Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Somebody explain why Russians believe Ukraine is part or Russia....

192 replies

jobhunter7 · 02/03/2022 20:58

I know it used to be part of the Russian Empire. But do they believe the same about Poland or Finland which were too? And what other former parts of the USSR do they believe to be still basically Russia.

OP posts:
merrymouse · 03/03/2022 11:58

All it might take though is a committed narcissist on one side or the other with a glory complex to decide to stoke up tension.

Agree

Thereisnolight · 03/03/2022 11:57

@mathanxiety

I think of it like Northern Ireland and the UK in a broad sense. Some want a united ireland and some don’t. Putin wants a united USSR.

Or alternatively, some want a chunk of Ireland to be in the UK and some do not.

Feelings still grumble on re Northern Ireland with a few hardliners on both sides. But the vast majority on both sides prioritise their ability to simply walk safely by the sea (which was here long before any of us snd will be here long after we’ve all left) above whatever colour flag may have been hung up over one building. All it might take though is a committed narcissist on one side or the other with a glory complex to decide to stoke up tension. Currently the average NI citizen has less than zero interest in a war regardless of their flag preference - a result of their elders on both sides making the decision to bite their lips and swallow their pride and let things go - but I must admit I was taken aback talking to some Polish colleagues re the depth of their rage and willingness to fight. The mindset in this generation over there is different to what we’ve become used to here. One Polish person said to me that we lived in paradise and could never understand.
merrymouse · 03/03/2022 11:55

Ukraine only split off from Russia as a separate sovereign nation a century ago.

Many (most?) countries in Europe didn’t exist in their current form 100 years ago. That isn’t unusual.

jojojane · 03/03/2022 11:51

@IvorCutler

Yes *@jojane*, that’s what I was getting at with my comment. I live in Ireland. I’m also gobsmacked by the level of ignorance.
Irish, living in England. I'm often gobsmacked at how little people know about NI, and make zero attempt to learn, yet when it suits their narrative, they feel they have a right to comment. And usually those comments are insulting and disrespectful. And incorrect!

I understand the comparison was hypothetical, I get that. But the way in which it has been worded, shows a deep ignorance to the actual difficulties and history of Ireland. So why make an example of a real situation you know nothing about, I just don't understand.

EmpressCixi · 03/03/2022 11:49

Can’t really compare U.K. and Ireland to Russia and Ukraine. This is because Ireland started out a fully independent country, ethnicity and language. The invasion of Ireland occurred when England’s Norman invaders expanded from England into invading Wales, Ireland and Scotland (as well as constant wars with France to hold on to their French territories and duchies). So that’s a foreign Norman power invading & conquering England and then invading the surrounding different kingdoms of the British Isles.

Ukraine started out as the original Russian kingdom in the 400s founded by Vikings that then expanded north and east into the Russia we know today as well as south into Crimea as part of their river trade link to the Arab ME. For a few hundred years Ukraine was occupied by the Mongols while the rest of Russia fought to gain their lands back in the 1400s. So when Ukraine was liberated back to Russia, Moscow was by then the new capital of Russia as Kyiv had been under Mongol rule. Ukraine only split off from Russia as a separate sovereign nation a century ago.

The two can’t really be compared as the history is too different.

merrymouse · 03/03/2022 11:45

Kyiv (Kiev) is the birthplace of Russia since medieval times.

Normandy was the ‘birth place’ of the Norman Kings of England and it was hundreds of years till the English finally lost Calais, but nobody cares about that now.

I think Putin’s claims on Crimea have more to do with strategic military importance of access to the Black Sea and his ego.

DottyDoge · 03/03/2022 11:42

Surely the Ireland / UK parallel is hypothetical. Am I misunderstanding something?

RitaFires · 03/03/2022 11:36

I think only one person on thread has said Ireland is like Russia, everyone else is saying Ireland is in the Ukraine role. Even the Russian defence minister when he was trying to make an analogy used Ireland in the Ukraine role and the UK as Russian equivalent.

Unfortunately the Ireland Russia comparison is a bit of Unionist talking point and turns up a lot on reddit and the likes. As an Irish person I find it better to just try and avoid reading it, Northern Ireland seems to be like the immaculate conception, people think they know about it but often what they think is totally wrong.

EmpressCixi · 03/03/2022 11:35

Because history.
Kyiv (Kiev) is the birthplace of Russia since medieval times. It was the capital city of Russia...known as Kievan Rus from 482 for almost a thousand years until the Mongols invaded. The Russians then won independence piece meal making Moscow their new capital and not taking back Ukraine and Kiev until 1480. Then Ukraine and Kiev were part of Russia until 1921. Then after WWII, Ukraine was behind the iron curtain and while nominally a separate country was under USSR control until 1991. Russia has been trying to take back the Ukraine since 2014.

CharlotteRose90 · 03/03/2022 11:35

Moldova is next that idiot from Belarus admitted it the other day then it got covered up. This war has been going on for years and won’t stop for a while. Putin is the new hitler and deserves shooting .

ChiefPearlClutcher · 03/03/2022 11:31

Apologies I meant to reply to @BitOutOfPractice

ChiefPearlClutcher · 03/03/2022 11:30

Our Polish friends said on day 2 of the invasion that Moldova will be next.

MaMaLa321 · 03/03/2022 11:28

so - what's the AIBU?
the internet is full of information on this, the Ros Atkins short videos are especially good.
Do you really think the best way is to rock up and ask a load of randoms on MN?
I hate the phrase 'educate yourself' but really!

Whatswrongwithakipper · 03/03/2022 11:23

Most young Russians don’t believe that what is happening is right or fair. I have a large Russian team based in Russia and they are all appalled that their government is involved in this and are scared and horrified for their lives and that of the people of Ukraine

IvorCutler · 03/03/2022 11:13

Yes @jojane, that’s what I was getting at with my comment. I live in Ireland. I’m also gobsmacked by the level of ignorance.

merrymouse · 03/03/2022 10:57

Do you believe England to be the aggressor (Putin) in these comparisons? Given their initial invasion of Ireland.

I don’t know whether the comparison works, but I don’t think Henry II or Oliver Cromwell were overly concerned about what the general populace in England thought.

jojojane · 03/03/2022 10:44

To those comparing in this situation to Northern Ireland.

Do you believe England to be the aggressor (Putin) in these comparisons? Given their initial invasion of Ireland.

jojojane · 03/03/2022 10:40

@YouSayYesISayNo

I agree with likening it with the Ireland/NI/UK scenario.

Suppose the UK decided there was a danger that Ireland would take NI by force (because it used to be part of Ireland). There is no evidence that Ireland is going to do so, but the suggestion has been made.

So the UK decides to invade Ireland. They are going to cleanse the island of Ireland from Irish Nationalists who want a United Ireland. They send in troops to take Dublin and Cork, and spread out to the whole island. They are liberating the unionists (in the north) by neutralising the threat that Ireland might take over NI.

Obviously Ireland would be pretty pissed off. After all, they have no intention of illegally annexing NI. They are an independent country; the UK has no right to invade.

I really hope that in that situation NATO would step in (despite Ireland not being a member) and tell the UK to fuck off Hmm

I have actually read this 3 or 4 times now to try to get my head around what you've said. The privileged, naive tone of your comment is astounding. Please, please do not comment on a situation you clearly do not have appropriate level of knowledge on, and in such a confident, "factual" manner too. It's insulting and disrespectful.
Davros · 03/03/2022 10:17

@merrymouse

I don’t know how well comparisons to Ireland stand up, but that example does demonstrate how difficult it is to rule without consent.
One difference with Uk/Ireland is that the partition was negotiated and agreed by the leaders of the time. Many Irish citizens did not agree with it and it caused great division, even recently people knew which side of that debate different families and communities were on.
OneTC · 03/03/2022 09:49

Russia back in the USSR days played an exceptional long game strategy. By repatriating ethnic Russians throughout the region that was then the USSR. This means when they go into any of those countries they can say they are protecting ethnic Russian interests

Also Kiev was like the 3rd city in the USSR, it's important to them

merrymouse · 03/03/2022 09:42

We haven't lost land

Until the 1500’s England had bits of northern France as a legacy from the Normans (hence Channel Islands) and some English kings have claimed all of France. And that’s before you get into Ireland and the Empire.

SkyBlueCloudyLakes · 03/03/2022 09:27

MangyInseam (sorry added the name since not sure how to reply)
No, there are no pro-Russian people in Finland. During the Civil war the reds were supported by Russian government - they lost. So no support since 1918.

ScrollingLeaves · 03/03/2022 09:14

@mathanxiety
Thank you for that brilliant animation of the changing borders over the last few thousand years.

DustyMuse · 03/03/2022 08:37

In answer to your question, found this video very informative and helpful.

Thewindwhispers · 03/03/2022 08:29

@FrothyB

Whilst we in the UK have been encouraged for the most part to see our cultural roots as unimportant, as we are all the same, anyone can be British, we can take the favourable bits of different cultures and use then to make our own more vibrant etc, that is not often the case in other parts of the world, even in Europe.

England as a country has been pretty well defined for over 1000 years. Great Britain as a singular entity for nearly 300 iirc. We haven't lost land, we haven't been conquered, or ruled by an outside force (from a purely English perspective), so we can't understand the emotions of what drives a conflict like this.

Consider the Scottish independence vote. 45% was it that said yes to leaving the union? And that's before the issue of Brexit came into the picture. Consider the troubles in Northern Ireland.

As another example, Hungary was chopped up in 1920, with lands Hungary had owned for hundreds of years given away to other nations, including half of what is now Romania, and indeed a section of Ukraine which is known as Karpatalja. These regions held many ethnic Hungarians who were suddenly separated from their countrymen, from their culture. In the areas where they are a majority, they still fly Hungarian flags, speak the Hungarian language primarily and refuse to be Slovak, Ukrainian, Serbian etc in any meaningful way, and the break up of greater Hungary is still felt keenly by many in modern day Hungary. That is after 100 years. 3 generations at least have never known greater Hungary, or have lived in "Hungary" yet the feeling is still so strong.

That's what is at the heart of this war, at least for the men and women on the ground. Bringing those they see as brothers and sisters back into the fold. Reclaiming land lost to them that had been historically theirs for centuries, united under the banner of one nation again.

I fully support Ukraine by the way. I've been many times and it breaks my heart to see it at war this way, I was just trying to paint a picture of the feelings of different peoples that for us in the UK can be hard to empathise with.

I don’t recognise this version of history.

Ukraine became part of Russia in 1686. At which time Britain had already ruled America for 79 years. We don’t rule America anymore but we aren’t trying to turn the clock back despite sharing a common language and a lot of common culture.

Russia need to get the fuck over it.