Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Somebody explain why Russians believe Ukraine is part or Russia....

192 replies

jobhunter7 · 02/03/2022 20:58

I know it used to be part of the Russian Empire. But do they believe the same about Poland or Finland which were too? And what other former parts of the USSR do they believe to be still basically Russia.

OP posts:
CyclingUpHill · 03/03/2022 14:08

Basically Putin and his cronies have the power and might to do exactly what they want with respect to neighbors. To date, the words and the sanctions seem to mean nothing to those with the levers of power. There is an analogy here to rape, there is NO consideration of the victim. They feel there are entitled to do what they want regardless.

Yes, we were the same in the not too distance past. However, the social and economic impacts of WWI and WW2 put an end to it.

Let's hope that Russia can undergo the same transformation we did. It took time, and we didn't do it willingly, but it happened. Fingers crossed!!

Amortentia · 03/03/2022 13:59

@NorthFaceofthelaundrypile

Read Prisoners of Geography by Tim Marshall. Does a great job of explaining how vital having the access to the Black Sea via Crimea is to Russia.
I was just going to post this. I've just finished it, and you would think it had been published just this week it's so relevant to recent events.
Donson · 03/03/2022 13:52

Finland and Poland were in the USSR? Ummm... wow

jojojane · 03/03/2022 13:48

@meloncolic the accuracy of this! Yes, this is the more accurate hypothetical comparison.

IvorCutler · 03/03/2022 13:44

Perfect description @meloncolic

deadflowers · 03/03/2022 13:42

We were indeed Putin/Russia, until very very recently. Here's a recent piece from New Yorker, and think about the dates

www.newyorker.com/magazine/2020/11/02/misremembering-the-british-empire

merrymouse · 03/03/2022 13:31

I think Ireland isn’t quite the same because the impact of the conflict is still tangible for people now.

FastFashun · 03/03/2022 13:30

I'd think it has to do with the imperialist legacy. My country (England) regularly sent our troops to invade, murder, rape and exploit other countries, including (bot not only) our neighbors. It's what imperialists do. You really don't have to go back far ... and we were Russia/Putin.

Several Russian people work at the same company as me, and I've never heard one stating support for the invasion. But for those in Russia? I really have no idea.

meloncolic · 03/03/2022 13:30

@IvorCutler

It’s nothing like Ireland! It’d be more like the UK coming back for control of the republic than NI uniting with ROI.
Yes, it’s more like if Boris had been brooding for years that the answer to all U.K. problems was not letting go of NI (which actually I think he would LOVE to do in reality) but to roll in to the republic (just calling it the republic to differentiate it from the island of ireland before ye all huff on to say ‘it’s just IRELAND, actually’) with the tanks all blazing and raze dublin to the ground with thermobaric weapons while Leo varadker etc are like ‘wtACTUALf’ throwing Molotov cocktails in Guinness bottles from the roof of Leinster house and obvs the rest of the world would be like ‘what the fuck are you doing you psychotic maniac’

And Boris being all ‘I love history and the power of these United isles etc and telling people in Norwich that the people of belfast WANTED him to do it.

Is actually a better historical comparison.

Thereisnolight · 03/03/2022 13:23

There’s always someone just waiting to take offence at something. Look at any mumsnet thread, ever.
Get all these people together with a few weapons, conscript the rest and you have a war.

ScrollingLeaves · 03/03/2022 13:19

“@merrymouse
However recent events in the U.K. and America have shown how easy it is to cynically whip up nationalism.“

Yes, and even on this thread matters relating to Ireland seem to hit raw nerves.

merrymouse · 03/03/2022 13:15

Then we have some modern nations where that kind of thinking is very much subdued. It's not at all clear to me that this is a function of time so much as a real change in thinking.

I think that is just the current state of politics.

We are all just human, and the reason the U.K. doesn’t fear invasion by e.g. Norway (vikings!) is because of our political situation now, not something intrinsic to our being.

However recent events in the U.K. and America have shown how easy it is to cynically whip up nationalism.

MangyInseam · 03/03/2022 13:02

@Mrsjayy

The Russian Empire and Ussr are not the same. Basically Putin is of the old Ussr and is "insulted" that Ukraine is independent . The man's a psychopath
I suspect though he is harking back to the Russian Empire as much as the old USSR idea. Look what he's done with the Church.
alienbotanist · 03/03/2022 13:02

And a better analogy of NI would be Karelia Oblast in Russia. Transfer 'agrees' in similar circumstances really.

alienbotanist · 03/03/2022 12:59

I think a better analogy for Englanders would be if Scotland decided to suddenly annexe Berwick-upon-Tweed this week.

MangyInseam · 03/03/2022 12:49

@merrymouse

Kyiv (Kiev) is the birthplace of Russia since medieval times.

Normandy was the ‘birth place’ of the Norman Kings of England and it was hundreds of years till the English finally lost Calais, but nobody cares about that now.

I think Putin’s claims on Crimea have more to do with strategic military importance of access to the Black Sea and his ego.

I'm not sure this is important in terms of trying to trace people's sense of either being part of the same people, or, alternately, of enmity.

Speaking of Ireland for example, we can easily go back before England claimed to rule there to a time when Irish raiders were feared in English coastal towns and took slaves back with them. Did this kind of feeling about the Other affect ongoing sentiment of the English towards the Irish, even generations after it stopped? I suspect it did even though the reasons for it might have been forgotten.

I really think that where these sentiments of fear or alienation, or belonging and identity exist that people will find justifications around political arrangements. And it's not unique to aggressor nations.

It can be very interesting to consider how long it takes peoples to really leave these kinds of thoughts in the past and see them as history rather than as part of their current identity. It seems to me that in some cases it can last centuries, even a thousand years.

Then we have some modern nations where that kind of thinking is very much subdued. It's not at all clear to me that this is a function of time so much as a real change in thinking.

valerianaofficiana · 03/03/2022 12:46

If Pupski touches a NATO country, be it Estonia or UK, NATO will act. That's the whole point of it, its raison d'etre as a defensive military alliance.
Shitsky will hit the fansky and Russia knows this. By directly threatening Finland and Sweden Russia demonstrated that, as these countries are not part of NATO.
Ukraine is fighting for whole Europe, no, for the whole world. They are drawing Russian military resources, hardware for which will be difficult to replenish due to the sanctions.
The longer Ukraine fights back, the more Russian might weakens.

MangyInseam · 03/03/2022 12:27

I understand it was a hypothetical post, but it's completely skewed in favour of the original aggressor, and comparisons to Ukraine are completely off.

I think that's because the OP is trying to understand how someone like Putin or a Russian would conceptualize it. That's the whole point of the question.

Ireland is just an example that people here might find more intuitive.

ThatsBullshirt · 03/03/2022 12:23

Sorry @zoeFromCity quoted the wrong message.

ThatsBullshirt · 03/03/2022 12:21

@zoeFromCity

Latvia, Estonia and Lithuania are NATO members, and NATO (or specifically Poland, US, Turkey and rest of EU) are now up and ready to do something, so not a great target.

If Ukraine went well for Russia, Moldova or officialy adding Belarus would be more probable targets.

I find this absolutely terrifying as someone with Estonian family - not that it's not terrifying what is going on in Ukraine right now! But I think you are right. Ukraine is just the first country of probably many that he has his sights set on in a bid to restore the USSR/Russian Empire. I just hope he never gets the chance to get that far.
merrymouse · 03/03/2022 12:16

@Mrsjayy

The Russian Empire and Ussr are not the same. Basically Putin is of the old Ussr and is "insulted" that Ukraine is independent . The man's a psychopath
Not just independent, but being ‘western’. That really threatens his dick size. He therefore has to send Russian 18 year old conscripts to die.
Bluecatsalltheway · 03/03/2022 12:10

I read on foreign political website that a leak document showed next one will be Moldova if Ukraine will be going well for him.

Mrsjayy · 03/03/2022 12:04

The Russian Empire and Ussr are not the same. Basically Putin is of the old Ussr and is "insulted" that Ukraine is independent . The man's a psychopath

MorningStarling · 03/03/2022 12:03

I'm not sure how the Ireland situation is comparable or relevant. The Irish people (southern Ireland) are originally from what is now the UK anyway. They spread there and drove the previous inhabitants out, who went to Scotland and removed the previous occupants from there (the Picts).

Nobody is actually suggesting that Ireland is forcibly made to join a customs union with the UK or be incorporated as a part of the UK. It's just a good idea that would solve a lot of problems for both countries, but nobody is forcing it to happen it would need to be decided in a referendum in both countries.

That could/should have been what happened in Ukraine. If a majority of people wanted to rejoin Russia that would have been the way to resolve i.

Thereisnolight · 03/03/2022 12:00

Oops - I see that there are a lot of people prepared to take offence at the Ireland analogy. I have NI roots and I wish they wouldn’t. It’s pretty obvious what the first poster meant and they didn’t mean to be offensive.