Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Somebody explain why Russians believe Ukraine is part or Russia....

192 replies

jobhunter7 · 02/03/2022 20:58

I know it used to be part of the Russian Empire. But do they believe the same about Poland or Finland which were too? And what other former parts of the USSR do they believe to be still basically Russia.

OP posts:
MrsSkylerWhite · 03/03/2022 08:28

RedWingBoots

MrsSkylerWhite
Crimea is not Ukraine?
It is Ukraine.

Borders in countries change all the time but the population of that part of the country needs to agree to the change, and then it has to be recognised internationally.“

I know. Hence the question mark. I put it badly.

AhNowTed · 03/03/2022 08:24

@merrymouse

This level of ignorance about Ireland fucking angers me.

The example is completely hypothetical and there is no suggestion that it would be justified.

“There is no evidence that Ireland is going to do so, but the suggestion has been made.”

“After all, they have no intention of illegally annexing NI. They are an independent country; the UK has no right to invade.”

The idea that Ireland would be "illegally annexing NI" 🙄

I understand it was a hypothetical post, but it's completely skewed in favour of the original aggressor, and comparisons to Ukraine are completely off.

WizardOfAus · 03/03/2022 08:02

[quote EmpressaurusWitchDoesntBurn]I read this that explained the background. www.chathamhouse.org/2021/11/ukraine-russia-relations[/quote]
Thanks for this useful link!

merrymouse · 03/03/2022 08:00

This level of ignorance about Ireland fucking angers me.

The example is completely hypothetical and there is no suggestion that it would be justified.

“There is no evidence that Ireland is going to do so, but the suggestion has been made.”

“After all, they have no intention of illegally annexing NI. They are an independent country; the UK has no right to invade.”

SoupGiveMeSoup · 03/03/2022 07:54

Putin wrote an article titled "On The Historical Unity of Russians and Ukrainians" where he argues that Russians and the Ukraine are one people "of what is essentially the same historical and spiritual space" that the division between the two countries is due to a deliberate effort by those forces who have always sought to undermine our unity. He basically blames the West.

The most telling line in the article is

"that the demise of the Soviet Union was the greatest geopolitical catastrophe of the century. As for the Russian people, it became a genuine tragedy. Tens of millions of our fellow citizens and countrymen found themselves beyond the fringes of Russian territory"

Not WWII but the collapse of the USSR as the biggest catastrophe.

There is a really good talk from Cambridge University King's College politics department about the US's involvement and why Putin has invaded well worth a a watch or listen.

AhNowTed · 03/03/2022 07:47

@YouSayYesISayNo

I agree with likening it with the Ireland/NI/UK scenario.

Suppose the UK decided there was a danger that Ireland would take NI by force (because it used to be part of Ireland). There is no evidence that Ireland is going to do so, but the suggestion has been made.

So the UK decides to invade Ireland. They are going to cleanse the island of Ireland from Irish Nationalists who want a United Ireland. They send in troops to take Dublin and Cork, and spread out to the whole island. They are liberating the unionists (in the north) by neutralising the threat that Ireland might take over NI.

Obviously Ireland would be pretty pissed off. After all, they have no intention of illegally annexing NI. They are an independent country; the UK has no right to invade.

I really hope that in that situation NATO would step in (despite Ireland not being a member) and tell the UK to fuck off Hmm

You have got this so backward it's unbelievable.

This level of ignorance about Ireland fucking angers me.

And by the way, any wanting to read up on Putin and Ukraine, I'd suggest this

www.politico.com/news/magazine/2022/02/28/world-war-iii-already-there-00012340

WhathaveIdoneagain · 03/03/2022 07:34

@FrothyB Well put.

merrymouse · 03/03/2022 07:27

I don’t know how well comparisons to Ireland stand up, but that example does demonstrate how difficult it is to rule without consent.

valerianaofficiana · 03/03/2022 06:35

@eatsleep... there are not so many cultural similarities between Baltic countries and Russia/ Slavic ones.
The ethnic Russians who live there were sent by Stalin to replace the parts of native populace who were killed by the Red Army or sent to Gulags.

valerianaofficiana · 03/03/2022 06:30

@aramox not according to his speeches, Putin wants to unite the Great Russia, containing Russia, Belarus - already in its pocket - and Ukraine, ass Slavic countries.
He has also alluded to the Great Russian Empire but never to ussr.

DottyDoge · 03/03/2022 05:38

Crimea was always Russian. It was historically not part of Ukraine, but Khrushchev gifted crimea to Ukraine in 1954 thinking this would just be a formality (given that it was all USSR) but when Ukraine became independent, Crimea went with it.

If you want to be historical about it, it's the other way around (according to a show on BBC Radio the other day). What is now Crimean was a part / satellite of the Kievan Rus which existed before Russia. What is now Crimea became part of the Russian empire at the end of the 18th Century, and as others pointed out, was given to Ukraine in 1954.

So, it's not correct to say Crimea was always Russian.

Even so, none of that gives anyone a right to invade anyone.

newusername1977 · 03/03/2022 04:45
Not sure if this link will work, it's long but really interesting, helped me understand a lot
Usernameinsponeeded · 03/03/2022 03:51

I’m Russian and I don’t think this. Please don’t paint an entire nation with one brush...

mathanxiety · 03/03/2022 03:18

Who people feel connected to in terms of national identity is not always as simple as modern borders, language and religion often have a lot to do with it. Those things are tangible while lines on a map can be abstract and arbitrary.

I think this point needs to be emphasised. Borders are not static, even within the islands off the northwest coast.

www.visualcapitalist.com/2400-years-of-european-history/
This is an animation of Europe's ever-changing boundaries and borders from 400BC to the present day.

fallfallfall · 03/03/2022 02:38

@jobhunter7,
I found this a helpful video
m.youtube.com/watch?v=nK-yJD_fAtk

MangyInseam · 03/03/2022 02:33

There are in fact pro-Russia people in Ukraine. Just as at one time there were pro-Russia people in Finland (I don't know if there are any now.) Who people feel connected to in terms of national identity is not always as simple as modern borders, language and religion often have a lot to do with it. Those things are tangible while lines on a map can be abstract and arbitrary.

Keep in mind that there are many many Russian speaking households in Ukraine, I believe it is almost half. There is also a split between people who are Ukrainian Catholic and Russian Orthodox and I think somewhat more of the latter, which means they have a connection to the Russian Patriarch who is very pro-Russia as you might expect. It would be very easy for Putin and other Russians to think of people who have Russian as a cradle tongue and who are Orthodox as their own people.

mathanxiety · 03/03/2022 01:44

I think of it like Northern Ireland and the UK in a broad sense. Some want a united ireland and some don’t. Putin wants a united USSR.

Or alternatively, some want a chunk of Ireland to be in the UK and some do not.

ThymePoultice · 03/03/2022 01:18

[quote Horological]@XelaM can you explain why the history of Crimea is relevant? Putin has not invaded Crimea he has invaded the whole of Ukraine.[/quote]
He seized Crimea 8 years ago.

BitOutOfPractice · 03/03/2022 01:07

@zoeFromCity I didn’t say I thought they’d be a great target. I said that Putin believes, in his shady brain, that they are not “real” countries and he’d like them back under Russian control. Who knows what stupid decisions he might make. I mean, a few short weeks ago who’d have thought he’d actually invade another sovereign state.

YouSayYesISayNo · 03/03/2022 00:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

zoeFromCity · 03/03/2022 00:38

Latvia, Estonia and Lithuania are NATO members, and NATO (or specifically Poland, US, Turkey and rest of EU) are now up and ready to do something, so not a great target.

If Ukraine went well for Russia, Moldova or officialy adding Belarus would be more probable targets.

BitOutOfPractice · 03/03/2022 00:15

I believe Latvia, Estonia and Lithuania are next on Putin’s list of “not really countries” he’d like to see back in the Russian fold. He is a megalomaniac

BitOutOfPractice · 03/03/2022 00:14

*someone

BitOutOfPractice · 03/03/2022 00:13

[quote Horological]@XelaM can you explain why the history of Crimea is relevant? Putin has not invaded Crimea he has invaded the whole of Ukraine.[/quote]
You know that Russia annexed (euphemism for invaded) the Crimea in 2014. And that, at that time, Crimea was a part of the Ukrainian state. That was his toe in the water. Now he’s going in full throttle.

It’s a bit like done one invading Kent and taking it over before coming back for the whole of the UK.

DoorWasAJar · 03/03/2022 00:09

From Wikipedia, might be of interest

Somebody explain why Russians believe Ukraine is part or Russia....
Swipe left for the next trending thread