Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tissue donated to an 85 year old

217 replies

Nc4post99 · 02/03/2022 16:52

This is a mild aibu, as in if I’m BU please don’t be mean about it, it’s a painful situation.

I lost my father, quite traumatically in the summer. I used the staff loo in the itu and I saw the poster for involuntary organ and tissue donation in the toilet. I’ve always said when I die, If possible I’d want them to take everything and to tell my loved ones of all those helped/ saved. When he passed, I asked the nurse about it and they mentioned due to cancer he wouldn’t be a candidate for organ donation (which I was really disappointed about) but could donate some tissue if we were happy to progress. Nhs BT called and explained it all and it helped me through the grief was the mantra ‘the worst day of my life could be/ could lead to the best day of someone else’s. I thought it would bring me peace and this greater sense of understanding/ the circle of life if we got told that someone would be able to see again.

So we got the letter today, one cornea was used for an 85 year old and the other one was unusable even for research. But I don’t feel the peace/ understanding that I thought I would. I don’t know if it’s not how I envisioned in my head, a young person people able to see again or see for the first time and it was someone who was close to 20 years older than my father. I don’t know if it’s because the other was useless or i don’t know if it’s because I’d hyped it up so much in my head but it all feels anti climactic.

Please don’t mistake this for ageism, I am glad someone life has been made better by my dads and that he’s still touching lives after he’s gone but I’d like to understand my feelings and if they are irrational

Please be kind

OP posts:
Andacherryonthetop · 02/03/2022 19:43

I’m so sorry for your loss op. Your dad has probably given that man such an incredible gift. He might be able to see grandchildren he hasn’t seen before or just enjoy the details in things he had almost forgotten about like how leaves look on the trees, how the waves look on the beach. I’m sure he will be so so very grateful to your dad. Your not unreasonable at all, you’re grieving

Matildalamp · 02/03/2022 19:43

I can understand your feelings, it’s upsetting when you were hoping for some feeling of peace. I wonder if this will help, I had a cornea transplant in my right eye. At the time I was 36, and was told I was waiting for someone of a similar age to pass, the very oldest they could be was 45. I don’t know if that’s still the protocol. I wished I hadn’t known that, as my sister-in-law had died a year earlier at 42, and I couldn’t bear the thought of that devastation for some other family.

I suspect your dad’s corneas couldn’t have been used for a younger person, and I’m really sorry that wasn’t explained to you beforehand.

The other thing that crossed my mind is that restored or improved sight for an older person can make such a difference, especially if other faculties are failing.

I hope you can find some peace in the grieving process Flowers

dottydodah · 02/03/2022 19:43

Well Im sorry about your Dad.I think though that by definition more elderly people would be in need of a cornea maybe ? Also 85 can be very different for many people .My dear FIL lived to 94 .Still travelling abroad until 91 and driving around the village ! The receipent could be more like this nowadays .Even a poorly chap who finds it hard to get around, will have had his eyesight restored and can see all the Flowers and trees /Birds etc .Think of a gift like this and be happy a little piece of Dad lives on

amusedbush · 02/03/2022 19:43

On one hand, I can see why someone (not necessarily you, OP, I'm just musing) might have had an image in their mind of the donation giving a new lease of life to someone young. Like their loss had a profound impact on someone with their whole life ahead of them.

But on the other, my granny is 88 and she is wonderful. Sharp as a tack, wickedly funny, kind, caring and generous to a fault. Her body is failing her though; she has a heart condition but nobody will operate due to other conditions/medications. She will be living with it until she's not, to be blunt, and I wish there was something to be done. If there was a surgery available to her, I would be thrilled.

However you feel is fine and valid, OP. I'm so sorry for your loss.

Rockmehardplace · 02/03/2022 19:40

You are grieving, you have been through a massive trauma and done an amazing thing - you are allowed to feel however you feel, and don’t feel bad about that. You have a lot of emotions going on, organ donation is hard emotionally on both sides (I am an organ recipient and feel guilty all the time incase I am someway a disappointment to the donor family).

To give an elderly man joy in his final decade, to allow him to remain independent, to see the faces of those he loves, to give the gift of all those extra memories he can make that will live with his family forever…..that is an amazing gift to have given and a wonderful legacy for your father x

LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood · 02/03/2022 19:38

Bless you. I lost my mum last year. My heart is still broken.

Your feelings are your feelings. But, as others have said, just think about the joy that it will have brought to an older person who has had their sight restored. My mum was 81 when she died. She was very frail and virtually housebound. Her pleasures were knitting, crosswords, reading, board games, jigsaws. Has she lost her sight those last, simple pleasures would have been lost to her. And it would have brought me comfort for the rest of my days knowing her sight was restored. I hope you find the peace you are seeking eventually.

PinkPaleFlower · 02/03/2022 19:36

The 85 year old, will bless your family every day.

That’s all really.

What a fabulous gift of giving

ByGrabtharsHammerWhatASavings · 02/03/2022 19:32

I agree with the other posters OP, you are allowed to feel however you feel but you've done a wonderful thing and should also be proud. My fil is 85 and he is so fit and active. He's a huge reader, loves to garden, plays in a samba band, and until the pandemic was actually still flying to and from China for business trips. He loves to drive as well and takes great care of my MIL who despite being younger is much more infirm. The loss of his sight would be devastating to him, it would rob him of his joys in life, limit his income, and make it almost impossible for him and mil to live independently. He'd go from being full of life to hugely dependent. And it's not just him and mil who would suffer because if they need care in the home it'll be my sil who does the bulk of it and this will affect her, her husband, and their children, as well as my own family as my dp will of course also help (but we live further away). So many lives will have been touched and improved by your fathers donation, not just that of the recipient.

Nc4post99 · 02/03/2022 19:31

@BrutusMcDogface

Yanbu because your feelings, all of them, are completely valid. However, you and your dad have done a wonderful thing giving someone the gift of sight.

Maybe it’s the fact that the recipient is outliving your dad by 20 years; that must really hurt.

So very sorry for your loss Flowers

Yes you’re right, that hurts a lot. In the grand scheme of things he was so young. Not even 70. At the funeral countless people came up to me and asked what happened and all had the same thing to say ‘it’s so young, it’s no age these days, his parents lived longer etc. Whilst people meant well it was a gut punch. In some ways this is too. It’s a gut punch that the other was in effect useless, even for research. That’s how much his body was broken down, in life I had so much hope that he was going to get better, this is just further confirmation how his fragility. That hurts because it confirms suffering.
OP posts:
notwavingbutdrowning5 · 02/03/2022 19:30

I know an 87-year-old who is waiting for a cornea transplant. Apart from his eyesight he is fit and well, delightful company, and his mind is as sharp as mustard. He is also a carer for a 94-year-old. Your gift would have transformed both their lives, and they are lives that are very much worth living. You have done a wonderful thing. I don’t know how old you are but I suspect that as you get older you will appreciate that the age of the recipient really doesn’t matter. I’m so sorry you lost your father - it’s such a difficult thing to go through.

MurmuratingStarling · 02/03/2022 19:28

@Nc4post99 I do hope you're OK, and I am so sorry to hear about your father. YANBU to feel how you feel, and I believe many others would feel the same (despite the poll results here.) It's also not ageism. It's perfectly natural to think (for example) that a 25 year old should be given priority over an 85 year old, for an organ, or tissues, or corneas etc (from someone deceased.)

If someone saved the life of an 85 year old, over the life of a 25 year old (say rescuing them from a burning building or pulling them from a raging river,) I am sure many people would have some negative things to say about sacrificing the 25 year old, for the 85 year old.

Of course, all lives are worthy of saving and improving, but if most people are honest, they will have to admit that priority for something like this should surely go to a much younger person. I can only surmise - as a few posters have said - that your father's corneas were not in brilliant condition, but were suitable for someone of 85.

I am very happy this 85 year old chap got his sight saved, for as many posters have said, potentially 15-20 years. But YANBU to feel how you feel.

PigeonLittle · 02/03/2022 19:28

@JinglingHellsBells

I've not read the whole thread, but what struck me was that the cornea of an older person might not be the best match for a younger person simply due to the lifespan of that tissue.

It might serve an 85 yr older well for 5 or 10 years but a younger person would want 60 + years from it.

I'm sorry for your loss of course but be happy it's helped someone.

This is an excellent point Star
PigeonLittle · 02/03/2022 19:27

Yanbu, you feel how you feel Flowers

I had a friend who had a terminal illness and she was significantly younger than 85. As she got poorly and frail, her eyesight went. I have always thought how desperately sad it must have been to not be able to learn how to cope with blindness, and not have the physical strength or mental will to do much else but sit, unable to look at anything and wait for death.

You've done an amazing thing.

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 02/03/2022 19:27

I am not going to vote because you are not being U but it is also a wonderful thing for that recipient whatever their age. I dont know what expectations I would have in this situation, but am sure that I would be disappointed if what happened did not match what I had thought would happen. Take care of yourself and I am sorry for your loss.

BrutusMcDogface · 02/03/2022 19:26

Yanbu because your feelings, all of them, are completely valid. However, you and your dad have done a wonderful thing giving someone the gift of sight.

Maybe it’s the fact that the recipient is outliving your dad by 20 years; that must really hurt.

So very sorry for your loss Flowers

JinglingHellsBells · 02/03/2022 19:26

I've not read the whole thread, but what struck me was that the cornea of an older person might not be the best match for a younger person simply due to the lifespan of that tissue.

It might serve an 85 yr older well for 5 or 10 years but a younger person would want 60 + years from it.

I'm sorry for your loss of course but be happy it's helped someone.

Fraine · 02/03/2022 19:20

My elderly mum means the world to me, more than all the young people in my life. If someone donated a part of their body to her, however small, to give her good health, I would be grateful and as if they had given it to a baby.

HighOnPie · 02/03/2022 19:18

I totally understand how you feel. But imagine if the person who received the tissue was your grandparent. My gran was registered blind and it broke her heart that she couldn’t drive, read or watch TV when her sight became too compromised. She was so upset that she couldn’t see her grandchildren’s faces. It got her down so much that she was on anti depressants when she sadly passed away at 94. She had previously been the happiest, most positive person you could have ever known. Having her sight restored would have changed her life, she would have been thrilled. I imagine that the person who received the tissue is over the moon that their last few years on earth will be spent seeing the sun, a blue sky, being able to watch their favourite programme on TV 😊

I’m so sorry for the loss of your father Flowers

saraclara · 02/03/2022 19:18

Please don’t mistake this for ageism

In the nicest possible way, I'm afraid that it is. At some level you thing that an 85 year old isn't as worthy of it.

But try and see it this way. An 85 year old probably has a lot less stimulation in their life. This person might be housebound, and being able to see their TV, or read, or see their great grandchildren, might be if anything, MORE important than for a younger person who has more activity and social life.

My 93 year old auntie is blind in one eye, and is losing sight in the other. She lives alone and has always been hugely independent, but when the sight has gone in her other eye, she will have to go into a care home, despite being fit and healthy, and as sharp and intelligent as ever she's been. The gift of sight would would save her from losing her independence.

As others have said, an older persons cornea would probably not be transplanted into a young person. Your gift will be worth everything to the person who received it. And they're as worthy of it as anyone else.

Nc4post99 · 02/03/2022 19:17

He really liked pins, medals, badges, crests and certificates, you know that sort of memorabilia, anything with a bit of history attached. He doesn’t have a grave. This and the leaf on the tree In liverpool are all I have in any tangible way.

OP posts:
Nc4post99 · 02/03/2022 19:11

@newnameforthis76

I’m so sorry about your dad. You must be heartbroken.

I think it’s pretty clear from your post that your real issue isn’t that your dad’s cornea went to someone elderly, but that you understandably had built up the donation into part of the grieving process and was expecting to feel something different. I think when we read about organ donation etc we tend to read about the stories that are most likely to encourage people to donate - so they focus on young, PR-friendly recipients and that’s what we picture when we think of organ or tissue donation.

Others have made excellent points about the age of the recipient - this could make a vast difference to the next 10 or 15 years of his life. He may well be a fit, sharp 85-year-old whose eyesight is the only barrier to his independence. The transplant might be the thing that allows him to care for his wife rather her having to go into a home. There are so many wonderful ways in which you and your lovely dad could have made a tremendous difference not just to the recipient but to their whole family, and you did an incredible thing.

This is exactly it! Exactly it. Thank you @newnameforthis76, I couldn’t articulate or get my head around my feelings, but you have, thank you!
OP posts:
TheMagpie · 02/03/2022 19:11

Old people are just as deserving of these treatments.

Not only that, but that 85 year old may live 15 more years... a 20 year old may die next year. Age doesn't always mean they'll 'need it less'.

Bunnycat101 · 02/03/2022 19:08

There is a lot of complex emotions around organ donation. One of my friends has an organ transplant when she was young. Probably the candidate you’d want on paper if you were going to donate an organ. However, It took her years to feel able to process it. She was resentful not grateful and didn’t appreciate it until her 20s when she made contact with the donor family many years later. She talks quite openly about the complexity of the donation process and her feelings as a teenager.

The gift of sight to an 85 year old is amazing. It may be the difference between independent living and care and could make such an enormous difference to the quality of life.

bossybloss · 02/03/2022 19:08

Please don’t be hard on yourself..you did a wonderful thing.My dad had an eye operation in his eighties and in made the difference between him being allowed to drive or not.He was able to live the rest of his life much more independently and carry on with his hobbies.SO THANK YOU, x

KindlyKanga · 02/03/2022 19:07

I think a few posters have hit the nail on the head, the fact that the cornea may be only used for a few years but the quality of life for those last few years will be so vastly improved. Allowing someone to see their family in their final hours.