Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Housing Crisis by Design

65 replies

DoorWasAJar · 02/03/2022 20:39

Does anyone else think the housing ‘crisis’ is by design or AIBU? People die in the tens of thousands every year due to damp cold uninsulated housing they cannot afford to heat, what does the government expect to happen to them now, when the fuels prices are getting out of control? Why is it so hard for the government to do the most basic of things, people need proper shelter for God’s sake, not these vile new builds developers are vomiting in dribs and drabs while they hoard the development land. Then they use the guidelines for minimum room sizes as maximums. It just doesn’t seem reasonable to me that we’re not building at the proper rate we should be building at, to ensure the population have shelter.

Sorry for my incoherent rant, I’m just upset about this, many many children are growing up with a terrible quality of life due to this. We should be looking at countries where they’re getting right and learning from them. Off topic but Japan spend the same as the UK on healthcare but are 11 places ahead of us in quality of care.

www.dezeen.com/2016/09/30/phineas-harper-opinion-on-the-uk-housing-crisis-that-isnt-a-crisis/

OP posts:
JustAnotherPoster00 · 04/03/2022 12:15

this....wouldn't work here in the UK if you had to sell your flat screen TV before you could claim UC

Just that one sentence can be so revealing about a person's political leanings, can you buy TV's that aren't flatscreen anymore?

sst1234 · 04/03/2022 12:04

Mentioning Japan as an example is futile. They do something really smart that we would never be able to because of the unproductive, hard of understanding blue haired nimby protestors. They knock down older housing stock and build new. Anything older than 30 years is not seen as fit for purpose. We, on the other hand, are so wedded to older, badly insulated, high maintenance relics because they have ‘character’. Doesn’t matter about affordability and functionality, especially for those on low incomes - character is more important. The political narrative is overwhelmingly occupied by leftie middle class public sector types who are hell bent on avoiding progress at any cost. No matter how much hardship it brings for others. The political spectrum of full of people like these.

VelvetChairGirl · 04/03/2022 11:17

Homes in the is country are shit, please explain to me how the coldest city on earth manages with its soviet housing with triple glazing, the entire house heated by GSH altho different looking heating units to ours, which maintain the house to at least 20 degrees.

but I am sitting her in front of a fan heater in london in our mild winters because I cant get my 1 bed flat to be more then 10 degrees warmer then outside, and thats with bubble wrap on the windows etc

everything is moldy anyway and damp, even with air bricks, our homes are just shit, poor standards very poor and backwards in every way, too cold in winter, too hot in summer, shitty old fashioned bathrooms and kitchens, lack of storage, no solar or wind etc on new builds no real energy efficient heating systems etc, no storage, no space your lucky if the builders even factored in how large a bedframe is before buildind, and insanely over priced to boot so no one can afford them or they get trapped paying for them for the rest of their life until they have to sell them to pay for care.

government and builders are taking the piss, thats what happens when you vote in tories decade after decade, nothing ever improves theres very little difference between a house built now and one 200 years ago except size, we are way behind, yet no one cares so they keep building crap as some one will buy it for an investment.

I hope the entire housing market implodes massively leading to a great depression and a total crumbling of the current neo lib capitalist system, its long over due.

collosalbrainbearer · 04/03/2022 10:51

@MysteryFog60

There needs to be a cap on how many houses one person owns. Nobody needs 10 houses.

Tell that to the overseas investors with their portfolios. I had a foreign investor landlord, they were useless landlords and they don't care because they don't see you- just a name on a contract

EmmaH2022 · 04/03/2022 10:42

PS not having a go at you Mint.

Just really befuddled by the lack of basic general knowledge here.

Props to you and other posters who can be arsed to address it.

EmmaH2022 · 04/03/2022 10:40

Mint "A year ago that didn't seem important but now it does."

How could it not seem important a year ago?

That said, I'm astounded by a lot of what is on this thread.

MintJulia · 04/03/2022 10:13

We are witnessing the risks of relying too heavily on another country for basic needs like heat. Russia has too much control of Europe's gas supply.
The same can happen to countries that cannot produce their own food. The U.K. currently produces about 50% of our food (and we throw about a third of our food away). If we keep building on farmland, we reduce our ability to feed ourselves. A year ago that didn't seem important but now it does.
So using brownfield sites, as effectively as possible is not only environmentally sound, it's strategically sensible as well.

KeepYaHeadUp · 04/03/2022 09:51

@MintJulia

You talk about damp, uninsulated housing and then talk about new builds. New builds are dry & insulated but they are small, making them less expensive to heat. Larger houses cost more to heat.

But home owners (and landlords) must take some responsibility for the poor condition of some of Britain's housing. People buy houses and don't budget for ongoing maintenance or learn how to maintain them. Then when something goes wrong they either ignore it, move or bodge it.

The conflict between "were running out of space and homes" and "new homes are too small" is an interesting one too. How much space do we really need? Japan has been mentioned upthread as a good solution. Tokyo development is extremely high density - small, compact, high-rise. Less space means less time/money spent filling rooms with furniture and other "stuff". So how much space do we need?

Our current planning system requires "best use of space" so the density is required to be a high as possible to avoid sprawling detached houses with huge gardens in urban areas, for instance. This isn't a bad idea as long as storage (inside and for cars, bins, bikes) and pavements etc are provided

KeepYaHeadUp · 04/03/2022 09:47

@bellamountain

If you drive on any motorway in this country, all you do is pass by miles and miles of fields. We have plenty of land but it seems planning developers want to destroy what is left in already over populated towns and cities by cramming in flats and tiny homes.
@bellamountain - the alternative to urban extensions (building in/adjacent to existing towns) is:
  • building on a small scale on these fields you see in the middle of nowhere, with no infrastructure (besides roads), facilities (shops, community buildings, schools, public transport, etc) meaning everyone is reliant on their cars and nearby town/village facilities,( hint - this is the very definition of unsustainable development), or
  • new towns / entire new settlements on green fields - which deliver lots of homes and all the infrastructure to be self-sufficient and "consume their own smoke". These don't impact on as many people but GOOD LUCK getting community support from the wealthy nearby home owners posing as conservationists, organisations like CPRE who seem to think we can solve the housing crisis building on brownfield sites (hunt - we can't)
TonTonMacoute · 04/03/2022 09:45

@Graphista

Read the report!

It explains a lot of things strangely enough Hmm, including the issues you raise. It even addresses the issue of powerful interests who are at the root cause of the problem, some of whom you guess but not for the reason you state.

The entire report is about how to build homes for those in most desperate housing need, like OP.

bellac11 · 04/03/2022 08:42

The only way that the crisis can be averted is to build large scale numbers of social housing (that either being for housing associations or council), it needs to be let at the housing benefit rate for the particular area.

However the public will to fight for that or even agree to that is missing and thats the problem.

For private rentals, you either cant afford them if you are solely on benefits because of the benefit rate for housing and/or you need a huge deposit and first months rent up front and a guarantor which many dont have (and shouldnt need but its become a thing now)

So social housing should remove those obstacles to housing

Pazuzu · 04/03/2022 08:35

@Findwen

Government - both Tory & Labour would love to solve this. Think how much the Tories crowed about the really successful vaccination project, if they could solve it - they would and it would be in every election leaflet.

Why don't they then ? Bunch of reasons... it's all very well building a set of homes in one the 'miles and miles of fields' as one poster put it - but that is not enough, you need to run electricity, gas, water, sewage, phone, internet to this field.

You need to consider the water table in that field, where will rain water drain to.
You need to consider where they will get food and supplies.
You need to consider schooling for kids who grow up there.
You need to consider medical needs (hospital provision, GPs, chemist, dentist, carers, adult social services).
You need to consider the number of cars they will own and therefore the size and safety of the roads to the site, these also add to drainage issues as you link it to the main road.
You need to consider how the site will be governed (i.e. New local government ? Join with existing authority).
You need to consider how the site will be served by public transport (buses ? trains ?)

Probably much more that I haven't mentioned.

Once you have done that. you need to consider jobs - some jobs can be done remotely but most cannot and people seem to think it is the governments job to ensure them.

Once you have planned all this, be prepared for the vast number of objections from nearby residents, environmentalists and a host of other special interests. Be prepared to be taken to court... multiple times.

I'm not in the home building industry or government, so I am sure there is even more to it. Plonking down bricks is the easy part.. making it a livable home that meets modern needs is crazy hard.

All good points, I'd just add that no matter how many houses we build, it's unlikely we are going to match supply to demand any time soon due to the huge population increase over the last 40 years.

Oh, and the increase in single person living and so on.

You can have lots of houses or you can have "decently sized" housing, you can't have both.

Findwen · 04/03/2022 08:29

Government - both Tory & Labour would love to solve this. Think how much the Tories crowed about the really successful vaccination project, if they could solve it - they would and it would be in every election leaflet.

Why don't they then ? Bunch of reasons... it's all very well building a set of homes in one the 'miles and miles of fields' as one poster put it - but that is not enough, you need to run electricity, gas, water, sewage, phone, internet to this field.

You need to consider the water table in that field, where will rain water drain to.
You need to consider where they will get food and supplies.
You need to consider schooling for kids who grow up there.
You need to consider medical needs (hospital provision, GPs, chemist, dentist, carers, adult social services).
You need to consider the number of cars they will own and therefore the size and safety of the roads to the site, these also add to drainage issues as you link it to the main road.
You need to consider how the site will be governed (i.e. New local government ? Join with existing authority).
You need to consider how the site will be served by public transport (buses ? trains ?)

Probably much more that I haven't mentioned.

Once you have done that. you need to consider jobs - some jobs can be done remotely but most cannot and people seem to think it is the governments job to ensure them.

Once you have planned all this, be prepared for the vast number of objections from nearby residents, environmentalists and a host of other special interests. Be prepared to be taken to court... multiple times.

I'm not in the home building industry or government, so I am sure there is even more to it. Plonking down bricks is the easy part.. making it a livable home that meets modern needs is crazy hard.

CarrieHughes · 04/03/2022 06:52

@bellamountain

If you drive on any motorway in this country, all you do is pass by miles and miles of fields. We have plenty of land but it seems planning developers want to destroy what is left in already over populated towns and cities by cramming in flats and tiny homes.
Where do you think your food comes from?
Allelbowsandtoes · 04/03/2022 06:39

@MysteryFog60

There needs to be a cap on how many houses one person owns. Nobody needs 10 houses.
Yep, this. Landlords hoarding property need to get a real job.
MysteryFog60 · 04/03/2022 03:38

There needs to be a cap on how many houses one person owns. Nobody needs 10 houses.

Graphista · 04/03/2022 03:27

It is by design but not in the way you mean

Housing prices are being kept high because too many mps (all parties) and/or their family members are landlords and property developers etc and it benefits them to have housing prices high and little social housing available

The current housing minister is a landlord who voted AGAINST A motion to make housing fit for human habitation legally defined

@sst1234 you make excellent points the one I would dispute is the short term poor decision making has been for at least 40 years mainly as we haven't had a left wing govt in that time - and I agree new labour don't count!

They're private businesses that need to make profit. They (mostly) follow the planning policy set by national and local gov.

See my original point! They are far too closely linked for my liking

My pet hate is the term 'affordable housing', unless someone on minimum wage can afford to buy/ rent without state help it is NOT affordable.

Totally agree

It isn't lack of properties but lack of political will.

Exactly

@TonTonMacoute how can you work in this area, inc talking to mps and NOT know/be aware of the huge and accepted conflicts of interest there?

Does that report (I'm not wading through it right now!) include higher nmw, building actually affordable homes and plenty of good quality social housing? Refurbishing unused properties?

Lemonlady22 · 04/03/2022 01:53

'65% of elderly Japanese live with family, the Japanese benefits system is very strict, anything seen as a luxury has to be sold before you can access government aid' stopped reading after this....wouldn't work here in the UK if you had to sell your flat screen TV before you could claim UC, don't think Japan do care in the community for pensioners either. There health system might be better on paper but you really need to be a patient there before saying its perfect. Every country has its problems imo, funny how you never hear about refugees fleeing to Japan though!

Poorlyplants · 04/03/2022 00:50

To answer a PP, my problem with the new builds is the same as the old ones: poor quality, ridiculously small sizes, no storage, poor or no insulation, poor or no ventilation.

Can you post a link to a new build property that fits this description of poor build quality, no insulation and no ventilation? I’ve just had a look at some new builds online in Cornwall and they look absolutely fine!

MintJulia · 03/03/2022 23:56

You talk about damp, uninsulated housing and then talk about new builds. New builds are dry & insulated but they are small, making them less expensive to heat. Larger houses cost more to heat.

But home owners (and landlords) must take some responsibility for the poor condition of some of Britain's housing. People buy houses and don't budget for ongoing maintenance or learn how to maintain them. Then when something goes wrong they either ignore it, move or bodge it.

TonTonMacoute · 03/03/2022 23:40

No, it's not by design, but it has been mishandled, and not really been given the proper priority it needs, for far too long. 18 Housing Ministers in the last 17 years, or something along those lines, it's not a sexy job in political terms unfortunately.

This report has just been published - it's a chewy read but you can flick through and get the idea.

I work in this area and I do talk to MPs and I know that they are genuinely concerned about the chronic shortage of truly affordable and social rented accommodation. Many of them are feeling quite positive about the new initiative underway from Michael Gove, even though a couple have said they are not big fans of him personally, they do believe that he has a chance of really getting things moving.

If you read the report it focuses on finding solutions to provide enough really affordable homes.

Report

PickAChew · 03/03/2022 23:27

It's not the new builds that are the cold houses.

bellamountain · 03/03/2022 23:25

If you drive on any motorway in this country, all you do is pass by miles and miles of fields. We have plenty of land but it seems planning developers want to destroy what is left in already over populated towns and cities by cramming in flats and tiny homes.

DoorWasAJar · 03/03/2022 23:15

@EmmaH2022

I do think we have a price crisis by design. There was a great programme explaining how Blair wanted property to be that way but it has vanished from iplayer. Funny that.
Ah that’s annoying, I’d love to watch it! Do you know what it was called? Was it video or a radio programme? Sorry I can’t remember if iplayer is just for video. I had to stop paying tv license since not having a tv anymore so I haven’t been on it in ages ☹️
OP posts:
DoorWasAJar · 03/03/2022 23:13

@EmmaH2022 I’m glad your is insulated well, but what do you mean when you say it’s over-insulated? Is there no sufficient ventilation? That’s not good but it can be fixed by adding ventilation. Are your heating bills very low due to the high level of insulation?

Just found this article claiming that our natural uk population is dropping and by 2025 we will rely on migrants to fill the gap, as they did in Japan... I remember reading there’s a world wide fertility/birth rate shortfall, with the exception of Nigeria, IIRC.

www.ft.com/content/7a558711-c1b8-4a41-8e72-8470cbd117e5

‘The natural population of the UK will begin to decline by the middle of the decade, leaving the country dependent on migration to increase the working-age population, according to new data.

Falling birth rates and an ageing population mean more people will die than are born annually by 2025, marking a long-term reversal of a historic trend, projections released on Wednesday by the Office for National Statistics showed.’

OP posts: