Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Somebody explain why Russians believe Ukraine is part or Russia....

192 replies

jobhunter7 · 02/03/2022 20:58

I know it used to be part of the Russian Empire. But do they believe the same about Poland or Finland which were too? And what other former parts of the USSR do they believe to be still basically Russia.

OP posts:
DublinFemale · 04/03/2022 07:05

I still find it fascinating how people leave Ireland decades ago yet appear to have inside knowledge as to how most Irish people feel.

As for the people of NI been the only voice in the issue, well that's not true. Ireland changed its constitution to get the GFA over the line. Irish people with a vote most certainly have a voice.

Anyways back to real topic, the situation in Ukraine.

mathanxiety · 04/03/2022 01:21

MorganKitten

No, that's not why.

Russia and Ukraine were like England and Scotland are now for a few hundred years.

mathanxiety · 04/03/2022 01:18

...Scotland...

mathanxiety · 04/03/2022 01:18

Excellent point. (whispers) Gibraltar...

...Northern Ireland, Chagos Islands...

YouSayYesISayNo · 04/03/2022 00:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

AhNowTed · 04/03/2022 00:10

@YouSayYesISayNo

But that was my entire point. Ukraine also gained independence from another country, and some in Ukraine would feel that they didn't get all of it, and some is still occupied, and now the invader is trying to get it all again.

I'm Irish and I'm well aware that there are a significant number of people from the UK who seem to think Ireland should have followed the UK out of the EU, who think that we are pretty much part of the "British Isles", who don't realise we don't take Sterling in our shops etc.

It's no joke, when people from one country feel they own bits of another. However, my post pointed out that it would obviously be completely wrong for the UK to "take back" Ireland, and similarly it's it's completely wrong for Russia to "take back" Ukraine.

I'm genuinely baffled that anyone would think I was saying it'd be a fair enough thing to do. I'm being accused of insensitivity, ignorance and minimising by one or two posters who completely misread what I said and decided to attack me for what they thought I said.

It's pretty insulting, tbh.

Hi

I was one who was gobsmacked at your post.

I'm also Irish, living in the UK for 30 odd years.

The bit that led me to believe you couldn't have a clue when taking about Ireland was this:

"After all, they [Ireland] have no intention of illegally annexing NI."

The very idea that Ireland could be accused of "illegally annexing" NI is ludicrous.

When it was literally robbed in the first place.

And to the poster who said "it was agreed by both sides". Ostensibly perhaps, but under extraordinary duress.

Post-Brexit I honestly believe we will see a united Ireland in my lifetime.

But it won't be because Irish citizens want it. Most Irish people from the Republic couldn't care less.

It will be because the citizens of NI will see it's economically in their best interest.

MorganKitten · 03/03/2022 18:53

Because it used to be in the Soviet Union, which was pretty much all Russia

LadyMonicaBaddingham · 03/03/2022 18:47

@Gizacluethen

In my head I've kind of considered it the same kind of thing as the Falklands.
Excellent point. (whispers) Gibraltar...
YouSayYesISayNo · 03/03/2022 18:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Lincslady53 · 03/03/2022 18:39

The video explains that since the break up of the USSR, Russia have been paying Ukraine for transporting gas across Ukraine to Europe. They have now built more pipelines bypassing Ukraine, but Natural Gas deposits have been found in Ukraine, and in Crimean waters. If Ukraine develop this gas, it will seriously affect the amount of gas that Europe buys from Russia. It also covers how Nato have expanded its membership Eastwards, which is seen in Russia as a security threat. It is an interesting watch, however it is one persons analysis of the situation, so other videos will have different views.

Lincslady53 · 03/03/2022 18:33

This is interesting.

blahblahbiscuits · 03/03/2022 18:22

@YouSayYesISayNo I can't speak for anyone else, but I'd imagine the example you used and the wording touched a nerve because England has already invaded Ireland. Ireland had to fight for independence, and many believe they didn't get the full country back and the job was half finished hence those in both the republic and NI calling for a united Ireland. For many living in the North of Ireland, this led to life changing consequences in that they no longer lived in Ireland, instead they lived in Northern Ireland. The effects of 'The Troubles' that ensued because of this are still being felt in every day life. Just yesterday I sent my condolences to a friend whose father was shot 30 years ago, the day after her 3rd birthday, as he innocently walked down the road, he was a victim of the troubles. There are so so many of them.

This is why, using the example that you did may have caused some upset. I understand that you meant it in a light, non confrontational manner, and wanted to highlight how ridiculous it would be if it was to happen. But for many it doesn't sound all that ridiculous at all actually.

YouSayYesISayNo · 03/03/2022 17:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

HeartOfClass · 03/03/2022 16:48

I agree on the @merrymouse comment. It is not all Russians, but I do wonder how many support the war/invasion? The few Russian people I know here in UK (at work, tech area) are dismayed but it.

I wonder when our soldiers were being sent abroad to invade, conquer, murder, rape, etc. how much popular support there was for it? I'd imagine the idea and concept of our empire was very popular across all classes?

Again, I've no idea, but the popular support for our invasion of Iraq must have been very small. Most I know were totally against it, but the government/leaders could pus ahead with it regardless. Maybe that's the same in Russia today?

merrymouse · 03/03/2022 16:31

The title of this thread is stupid. 'Russians' definitely don't think Ukraine is part of Russia. Ludicrous, cringeworthy oversimplification.

Not given the circumstances, which are that Russia is seeking to occupy Ukraine.

If this has created misunderstandings, blame Putin.

debwong · 03/03/2022 16:04

I think the England/Ireland analogy can be helpful for people who don't know anything about the other situation. Two neighbouring peoples, one more powerful than the other, who have a difficult and violent history together but nevertheless share a lot of family ties today.

Cheeserton · 03/03/2022 16:03

"Putin wants to restore the USSR, hence Ukraine and Chechnya."

What the hell did I just read? Chechnya is part of the Russian Federation. Nothing to do with the USSR.

The title of this thread is stupid. 'Russians' definitely don't think Ukraine is part of Russia. Ludicrous, cringeworthy oversimplification.

Teawaster · 03/03/2022 15:35

I'm from ROI , living in NI and I didn't take offence to the comments made by the poster who compared the Irish situation to what's happening . It was completely hypothetical which the poster made clear and in my view she was just making it more relevant by using an example with countries that we are more familiar with , which have had a turbulent past

AryaStarkWolf · 03/03/2022 15:22

@Usernameinsponeeded

I’m Russian and I don’t think this. Please don’t paint an entire nation with one brush...
I think most people realise that ordinary Russians have no desire for this war
Hrpuffnstuff1 · 03/03/2022 15:03

@merrymouse

DW is from a former Soviet-controlled country, her mother and grandmother have fond memories of life under Soviet rule.

But Putin isn’t offering Soviet rule. He is offering ‘seizing the natural assets and dividing them up amongst my cronies so they can stash the profits elsewhere and buy a super yacht rule’.

What's the point in that. The oligarchs all left Russia to stay alive. Where's Putin to going to spend this money on the global market. I think it's a power move. Although one which has sealed his fate and place in history. Not as a moderate moderniser but a tyrant.
LookItsMeAgain · 03/03/2022 14:53

@MorningStarling - I'm not sure how the Ireland situation is comparable or relevant. The Irish people (southern Ireland) are originally from what is now the UK anyway

Oh FFS! Jesus wept!!! Where to start in with this.

For those of you in England (less so Scotland and Wales) that have a difficulty in picking up a history book or even Googling what the situation was like in Ireland, there were IRISH people living in IRELAND (in the 32 counties of our island) BEFORE the British invaded our country. We were a quite content little nation on the fringes of the Atlantic Ocean.

Oh and the term you're looking for MorningStarling is people in the Republic of Ireland. Southern Ireland is Cork, Kerry, Waterford, Wexford. That would be like saying Southern Scotland, meaning Devon, Cornwall, The Isle of Wight etc.

LookItsMeAgain · 03/03/2022 14:40

@Windbeneathmybingowings

I think of it like Northern Ireland and the UK in a broad sense. Some want a united ireland and some don’t. Putin wants a united USSR.
Oh my....where to even begin with this comment.

It would be more like the UK wanting the REPUBLIC OF IRELAND to rejoin the "United" Kingdom than the Irish in the 26 counties wanting a 32 county Republic of Ireland.

Time to go back and learn Anglo-Irish History (the last 800 years or so should be enough to give you a good understanding of the events).

Then you can start to read up on the historical events that have lead up to the War in Ukraine.

merrymouse · 03/03/2022 14:38

DW is from a former Soviet-controlled country, her mother and grandmother have fond memories of life under Soviet rule.

But Putin isn’t offering Soviet rule. He is offering ‘seizing the natural assets and dividing them up amongst my cronies so they can stash the profits elsewhere and buy a super yacht rule’.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 03/03/2022 14:33

DW is from a former Soviet-controlled country, her mother and grandmother have fond memories of life under Soviet rule.
I think they found comfort in having the basics of life, work-there own farm-accommodation. Even though by western standards it was in fact abject poverty. When she shows me photos of her childhood, everyone seems happy.
There's a lot of cultural homogeneity with Russia all across the Central and Eastern parts of Europe. The identity is steeped in history.

Although I feel Putin has gone too far, this time.

merrymouse · 03/03/2022 14:09

Yes, it’s more like if Boris had been brooding for years that the answer to all U.K. problems was not letting go of NI (which actually I think he would LOVE to do in reality)

I’m not denying that there would never be a situation where this would be the case, but with the benefit of hind sight and sanity, all the pain death and expense of the conflict hasn’t had political benefits for any U.K. government. As has been noted on this thread, awareness of NI is low in England.

Brexit showed how easy it is to create conflict where previously feelings were low, but England is generally indifferent to maintenance of the Union.