthebest

What about the U.K. opening doors to people from Hong Kong? They’re not white. It’s because we have a shared history and connection with them. We feel we owe them greater help.

We should have given Hong Kongers citizenship in 1997 instead of just dumping them with no protection and running. If they were white we would have done. This is a small step to correcting that.

Discodancinggiraffe · 03/03/2022 04:27

Could the fact that you admittedly lied to get into the country have something to do with you being rejected 6 times and your overall experience?

fallfallfall · 03/03/2022 02:26

It’s not a race to the bottom.
As every year goes by, personal ID, is getting easier to confirm. Along with motive.

RoastedFerret · 03/03/2022 02:17

Are you saying that you would have been happier with a 3 year visa then you head off home than with being granted asylum? You want EU countries to grant temporary visas straight away when there is turmoil in a country then send them home again after few years rather than allow people to claim permanent asylum?

Greeceisthebest · 03/03/2022 02:08

And I’m also v sorry to hear about your experience. I wish we could do more and help more people, but every stable country needs to play their part

Greeceisthebest · 03/03/2022 02:07

What about the U.K. opening doors to people from Hong Kong? They’re not white. It’s because we have a shared history and connection with them. We feel we owe them greater help.

Poland and other Eastern EU countries are doing more to help Ukraine refugees than the rest of the world because they’re neighbours.

I think that makes sense, that you will go further to help those fleeing countries where there are stronger connections.

RealRaymondReddington · 03/03/2022 01:58

We are doing better but in UK I still believe it is not enough. I am sorry for what you have been through, the system seems very cruel sometimes. I think the media and public pressure has been partly responsible for the reaction to the Ukraine invasion. Hopefully we will all continue to make kinder decisions in future. I am aware more than ever that we are all just one event away from being refugees.

GrumpyPanda · 03/03/2022 01:58

I do understand your feelings but YABVU. It's actually a principle in international refugee law to put the onus on neighbouring countries to take in refugees - that's the "first country of asylum" rule. So the country with the highest number of Venezuelan refugees I believe is Colombia; Syrians, Lebanon and Jordan, and so on. There's tons of good reasons for it, logistics of course but also better prospects for repatriation once a conflict is over. Resettlement to other countries kicks in once the first port of call becomes overburdened, such as was/is the case with Lebanon, and of course anyone is entitled to move on for reasons of family reunification, better economic prospects etc ( I believe the technical term experts use at that point is "mixed migrations".)
Clearly the first country principle didn't work for you from what you're saying and that's truly shit. And yes, the international community needs to do much better in cases where countries in the region clearly aren't coping. But that's not a valid reason to overturn the principle and tell Ukrainians to try Ecuador or Thailand rather than the EU?

On the psychological side, yes there's been some dreadfully racist comments on the media in particular and that's a shame. But that doesn't mean people aren't allowed to feel a special sense of obligation and possibly guilt on the basis of familiarity - there but for the grace of God and all that.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 03/03/2022 01:48

Two main reasons.

  1. They are white European (mainly).
  2. The aggressors in this conflict has been Europe's and America's greatest foe for the past 70 odd years.

Those two factors are enough for a surprising majority of people to turn a blind eye to any issues that may arise from granting unrestricted entry to any Ukrainian.

silentpool · 03/03/2022 01:47

I think this is viewed as a regional conflict. The UK/EU cannot take refugees from every conflict on Earth. That's not me being unkind, it's just realistic. Each region needs to manage refugees flows as far as possible.

The current difference with Ukrainian refugees is that they are identifiable, largely women and children (most vulnerable by every measure) and are fleeing regionally, as opposed to primarily male, lacking ID and from the ME/Africa etc. There has also been a lot of muddying of the waters between refugees and economic migrants in recent years - which adds to the cynicism.

blueberryporridge · 03/03/2022 01:40

@cuno Just to clarify: in my post above, I was suggesting a possible explanation to OP. I was not saying that I thought that white people whose way of life seems like ours should get preferential treatment.

deragod · 03/03/2022 01:15

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karta_Polaka
Thus, being let in into Poland does not mean being accepted in the rest of the EU. Although countries that share post Soviet trauma decide to open the borders too.

deragod · 03/03/2022 01:08

And you will still deny your own xenophobia...

Poland alredy had special measures for Ukrainians, there is long and complicated history. That's all. Many of Ukrainians living in Eastern Ukraine alredy had 'polish card'

Why2why · 03/03/2022 01:04

I’m very angry about what’s happening to Ukraine and if I could help them fight against Putin, I’d readily do so. However, I’m not happy with what’s happening to black, Asian and other ethnic minorities as they too try to flee. Dealing with the Russian invasion plus racism must be hell. I’m also not happy with the superior attitude some of the Ukrainians I’ve listened to have towards other asylum seekers or refugees.

Why2why · 03/03/2022 00:59

They are white.

I’m not an asylum seeker and I do not come from a war torn country but I do take massive offence when I hear Ukrainians say that Ukrainians are “proud” people who don’t see themselves as asylum seekers. In other words, asylum seekers are generally lacking in any sense of pride. I find the mindset rather questionable.