Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I not try to prevent a fire?

82 replies

hdjdjehhdhdvsv · 02/03/2022 21:18

I have always been scared of dying in a fire. It's my main fear and to mitigate this fear and help me feel safe (also because its something I was told to do by the fireman who visited our school) I keep a towel and bottles of water in the bedrooms so if a fire does break out, I can soak the towel and put it against the door to stop the smoke coming in.

fire extinguishers wouldn't be able to stop smoke coming into the bedrooms so that's not an option.

DH has said he's sick of seeing bottles of water everywhere, it's 2 under our bed hardly loads. I haven't got any in the children's room for obvious reasons but I feel bad and might stick some on top of the wardrobe just incase. They mostly sleep in my room anyway though so it's not a big deal.

I have said I'm not getting rid of them because it's hardly an invasion of space sat under the bed, and it could save our lives if a fire broke out.

Aibu to keep water under the bed?

Yabu - you don't need water and towels
yanbu - better safe than sorry

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LampLighter414 · 03/03/2022 12:19

This sounds irrational to me.

You don't seem to have answered questions on if you have anything else arranged 'just in case' whether that is for a fire or other things you worry about.

Rory1234 · 03/03/2022 12:03

My family had a serious house fire when I was a child so I am very fire safety conscious - we have smoke alarms and fire safety ladders tucked under beds in the upstairs rooms that can be used as an escape route from upstairs windows.

I had a fireman friend come round to advise and he said by far the biggest issue they see is no smoke alarms or smoke alarms where the batteries have run out. I test ours on the first day of every month.

If it’s something you are worried about, having an escape route planned and making sure your children know it when they’re old enough is your best bet (the fact my parents had a plan to get us out of the upstairs in the even of a fire saved my life as a child).

Sirzy · 03/03/2022 12:01

But your not taking the sensible measures. You have become obsessed with one tiny measure which realistically won’t be a massive help.

It’s fire alarms and properly planned escape routes which saves lives not a bottle of water and a towel

AgathaX · 03/03/2022 11:20

I think your bottles of water are harmless, and good if they give you some peace of mind.
Please fit some more smoke detectors though. We have them in most rooms of the house. I think these days with things like phones being on charge overnight etc, they're essential in bedrooms.

MorningStarling · 03/03/2022 10:42

What's your plan for when the children no longer want to sleep in the same room as you? Presumably if there's a fire you're not going to just douse your towels in water and block yourself in your bedroom, you might want to check the children are OK first. Going out of your room to collect them might mean going through the fire.

I think you should get a fire extinguisher or two in your bedroom in case you need to get out. CO2 extinguishers are my personal preference but powder is an acceptable choice too.

And as PP said, get one of those roll-out ladders. It's more important to plan your escape than to expect to be rescued. In normal circumstances the fire brigade will probably get to you in time, but what if there are unusual circumstances - a riot or bomb attack for instance - which means dozens or hundreds of properties are on fire at the same time. Most people who haven't escaped themselves will not be rescued in time because the fire service will not be able to cope.

PS. Good idea about keeping the "weapons" in the bedroom. It's important to do it like you have, having things like a paperweight that have an innocent explanation for being there. When you disable your attacker with a baseball bat you'll probably end up in a lot of trouble yourself unless you can convince the court there was a good reason for it being under your bed - much easier to explain a paperweight being on your bedside table.

RitaFires · 03/03/2022 10:40

I'm very aware of the risk of fire, I have interlinked mains wired fire alarms that use sirens and voice. Plus a fire extinguisher and fire blanket in the kitchen.

I've never heard of putting wet towels under the door, I would rather get out of my house if it were on fire.

It does sound like you're very preoccupied with fire risk but your plan isn't the most advisable for your current circumstances. Make a new plan for your current home it might relieve your anxiety a bit.

TempName01 · 03/03/2022 10:31

Hi OP, did you know you can buy fire safety ladders which you can clip on the window and roll out, you can buy them on Amazon!

hdjdjehhdhdvsv · 03/03/2022 10:22

thank you so much dotdoo
i will keep a toothpaste just incase, I suppose that would work the same as lipstick
and eyes shut is a good idea too.

but I can't believe so many people are saying I'm anxious. I spent almost a decade 10 floors up. in that time grenfel Tower happened and also a block up the road caught fire and 2 families had to move. as well as a small electrical fire started in my kitchen (very small, it burnt a teatowel and there were no actual flames) from a faulty plug socket.

Several of my neighbours had gas heater things even though you aren't allowed them in aassove block of flats but they are cheap to run so lots did anyway.

Fires do happen. I am very aware. DH things as we live in a house now, not a flat, the bottles and towel is unnecessary BUT I think there is no harm, you never know what happens and its a small way to comfort myself.
lots of people wouldn't want their families or children to be burnt alive and this was a tip from a fire man remember. Not just rogue me, running around fighting flames with 4 litres of stale water.

OP posts:
ThatsALotOfPassionfruit · 03/03/2022 10:14

Well if you’ve got no smoke alarm upstairs your bottles of water are actually useless.

I agree it’s less the bottles of water themselves and more the anxiety around it all.

CognitiveDissolver · 03/03/2022 08:24

Quick question, why do i need therapy for putting water and a towel in my room incase of a fire? would you feel the same if it was a fire extinguisher or a smoke alarm? what is the difference?

Because its demonstrating slightly illogical, possibly paranoid thinking.

Its illogical because you don't have mains linked smoke alarms with battery back up, a fire action plan, knowledge of any PAT tests on appliances, checking labels for fire retardent materials, and it would be a lot easier to have a fire blanket instead of bottles of water on top of wardrobes that you almost certainly wouldn't be able to reach in the panic of a fire and wouldn't provide sufficient water to soak a towel.

I'm also intrigued about where you lived previously not having a bedroom window? Now that is a genuine fire risk but you don't live there any more and most fire brigades consider an opening window that an adult can fit through to be an adequate safety option.

ClitorisAllsorts · 03/03/2022 07:35

OP, why don’t you request a Home Fire Safety Visit from you local Fire Service? I know you said you’d had one in your old flat but if you’re in a house now your escape plan will look very different, and they can help you formulate or refine that. Also they will know the general response times in your area, also fire safety advice changes and moves on, so you may find they have more up to date advice for you and be in your property so be able to give specific prevention as well as protection advise to you.

KindlyKanga · 03/03/2022 07:20

I'd sort out the fire alarm situation. If your partner things you're over the top for that them you know it's him not you with the issue.

mnnewbie111 · 03/03/2022 07:17

Loving all the cool kids who suggest you need therapy for being sensible, you're all so chilled, you're amazing

WildfirePonie · 03/03/2022 07:03

Sounds good. We have a fire extinguisher in the hall and a fire blanket.

Better to be safe than dead.

Sirzy · 03/03/2022 06:41

It does sound as if your letting your anxiety rule a bit here. I get it I really do but it’s not healthy.

NarrowHippedVixen · 03/03/2022 06:32

I wonder if you could also buy a heavy decorative draft excluder to quickly wedge up against the doors, instead of the "opening bottles of water and grabbing a towel" idea?

NarrowHippedVixen · 03/03/2022 06:28

As others have said, my guess is that it's the phobia and anxiety that's upsetting your husband OP, not the bottles themselves.

If you want some extra reassurance beyond fire extinguishers, we live in a third floor flat and have a fire escape ladder that goes out of the window (theoretically - never actually practiced and I do wonder if in a real situation we'd just panic and have to jump).

Having some bottles of water around is good from a prepping point of view - we've had our water cut off accidentally before so we always have a couple of big bottles around.

Selttan · 03/03/2022 06:07

I don't see the harm and it's not like they are on full display.

I requested a fire blanket for Christmas from my parents to keep in the kitchen and they didn't think anything of it - just bought it for me.

Suzi888 · 03/03/2022 05:45

@HirplesWithHaggis

I think a number of people are imagining the water is to tackle the fire, whereas I understand it to be used to soak the towel and block the bottom of the door to prevent smoke coming in.
Confused then what? You planning to smell the smoke /see flames, grab children (panicking and probably can’t see due to the smoke) barricade yourself in the bedroom with a wet towel and wait it out?

The fumes would probably get you first but if a bottle of water makes you feel better, go for it.

I find it bonkers personally. If there’s a fire you get out, you don’t faff about with bottles of water and towels.

TracyMosby · 03/03/2022 05:42

I think it is probably your anxiety that is stressing out your husband, not the two bottles of water.

But for someone who is so afraid of a fire, you've hardly anything actually useful.

I agree that you should have the fire brigade round and fit smoke detectors. Gets extinguishers. Don't faff about with bottles of water everywhere.

Myturnatlast · 03/03/2022 05:39

You do know this won't actually prevent a fire don't you? It'll just delay smoke entering your room, giving you time. From the title of your thread it read like you thought this would prevent it?

labyrinthlaziness · 03/03/2022 05:34

People are attacking the op because they have problems with this issue imo. Deep down we all fear fire, for good reason, we just don't think about it. Most of us have smoke alarms and they are our talisman.

I see nothing wrong with the bottles of water, it harms no one. Whether it is really helpful is another matter.

I turn all plugs, except the fridge, every night. Maybe I need CBT too!

I do agree the op should get up to date fire advice and have a proper plan. An upstairs smoke alarm is essential.

Hibye23289 · 03/03/2022 05:32

I get it but i hope you're not showing your kids anxiety and passing it onto them

Clymene · 03/03/2022 05:23

Aren't you going to want to open her door to get to your children? I have smoke detectors wired in upstairs and downstairs and a planned escape route.

PinkSyCo · 03/03/2022 05:15

I really don’t see the problem with you keeping a couple of bottles of water under your bed. If it bothers your husband so much maybe he’s the one that needs therapy not you. Confused