Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who tuck in before everyone is served - rude?

265 replies

SarahAndQuack · 02/03/2022 22:33

Say you have family/friends over and you are cooking a meal for, say, 8 or 10 people - enough that it takes a bit of time to get on the table. Either you dish it up on plates and pass them out, or you serve everyone at table - you do guests first, of course. Guests tuck in straight away, while everyone else is still being served.

Is that rude?

I was brought up to think you wait for everyone to be served, if it's a sit-down meal.

What do you think?

OP posts:
LaChanticleer · 03/03/2022 12:37

Do other countries do this?

Yes. But then my German & French family & friends are also upper-middle class, and brought up with what a lot of you regard as "old-fashioned" manners.

We think of it simply as consideration & respect for others.

Brefugee · 03/03/2022 12:34

I think this does show that the middle-class system just hasn’t been thought through properly.

well, it shows that some people who might count themselves as middle-class haven't read through to the end of the rules which, as has been mentioned here several times, if you think your guests are in danger of eating cold food - you tell them to start.

LaChanticleer · 03/03/2022 12:33

It doesn't take that long to put everything on a normal table...

Well, quite.

And even at largeish formal dinners (or weddings & the like) if the service is good, one of the things they aim for is that each table (in a multiple table room) is served at pretty much the same time. At along dinner table, there should be enough service staff so that people are served almost all simultaneously, or certainly with minimal gaps.

It really isn't a matter of food going cold ... people are overreacting!

LaChanticleer · 03/03/2022 12:29

The upper and working classes tuck in.

Not my upper-middle/upper class experience at all. Formal official public dinners work somewhat differently, but normal family, or informal dinner parties, it is so rude to start eating as soon as you're served.

It just looks greedy - as though you're afraid there won't be enough food. And it means you're not taking notice of your fellow guests, or your host, or your guests (depending on whether you are a guest or a host) to ensure everyone has what they want, and everyone has enough, and is served.

It's about consideration & care for others, not getting as much food as you can down your throat.

Grinling · 03/03/2022 12:28

@TYbakedpotato, I'm Irish, and all those things are absolutely just as Irish. See also the only mildly exaggerated Mrs Doyle in Fr Ted, who bears a distinct resemblance to my mother. who thinks people who refuse a cup of tea are just being polite, because she would refuse a cup of tea just to be polite, so she just serves it anyway because she thinks she's doing what they want but are too polite to say. (And by 'cup of tea', she also tends to mean 'sandwiches, cake, biscuits etc.)

She is absolutely baffled by more direct cultures or individuals who see a refusal as an indication that the person genuinely doesn't want a cup of tea/three-course meal, so they don't keep offering.

I once told her about a student friend of mine who politely refused dessert on her first night as an au pair in France, and was taken aback when it wasn't offered a second time. Nonetheless, she politely refused again the next night, and the next, and after that the family stopped offering because they'd concluded she didn't like sweet stuff. I told this as a joke on my friend, because she's an absolute pig for sweet stuff, but I've heard my mother retell it on numerous occasions as a joke on French people, because imagine not offering and re-offering time after time, night after night. The height of rudeness! Grin

TYbakedpotato · 03/03/2022 12:15

@Grinling

It certainly isn’t just British! And unless there’s some major mess-up, it will usually involve you waiting an extra 30 seconds to a minute.
I'd say the dance is quintessentially British.

Not necessarily encouraging those with food to start, but having to ask twice, because the first time no one follows the command as that's not how the dance works.

Like... the credit card dance if someone is treating you. 'Let me get this.' 'No, no, let me get this. 'No, really, I insist.' 'Oh, okay then, that's very kind, thank you.'

Or... asking how someone is. 'How are you?' 'I'm fine.' 'No, really, how are you?' 'Actually, my arm has just fallen off and I'm about to bleed out, so if you wouldn't mind terribly, could you please call me an ambulance?'

phoenixrosehere · 03/03/2022 12:15

I spent a few years living in USA and Caribbean and it was absolutely the done thing to wait until everyone was served there too.

American here. It’s a regional thing. Third option would be offering to share some of ones food while someone waited if in a restaurant setting so everyone is eating, no one is left out, and everyone got the meal at the temperature they order it for.

BoredBoredBoredB · 03/03/2022 12:12

It’s probably more of a British obsession that food should be hot.
I suppose @SarahAndQuack that you just have to take a detached anthropological view. People have different manners.
It wasn’t something I learnt at home, but it is the norm in the circles I now move in (to wait that is) although I think even my family would tend to wait for everyone to sit down.
I get the impression that it wouldn’t be a long wait in your system so I think that works both ways. They can’t be much ahead of you.
I absolutely agree that tackling other people’s rudeness head on is bad manners. I also do understand how upsetting bad manners can be even if it’s something not particularly rational.

AtLeastThreeDrinks · 03/03/2022 12:06

Really rude, I never eat with anyone who’d start before everyone is served (unless encouraged to dig in). It’s a sociable thing, the main purpose it to be convivial, not to shove food down your gullet at record speed.

I also hate eating when everyone else has finished. Went for lunch with friends the other week and someone’s meal didn’t come out – she encouraged us to start, which we did, but we all ate very slowly so she wasn’t eating alone!

lockdownalli · 03/03/2022 12:02

How would your food get cold in the time it takes for a few more plates to land or be loaded? Do you eat your food in that timeframe too?

I spent a few years living in USA and Caribbean and it was absolutely the done thing to wait until everyone was served there too.

LampLighter414 · 03/03/2022 12:02

At home with family and (close) friends - who cares

In a restaurant I would generally wait but have to consider the vibe and group consensus at the table. Sometimes when service is slow someone waiting for food usually speaks up and encourages people to tuck in and everyone else is quick to agree. Nobody really wants to let their food go cold...

Grinling · 03/03/2022 11:59

It certainly isn’t just British! And unless there’s some major mess-up, it will usually involve you waiting an extra 30 seconds to a minute.

ofwarren · 03/03/2022 11:55

@lockdownalli

I am so shocked at the number of people who don't know this is really rude!

I feel SOOOO OLLLLLDDDD!!!!!!

It's nothing to do with 'knowing' it's rude. It's a silly bit of British etiquette that I think is pointless.
Who would want to wait till their food is cold before starting to eat?
What's the benefit of it?
Do other countries do this?

lockdownalli · 03/03/2022 11:47

I am so shocked at the number of people who don't know this is really rude!

I feel SOOOO OLLLLLDDDD!!!!!!

thegreylady · 03/03/2022 11:29

I was taught never to let hot food get cold. It isn’t rude to start eating as soon as you are served as long as you don’t take take large portions of ‘serve yourself’ dishes.

beenaroundtheblox · 03/03/2022 11:27

@FixTheBone

Terrible, I often cook, literally 4 or 5 hours for my inlaws / extended family (usually about 16 people).

I'm sick of cooking it to perfection, timing it so everything comes out simultaneously with hot plates and serving dishes, and sitting down to find I sometimes don't even get a share.

You're not making enough food 😂 No really I agree with you, I always wait but as a host I always try to get guests to start. Takes the pressure off me a bit.
MaMaLa321 · 03/03/2022 11:26

It's rude, unless the server specifically asks you to start.
I really don't like serving food out, then sitting down to eat and having some greedy bugger sitting there with an empty plate, waiting for 2nd portions. Plus, the whole point of a meal is to enjoy the food together.

doingitforyorkshire · 03/03/2022 11:26

@Babdoc

I agree (reluctantly) it is polite to wait until all are served. But I always suffered cold food under this policy! MIL was formal, and when all 18 of the extended family were gathered for a meal, I (as eldest female in law) was always served first. By the time she reached the 18th plate, mine had congealed… sigh.
I would hate this to happen if I hosted. A lot of effort for someone to then have to eat congealed cold food and an unhappy, hungry guest too.
Sceptre86 · 03/03/2022 11:24

I hate people putting my dinner on a plate for me. They either over or under estimate how much I want to eat. Use serving dishes if you have them and let me serve myself. I would normally wait yo start eating. I don't do this at home though, kids are welcome to eat straight away.

littlepeas · 03/03/2022 11:23

@Nutellaonall

It’s a class thing isn’t it? The upper and working classes tuck in. The middle classes wait.
Upper class definitely wait!
doingitforyorkshire · 03/03/2022 11:19

I would hate any guest to have to eat a meal gone cold. I want them to enjoy the food at its best, I would be cooking for them to enjoy it so why wouldn't I let them just dig in and enjoy it hot and fresh?
Also, If my meal was the last one to arrive I would feel awful making others wait to the point I would again insist they dig in and enjoy their food.

caringcarer · 03/03/2022 11:18

I have heated hostess thing that goes on table plugged into electric. Everything is kept really hot and asks guests and family to help themselves. If I am put at a function dinner and it is waiter service I get really annoyed if waiters bring half of table their meals then disappear for for ages before bring the rest of tables meals. Everyone sits around waiting and half the table end up with cold meals.

Pyewhacket · 03/03/2022 11:17

@fairylightsandwaxmelts

I'd rather people started eating than potentially ended up with cold food.
Absolutely. Otherwise you just have a queue for the microwave.
MrsTimRiggins · 03/03/2022 11:17

Oh I find it so rude, and my husbands family are terrible for it. That being said, if the host says to start, then that’s fine, but it’s when people fall on their plates like they’re starving when only one or two have been served so far!

Topseyt · 03/03/2022 11:16

Hosts who expect guests to wait while their food goes cold while they (the host) fart about for ages are the rude ones.

My MIL would fart about for ages when she was hosting - tidying up the kitchen, emptying and reloading the dishwasher. She rarely just sat down to eat with her guests. You soon learned to just get on with your food and ignore the faffing.