Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Somebody explain why Russians believe Ukraine is part or Russia....

192 replies

jobhunter7 · 02/03/2022 20:58

I know it used to be part of the Russian Empire. But do they believe the same about Poland or Finland which were too? And what other former parts of the USSR do they believe to be still basically Russia.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AhNowTed · 05/03/2022 15:36

Here's a useful reminder of what makes up the UK

Somebody explain why Russians believe Ukraine is part or Russia....
DownNative · 05/03/2022 13:48

@merrymouse

Northern Ireland is internationally recognised as part of the U.K., hence all the Brexit negotiations about trade.

There is provision in statute for NI to leave the U.K. in the event of a majority vote.

Most English people are barely aware that the U.K. shares a land border with the EU and don’t have strong opinions on the subject,

The Ashcroft poll makes it clear most English people ARE aware the UK shares a land border with the EU.

It also shows more English people want Northern Ireland and Scotland to remain in the UK in similar levels. A significantly smaller proportion of them would prefer they leave. More tellingly, only a tiny minority would be happy if the UK broke up.

DownNative · 05/03/2022 13:44

@Ihopeyoulikemymuff

Somebody explain why British people think Northern Ireland is part of the UK ;)
Eh?

Northern Ireland IS literally and very much officially part of the UK! Hmm

The Republic of Ireland gave up ALL territorial claims over Northern Ireland in 1999 and formally recognised we are separate from them.

This really isn't difficult to understand. The GFA is actually very explicit that Northern Ireland is part of the UK, in fact.

merrymouse · 05/03/2022 13:29

Northern Ireland is internationally recognised as part of the U.K., hence all the Brexit negotiations about trade.

There is provision in statute for NI to leave the U.K. in the event of a majority vote.

Most English people are barely aware that the U.K. shares a land border with the EU and don’t have strong opinions on the subject,

LawnFever · 05/03/2022 13:20

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Ihopeyoulikemymuff · 05/03/2022 13:03

Somebody explain why British people think Northern Ireland is part of the UK ;)

TheCrystalShip · 05/03/2022 12:31

I found the Washington Post here: www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2022/03/02/long-history-russian-imperialism-shaping-putins-war/

I wonder what is Putin's longer term imperialist play? Install a puppet government? Or more move in more Russian settlers as they done in other regions in the past?

The Nazi German approach would have been to move in settlers, as we did in North America, Australia, Ireland, etc The American approach these days seems to be to have a compliant regime, and local army bases.

DownNative · 05/03/2022 11:43

As far as the hypothetical this thread is trying to provide, the most obvious one is a pretty glaring omission.

What if Germany rebuilt its army, planned and invaded German speaking areas just outside its borders as a pretext for occupation?

This hypothetical is much, much closer to the Russian invasion of Ukraine today. Simply put, the attempted hypothetical of the UK, Northern Ireland and Republic of Ireland situation is absolutely ludicrous. That offers no semblance of understanding of the current crisis whatsoever.

A what if involving Germany makes more sense and many of us are, I presume familiar with Germany's Nazi period so could understand the current Ukrainian situation through that lens much better.

Now, that would more than enable people to understand the situation in Ukraine today better.

bythebanksof · 04/03/2022 20:51

Washington Post has an excellent analysis, Google Putin and Imperialism

DownNative · 04/03/2022 19:57

@RichardMarxisinnocent

Both languages evolved from a common ancestor language - Old East Slavic. Both use the Cyrillic script and are the only Slavic languages that do

Belarusian, Bulgarian, Macedonian and Serbian are all Slavic languages which use the Cyrillic script

I stand corrected and I actually misread some information on the two. I see that more than 50 languages use Cyrillic alphabet.

Ukrainian is closer to Polish and Belarusian than Russian.

Interestingly, Russian is closer to Belarusian than Ukrainian as well. Add in Bulgarian, Serbian and Macedonian.

Nationalism is the root of the differences.

"Nationalism is power hunger tempered by self-deception. Every nationalist is capable of the most flagrant dishonesty..." - Orwell

RichardMarxisinnocent · 04/03/2022 19:19

Both languages evolved from a common ancestor language - Old East Slavic. Both use the Cyrillic script and are the only Slavic languages that do

Belarusian, Bulgarian, Macedonian and Serbian are all Slavic languages which use the Cyrillic script

Ieatmarmite · 04/03/2022 18:28

This from Oliver Stone is interesting although it is quite long. m.youtube.com/watch?v=kGQfiImnZHE&feature=youtu.be

DownNative · 04/03/2022 18:22

[quote Thereisnolight]@downnative
You sound obsessive and a bit unhinged. Go and have a lie-down. Then maybe start your own thread. This thread was about Ukraine.[/quote]
It wasn't I who brought in the UK, Northern Ireland and Republic of Ireland comparison in. Your ire should be with previous posters.

The hypothesis itself is ludicrous anyway.

HeartOfClass · 04/03/2022 18:20

Carrying on the theme on unhinged, but in relation to Ukraine, I found it informative to read read: sputniknews.com/

DownNative · 04/03/2022 18:19

@jobhunter7

I know it used to be part of the Russian Empire. But do they believe the same about Poland or Finland which were too? And what other former parts of the USSR do they believe to be still basically Russia.
If we look at some statistics about Ukraine, we can arrive at an answer.

Between 43-46% of people in Ukraine speak Russian. Crucially, about the same proportion of people speak Ukrainian.

Both languages evolved from a common ancestor language - Old East Slavic. Both use the Cyrillic script and are the only Slavic languages that do.

Despite this, they are NOT mutually intelligible languages. This is because the two languages evolved differently for 600 years and had other influences. For example, Ukrainian has a lot of Polish influences.

The peoples of Ukraine and Russia have a shared history, including ancestry. Similarly, the Spanish and Portuguese have a shared history in many ways.

The main reason Russia and Ukraine don't share the same outlook is basically Nationalist politics.

Russian nationalism views Ukraine and Crimea as part of Russia. The Soviet flag seen on a Russian tank recently demonstrates a desire for reforming the Soviet Union.

Ukrainian nationalism went a different route and desired independence as well as closer ties to Europe.

Other European countries have similarities in outlook like above. Spain once had the same view of Portugal as Russia does of Ukraine, but hasn't for a long time.

More relevant to the British Isles, Irish Nationalists and Republicans view Northern Ireland as not being a real country and theirs - despite the 1999 referendum vote in the ROI. Northern Irish Unionists and Loyalists wished for closer ties to the British and to be separate from the ROI - Similar to the Ukrainian sentiment.

More importantly, Russia and Ukraine do not have a Good Friday Agreement of their own. That's where the UK, Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland are more fortunate.

These are the main reasons why some countries view others as part of their own whilst other countries do not.

It's Nationalist politics. Often dressed up as something else. In Putin's case, NATO expansion.

Thereisnolight · 04/03/2022 18:07

@downnative
You sound obsessive and a bit unhinged. Go and have a lie-down. Then maybe start your own thread. This thread was about Ukraine.

CyclingUpHill · 04/03/2022 18:06

Chill out :)

DownNative · 04/03/2022 18:02

[quote CyclingUpHill]@DownNative, your post seems as if there is an underlying agenda you're trying to push, and I'm not bothered to read up on dysfunctional politics of Northern Ireland.

Time will tell.[/quote]
Well, it's called discussing.

Quire interesting some would rather not know these pieces of history.

DownNative · 04/03/2022 18:00

@merrymouse

The last year's of the Union of The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland were actually the best years.

Still, the south left us. We, on the other hand, didn't leave them.

ROI seceded 100 years ago. You must be Mumsnet’s oldest poster.

Indeed it did. Yet throughout most of that time the ROI has had very similar rhetoric to Russia.

As everyone has recently discovered, it's a short leap from rhetoric to planning an invasion. From there, an even shorter leap towards mounting an invasion.

The ROI stopped short of mounting one. Irish newspaper headline from 2009 - "Operation Armageddon would have been doomsday - for Irish aggressors".

There are SOME similarities to the Ukrainian situation. But it still remains that the hypothesis of the UK invading the ROI is ludicrous. It never planned one. But the ROI did.

CyclingUpHill · 04/03/2022 17:58

@DownNative, your post seems as if there is an underlying agenda you're trying to push, and I'm not bothered to read up on dysfunctional politics of Northern Ireland.

Time will tell.

DownNative · 04/03/2022 17:53

@CyclingUpHill

I assume at some point there will be a vote in Northern Ireland, like there was in Scotland. And then a generation later, another vote. If you look the long term trends they'll both go. The sooner the better! And I really wish them all the best.

Scotland and Northern Ireland will then get the chance to be in the EU again as they voted last time, and get someone else to fund them!

It's possible, but by no means a given that there'll be a future referendum in Northern Ireland.

A careful reading of the GFA tells us it's actually pretty difficult to get one - Nationalism and Republicanism either didn't note the wording or they knew they didn't have the influence to get it changed.

If by longterm, you mean more Catholics equals increased demand for a border poll...that'd be incorrect. The trends indicate there's more than twice as many Catholic Unionists than there are Protestant Republicans.

Furthermore, the trends tell us that the Northern Irish identity will grow. There's already more identifying as Northern Irish than Irish in Northern Ireland. This is a POST-GFA trend most didn't see coming.

merrymouse · 04/03/2022 17:48

The last year's of the Union of The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland were actually the best years.

Still, the south left us. We, on the other hand, didn't leave them.

ROI seceded 100 years ago. You must be Mumsnet’s oldest poster.

DownNative · 04/03/2022 17:45

@CyclingUpHill

Thanks *@JenniferBarkley* for the tip on DownNative. There's always a few of those :) It's what makes these forums amusing sometimes!
I can assure you Jennifer is Bark-ley up the wrong tree there.

What's more significant is the lack of acknowledgement of the actual history of what I've previously stated. You can probably find the programme "What If Lynch Invaded?" On YouTube which was first broadcast in the Republic of Ireland in 2009.

DownNative · 04/03/2022 17:42

@JenniferBarkley

I think I recognise DownNative - there is a poster on here who regularly name changes and who has some... let's say interesting views on Ireland and what it means to be Irish.

I see no problem with @YouSayYesISayNo 's post (Irish, from ROI now in NI - indeed, I'm sitting in Co Down as I write this).

Nope, I'm a new poster here which I'm sure Mumsnet can verify.

Let's not let your post distract from the actual history I have previously quoted, shall we?

DownNative · 04/03/2022 17:40

@IvorCutler

Easter rising anyone?
The Easter Rising was an unpopular insurrection which a majority of people didn't support or take part in.

Let's not revise that one....