Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who tuck in before everyone is served - rude?

265 replies

SarahAndQuack · 02/03/2022 22:33

Say you have family/friends over and you are cooking a meal for, say, 8 or 10 people - enough that it takes a bit of time to get on the table. Either you dish it up on plates and pass them out, or you serve everyone at table - you do guests first, of course. Guests tuck in straight away, while everyone else is still being served.

Is that rude?

I was brought up to think you wait for everyone to be served, if it's a sit-down meal.

What do you think?

OP posts:
SamphiretheStickerist · 03/03/2022 09:46

@CadvanTheBard

It is rude, but as the host you should say to tuck in and not wait.
Why?

If all plates are hot and nobody is dying of hunger why shouldn't everyone wait and ensure nobody goes without?

It's far more conducive to chatting, a pleasant atmosphere, if everyone is passing bowls, asking for the gravy etc, at the same time, rather than one or two people eating whilst others are still waiting.

There is nothing polite about a host martyring themselves for rude guests.

TheOriginalEmu · 03/03/2022 09:43

This is why I think I’m broken; why does anyone care? Just eat!

CadvanTheBard · 03/03/2022 09:42

It is rude, but as the host you should say to tuck in and not wait.

TYbakedpotato · 03/03/2022 09:41

The way I've been brought up...

People getting their food first wait.

People without food say, 'You should start, yours is here.'

People with their food continue to wait.

People without food say, 'Seriously, do just start - mine will be here soon, I'm sure. Don't let yours get cold!'

People with their food 'reluctantly' start eating.

There has to be an awkward etiquette dance! A dance is the British way!

FudgeSundae · 03/03/2022 09:40

@RobertSmithsLipstick

It all seems a bit pointless among friends. All looking at the host expectantly, waiting for them to tell you when you may begin.
But if it’s a friend why aren’t you helping the host so that they can sit down and eat too? This is the part I don’t get - either it’s formal, so wait until host lifts their fork, or it’s not, in which case help the host so they can get to eating quicker?
Brefugee · 03/03/2022 09:40

Therefore in institutions (jail, e.g.) and army manouvers waiting doesn't apply.

Eating a full dinner in a mess-tin, main on one side, pudding on the other, is one of the few things i miss about being on exercise Grin

Most people learn to go with the flow. Prison, boarding school, on exercise: get your food, eat it before someone else does, get out

Dinner at home: family rules (my OH comes from a large poor family and it was everyone for themselves at dinner time, he has learned not to wolf food over the time I've known him but when he's with family all rules out of the window)

Our family: wait until everyone is served. If we're using serving dishes, start helping yourself but don't eat until everyone is ready. Never ever take the last of anything without checking if someone else wants it.

And so on and so forth

EliyanahM · 03/03/2022 09:38

With Jewish holidays particularly Pesach (Passover) requiring an entire book to be read before eating, I would also wait till every person was served as I'm used to cold food. If you were a millionaire you could maybe buy plate warming placemats or something.

harriethoyle · 03/03/2022 09:37

Yes OP I think this is terribly rude. Grinds my gears when the kids do it! But not my place to pick them up on their table manners so...

Grinling · 03/03/2022 09:31

@notangelinajolie

Yes it's rude to start eating before everyone has been served.. and why I make sure FIL is always the last to get his Christmas dinner. He'd have wolfed the lot down before I'd finished serving if I didn't. My mum always insisted on table manners and waiting for everyone to be served was a biggie.
My father is a wolfer. Nothing anyone has been able to say over the years changed him, and believe me, I’ve tried. At restaurants he actually grabs the plate out of the waiter’s hand as they’re placing it on the table, and immediately gets stuck in. He eats fast, without speaking between mouthfuls, and has sometimes finished and is sitting there ready to go home by the time other people have taken their first couple of bites. My FIL does the same.

Now, they’re both from large, very poor families where if you didn’t eat quickly, you risked getting nothing, but so are my mother and my MiL, who have somehow absorbed the rudeness of this over the years. It seems that women are more receptive to scripts that overlie their childhood lessons.

SoberSerena · 03/03/2022 09:30

I think it's rude in some circumstances. If it's a roast dinner with loads of different veg, I would prefer people started while everyone was swapping dishes over to get a bit of everything. But that's assuming nobody is overly greedy or a very fast eater who would look for seconds before everyone else has even started their first helping. That's obviously rude.

If it's in a restaurant or a plated meal, I do find it rude that people sometimes start eating before everyone else has food, unless the host says to start.

My late grandmother was like this when she got into her 90s and we didn't comment on it. She was fastidiously polite all her life but when she hit her 90s I think she just couldn't be bothered and fell upon her food as soon as it arrived. Yes, quite rude, but we didn't comment

puffyisgood · 03/03/2022 09:30

I don't feel at all strongly about this one. I personally would tend to wait, but I've never yet been offended by someone just piling in.

warmeduppizza · 03/03/2022 09:30

You wait until everyone is ready to start.

My only exception is when I’ve done the cooking and I’ve put everything on the table and DH decides then that he needs the toilet - then I do start.

BertieQueen · 03/03/2022 09:25

*brought

BertieQueen · 03/03/2022 09:25

I was always brought up that you wait until everyone’s meal is in front of them before starting to eat at home and in restaurants. This also includes starters/dessert as well as the main meal.

I have bought my son up the same.

SamphiretheStickerist · 03/03/2022 09:18

It's rude. MIL used to serve Sunday lunch on hot plates, veggies in hot bowls on the table. She'd be handing out the hot plates with meat on and before she could sit down with her own her golden boy would have his plate in the air asking for more. He would then fill up his plate a second time taking the last roastie, no matter how many there were left.

And he ate like a starving alsatian, using knife and fork to launch food upwards, then chasing it back down to the plate, slobbering and chomping as he went.

I wish I were exaggerating.

In the first few years I would occasionally forget myself and just sit staring at him, repulsed. MIL would smile fondly and everyone else would pretend it wasn't happening.

So definitely rude. Hot plates and good manners make a great family gathering.

phoenixrosehere · 03/03/2022 09:14

*hot

phoenixrosehere · 03/03/2022 09:14

Those of you who just dig in wat do you do if there are serving dishes on the table?*

I don’t dig in when there are serving dishes. I do however dig in when I’m at MILs which I learned to do from my DH. MIL plates everything and by time you get it and everyone finally sits down (Love SIL but she faffs a bit and then there’s a question of seating when it really doesn’t matter, 8 adults and three kids at table), vegetables are lukewarm to cold while meat and potatoes are warm-ish. The gravy is usually the hottest thing on the table and not by much. I didn’t know for awhile that Sunday Roasts were meant to be warm until my DH took me to one in a pub.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 03/03/2022 09:12

It depends entirely on what you have been taught to do. It's rude to you.Presumably it's not to those doing it.

sashh · 03/03/2022 09:12

@TwoLeftSocksWithHoles

Well, the natural way of things is just to dig in...

You don't see lions all waiting for the rest of the pride to assemble around the zebra carcass before starting,
...and I don't think they bother with Grace either.

That's a really bad example.

Mr Big Daddy head of the pride eats first and the others wait their turn.

SarahAndQuack · 03/03/2022 09:11

@Lazypuppy

OP why ask when you clearly think you are right?

I think it is rude to make people wait for everyone to have their food, definitely start eating while its hot. However, i always say that to guests when i hand them their plate, or if we are out in a restaurant.i think you've let people start for too long, you should have said something the first time if it bothers you.

YABU

Grin I asked because I wanted to know if other people thought I was right too!

I did say something the first time - I've got a small daughter and I've always said 'DD, wait until everyone's served'. I'm not going to say anything directly to them; they're adults and although it irritates me, IMO it's rude to say anything directly about other people's manners.

I really, really don't think it is about the food being hot in this case, either.

OP posts:
BoredBoredBoredB · 03/03/2022 09:10

I suppose if everyone has to wait then serve yourself first. Someone at my wedding pointed out that the top table got everything first except the champagne. As everyone waits for the toast, you’re better off being served last - the same logic could apply to hot food.
I don’t know people think serving dishes are a solution.

Fayekrista · 03/03/2022 08:57

I guess it can depend on the meal but typically when my family are all together so 10+ everything's put into serving dishes in the middle of the table & we all plate ourselves up.

Lalliella · 03/03/2022 08:47

The 1970s have called and said you need a hostess trolley! Actually I think they’re fab.

Yes OP I agree it’s rude. But ok if the host says “please start”.

Ivyonafence · 03/03/2022 08:45

I'm also going to be very Mumsnet and say I hate the phrase 'tuck in'

But otherwise, YANBU op

SteakChips · 03/03/2022 08:44

@SarahAndQuack I was brought up with this as well. Guest first then everyone and wait for the last person. Unless I've been told by the person who cooking to tuck in and don't let food go cold.

I think it's a generation possibly culture thing (I'm in my late 30's). I don't think it's in practice now or a bigger deal when I was growing up. Like children asking to the leave the table. Sadly my step sons just up and leave once food is eaten and straight to their phones or PlayStation.