Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Exceptions for Ukraine refugees

410 replies

myear · 03/03/2022 00:24

I would genuinely be happy if someone can explain to me how IABU so I can feel less upset!

I am pleased for the Ukrainians that the EU is making exceptions for them so that anyone can come in, can get jobs straight away, no need for a visa for 3 years etc, but AIBU to feel bitter about my own treatment as an asylum seeker many many years ago? I can’t help but wonder why these exceptions are made for people fleeing the Ukraine, but not for people who fled my country to survive ethnic cleansing and what the UN found was war crimes against my people.

We had to lie to get a visa to Europe, lie to then get into the country when we were taken away for questioning at the border, apply for asylum 6 times as it kept being rejected, and only got approved on the basis that we had stayed too long to be kicked out, couldn’t work for a long time, and no exceptions were made to reduce bureaucratic hurdles. To be blunt, I question whether exceptions are being made for the Ukrainian refugees because they are white and people from my country are black.

My white DH, who is from the European country that took me in, is upset that the UK is not waiving visa requirements for Ukrainians and only allowing those with family in, rather than anyone seeking refuge. But, he doesn’t really see a problem with how I was treated by his country either, for reasons such as:

  1. We fled a civil war whereas Ukraine is being attacked by another country. Countries need to deal with their own problems (but incidentally thinks it was right to intervene in NI / ROI - again white).
  1. It’s not his country’s duty to help my country as they didn’t cause the war (but neither did his country cause the Ukraine war yet they are making exceptions for them).
  1. Ukraine is geographically closer, although not a direct neighbour (so?)
  1. Why am I not upset at the people who caused war in my country (but how is that relevant to the differing treatment I’m now seeing?)
  1. Why am I not upset at neighbouring countries, they didn’t help either (again, how is that relevant?)
  1. No exceptions were made for Kosovo, Bosnia etc so the Ukraine exceptions are not based on race (can't argue against that!)

I am very grateful that we were able to find safety in Europe and have a great life, but this seems to be upsetting me more than I can rationally explain.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Why2why · 06/03/2022 21:11

Or who hates black people the most.

Why2why · 06/03/2022 21:10

Western media is Western media. I’m not interested in which country is least or most racist.

CarrieHughes · 06/03/2022 20:54

@Kendodd

Given Europe has a declining birth rate and an ageing population whilst the rest of the world doesn't have this I wonder what they're gonna do This isn't true though. Many, many countries outside of Europe have very low birth rates and aging populations. I read recently that the birth rate in India was now below replacement level.
India doesn't need to 'replace' its population. There are too many people already. The main reason it's an issue (apart from the ageing population) is the constant obsession with GDP driven by the consumerist agenda.

@Why2why what the hell is even 'Western media'? Do you mean Anglophone media (US, UK being the main ones)? French? German?
The rich of the world are global citizens. They don't give a shit about politics. The ones from my country anyway (just like the Russian oligarchs) happily launder money in the UK, give business to 5-star restaurants in London and enjoy jetting around with the proceeds of their thievery.

Everyone else is too busy trying to survive to bother.

And don't get me started on what China thinks of Africans.. google 'anti-black' racism.

The blacker your skin, the blacker your drinking water.. the world is united in its hatred of dark skinned people. Yeah, maybe some of it was colonization but not all. Like India's caste bias.

RoastedFerret · 06/03/2022 19:43

It means we should use the West's new empathy for refugees to make sure than all future refugees, including non-white and non-Christian ones, get the same kind of treatment the Ukrainians have got, or preferably better

The same kind of treatment? Do you think a temp 1-3 year visa is what someone fleeing from Eritrea needs? Or better treatment for all future refugees even the people who apply for asylum from the US and Australia(all of whom had their asylum claim denied in my country last year)? What do you think an asylum seeker from Australia should get that is even better than the treatment Ukrainian refugees are getting? No quibble permanent visas for anyone that declares themselves a refugee? That defeats the purpose of borders at all really doesn't it?

Does it not make more sense to take things on a case by case basis rather than jumping to all asylum seekers should be given better treatment than the Ukranians because it makes for a good sound bite? Incidently in my country 100% of the Syrian, Afghan, Eritrean cases that were heard last year were granted asylum.

Kendodd · 06/03/2022 18:47

Given Europe has a declining birth rate and an ageing population whilst the rest of the world doesn't have this I wonder what they're gonna do
This isn't true though. Many, many countries outside of Europe have very low birth rates and aging populations. I read recently that the birth rate in India was now below replacement level.

Why2why · 06/03/2022 17:24

And it’s not easier to portray anyone as racist. If they are racist they are racist. Period. Looking across the street and pointing at someone else, saying oh but they are racist too and it’s easy for them to say I’m racist, is pointless. One country cannot excuse it’s horrendous treatment of people of colour by these ridiculous excuses of others are racist and how it’s unfair that their own racist behaviour is being exposed. Is there a competition for who is less racist? Is there a competition for who commit more abuses of people of colour and who started it first?

Why2why · 06/03/2022 17:20

[quote User121212121212121212]@Why2why
But Ukraine or Poland isn't West. They never exploited African and Asian countries like UK, France or The Netherlands did. Racism isn't exclusive to those countries, it's a world wide thing. The media focused on those stories because it sells, and because Polish and Ukrainians are regarded in 'West' as second class citizens. They conveniently omitted the amazing acts of kindness that were done by Polish like the story of 22- year old student that took a family of refugees, including four Moroccan students and an Afghan to Warsaw. You don't hear about this stories. Why? Because it's easier to portray Poland or Ukraine as a racist hellhole rather than admit that other countries like UK haven't done anything to help these people.[/quote]
But I did not say Ukraine and Poland are in the West. I referred to Western media AND countries with a culture of racism.

VladmirsPoutine · 06/03/2022 15:48

Given Europe has a declining birth rate and an ageing population whilst the rest of the world doesn't have this I wonder what they're gonna do. Seems like it's gonna be tough out there.

User121212121212121212 · 06/03/2022 14:54

@Why2why
But Ukraine or Poland isn't West. They never exploited African and Asian countries like UK, France or The Netherlands did. Racism isn't exclusive to those countries, it's a world wide thing. The media focused on those stories because it sells, and because Polish and Ukrainians are regarded in 'West' as second class citizens. They conveniently omitted the amazing acts of kindness that were done by Polish like the story of 22- year old student that took a family of refugees, including four Moroccan students and an Afghan to Warsaw. You don't hear about this stories. Why? Because it's easier to portray Poland or Ukraine as a racist hellhole rather than admit that other countries like UK haven't done anything to help these people.

Why2why · 06/03/2022 14:23

[quote User121212121212121212]www.spectator.co.uk/article/the-myopic-focus-on-racism-at-the-polish-ukrainian-border[/quote]
Thanks for sharing. Which is why we all should push hard against such nonsense. It is not narrow and it is perfectly possible to suppress Ukrainians whilst condemning racism.

My worry is that if the western media continues to behave the way they do, and if some countries continue with their culture of f racism, they will find little sympathy with the rest of the world. Quite frankly the west needs rest of the world and the rest of the world like India, China, and Africa are growing closer and their strength is increasing. They will not forget the treachery of the West and how much the West love their wealth but hate them because of the colour of their skin.

missmoon · 06/03/2022 11:45

I’ve seen several people on this thread say that refugees must claim asylum in the first country they reach. That is most definitely NOT the case under international law (as interpreted by both international and domestic courts).

There is an arrangement within the EU for returning refugees to the country where they first claimed asylum (usually the point of entry to the EU), but that no longer applies to us as we’ve left the EU. It also doesn’t apply to Ukrainian refugees (the EU has put in place a separate and much more generous arrangement).

Why2why · 06/03/2022 08:33

Worth listening to this. I’m glad people are creating awareness of this. It’s too blatant and silence is not an option

fb.watch/buEFKdhnBU/

Trainbear · 06/03/2022 07:51

There have been parts of the UK with a large Ukrainian diaspora since Ww2. They are know, and have settling into the local community. Refugees from Iraq/ afghanistan are a more recent phemonena.

Jamboree01 · 05/03/2022 22:38

@fenestrina

My parents both came here as refugees from the Nazis - many pf my relatives were murdered because no country would take in more than a small number of Jews. Israel didn't yet exist.

I'm very glad that the Ukrainians fleeing now are treated better than Jews were then.

Yes, it is racist that Jews from Nazi-occupied Europe, Syrians, and the many other non-white, non-Christian refugees were refused entry to the UK or treated badly. But that doesn't mean we should treat Ukrainians the same as they were treated.

It means we should use the West's new empathy for refugees to make sure than all future refugees, including non-white and non-Christian ones, get the same kind of treatment the Ukrainians have got, or preferably better.

Hopefully better treatment than some of the white Christians in the north of Ireland received too.
fenestrina · 05/03/2022 22:33

My parents both came here as refugees from the Nazis - many pf my relatives were murdered because no country would take in more than a small number of Jews. Israel didn't yet exist.

I'm very glad that the Ukrainians fleeing now are treated better than Jews were then.

Yes, it is racist that Jews from Nazi-occupied Europe, Syrians, and the many other non-white, non-Christian refugees were refused entry to the UK or treated badly. But that doesn't mean we should treat Ukrainians the same as they were treated.

It means we should use the West's new empathy for refugees to make sure than all future refugees, including non-white and non-Christian ones, get the same kind of treatment the Ukrainians have got, or preferably better.

lemongreentea · 05/03/2022 22:30

@myear

Sorry *@BessieFinknottle* for not responding. It started to feel a bit heated and I didn't want to upset any more people by responding particularly on a matter that I don't know as much about as other people, and which would have detracted from my point anyway. I also started losing track of who asked what!

I realise I am not coming across well and didn't want to get people's backs up any further. On this thread, I have been told to admit I hate the Irish, despite saying absolutely nothing to suggest that. I have been told I don’t like the Ukrainians, despite me opening my home to a refugee. I have been questioned whether I am one of Putin’s cyber attackers trying to create negativity for the Ukraine, despite saying nothing negative about Ukraine. I have been told that it was wrong for us to tell lies in order to escape a war, even if telling the truth will lead to the death of an innocent mother and her children. I have been told that the system was correct to turn us away as victims of genocide and war crime, with our house bombed to ashes. Incidentally, the UK Home Office guidelines at the time was that asylum seekers from my country have a credible claim. The country we went to was much closer than the UK and had a different view.

But people have also kindly explained to me why I didn't get the same treatment as the Ukrainians, which has helped me to understand things a bit better. Sometimes when you are consumed by your own pain, it's hard to see things clearly, and AIBU has certainly helped with that!

I'm sorry for those who posted on this thread with their own stories and hope you have a peaceful life now.

FlowersFlowers
SommerTen · 05/03/2022 22:24

Exactly. Ww2 is still within living memory.. I looked after an elderly man the other day who actually had an 80 yr old gunshot wound he got in Europe during Ww2.

BessieFinknottle · 05/03/2022 22:24

Thanks Sometimeswinning.

Thank you too OP. Hope you're okay.

JellybeansJelly · 05/03/2022 22:03

[quote SommerTen]@myear I've come to this thread late and have just read your.opening post.
To me what you are saying about feeling upset at the situation you had to go through in the past compared to that which the Ukrainian refugees will go through is actually quite rational.
I would feel just as upset.

I really really hate to say this but a close relative said to me that seeing Ukrainian civilians getting hurt etc has really upset them. Well, I said, but didn't you feel the same about the Afghans & Syrians?
No, they said, the difference is that the Ukrainians look 'like us' (ie theyre White and dress in western clothes). They should be allowed to come here. What about the other refugees, I asked. Not them, just the Ukrainians, they can settle in easily & do the jobs that need filling they said.

This relative doesn't see themselves as racist mainly because they've had relationships with three Black men.

But they obviously are more racist than I had realised.

I think many British and White Europeans think the same way as my relative sadly regards refugees and where they originate from.

I'm glad you have found a safe home in the UK but I'm sorry it was such a difficult process for you to go through OP.[/quote]
Things like this don’t happen in Europe, it’s reserved for developing nations in Africa and the Middle East.

As though people in those nations are deserving of it. As though it wasn’t Europe that has two world wars in the last 110 years, was embroiled in the Cold War and invaded other countries causing immense loss and suffering, including loss on Europe’s side.

SommerTen · 05/03/2022 21:53

@myear I've come to this thread late and have just read your.opening post.
To me what you are saying about feeling upset at the situation you had to go through in the past compared to that which the Ukrainian refugees will go through is actually quite rational.
I would feel just as upset.

I really really hate to say this but a close relative said to me that seeing Ukrainian civilians getting hurt etc has really upset them. Well, I said, but didn't you feel the same about the Afghans & Syrians?
No, they said, the difference is that the Ukrainians look 'like us' (ie theyre White and dress in western clothes). They should be allowed to come here. What about the other refugees, I asked. Not them, just the Ukrainians, they can settle in easily & do the jobs that need filling they said.

This relative doesn't see themselves as racist mainly because they've had relationships with three Black men.

But they obviously are more racist than I had realised.

I think many British and White Europeans think the same way as my relative sadly regards refugees and where they originate from.

I'm glad you have found a safe home in the UK but I'm sorry it was such a difficult process for you to go through OP.

Jamboree01 · 05/03/2022 21:50

@myear

Sorry *@BessieFinknottle* for not responding. It started to feel a bit heated and I didn't want to upset any more people by responding particularly on a matter that I don't know as much about as other people, and which would have detracted from my point anyway. I also started losing track of who asked what!

I realise I am not coming across well and didn't want to get people's backs up any further. On this thread, I have been told to admit I hate the Irish, despite saying absolutely nothing to suggest that. I have been told I don’t like the Ukrainians, despite me opening my home to a refugee. I have been questioned whether I am one of Putin’s cyber attackers trying to create negativity for the Ukraine, despite saying nothing negative about Ukraine. I have been told that it was wrong for us to tell lies in order to escape a war, even if telling the truth will lead to the death of an innocent mother and her children. I have been told that the system was correct to turn us away as victims of genocide and war crime, with our house bombed to ashes. Incidentally, the UK Home Office guidelines at the time was that asylum seekers from my country have a credible claim. The country we went to was much closer than the UK and had a different view.

But people have also kindly explained to me why I didn't get the same treatment as the Ukrainians, which has helped me to understand things a bit better. Sometimes when you are consumed by your own pain, it's hard to see things clearly, and AIBU has certainly helped with that!

I'm sorry for those who posted on this thread with their own stories and hope you have a peaceful life now.

As one of the posters who questioned your point on Ireland, I have to say I didn’t see a comment telling you to admit that you hate the Irish. I may have missed that. The way you used your point is hurtful to myself and many, many others for a number of reason but I fully accept you may not have understood that.

My life is not at peace no as we are still fighting for truth and justice for two of my own family members- and are supporting thousands of others to do the same.

My door will always be open to anyone no matter where they come from. I would be hesitant if it were a British soldier I can tell you. I wish you well.

JellyBeansJelly · 05/03/2022 21:49

@myear Your posts come across very sincere and I hope you’re ok. I know how painful this subject is.

Unfortunately there are too many people who don’t want to believe that racism exists, and that there is a reason for whatever is happening. These are the people who will try and bring you down by discrediting you and what you say. This is exactly what has happened on this thread. And I’m sorry if it has caused you any upset.

myear · 05/03/2022 21:35

Sorry @BessieFinknottle for not responding. It started to feel a bit heated and I didn't want to upset any more people by responding particularly on a matter that I don't know as much about as other people, and which would have detracted from my point anyway. I also started losing track of who asked what!

I realise I am not coming across well and didn't want to get people's backs up any further. On this thread, I have been told to admit I hate the Irish, despite saying absolutely nothing to suggest that. I have been told I don’t like the Ukrainians, despite me opening my home to a refugee. I have been questioned whether I am one of Putin’s cyber attackers trying to create negativity for the Ukraine, despite saying nothing negative about Ukraine. I have been told that it was wrong for us to tell lies in order to escape a war, even if telling the truth will lead to the death of an innocent mother and her children. I have been told that the system was correct to turn us away as victims of genocide and war crime, with our house bombed to ashes. Incidentally, the UK Home Office guidelines at the time was that asylum seekers from my country have a credible claim. The country we went to was much closer than the UK and had a different view.

But people have also kindly explained to me why I didn't get the same treatment as the Ukrainians, which has helped me to understand things a bit better. Sometimes when you are consumed by your own pain, it's hard to see things clearly, and AIBU has certainly helped with that!

I'm sorry for those who posted on this thread with their own stories and hope you have a peaceful life now.

OP posts: