Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who tuck in before everyone is served - rude?

265 replies

SarahAndQuack · 02/03/2022 22:33

Say you have family/friends over and you are cooking a meal for, say, 8 or 10 people - enough that it takes a bit of time to get on the table. Either you dish it up on plates and pass them out, or you serve everyone at table - you do guests first, of course. Guests tuck in straight away, while everyone else is still being served.

Is that rude?

I was brought up to think you wait for everyone to be served, if it's a sit-down meal.

What do you think?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hydrate · 04/03/2022 05:17

@Ragruggers

Yes,rude unless the host says please start or the food will get cold.It takes a while to serve 8 people.
Agree.
MangyInseam · 04/03/2022 03:28

@Pedalpushers

Is there an actual reason for wanting people to wait other than 'etiquette'?

I am all for etiquette when it enhances a social experience but I HATE petty rules for the sake of it. It's a form of social control, keeping people in their place by making 'proper' society full of inaccessible rules.

And frankly, when someone has got their dinner and is sitting there refusing to start, all I can think is, you're making ME feel uncomfortable because your food is going cold and there's nothing I can do to fix the situation.

So the host can sit down and eat with you. So some people haven't finished while other people have empty plates.
KosherDill · 04/03/2022 03:15

@Grinling

Are you all eating soufflés in particularly draughty igloos, such is the concern at food getting col?

Exactly! Just how cold does food get in 3 or 4 minutes??

KosherDill · 04/03/2022 03:14

@Pedalpushers

Is there an actual reason for wanting people to wait other than 'etiquette'?

I am all for etiquette when it enhances a social experience but I HATE petty rules for the sake of it. It's a form of social control, keeping people in their place by making 'proper' society full of inaccessible rules.

And frankly, when someone has got their dinner and is sitting there refusing to start, all I can think is, you're making ME feel uncomfortable because your food is going cold and there's nothing I can do to fix the situation.

Well, for one thing, a gathering ostensibly is about the socializing, not the opportunity for free food. If one is so anxious to shovel it in that one cannot converse and hold out until all are served, perhaps one should just stay home and focus on eating with no distractions.

Second, it's always rude to partake in something your companions don't have. Is it really that difficult to restrain for a few minutes until all are served?

Pedalpushers · 04/03/2022 01:38

Is there an actual reason for wanting people to wait other than 'etiquette'?

I am all for etiquette when it enhances a social experience but I HATE petty rules for the sake of it. It's a form of social control, keeping people in their place by making 'proper' society full of inaccessible rules.

And frankly, when someone has got their dinner and is sitting there refusing to start, all I can think is, you're making ME feel uncomfortable because your food is going cold and there's nothing I can do to fix the situation.

TooOldToBeAGoth · 04/03/2022 00:41

Yes, at a sit down dinner you wait until everyone is served and seated

capstix · 04/03/2022 00:31

Yes - formally one should wait until everyone has been served before eating. I'd argue, however, that a good host will overlook the ignorance of a guest. My mother always told me that if you see a guest drinking their finger bowl, you should immediately do the same to put them at their ease. At one formal lunch I was at, a young teenager cut into a roast potato which, being brittle, flew off the table onto the floor. My uncle immediately said, "Don't worry, Tom! Catch!" and threw him one of his. It got everyone laughing and saved the boy's embarrassment. It helped that he caught it.

ukborn · 03/03/2022 22:22

Yes it is. But the host would probably tell the first few people to start while it's hot.
Better to organise it so the food is able to be quickly served (like cut up the roast before bringing it to table), and people can pass different dishes around to help themselves.

PriamFarrl · 03/03/2022 22:20

@Grinling

Are you all eating soufflés in particularly draughty igloos, such is the concern at food getting col?
I was thinking that. If the plates are warm and the room not a freezer I can’t see how the food is going to be so cold after a minute.
Grinling · 03/03/2022 21:43

Are you all eating soufflés in particularly draughty igloos, such is the concern at food getting col?

Babymamaroon · 03/03/2022 21:28

I was brought up to never wait, as it would allow food to go cold, thus being an insult to the cook.

Nowadays, someone will always say please start before it gets cold etc.

That said, depending on the setting, I would wait until my dinner companion had their food before I began.

AreWeThereYetMummy · 03/03/2022 16:23

Life is too short to worry about this kind of thing!

Bayleaf25 · 03/03/2022 15:38

I would always wait as a guest, but as a host I would always urge people to start before it gets cold.

BogRollBOGOF · 03/03/2022 15:33

I'd assume that I'm waiting for everyone to be served unless told otherwise.

In a restaurant you may need to be encouraged to start if one meal is slow to be served.
At larger events it's normally one table at a time.
In a house, there's not normally the capacity to accommodate a large enough number at one table in one sitting to make cold food too big an issue.

When eating with company, it's as much a social purpose as getting nutrition.

Twinsforthewin · 03/03/2022 15:19

Seem to remember reading an Edwardian etiquette book that said if it's more than 8 at the table you start as soon as your food arrives/is served, otherwise the people who got served first have to eat cold food (not being melodramatic, but I think we can all agree cold food is the worst thing ever)

Fewer than 8, YANBU, it's SO rude and does my head in, but up to you whether you want to call people out on it

Warm plates help with everything

SartresSoul · 03/03/2022 13:31

It’s best to wait until everyone has been served but it isn’t always reasonable to do so if their meal is taking much longer than yours, you’d just end up with cold food. I’d honestly rather everyone else start eating than leave their food to go cold waiting for mine.

justmaybenot · 03/03/2022 13:26

It's absolutely not just a British or English thing. Nor necessarily a class thing. The number of people on here who think that upper/middle class English people have a monopoly on politeness or set the standard for others is so embarrassing! It's really not that likely that food will go stone cold in a domestic setting.
I've lived in a number of different countries including USA, NZ, Ireland, England, Spain, Greece, Singapore and it's generally accepted that if someone cooks you a meal then you wait until everyone is at the table and everyone starts eating together. In most cultures, the point of eating together is not that everyone gets their meal at some optimum red hot temperature, but the actual social ritual of eating together.

Donson · 03/03/2022 13:15

It’s not rude but also polite for the host to say to go ahead.

MangyInseam · 03/03/2022 13:11

[quote Grinling]@TYbakedpotato, I'm Irish, and all those things are absolutely just as Irish. See also the only mildly exaggerated Mrs Doyle in Fr Ted, who bears a distinct resemblance to my mother. who thinks people who refuse a cup of tea are just being polite, because she would refuse a cup of tea just to be polite, so she just serves it anyway because she thinks she's doing what they want but are too polite to say. (And by 'cup of tea', she also tends to mean 'sandwiches, cake, biscuits etc.)

She is absolutely baffled by more direct cultures or individuals who see a refusal as an indication that the person genuinely doesn't want a cup of tea/three-course meal, so they don't keep offering.

I once told her about a student friend of mine who politely refused dessert on her first night as an au pair in France, and was taken aback when it wasn't offered a second time. Nonetheless, she politely refused again the next night, and the next, and after that the family stopped offering because they'd concluded she didn't like sweet stuff. I told this as a joke on my friend, because she's an absolute pig for sweet stuff, but I've heard my mother retell it on numerous occasions as a joke on French people, because imagine not offering and re-offering time after time, night after night. The height of rudeness! Grin[/quote]
A good friend of mine, who is quite thin naturally, spent a year in Africa as a student living in a tiny village. When she came back she was positively fat, because the one thing you did not do was refuse offered food. Or seconds. And wherever she went, people offered it. She said the day she left she ate seven full meals.

MangyInseam · 03/03/2022 13:09

It's nothing to do with 'knowing' it's rude. It's a silly bit of British etiquette that I think is pointless.
Who would want to wait till their food is cold before starting to eat?
What's the benefit of it?
Do other countries do this?

It's absolutely the norm in a great many places, not just the UK and not just the English speaking world. In some places it would be even less acceptable.

The "benefit" is that it acknowledges that eating is a communal bonding activity as well as about fueling the body, it acknowledges the host, and in a lot of cases it means people won't be half finished eating before the cook gets to sit down and eat too.

Usually food doesn't go cold in a 5 minute span.

stripeyflowers · 03/03/2022 13:06

Brought up to politely wait until all served no matter how long it took or that your meal was now cold. If I'm out with a group now I'll wait a certain length of time but if it becomes obvious the food will likely be getting cold by the time the time the last person is served I would begin to eat. Most people want to but daren't look rude but will then follow suit of someone else starts. If I was hosting I would tell people tuck in as seems a waste of money and effort to have food eaten cold.

123becauseicouldntthinkofone · 03/03/2022 13:01

@Ragruggers

Yes,rude unless the host says please start or the food will get cold.It takes a while to serve 8 people.
This
LaChanticleer · 03/03/2022 12:50

*which, as has been mentioned here several times, if you think your guests are in danger of eating cold food - you tell them to start8

Of course one does this! It's about making guests feel comfortable, but making sure everyone is comfortable, not just the person who's served first!

BoredBoredBoredB · 03/03/2022 12:47

@Brefugee

I think this does show that the middle-class system just hasn’t been thought through properly.

well, it shows that some people who might count themselves as middle-class haven't read through to the end of the rules which, as has been mentioned here several times, if you think your guests are in danger of eating cold food - you tell them to start.

I still feel that there’s an intrinsic lack of logic to serving people in order of precedence if the default is to all start at the same time unless there’s an explicit instruction from the host.
eastegg · 03/03/2022 12:46

@dfendyr

Neap?? Meal
I thought you were Scottish and meant a turnip!
Swipe left for the next trending thread