Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Toddler behaviour causing problems

132 replies

Behaviour101 · 02/03/2022 14:55

Posting for traffic. I'm desperate for some help. Also posted in behaviour.

My DS is nearly 2 and I'm struggling with behaviour at home and at friends houses.

He pushes and hits other children at home and at his friend's homes. We're starting to see people less and less as they don't really want their child to spend time with mine. I really don't know what to do!

The other day he slapped my friend's child around the face so hard he left a hand print - this was after he pushed him face first into a cupboard. He'll also snatch food and take all of the toys in a room and hide them.

Nursery say he behaves there, it's just everywhere else.

AIBU to think this is just a phase?!

OP posts:
LethargeMarg · 02/03/2022 19:10

Don't get him to hug kids as an apology it's not fair on the other child who probably doesn't want the child who has just hurt them in their personal space again . I'm also not sure if toddlers understand sorry or unkind but they will understand it if they are taken home when things like this happen. You need an age appropriate consistent consequence and removing him quickly from the situation is better than hugs or saying sorry as he will quickly learn that's what happens if he lashes out, although worth thinking if he is actually over stimulated and wanting to leave and the behaviour is his way of trying to escape ?? Maybe limit play dates for a while especially if he is at nursery and seeing lots of children there as he may need some down time ?
Definitely one to monitor - all toddlers have aggressive traits and moments but if it's happening a lot and doesn't seem to be just a phase I would talk to your health visitor.

nanbread · 02/03/2022 19:09

Obviously appropriate consequences such as a time out, 1-2-3 magic etc.

123 Magic is hideous, and inappropriate especially for a child this age. Time outs not much better either.

Howareyouflower · 02/03/2022 19:02

I'd really recommend that you develop "THE VOICE". It isn't a shout, it's a powerful low toned voice, so that "Stop!" or "No!" sound as if you mean it.

MangshorJhol · 02/03/2022 19:02

Also as the mother of a kid who regularly got beaten up by ‘boisterous’ ones sometimes please DO take them home. It’s not performative discipline. It’s calling an end to something that isn’t working. And my child is not the Guinea pig for your child to learn their social skills. After the 3rd time your child has whacked mine please please do take them home because I am too kind to throw you out!

Coyoacan · 02/03/2022 19:01

OP, children like and need boundaries. Your little one is angry because he knows he is unsafe with parents who don't give him any boundaries.

Do you have any compassion for the children he hurts and takes the food away from?

MangshorJhol · 02/03/2022 18:59

@SuperSleepyBaby he’s nearly two. And it’s possible to be stern with a child without emotional harm. You can be strict without punishment or being punitive. It is possible to set really firm boundaries with small kids. In fact I would go so far as to say that the boundaries make kids feel safer.

With older kids and I have a 10 year old they won’t behave like a toddler because well…peer pressure. But actually there are boys in my son’s class whose behaviour is appalling and whose mothers think the sun shines out of their arse- they are rude, can’t work cooperatively with other kids- it’s their way or the highway. It’s not their fault per se, I would blame the parents. And I bet they were ‘boisterous’ as toddlers.

sadpapercourtesan · 02/03/2022 18:58

Appropriate consequences at this age are a firm "No" or "We don't hit" and physically - gently - moving the child from the immediate vicinity of the toy/food/other child. Then distraction and getting on with the day. Time-outs are not appropriate - he's too young and it will only confuse and distress him. Taking him home will do no good either - he'll have forgotten what it's all about before you even make it to the car.

So many parents fall into the trap of doing "performative discipline" with children who are too young for it to be meaningful, usually because they want to look like proactive parents to other adults. What he needs is for you to helicopter him, gently but firmly discouraging/moving him every time he does it. No drama, no punishments, and it will take a little while for him to respond - that's because he's a tiny toddler, not because the consequences aren't stiff enough.

EmbarrassedAllOver · 02/03/2022 18:56

We know a child who's been very difficult. Not as physical as yours, but many huge tantrums, rude language, hitting parents. He's 5 now and still the same.

The issue for him is his parents. Mum has anxiety so never follows through with any discipline. There's always an excuse or quite literally just turns away so she "doesn't see" it. She's weak in her approach.

The dad is similar. When child was younger the dad would laugh when child was rude. He thought it was cute.

As the child's gotten older, it's become unenjoyable to be in their company. It's hard to stand by and watch him be rude to others with no consequences.

OP - this is the time to act. Be serious, be present and be strict. He can't teach himself, that's your job. When he hits, you hold his wrist, speak loudly and deeply "no, don't do that. If I see you hit again, we will be leaving". And if he does it again "no. I told you not to hit. I warned you we would leave. We are leaving". Then leave.

When making playdates, let parents know in advance it may be short as you're trialling a new way of disciplining to try to improve his behaviour so you may have to shoot if he's persistently naughty. Be honest with people and you may find they don't mind meeting again. So long as their child is safeguarded from harm.

I know it doesn't feel nice to have your child cry, but surely better that than him have no nice friends at school. (My friend's son has a few friends despite being a little s**t but he's friends with the other naughty kids so not a great situation).

And no, I don't think they do always grow out of it organically. Big hugs, no easy.

SuperSleepyBaby · 02/03/2022 18:52

A good nap and a 10pm bedtime can work for some children - and not others. Its not one size fits all.

Heronwatcher · 02/03/2022 18:47

He needs very firm and consistent consequences, yes even if he cries, otherwise this will be a very long phase! Obviously appropriate consequences such as a time out, 1-2-3 magic etc. I’d also watch some super nanny episodes for tips and try to make sure bedtime is closer to 7 than 10pm (which is too late, even with a good nap). I would also look at screen time/ diet too.

Iliveonthexbox · 02/03/2022 18:42

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

SuperSleepyBaby · 02/03/2022 18:42

‘Intense disapproval’. - ‘severe tone’. For a one year old Grin

Viviennemary · 02/03/2022 18:40

He is very young. But you must express intense disapproval of this behaviour and take him home immediately. No point in talking in a calm nicey nicey voice. Use a severe tone.

istandwithukraine · 02/03/2022 18:39

but he cries and it upsets me.

Somehow knew this was coming.

It's not him it's you and your wishy washy softly softly parenting that's the issue

Hoppinggreen · 02/03/2022 18:34

@SuperSleepyBaby

Yes - quick OP lay down the law or when he grows up he most likely will end up a serial killer!!! Shock
Or just a child that nobody want s to play with if we want to be a bit less dramatic
Gizacluethen · 02/03/2022 18:32

If he’s not doing it at nursery then I’m afraid it’s you not him that’s the issue.

This. Sorry.

Yes he's young. But actually he does know better because he can be better, you need to give him logical consequences, not punishments. But if you hit, you can't keep playing.

My god if someone's child left a mark on mine and their mum tried to get them to just say sorry and give him a hug I'd be absolutely fuming with her. Not the child, the mum. And I don't think I'd let them hug actually. I'm not teaching my child that kind of hit, hug, hit, hug relationship is OK.

"He punched me but he said sorry so it's ok"?

SnackSizeRaisin · 02/03/2022 18:30

It's not acceptable to let him hit other children. The problem is that you obviously think it's not ideal but not that much of a problem.

Just don't allow him to do it. It's not complicated. Stay close enough that you can physically restrain him. If he persists in trying then leave. Avoid situations that he finds difficult. He's far too young for apologies and hugging. Why is he hugging someone he's just hit anyway. That's a really odd thing to encourage. You need to keep him away from the other child instead. You can try to get another parent on side and explain that you need help to socialise him in a low key setting. But if you are unable to stop him being violent then just stay away. Other children won't want to play with him soon anyway. A child hit mine twice, a few weeks apart about 6 months ago. I never mentioned it to my child since. She still remembers and won't play with him. She's only 2.5.

InThePresenceOfWeevil · 02/03/2022 18:24

"My partner thinks we should use time out as a consequence, but he cries and it upsets me."

There lies the problem. How would you feel if he was crying because another child had hit HIM?

You're the adult and parent so you need to take that role. A stern no and some consequences.

nopuppiesallowed · 02/03/2022 18:23

'He cries and it upsets me'? Flaming Norah! When he's 10 and he smashes someone in the face and you sweetly explain that he must say 'sorry' he's definitely going to be Mr Nomates. Or he'll be hanging out with a group of other thugs. If he knows crying upsets you, he'll be using that tactic for ever more.

Grumblegard · 02/03/2022 18:21

I think it's possible to have compassion for this child and not see him as a bully, but still be effective in dealing with the problem.

FWIW, I think this is fairly normal behaviour for some (not all) toddlers and it makes sense it happens with mum because that's where he is most comfortable to show all his emotions.

BUT, I would follow him, get between him and other kids ("I can't let you hit," and physically block). If he tries more than once, "wow, you're having a hard time not hitting, I need to keep everyone safe so we're going home now." Pick him up and go.

He's telling you by behaving this way that he can't cope with the situation he's in. But you can do it calmly, with authority and with compassion for him as a small person not in control of his feelings, which must feel scary.

UpToMyElbowsInDiapers · 02/03/2022 18:01

@Happyhappyday

Try reading How to talk so little kids will listen. It has a lot of good coping strategies, time out doesn’t always work but I agree with PP that saying he cries and it upsets you is pretty wet of you. You need to be in charge, setting clear boundaries will ultimately make him happier and there are kind ways to do it.

As to it being a phase, it will be if you parent appropriately, but while it is I personally would limit play dates. It’s ok to say DC is going through a tricky phase so we’re sticking around home until we figure things out. I wouldn’t invite you over or go over if your DC was behaving like that.

I second this! I love “How to Talk So Little Kids Will Listen.”

Also, a trick nursery taught me that works brilliantly with my kids: don’t just tell them what they CAN’T do. Also tell them what they CAN do. The mantra my 4-yo and 2-to recite from nursery is “hands are not for hitting, hands are for playing”. They police EACH OTHER that way and it’s brilliant. They very, very rarely tussle (maybe once a month?) but when they do, if one hits the other, they recite this and an apology is usually very quickly forthcoming. It rarely escalates and is rarely repeated.

Each of my kids had a one-week phase around 18 months old where they tried hitting more frequently. We recited the mantra, we removed them immediately from the situation in which they hit (even if they were kicking and screaming at us), we made sure they were watching while we apologized to the child who had been hurt (if they weren’t ready to apologize yet - usually they did it themselves), and at home we played with dolls a lot… I’d have one doll (let’s call him Teddy) hit another doll (fox). I would ask: “how does fox feel?” “Why did Teddy hit fox?” “What could Teddy have done instead?” And we would act out Teddy asking to share, asking for a turn, getting a parent or teacher if something was going wrong, or taking deep breaths if he was simply feeling annoyed. I swear… It really worked!

Thebedistoohot · 02/03/2022 17:53

This is on you. You need to helicopter and be right by him at all times on play dates, first sign of hurting other kids and you tell him no in no uncertain terms. If he keeps doing it you leave.

SuperSleepyBaby · 02/03/2022 17:49

Yes - quick OP lay down the law or when he grows up he most likely will end up a serial killer!!! Shock

Marmelace · 02/03/2022 17:43

@oakleaffy

There used to be a ''Thuggy'' toddler at our local 'Mothers and toddlers'. We referred to him as ''Bullet head''. He was like a mini Putin, bullying, forcing smaller children to give up their toys. He was extremely unpopular, but his mother did NOTHING to stop him.

She just sat there with her new baby, and looked on.

He had zero discipline, he should have been told ''NO!'' in no uncertain terms, and taken away the minute his bullying started.

A bullying child, especially one who hits out will be ostracised swiftly, so it is crucial that you give consequences.

It isn't ''Normal'' behaviour.

You're talking about op child's behaviour not being normal, whilst calling another child names and comparing him to a murdering, warmongering psychopath! Wow just wow! Think you need to take a serious look at yourself!
Christmas1988 · 02/03/2022 17:42

His problems are definitely due to lack of attention, children don’t bite/punch/kick etc. For no reason.

Swipe left for the next trending thread