Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tissue donated to an 85 year old

217 replies

Nc4post99 · 02/03/2022 16:52

This is a mild aibu, as in if I’m BU please don’t be mean about it, it’s a painful situation.

I lost my father, quite traumatically in the summer. I used the staff loo in the itu and I saw the poster for involuntary organ and tissue donation in the toilet. I’ve always said when I die, If possible I’d want them to take everything and to tell my loved ones of all those helped/ saved. When he passed, I asked the nurse about it and they mentioned due to cancer he wouldn’t be a candidate for organ donation (which I was really disappointed about) but could donate some tissue if we were happy to progress. Nhs BT called and explained it all and it helped me through the grief was the mantra ‘the worst day of my life could be/ could lead to the best day of someone else’s. I thought it would bring me peace and this greater sense of understanding/ the circle of life if we got told that someone would be able to see again.

So we got the letter today, one cornea was used for an 85 year old and the other one was unusable even for research. But I don’t feel the peace/ understanding that I thought I would. I don’t know if it’s not how I envisioned in my head, a young person people able to see again or see for the first time and it was someone who was close to 20 years older than my father. I don’t know if it’s because the other was useless or i don’t know if it’s because I’d hyped it up so much in my head but it all feels anti climactic.

Please don’t mistake this for ageism, I am glad someone life has been made better by my dads and that he’s still touching lives after he’s gone but I’d like to understand my feelings and if they are irrational

Please be kind

OP posts:
KindlyKanga · 02/03/2022 19:05

@RegardingMary

A corneal transplant let my grandmother see her great grandchild who had only ever been described to her. It meant the world to her, and while she may have died a few years later it meant the world to her and me that she'd had the chance

You've given an amazing gift, not just to anc85 year old, but to his entire family. Thankyou.

This is so moving.
Lalliella · 02/03/2022 19:02

My friend’s mum just died. She had a terrible quality of life in her last few years, being unable to see or hear properly. Your donation has probably improved someone’s last years immensely. At a time in their life when seeing things may be their only pleasure. YANBU to feel the way you do, but try to think of the positive aspect of what you’ve done.

ThanksItHasPockets · 02/03/2022 18:55

OP, my mother is losing her sight to an incurable condition. It has been a slow and painful process of giving up a lifetime’s worth of skills, pleasures, and independence.

I cannot tell you how dramatically it would transform her remaining years of there were a treatment which could restore even part of her sight. Your gift has done this for someone else and I hope that with time you can draw comfort from this knowledge. I’m so sorry for your loss Flowers

whynotwhatknot · 02/03/2022 18:51

@caringcarer

You were very generous at a time you would have been very upset personally. We need more like you in society. My best friend's son was run over by driver high on drugs who mounted pavement many years ago. After 2-3 weeks she had to turn off life support but she chose to give his organs to others. She got a letter back after some time, both his corneas, and his liver were used for other children. They used his one of his kidneys but it did not work. She cried happy tears became a little bit of him lives on.
thats lovely so sorry for her loss
whynotwhatknot · 02/03/2022 18:49

its a lovely thing you did but i understand youre feelings-the gift of sight is amazing though you bot did a grea thing

RedPinkRose · 02/03/2022 18:47

I think I understand this. I think that this situation may serve as a painful reminder that your loved one did not get the chance to experience being cured and growing older. The donation is a wonderful thing to be celebrated by the gentleman who received your fathers gift and for the doctors who were able to help a patient but for you, yes, I imagine it would be another painful reminder of the loss of your father and the future you’d imagined spending with him.

I do understand. I still and always will envy those who have elderly parents though I know and understand that it’s hard to watch parents age and comes with its own heartache and challenge.

I hope this helps, OP. You are grieving and it’s very raw. Your feelings are understandable. Flowers

caringcarer · 02/03/2022 18:47

You were very generous at a time you would have been very upset personally. We need more like you in society. My best friend's son was run over by driver high on drugs who mounted pavement many years ago. After 2-3 weeks she had to turn off life support but she chose to give his organs to others. She got a letter back after some time, both his corneas, and his liver were used for other children. They used his one of his kidneys but it did not work. She cried happy tears became a little bit of him lives on.

WonderfulYou · 02/03/2022 18:46

You didn’t want your dad to die in vain.
You wanted his memory to live on and the end not so final. Which is of course understandable.

Your feelings are completely valid but YABU.
Organ and tissue donation is such a lovely thing to do and helping someone is helping someone no matter how big or small.
Give it time and you will feel much better about it.

A good deed always leads to another good deed.
From that act this women could also become an organ donor or donate money to charity from her will which will help other people.

maddiemookins16mum · 02/03/2022 18:46

My Aunt had a double Cornea transplant at 76. It changed her life (she’s 92 now and still lives alone). She was also able to visit her Father’s grave (for the first time - he had been killed during the War) at Souda Bay in Crete about 12 years ago, without that transplant she’d never have been able to do that.

But, I get where you’re coming from, you wanted this part of your Dad to be around for a long long time (it would give you comfort knowing this) and obviously that won’t be the case in an older person.

KeepingAnOpenMind · 02/03/2022 18:44

I think it is a bit ageist really. The 85 year old might live for another 20 years and be a wonderful person. The gift of sight is an amazing thing.

rwalker · 02/03/2022 18:42

Your dad gave the gift of sight so someone so they could have some quality final years

LaChanticleer · 02/03/2022 18:39

I think had the organ gone to somebody decades older than their dad then they’d have felt a bit…I’m not sure there is a word for it. ‘Cheated’ doesn’t seem right, nor does ‘disappointed’. I really can’t think of a word for it

The word is "ageist" - and I hope no-one uses your current feelings to act on a donation in relation to you when you need some help when you're 80.

Pombear47 · 02/03/2022 18:38

Im so very sorry for your loss and given the young age your dad died I think you’re feelings are completely understandable. Please try to remember that by helping one person you’re also helping all those on the list to get closer to having their transplant. My mum is 55 and waiting for a double cornea transplant, from myself and my three young children I thank you for bringing her closer to good health. x

Gizacluethen · 02/03/2022 18:38

I completely understand why you feel like that. I don't think it's bad at all.
But just think of that old man, who has lost his sight, too old to relearn his whole life, confused and not being able to go anywhere alone, even simple things like eating your dinner. Imagine losing your sight now. Everything you'd be unable to do. And your dad gave him his sight back. Gave him independence back. Maybe he'll only have a few years, but imagine what those years would have been like for him.

ilovesushi · 02/03/2022 18:37

YANBU, but you gave a wonderful gift irrespective of who received it and how many years they and their family will benefit from your amazing generosity.

LaChanticleer · 02/03/2022 18:37

Please don’t mistake this for ageism

I'm sorry, but it is.

I think you had a consolatory fantasy in your head about your aged father helping a young person (like you, or your children, maybe?) as a way of deflecting the grief at his death a little. While you could imagine this, you could deflect some of your grief.

Then when the reality of whom the donation had helped came, the full reality of your father's death hit you, with no fantasy about a young person helped to see. Instead, the age of the recipient reminded you of your elderly father, and the grief has hit you again.

YABU - whoever received your father's generous donation has benefited. You should hang onto that.

grapehyacinthisactuallyblue · 02/03/2022 18:35

Imagine that because of it, someone has got a wonderful time to cherish, even for short years. That is priceless.

SerendipitySunshine · 02/03/2022 18:33

You did a really good thing and I think your dad would be delighted. You've given an older person the gift of sight again, of the last chance to see their partner or watch their children and grandchildren grow up.
You've given them some independence too, and you've shown them that at the most difficult time in life, that someone cared.
Hang your medal high, you did a great thing.

newnameforthis76 · 02/03/2022 18:31

I’m so sorry about your dad. You must be heartbroken.

I think it’s pretty clear from your post that your real issue isn’t that your dad’s cornea went to someone elderly, but that you understandably had built up the donation into part of the grieving process and was expecting to feel something different. I think when we read about organ donation etc we tend to read about the stories that are most likely to encourage people to donate - so they focus on young, PR-friendly recipients and that’s what we picture when we think of organ or tissue donation.

Others have made excellent points about the age of the recipient - this could make a vast difference to the next 10 or 15 years of his life. He may well be a fit, sharp 85-year-old whose eyesight is the only barrier to his independence. The transplant might be the thing that allows him to care for his wife rather her having to go into a home. There are so many wonderful ways in which you and your lovely dad could have made a tremendous difference not just to the recipient but to their whole family, and you did an incredible thing.

James83 · 02/03/2022 18:31

There have been obituaries of people over a 100 recently, so maybe that lucky guy gets an improved life for another 15 yrs.
However I do understand what you felt. Maybe it would be interesting to hear your opinion in 13 months time.

MeridianB · 02/03/2022 18:29

@JaneExotic

I understand. But I’m also touched to think of an elderly man, who many people would think was too old to bother with, being able to see his wife/children/grandkids/dog/view from the window etc. Whatever the situation, his quality of life will have improved, thanks to you and your dad x
I second this. Many 84 year olds has SO much life to live and would appreciate this every single minute of every day. 💐
LizzieSiddal · 02/03/2022 18:27

I do understand where you’re coming from. Someone very close to me lost their 17 year old child, 4 organs were donated and when the letter came it was all people in their 50s and 60s. I felt really blindsided as I had assumed they would go to saving the lives of youngsters. It took me a few months to come to terms with it and realise that those people really did deserve those organs. This was several years ago now and I can see how irrational it all was. Be kind to yourself.Flowers

IlonaRN · 02/03/2022 18:21

@JaneExotic

I understand. But I’m also touched to think of an elderly man, who many people would think was too old to bother with, being able to see his wife/children/grandkids/dog/view from the window etc. Whatever the situation, his quality of life will have improved, thanks to you and your dad x
This.

You did a wonderful thing in extremely difficult circumstances.
My condolences for your loss xx

CafeCremeMerci · 02/03/2022 18:21

@Nc4post99

I'm sorry to hear about your Dad. My Dad died a few years ago and he was a healthy 65 yo. I too feel very cheated. I grew up with my Dad giving regular blood donations and knowing he was an Organ Donor... when he died (very suddenly) he had to have an autopsy & he wasn't able to Donte anything.

Much to my shame, I was somewhat relieved at the time, because I simply could not have given them permission.

So I think you have been incredibly brave. I'm sorry it hasn't brought you the feelings you expected, but if you can focus on the joy (& possibly even independence) it has brought an older person & come to terms with the fact that not doing it wouldn't bring your Dad back and it was likely to have been unsuitable for a younger person, hopefully in time you can feel more positive about it.

However you feel is ok though, I just hope you can feel better for YOUR sake.

Much love, it's bloody hard xx

Sswhinesthebest · 02/03/2022 18:21

I think with grief you have to expect the unexpected. There is no right or wrong way to feel.
Allow yourself to feel how you feel but he really has touched that 85 year olds life in a positive way.